10 More Bands Who Had Huge Potential (But Wasted It)

They could been massive, but fate had other ideas.

By Jacob Simmons /

Potential is a very strange thing when you think about it. Everybody's got it, in theory, but some seem to have it more than others. However, even if a person or group do have lots of potential, there is no guarantee that it will ever lead to anything.

Advertisement

Nowhere is this more true than in the world of music, where acts with tonnes of promise come and go without leaving even the faintest of marks on the industry. A band can have a huge hit with their first song, get signed to a major label and be promised the world, only to have it all dry up and then be dropped like a bad habit.

The following bands could all have been much bigger than they ended up being, but, for one reason or another, the world just didn't want them to succeed. Some of them made such an impact in such a short time that they are still famous, it's just a case of them not being as famous as they should be.

Of course, there's every chance they make a comeback and finally complete their rise to the top, but for now, they will just have to stay as "what ifs?".

10. Neutral Milk Hotel

As you may have deduced from its offbeat name, Neutral Milk Hotel were an indie band who were first around from 1989 to 1998.

Advertisement

In that time, they released two albums, On Avery Island and In the Aeroplane Over the Sea, neither of which were particularly successful upon their initial release. Everything would change for the band with the advent of one of the most powerful and divisive inventions in human history - the internet.

With the rise of the web in the late '90s and early 2000s, Neutral Milk Hotel’s music began to take off in very unexpected ways. They amassed a sizable cult following, which might seem like a good thing on paper, but would eventually lead to their downfall.

Lead singer Jeff Magnum (which is a sensational name) did not enjoy being famous. His band’s popularity sparked a severe downturn in his mental health, so he called for them to go on hiatus. This break would end up lasting for 15 years.

The band could have easily jumped on the bandwagon of their internet success, but who knows what toll that would have taken on them. Ultimately, they made the right call.

9. Glamour Of The Kill

Formed in 2007 in York - that most famous of rock cities - post-hardcore band Glamour of the Kill made good headway in their early years, touring with the likes of Bullet for My Valentine and Avenged Sevenfold ahead of the release of their first album.

Advertisement

The Summoning came out in 2011 and was given some very good press. Then came the follow-up, 2013’s Savages, which continued these positive trends. However, the good times were not to last.

In 2015, shortly after they had completed tours with Heaven’s Basement and Motionless in White, Glamour of the Kill made the shocking announcement that they were done. In a statement on their Facebook page, the band cited the financial strain of international touring as the main reason for their split and said that there were no plans for them to do anything together for the foreseeable future.

It’s hard to fully argue that this band “wasted” their potential, but if they had managed to make themselves financially viable, there’s every chance they might have been much bigger.

Money isn’t everything, but it sure does help.

8. Jawbreaker

If you were a fan of punk music in the 1990s, chances are you will have been a huge fan of Jawbreaker.

Advertisement

This California band helped usher in the era of emo punk, bringing more emotional stakes to hardcore music in a way that resonated with hundreds of disaffected youngsters. Lead singer Blake Schwartzenbach was a huge cult idol thanks to his deep lyrics and on-stage charisma, and they looked set to break out after their 1994 album 24 Hour Revenge Therapy.

Unfortunately, this would turn out to be a classic case of being careful what one wishes for.

The band’s next album, Dear You, was much more mainstream, the result of them signing a big-money contract with a record label. Their initial passionate fanbase turned against them, accusing them of selling out, and Jawbreaker couldn’t find a new audience to replace them with. They would break up one year later in 1996, bringing a whirlwind few years to a disappointing end.

Jawbreaker lost what made them special once they became a signed artist; a cautionary tale about the dangers of commercialism.

7. Raspberries

The Cranberries. Bananarama. Blind Melon. There is a rich history of fruit-based musical acts, but one that often gets overlooked is the '70s pop rock band Raspberries.

Advertisement

Drawing influence from the British invasion bands that had dominated the previous decades, Raspberries quickly found favour with a younger audience, who saw them as a throwback to the teenybopper age. They put out four albums in five years, a couple of which were chart successes, but decided to call it a day in 1975 after interest in them petered out.

However, their legacy would continue in a number of surprising ways.

There was more to Raspberries than songs about holding hands and drinking milkshakes. Their melodies were far more intricate than anything their contemporaries were producing, with some scholars linking their work to the birth of power pop some years later.

Courtney Love is a big fan of these guys. Who saw that coming?

As with so many other visionary artists, Raspberries were ahead of their time. Whilst that’s a great thing to be in hindsight, it was probably of little comfort to them in the moment.

6. Altar Of Plagues

Ireland is not a country known for its black metal output, but the scene does exist and, at one point, it was home to this band called Altar of Plagues.

Advertisement

They were around from 2006 to 2013, releasing three studio albums in that time. Album number three, Teethed Glory and Injury, was a critical smash, appearing in several year-end lists of the best music of 2013. It even found its way onto Anthony Fantano’s Best Albums of the 2010s list. Now that’s high praise.

Not even the Internet’s Busiest Music Nerd could save this band from going under, as they announced their breakup in the very same year as their most successful record. The decision to split had actually been made before Teethed Glory and Injury had even been written, but it still came as a shock to their legions of fans.

What should really have been a launching pad for this young band actually turned out to be their swansong, which is honestly not a bad way to go out. It would have been nice if there had been some warning, but such is life.

5. Moby Grape

It would have made for a really nice intro if the electronic musician Moby had been named after this band, but alas, that’s not the case.

Advertisement

Moby Grape were a psychedelic rock band from the 1960s who rose up alongside several of the big hitters from that decade’s San Francisco scene. They were initially formed as a sort of offshoot from Jefferson Airplane, but quickly established their own brand of folk-infused rock that went over like crazy with the hippy crowd. They had two successful albums in 1967 and 1968 before things spectacularly fell apart.

Members Bob Mosely and Skip Spence suffered from mental health issues, which caused tensions within the group, and there was also the story of their manager, Matthew Katz. Katz and the Grape didn’t always have the best relationship, with the former famously signing away the rights to the band’s music without consulting them first.

This is a long and sad story of the universe conspiring against one well-meaning group of individuals, but at least the band have now regained the rights to their songs, which is a small victory.

4. Refused

Swedish hardcore punk band Refused were very good at establishing their brand.

Advertisement

They were fiercely left-wing, often writing their anti-establishment views into their music, and were also famously straight edge, which endeared them to an entire subculture of the rock community. They also made great music, which was probably also important.

Refused put out three albums in the 1990s, concluding with 1998’s The Shape of Punk to Come. It was a good album, one that the band were surely going to cement with their upcoming tour, but people at the time just didn’t get it.

The Shape of Punk to Come brought elements of other genres into the band’s work, which did not go over well. The reception to the record was actually so poor that Refused broke up whilst in the middle of the tour to promote it. The final show on the US leg of their tour was so disorganised, that it was actually shut down by the police.

Though they have since gotten back together, Refused have never reached the levels of success they once had. At least they haven’t had any legal trouble for a while.

3. The Seahorses

The previous list on this topic talked about The Stone Roses, a British indie band that could have been megastars in the Britpop era had they stayed together long enough. After the Roses broke up, guitarist John Squire formed a new band called The Seahorses, but the same curse that afflicted his old employers would strike again.

Advertisement

The Seahorses released their singular album, Do It Yourself, in 1997, and the public were big fans. It debuted at number two in the UK charts, as it looked like Squire might finally be getting the dues he had earned in his previous band.

They began recording their second album in 1999, but tensions between Squire and singer Chris Helme quickly got too much. After one argument, Squire walked out of the session and that was that. The Seahorses were done.

Anyone who had been disappointed by The Stone Roses’ fall from grace surely thought they had hit the jackpot when their spiritual successors put out such a strong first release. Imagine the heartache they must have felt when their new favourite band broke for exactly the same reasons as the old one did.

2. New Radicals

The story of the New Radicals is as fascinating as it is head-scratching.

Advertisement

The group was formed as a project of Gregg Alexander and Danielle Brisebois in 1997, with a series of session musicians filling the blank spaces. In October 1998, they put out their first album, Maybe You’ve Been Brainwashed Too, which was followed by the juggernaut of a single that was You Get What You Give.

This ultra-happy tune took the world by storm, as everyone thought they were witnessing the rise of the next big thing. In reality, what they were looking at would turn out to be the end.

Alexander announced in 1999 that New Radicals were done, just two weeks before the planned release of their second single. The singer basically said that he had achieved everything he wanted to with You Get What You Give and didn’t want to be famous anymore.

And that was the end of that.

Brisebois’ opinions on all of this are very hard to track down, but fingers crossed she wasn’t as surprised by this announcement as everyone else was.

1. Steppenwolf

Chances are if you’ve listened to a rock radio station at any point in your life, you’ve heard Born to Be Wild by Steppenwolf.

Advertisement

This rip-roaring number became forever associated with motorcycle culture after its inclusion in the 1969 film Easy Rider. It also marks the first time any rock song featured the term “heavy metal”, which makes it pretty damn important.

So, why is this the only Steppenwolf song anyone has ever heard of? Sure, you can cite something like Magic Carpet Ride, but that’s nowhere near on the same level as this.

Big success led to big arguments amongst the group’s members, particularly singer John Kay and guitarist Michael Monarch. The band announced a retirement tour in 1972, and although they have gotten back together in various combinations, it was never the same.

If its members had been able to keep their egos in check, then Steppenwolf could have been one of the biggest bands of the 1970s and enjoyed many more mega-hits on the same level as Born to Be Wild. Still, with the amount of money that song has made over the years, it’s not like they’ve gone without.

Advertisement