10 One-Hit Wonders Who Deserved A Second Hit

Excuse me, may I have another?

By Jacob Trowbridge /

For all of its streetwise corniness, Eminem's "Lose Yourself" did get one thing right: In the music business, you only get one shot. So you really cannot miss your chance to blow. (This opportunity comes once in a lifetime...and so on and so forth.) Unfortunately, even when an artist does in fact "blow" (in the good way) on their first shot, it doesn't necessarily mean the public is going to embrace them in the future. Thus...one-hit wonders. Those poor souls who get just a taste of fame before being unceremoniously booted off the face of the pop music landscape for the rest of their careers. Of course, that's not to say these musicians all just stop doing their thing. Some of them go on to have low-key, modestly successful careers. But others do throw in the towel soon after their sudden drop in popularity. And that's a shame. Because in retrospect, we realize that some of these artists had a wealth of talent, but we just couldn't/didn't want to see it at the time. Some of them truly deserved that ever-elusive second hit. Oh, and because the term "one hit wonder" can be a little misleading, for the purposes of this article, it's defined as any artist who was able to climb their way to the Top 40 on the charts, but were unable to repeat that feat a second time around, and had very little lasting success in the industry from then on.

Advertisement

10. Patti Smith

All right, so this is actually a bit of a cheat, because A) this was technically with "the Patti Smith Group" and B) she did show up in the Top 40 again in 1996 guesting on R.E.M.'s "E-Bow the Letter" and C) this is Patti freaking Smith and calling her a one-hit wonder is cruel and disingenuous. Still, "Because the Night" was really the first and only time we saw Smith recognized for her abilities as a performer. Until that point, she'd been known as the more poetic of the CBGB crowd, though she somehow failed to catch on with the "regular folks" like the Ramones and Blondie. But thanks to the Springsteen penned "Because the Night" and its symphonic crossover appeal, Smith was able to grab a quick shot of commercial success. But don't think for a second that Smith sold out her punk roots. After all, the same album that featured "Because the Night" also had a song called "Rock and Roll N--ger." No, for a beautiful (and all-too-brief) moment in 1978, Patti Smith pushed the limits of pop music and made the radio come to her. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sSdwpSuohk8

9. Wild Cherry

Even though the band's most famous hit became a rallying cry for the dorkiest of all Caucasians, Wild Cherry had an undeniable knack for crafting deliciously tight groove. There were certainly better funk bands than Wild Cherry, and better funk songs than "Play That Funky Music," but that shouldn't take away from their craftsmanship. Equal parts Sly Stone and Hot Chocolate, there's no denying that they had enough soul and swagger to carry even their more underwhelming tunes. Trying to capitalize on the public's surprise at finding out the members of Wild Cherry were white dudes, they released a follow-up single, "Baby Don't You Know," which was basically a collection of boasts about how they sounded blacker than you'd think. Not surprisingly, it didn't catch on quite as well. But future albums, which kept the funky overtones while splicing in some signature disco elements, should have rivaled The Bee Gees. Instead, they just kind of faded into oblivion. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_eMoRO_qGU

8. Spacehog

The 90s alt-rockers from New York scored big with their spacey brand of bombastic rock. With the exception of some mildly fuzzy guitar riffs, Spacehog was about as far away from the grunge sound that you could get in the mid-90s, yet they were still tacitly tied to the post-grunge genre thanks to their one big hit, "In the Meantime." They did have at least one thing in common with Nirvana, though: Both bands were heavily influenced by David Bowie and The Beatles. (Then again...aren't all bands?) The rest of Spacehog's debut album, Resident Alien, sounds like a Bowie tribute album funneled through a power pop sensibility. It was basically a collection of Ziggy-inspired party music. It was rad as hell. Unfortunately, the band's next two singles would place the emphasis squarely on the alt-rock side of their sound, and while "Cruel to Be Kind" (confusingly not a cover) and "Space Is the Place" are decent rockers, it doesn't quite capture their true essence. But 1998's "Mungo City" had much more of a glam-rock bent...and pretty much fell on its face. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E8Rwvwu3RrE

7. Marcy Playground

Marcy Playground enjoyed some very brief success as a post-grunge also-ran, releasing the melancholic single "Sex and Candy," which was just cheeky enough to stand out from their peers' sludgy offerings. But they quickly faded away, with the popularity of their hit single often attributed to its moderately scandalous subject matter. But that's simply not accurate or fair. Because Marcy Playground were incredibly adept at writing sharp-edged, fuzzily melodic tunes. It just so happens they came along at a time that was more focused on soaring balladry than tightly-crafted rock songs. In a different era, songs like "Saint Joe on the School Bus" (from their debut album) and "Bye Bye" (from their follow-up, Shapeshifter) would have been inescapable hits. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QPWZZ4QaSQ0

6. Augustana

Perhaps unfairly lumped in with the other brooding piano songwriters of the mid-aughts (Keane, The Fray, Snow Patrol), California-based Augustana fell victim to the typical curse of the record industry: Release a song that sounds like whatever is currently being played on the radio, watch the song skyrocket up the charts, then stand back as the general public quickly fatigues of the once-popular sound now eternally linked to the band. But, breakthrough hit "Boston" aside (which was actually re-recorded as a radio single), much of the band's debut album is grittier and less polished than their supposed peers. To use a Coldplay analogy (since every major critic of the band did), Augustana was less X&Y and more Parachutes. Unfortunately, the band's follow-up album was briskly shoved aside, and they reacted by producing one of the schmaltziest soft rock offerings of the recent past with their third release, firmly losing any chance of coming back bigger and better after a sophomore slump. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TMoKI02WgIg

5. Mountain

Despite being credited as a major influence in the development of heavy metal, hard rockers Mountain were never to achieve much success on the charts, even when heavy metal was burning them up. (Contrasting their success with Black Sabbath is an exercise in serious bumming.) But hey, at least 10 percent of current rock music fans have heard of "Mississippi Queen." That...has to be a consolation, right? (Although they likely only know that because the song was featured in a Rock band game.) Mountain deserves a better legacy than that. At worse, they at least deserved a second hit song. They were experts at mixing blues and hard rock, sounding like a looser Foghat with a pinch of Grand Funk Railroad thrown in for good measure. And if that doesn't sound like a winning combination, then you're clearly an insane person. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-8ZbOO9V0ak

4. Fool's Garden

Of all the artists on this list, Fool's Garden has dealt with their one-hit wonder status the greatest aplomb, taking the label in stride while releasing no fewer than 20 singles and 9 albums -- one as recently as 2015 -- since they had a surprise hit with "Lemon Tree." They don't care that most people will only know them from the quirky, Baroque pop hit from 1995. And according to lead singer Peter Freudenthaler, it could have turned out much worse for them:
€œWhat we have experienced with this song was awesome. Better to be a one-hit wonder than a Never Hit Wonder."
That's a pretty rosy outlook to have on the whole ordeal, especially considering that far too many would barely remember "Lemon Tree" if they heard it today. That's now quickly it flashed in the pan. It's unforgivable that this incredibly talented German pop band hasn't experienced, at the very least, a Ringo Starr level of success in the intervening years. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U-SpbqDqkaY

3. American Hi-Fi

Remembered as the modest creators behind the ironically forgettable "Flavor of the Weak," American Hi-Fi were unfortunately lumped in with summery pop-punk bands like Yellowcard and All-American Rejects before being unceremoniously dumped off the face of the earth, at least in the eyes of the general public. What's most unfair about their (rather rude) placement into the one-hit wonder category is that the bulk of their eponymous debut didn't sound much like the bland (but pleasing) pop-punk of that lead single. In fact, it's one of the best all-around rock and roll albums to be released in 2001. Sadly, it came at a time when we needed it the most (we were in the throes of nu metal, boy bands, and butt rock) but were also most unwilling to have it. Basically, American Hi-Fi may not have been the band we deserved, but it was the one we needed at the time. Any other song from that album, in a more reasonable era, would have at least matched the popularity of "Flavor of the Weak." Frontman Stacy Jones went on to become the drummer for Miley Cyrus, though, so at least he got another small taste of fame. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=woi55j7mZrE

2. New Radicals

Sure, New Radicals sounded like a bunch of pensive white boys who were trying too hard to sound threatening on their debut single. ("Come around, we'll kick your ass in!" remains one of the most unintentionally hilarious lyrics of the modern age.) But dammit, New Radicals were tight as hell. And their one and only album, Maybe You've Been Brainwashed Too, was an album that stood out from the muddled pop-rock bands of the time. They had a weirdly sexy vibe in most of their songs, incorporating a lot of classic rock elements and 70s soul into their melodies. And, in a weird twist for the typically downtrodden alt-rock of the 90s, they always sounded...happy. They went on to have moderate success with a follow-up single, the piano-driven "Someday We'll Know," but the band dissolved quickly afterward, with frontman Gregg Alexander saying he "lost interest in fronting a one-hit wonder." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ff0wgizErKQ

1. Harvey Danger

Raise your hand if you can remember a song by Harvey Danger not called "Flagpole Sitta." (No help from Google, either.) Got one? Awesome, then let me just say how exciting it is to know that one of the band member's parents reads WhatCulture! They were peppier than most people realized, with a lot of their music sounding closer to Ben Folds and Presidents of the United States than the harder-rocking bands they were often compared to. And that's not a bad thing...as long as you're not expecting a dozen more Flagpole Sittas on the record. Then you might be kinda bummed. The public weren't interested in hearing the rest of their dork rock stylings, however, and Harvey Danger eventually went the way of so many other misrepresented alt-rock "darlings" of the 90s.