10 Lost Albums That Were Released Years Later

Land of Musical Artifacts.

By Tim Coffman /

We don't really have to worry about not being able to get ahold of music anymore. Ever since the age of Spotify, we can pretty much pull together any kind of song that we want to without a care in the world. But what about those few albums that have been lost to history over the years?

Advertisement

That's not to say that these songs were necessarily not good enough. For the most part, some of these tracks could have been on par with some of the greatest things that these bands ever ever done, only to be scrapped at the last minute. Some say it was because of label drama, others think it was just a change in direction, but one thing's for sure. It's a miracle that we actually got to see these records come to fruition.

After years of waiting, these albums were eventually given to the public in some capacity, just not in the manner that you'd expect them to. As much as these records still hold up, it's almost like their old artifacts that have been lost to time. Considering that most of these were coming from a completely different headspace than when they were released, these are almost like getting a behind the scenes look at what went on behind those closed studio doors.

10. Smile - Beach Boys

Looking back on the story of the Beach Boys, it's hard not to feel sorry for Brian Wilson at the time. Here you have one of the greatest artists of his generation, and yet he's being told by everyone that what's he's doing is either too weird or not good enough to actually be made. While everyone was wrong about Pet Sounds, that kind of criticism can take its toll on even the sharpest minds.

Advertisement

Just after making one of the greatest pop albums of all time, Brian went into the studio to do it all over again, using the experimentation of Good Vibrations as his template. Once things started rolling on the new album Smile, it became clear to everyone that Wilson was hitting a wall, and would most likely suffer some sort of breakdown if he decided to go any further.

Though most of his songs would eventually be folded into psychedelic albums for the rest of the '60s, we finally did get to hear a version of Smile in the early 2010's, attributed to just Brian Wilson. Though it's rough around the edges, you can hear the bones of what Brian was getting at here, making songs that were equal parts wacky and catchy at the same time. Considering this was 40 years in the making, this is probably the closest we can get to see what's in Brian's head.

9. Buckingham Nicks - Buckingham Nicks

For many of the uninitiated, Fleetwood Mac would have been considered nobodies if they hadn't acquired Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks. While Fleetwood Mac had already been legendary as a blues rock outfit at the time, having two pop songwriters in the mix gave them the commercial power that they needed for albums like Rumours. As it turns out though, the power couple behind the Mac were a lot better in the band than left to their own devices.

Advertisement

Originally operating out of the same studio that Fleetwood Mac was working in, Buckingham Nicks was originally the name of the duo band that they had, which featured them sowing the seeds of what would become Fleetwood Mac material. Although most of the songs on here have gone out of print, the files that we have now give us a peek as to what the early days looked like.

Compared to the global force of songs like Rhiannon, there are scattered moments of brilliance on here, with the song Frozen Love being the song that originally got Buckingham the gig as the Mac's guitar player a few years later. If anything, this is a nice snapshot of what this folk duo was like before the breakup and fallout of everything that was on the horizon.

8. Songs From The Black Hole - Weezer

After Weezer became everyone's favorite nerd rock band in the mid '90s, Rivers Cuomo was burnt the hell out. Since this wasn't a guy who was necessarily ready for fame and fortune, the next few years saw him abstaining from music altogether and taking some time to go to college at Harvard. When he resurfaced though, Rivers had a vision for a new and improved version of what Weezer could be.

Advertisement

Or...that's what could have happened if Pinkerton wasn't a thing. Before the idea for the emotional sophomore album came up, Rivers' plan was to release a rock opera centered around space travel called Songs from the Black Hole. The band eventually took on the project and actually managed to get a lot of work done before Matt Sharp did a similar sounding project first with his band the Rentals.

Not wanting to look like a one trick pony, the band decided to scrap the project entirely and go with a more basic album approach, with Rivers eventually making stories about how uncomfortable he was being a rockstar. Considering the amount of bile that was thrown Pinkerton's way in the early days, there are probably millions of fans clamoring to hear the real rock opera. Though we have the tapes for what it could have been, it's unlikely that we'll ever see a new version of Songs from the Black Hole.

7. Carnival Of Souls - KISS

During the late '90s, KISS deciding to put the makeup back on was probably a genius move from a business standpoint. Since the era of grimy grunge wasn't doing them any favors, the idea of bringing back the face paint and massive stage get up was going to win over the people feeling nostalgic for the early days. That didn't stop them from leaking one final album with the new version of the band.

Advertisement

Despite them not wanting to have it released, Carnival of Souls is an interesting case study for the band that was known for their over the top personas. Instead of the usual party rock songs of their early days, most of this record feels more like KISS' attempt at grunge music, with songs like Hate and Rain sounding like they could have come off an Alice in Chains record. Albeit, an Alice in Chains record that's going through a bit of a midlife crisis.

Outside of obvious trend chasing though, this album still holds up as something special in the KISS canon, with Paul Stanley showing his softer side on I Will Be There and featuring the only lead vocals from guitarist Bruce Kulick on the track I Walk Alone. You can certainly find better in the grunge market, but if you're a classic rock nerd, this is still well worth the deep dive.

6. Household Objects - Pink Floyd

After Dark Side of the Moon, Pink Floyd had pretty much reached the point where they could do no wrong. Chances are that you could have made an entire album out of David Gilmour having a conversation with his dentist and it probably would have sold like gangbusters at the time. And to test that theory, the Floyd were actually intending to go for broke on their super-weird album Household Objects.

Advertisement

And yes I do mean weird, too. Much like the title would imply, this entire album was supposed to be an experimental project for the band much like their album Ummagumma, which would involve them creating full songs using nothing more than just recording technology and different objects that you'd find around the house, from cooking irons to an actual fridge.

When the band got off the road though, there was no chance of them being on the same creative page for something like that, being absolutely exhausted and channeling their disillusion into the songs off of Wish You Were Here. In this case, it was probably the right call, especially when you realize how important Wish You Were Here is in the legend of the Floyd. From the original demos though, it still sounds like Household Objects would have certainly been a trip.

5. Toy - David Bowie

Throughout every decade of rock music, it seemed like David Bowie was right there paving the way for all of us. Going from one strange musical venture to the next, the Thin White Duke seemed to have enough artistic talent in his body than most people have for 4 lifetimes. Even with all of that talent, even the musical aliens can be fallible sometimes.

Advertisement

Once the new millennium started, Bowie got to work on his new album Toy, which was set to bring him back to his roots. Alongside a handful of new songs, this was going to be Bowie reworking some of his older material and fleshing out songs from his youth that he never got to finish. After a fallout with the producer though, Bowie eventually relented to go in a different direction with his album Heathen.

While you do get different takes on Bowie's reaction to events like 9/11, Toy's eventual release online still showed us what could have been a great Bowie record. Hell, when you look at the bones of some of these songs, there are probably some who would argue that releasing this would have been an improvement over what we got on his past few records. Even when going back to his very early days, Bowie still had the songwriting chops to create something spectacular.

4. Eros - Deftones

When you're working on any kind of project, you have tomake sure that every band member can stay in the right headspace at the same time. For all you know, this could be the final time you're in the studio, so you always want to make sure you give it the best shot you can. Then again, circumstances can always change things.

Advertisement

During the recording for Deftones' next album, tentatively titled Eros, bassist Chi Cheng was involved in a horrific car crash, which left him comatose for the next few years until he eventually succumbed to his injuries. Although the last thing that the band had on their minds was recording, they still had half of an album unfinished and a commitment to make to their label.

Instead of continuing on with the tapes they had, they settled on making a return to form with Diamond Eyes, which ended up becoming a huge second wind for the group on the critical scene. Still, we have seen a bit of a release of Eros years later, with sources leaking a good chunk of the tapes to see where the band was at for the follow up to Saturday Night Wrist. If they had put out something half hearted after Chi's passing though, it would have seemed a lot more disingenuous by comparison.

3. Get Back - The Beatles

Towards the end of the '60s, all of the peace and love sensibilities of the Beatles were being thrown out the door. After the disastrous sessions for their self titled White Album, the Fab Four were slowly drifting apart and had to deal with the business of Apple Corps in between making records. Though Abbey Road was the real goodbye from the group that defined the '60s, it was actually covering up for what was originally planned on Get Back.

Advertisement

Much like the title and song would lead you to believe, this was supposed to be the group's return to roots record, where they would hunker down and get used to their bar band sensibilities again. Once they showed up for work though, the sessions grinded to a halt, with a bunch of lackluster equipment hanging around and cameras filming everything to be a part of the upcoming Beatles film.

By the time they released Abbey Road, there was no chance of getting every Beatle in the same room again, so Glyn Johns and Phil Spector eventually turned the tapes into the album Let It Be, which acted as the real swan song for the Beatles' last days. Even then the band wasn't fully happy with it, given that Paul McCartney was involved in Let It Be...Naked, which was how he would have wanted it. After years in production hell, we should just let these songs have peace.

2. The Black Album - Prince

As eclectic as Prince's career was during his prime, you can never really say there was a dull moment. Up until the '90s when he changed his name to a symbol, the amount of quality material brought out by the Purple One was more than any other pop artist in the world, from Sign O the Times to movie soundtracks like Purple Rain and Batman. Once he decided to do some soul searching though, we got robbed of one of the hidden gems of his career.

Advertisement

After the massive amount of material that came with Sign O the Times, Prince was all set to release the record that he wanted to make with the Black Album. Being his return to roots, this was supposed to win back his audience that he lost by going in a more pop direction.

Or at least...that's what was supposed to happen. In the middle of the sessions, Prince underwent a spiritual epiphany and was convinced that he had created something truly evil, making the musical 180 of releasing Lovesexy instead. Never before has an artist completely hated their own work this much, going so far as to include an apology in the video for the song Alphabet St. There's not thinking your record is up to snuff, but this is practically one notch below trying to start beef with yourself.

1. Lifehouse - The Who

Once Tommy became a cultural touchstone, the Who had the entire rock world watching their every move. Since this was one of the first ambitious concept albums by a major rock band, it was only a matter of time before Pete Townshend doubled down and released the record that would show us where rock was going next. Yeah, just reading that last sentence will tell you why the production for Lifehouse fell apart pretty quickly.

Advertisement

Now that you have one of the greatest albums ever created under your belt, how are you expected to do the entire thing again? Well, Townshend looked like he was going to for a little while, with the Lifehouse project coming together as our protagonist Bobby tries to find some sort of salvation through music. Though it seemed to borrow a few cues from Tommy, things seemed to be coming together until Pete suffered a near-mental breakdown trying to explain everything to the band members.

Eventually they decided to scrap the whole thing, using the few songs that were already finished for the album Who's Next. Considering those were the table scraps though, fans have wondered what would have happened if Lifehouse had came out at the time. Pete has made several attempts to recreate the spirit of what he was talking about, but since some of the songs have already seen the light of day, the Lifehouse we know today feels more like a collector's item when looking back on everything.

Advertisement