10 Most Important Member Changes In Rock Music History
These substitutions changed rock history for the better.
As anyone who was ever in a band in high school will tell you, members cycle in and out at breakneck speed.
Whether your guitarist's parents moved town or your drummer needed to get his maths grades up, it's easy for a promising young act to lose a vital member early into their run.
But what about if you're already established and have an album or two under your belt? What happens when a member goes AWOL then?
Well, in the case of the following ten bands, you thrive.
These groups all had to find replacements for key members after disaster struck. Creative differences, personal difficulties, and even tragic deaths were responsible for these changes, but they all worked out in the end.
To clarify, we won't be counting any member swaps that happened before a band got big. If we did that then we could choose literally any band that ever existed and just talk about when their original bassist left to get a job at the post office.
Instead, we're focusing on acts who were forced to make substitutions when they were already famous and ended up excelling as a result.
10. Justin Chancellor Replaces Paul D’Amour - Tool
American rock band/professional fan-frustraters Tool first formed in 1990 as a four-piece. Maynard James Keenan was the singer, Adam Jones was on guitars, Danny Carey was on drums, and Paul D'Amour was on bass.
The group's first album Undertow was a decent record that stood out nicely against the backdrop of grunge and pop punk. However, the band really took things to new heights with their next release - the much-revered Ænima.
In all this time, has anyone worked out how to actually say that word? Or what it means? Didn't think so.
Someone who certainly won't know is D'Amour, as he left the band before it was recorded. He claims that he wanted a bigger role in the group and that he didn't want to get stuck playing bass.
Thankfully, a man who was more than happy to pluck the four strings was Justin Chancellor, D'Amour's replacement. Chancellor quickly became a key part of Tool's set-up and the band switched around their style to include more of his bass work in their songs.
Considering how important that sound is to Tool these days, this was 100% the right call.
9. Rod Stewart & Ronnie Wood Replace Steve Marriott - Faces
The late Steve Marriott is widely regarded as one of the most underrated singers in rock history.
With his band Small Faces, Marriott won over legions of fans with songs like Itchycoo Park, Lazy Sunday, and Tin Soldier. Then, just when the band were reaching their apex, Marriott quit the band in dramatic fashion by storming off stage at a New Year's Eve gig.
Maybe he was just in a hurry to watch the fireworks?
This left the band in a bit of a tight spot. Marriott was easily the most popular member of the group, so they'd need to bring in a future legend to replace him. As it turns out, they brought in two.
Singer Rod Stewart and guitarist Ronnie Wood were both formerly members of The Jeff Beck Group. They teamed up with the original Small Faces line-up, dropping the "Small" part of their name to carry on as just Faces to great success.
Wood would go on to join The Rolling Stones in 1975 and as for Rod, well he's that weird old bloke your aunt always screams for when he comes on the telly.
8. John Frusciante & Chad Smith Replace DeWayne McKnight & D. H. Peligro - Red Hot Chili Peppers
This is the first example on this list of the people being replaced not being who you thought they were.
The original RHCP line-up was singer Anthony Kiedis, bassist Michael Balzary (or Flea, as he's better known), guitarist Hilel Slovak, and drummer Jack Irons.
Forming in 1983 (yes, the Chilis really are that old), this was their most famous arrangement until the fateful year of 1988.
Slovak died of a heroin overdose that Summer, tearing a deep hole in the band. Kiedis was so rocked by his friend's death that he skipped town and didn't even attend the funeral. As for Irons, Slovak's passing shook him so much that he left the band altogether.
The Peppers needed to find two new members or face extinction. Their short-term solutions were DeWayne McKnight and D. H. Peligro, but they soon made way for the names you all know and love - guitarist John Frusciante and drummer Chad Smith.
This is the most popular line-up of the band and the one that reunited in 2019. It's also the line-up that saved them and the one that we have to thank for so much incredible music.
7. Mike Patton Replaces Chuck Mosley - Faith No More
Rap metal, nu metal, funk metal, call them what you will, just call Faith No More a success.
The band were one of the forerunners of alternative rock in the 1980s, paving the way for the genre's explosion in the following decade. But this wasn't always how things were for them.
They actually started off a post-punk band, then had a brief stint with Courtney Love at the helm, before settling on vocalist Chuck Mosley for their first two albums.
However, things were not all smiles and rainbows for dear old Chucky.
Mosley began acting erratically in 1988, allegedly punching bandmate Billy Gould on stage and falling asleep during a release party for one of their records. This all proved too much and Mosley was let go.
In came Mike Patton, lead singer of a high school band called Mr. Bungle. Within two weeks of joining, Patton has written most of the lyrics to their biggest album yet, The Real Thing.
The rest, as they say, is history.
Patton's writing, vocal delivery, and stage presence all contributed to the massive success Faith No More experienced in the years following his arrival.
6. Travis Barker Replaces Scott Raynor - Blink-182
Before he inexplicably married a Kardashian, Travis Barker was the drummer for the man-children-in-chief Blink-182.
He joined up with Mark Hoppus and Tom DeLonge in 1998, first appearing on the beloved album Enema of the State. Over the years, he's contributed to such Blink hits as What's My Age Again?, All The Small Things, I Miss You, and Adam's Song.
He was brought in because original drummer Scott Raynor was developing alcohol problems in the late 1990s. Spare a though for poor Scott though, as he'd joined the band when he was just 14, meaning he was only 20 when these problems came around.
Everyone would struggle with that sort of fame at such a young age.
Unfortunately though, Raynor had to go, and Barker was drafted in. The first time the trio ever played together, the drummer learned an entire 20-song setlist in just 45 minutes.
Since gaining increased attention as part of Blink, Barker has drummed for numerous other bands, become a highly sought-after producer, worked as a model and designer, and, we cannot stress this enough, somehow married Kourtney Kardashian.
Can somebody please explain again how that happened? Slowly.
5. Brian Johnson Replaces Bon Scott - AC/DC
On the 19th of February 1980, the rock and metal community lost of one of its brightest sparks.
Bon Scott, lead singer with the preposterously successful AC/DC, passed away in London as a result of acute alcohol poisoning. This tragic event came just six months after the release of Highway to Hell, the album that spawned the iconic lead single and countless other gems.
AC/DC were at a loose end. They even considered packing it all in, until Scott's own parents convinced them otherwise. It's not what Bon would have wanted, they said.
After a series of auditions, the band found their new singer in the form of Newcastle native Brian Johnson. And oh baby, did things get interesting after that.
Johnson's first album with the band was only Back in bloody Black. The track listing reads like a greatest hits for the rockers: Shoot to Thrill, Hells Bells, You Shook Me All Night Long, the title track. All of them gold.
Scott's legacy still lives on in the hearts and minds of fans, but Johnson more than stepped up to the plate when it came to filling the shoes of a legend gone too soon.
4. Kirk Hammett Replaces Dave Mustaine - Metallica
Now, we're cheating ever so slightly on this one as technically Dave Mustaine left Metallica before their first album was released.
However, if you check the credits on Kill 'Em All, you'll find his name next to a few songs.
That's because Mustaine was the band's original guitarist and helped contribute to the album during its early stages. Then, he was fired from the group for excessive drug taking and alleged violent behaivour.
Whoops.
So Mustaine was gone, but his influence can still be felt on the debut album. He's credited on the songs The Four Horsemen, Jump in the Fire, Phantom Lord, and Metal Militia. All the others - that's pure Hammett, baby!
Kirk Hammett was recruited from a band called Exodus and fit right into the established line-up. He contributed guitar parts to the entire rest of the album and has remained a constant fixture of Metallica ever since.
Just don't ask Mustaine about him - the scorned ex-guitarist once claimed Hammett "stole" his job.
Don't feel too bad for him though, as he went on to found the band Megadeth and do rather well for himself there.
3. Lindsey Buckingham & Stevie Nicks Replace Bob Welch - Fleetwood Mac
It's easy to forget that Fleetwood Mac had a life before the album Rumours.
The group was founded by Peter Green, John Spencer, and Mick Fleetwood (after whom it's named) who added John McVie to the line-up in time for their 1968 debut album.
Over the next decade or so, the members chopped and changed. By 1974, the band consisted of Fleetwood, McVie, his wife Christine, and guitar player Bob Welch.
After a troubled recording process for the album Heroes Are Hard to Find, Welch left the band after falling out with the McVies. The group were facing turmoil yet again, until their prayers were answered one day in a recording studio.
Upon entering the venue, the group heard the song Frozen Love playing over the speakers. Eventually, they found out the tune they liked so much was the product of a young couple - Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks.
After Buckingham and Nicks were added to the band, Fleetwood Mac really hit it big. The first album to the feature the classic line-up was a total smash with Rumours following on just two years later.
Funny how fate works sometimes.
2. Dave Grohl Replaces Dan Peters - Nirvana
You might not think that Nirvana were around long enough to have a line-up change, but they did and it was a big one.
Kurt Cobain and Krist Novoselic first recruited the drummer Aaron Burckhard to play with them in 1987. Then came Dale Crover, then Dave Foster, before Chad Channing stuck around long enough to whack the skins on the band's debut album Bleach.
Sadly for double C, Kurt and Krist just weren't that into him. To be fair, he wasn't thrilled about being left out of the songwriting process either. As a result, Channing was gone and Nirvana needed yet another new drummer.
Dan Peters, who played in a band called Mudhoney, filled in on a single called Sliver that came out in 1990. Then, the group were introduced to a young drummer whose band Scream had just broken up.
Hello, Dave Grohl.
Grohl stayed behind the kit for the rest of the band's existence, playing on their two biggest albums Nevermind and In Utero, as well as their heralded MTV Unplugged release.
After Cobain's tragic death, Grohl went on to form his own band. And they were called... come on, do you really need to be told?
1. Bruce Dickinson Replaces Paul Di’Anno - Iron Maiden
Bruce Dickinson is so synonymous with Iron Maiden these days that it's hard to imagine they ever released an album without him on it.
Well, get ready for this - they released two of them!
The band's self-titled debut release came out in 1980 on EMI Records. Leading the charge was singer Paul Di'Anno, who had been introduced to bassist Steve Harris by Maiden drummer Doug Sampson.
Di'Anno's raw vocal sound helped create the mixture of punk and metal that the band were after and the first album became an underground hit. The album Killers quickly followed suit, as did a live EP called Maiden Japan.
Then, in a tale as old as time, Di'Anno was fired for unprofessional behaviour and drug usage.
And in came Brucey.
Dickinson's first appearance on a Maiden record was only the megahit The Number of the Beast. The new singer's wailing vocals added a whole new dimension to the act and he's been there ever since, bar a six-year hiatus in the 90s.
The voice of so many of their best songs, Bruce Dickinson and Iron Maiden are a match made in Heaven... or should that be Hell?