Let's get this out of the way: your favourite weird band is not on this list. Like the music business that spawned it, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame is a political animal. A list of obscure bands that you've just got to hear would be missing the point. So, sorry, no Husker Du for you. It's the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, not the College Music Journal. Keeping the nature of the institution in mind, this is a list of popular bands or artists who have yet to be inducted into the prestigious Hall. Some may find their way. Some will leave you saying, "Keep dreaming." Some were just put here to annoy That Metal Show's Eddie Trunk. The performers listed here not only had successful careers, but paved the way for others, including some who have already made it into the Hall. So draw the ace of spades and get ready for a magic carpet ride, because the boys are back in town.
10. Tom Jones
There are few things more rock n' roll than having to dodge women's undergarments. Tom Jones has been doing it for half a century. Granted, they're much baggier now, but that shouldn't diminish Jones's legacy. A husky baritone with an old-fashioned, macho swagger, Jones's take on rock n' roll combines his love of soul with his Welsh, folk music heritage. He's had hits in nearly every decade since he began, yet remains largely a guilty pleasure. Being a running gag on The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air probably didn't help matters either. You don't have to search through deep cuts to understand why he's good. Radio hits like "She's a Lady" and "It's Not Unusual" exemplify Jones's infectious approach. If pop songs were food, his would be hard candy. Many pop stars of his time used similar arrangements, combining horns and strings with a more traditional rock sound, mixing Glenn Miller with Chuck Berry. In the pop rock genre though, it's the singer who matters most, and Jones's rumble resonates more than any of his contemporaries.
9. Steppenwolf
Among the longest overdue for induction is Steppenwolf, not only for their musical acumen, but for their contribution to the culture at large. The opening bars of "Born To Be Wild" are familiar to anyone who hasn't been living under a rock for the past fifty years, never mind it's been used to score movies, sell cars and make yuppies look hip at karaoke parties. Singer/songwriter John Kay, taking a cue from William Burroughs, made history by making it the first mention of the words "heavy metal" in a musical composition. Its use in "Easy Rider" is so iconic, it's easy to forget how great the song actually is. Like every overplayed classic, it was so good it had to become lame. Steppenwolf touched the culture in other ways, too, with songs like "Magic Carpet Ride" and "The Pusher," which showed both sides of the emergent drug culture of the sixties. "Magic Carpet Ride" is light as a feather, a catchy number just as suitable for driving around with the top down as it is in your uncle's smoking room. "The Pusher," written by Hoyt Axton feels like a funeral dirge, but is actually a cautionary tale about harder drugs. Steppenwolf were more than a rock band. They were storytellers.
8. Deep Purple
"Smoke On The Water" has been dissected by critics, played badly by teenagers, and even rearranged by Richie Blackmore himself in songs like "Man On The Silver Mountain." Like the best rock riffs it has become part of the culture at large, becoming as recognisable as Beethoven - everyone can hum along to it. The band are essential to the history of rock n' roll composition; keyboardist John Lord made church organs cool, and eventually led to a split between two rock camps, those who eschew keyboards in rock, and those who love them. The band has had a number of good lineups and two great ones. Deep Purple Mark II featured the great Ian Gillian on vocals, and released not only "Smoke On the Water," but "Highway Star," "My Woman From Tokyo," and the undeniable "Speed King." The Mark IV lineup introduced included bassist Glenn Hughes, and launched singer David Coverdale into superstardom; one listen to the deep blues of "Mistreated," and you'll understand why. Deep Purple is as important to heavy metal as Led Zeppelin or Black Sabbath, and won't be denied for much longer.
7. Thin Lizzy
Henry Rollins once referred to Thin Lizzy singer Phil Lynott as his "road man," a singer whose words and voice can remind you of home, no matter where you are, no matter what your circumstances. It's true. Keep the Jailbreak album in your car or on your mp3 player, and you'll know. On your worst day, Lynott's voice is like that of an old friend's - one who's been there the whole time. Lynott drew upon several traditions to produce a sound that remains unique, even on classic rock stations. Thin Lizzy's instrumentation is pure seventies rock; powerful, up front, loud. The band's melodic approach on the other hand was steeped not only in early rock n' roll and Motown, but in the catchy harmonies of Irish folk songs. The early Lizzy albums were mellower than you'd expect, but once they permitted themselves to crank up the volume, their newer, harder sound was unmatched. They approached rock from a completely different angle, and influenced scores of bands thereafter.
6. Captain Beefheart
Like all musicians, Don Van Vliet began his quest as a music fan, especially when it came to the blues. His obsession with singers like Howlin' Wolf as well as a talent for mimicry led him to record early singles like Bo Diddley's "Diddy Wah Diddy." Close your eyes and you'll swear you're hearing one of Van Vliet's influences, rather than the man who would become Captain Beefheart. Along with the Velvet Underground and his childhood friend Frank Zappa, Beefheart and his Magic Band were largely responsible for creating the alternative rock genre, about thirty years before record companies figured out how to market the stuff. Trout Mask Replica is his masterpiece, an excursion into time signatures so odd they put progressive rock bands to shame, and melodies more dissonant than most punk bands. Bizarre songs like "Frownland" and "Dachau Blues" are delivered with Beefheart's trademark howl, which had by now developed into its own beast. It's loud and weird and hard to listen to, and that's exactly the point. If your Melvins-obsessed friends can't groove to this, get new friends.
5. Boston
The more you look into Boston's history, the more enigmatic the band becomes. They were far more than the radio-friendly hit-fest you hear on classic rock stations. Tom Scholz, Boston's founding member and mastermind, invented the guitar pedals that gave the band their signature sound. He had already received a bachelor's and master's from MIT, and was the senior product design engineer for Polaroid when he and his bandmates recorded the demos that would lead to the first Boston album. To this day, he shuns the limelight of stardom even though he led one of the most popular bands of the seventies - the rare type whose singles are still played and loved. It makes sense though; this is the band that defined the "corporate rock" sound carried on by bands like Styx and Journey. Rock fans were looking for something new in 1976, and Boston gave it to them. Their first album sold 17 million copies, an unheard-of feat for a new band - so if you're wondering why your classic rock station still plays "More Than a Feeling," there you go. They're a lot like Rush in a way, the kind of band that's adored by its fans, but utterly loathed by detractors. Listen to Boston enough, though, and their sound will eventually win you over. It may take minutes or decades, but it will happen.
4. Meat Loaf
"The sirens are screaming and the fires are howling way down in the valley tonight..." No one writes lyrics like Jim Steinman, and no one sings them like Marvin Lee Aday, a.k.a. Meat Loaf, the seventies' least likely candidate for a rock heartthrob. After years opening for psychedelic rock bands like Them and Janis Joplin, Meat Loaf gained some notoriety for his perfomance of "Hot Patootie" in The Rocky Horror Picture Show. When that film developed its unique cult (spawning the midnight movie tradition in the process), music fans noticed that Meat Loaf not only had the best song in the film, but the best voice. There had to be enough Meat Loaf to go around, right? (Sorry). Enter Steinman, a rock n' roll Gershwin who could make fire and brimstone out of fast cars and faster girls. Steinman became Meat Loaf's muse, and the end product was Bat Out of Hell, an album that mixed low culture with high art, long before that sort of thing was hip. The album is a melting pot of influences, yet still pulls off an original sound, owing a debt to early Springsteen, country and western ballads and of all things, baseball metaphors. It was all carried out by Meat Loaf's trademark voice, an operatic wail that rings in the memory, as well as the ears, long after it's left your speakers. The pair parted ways and reunited a few times later, notably for the Bat Out of Hell sequel and the monster hit "I Would Do Anything for Love (But I Won't Do That)," a song so enigmatic, it took an M&M's commercial to tell us what it actually meant.
3. Motörhead
So thrash fans got Metallica in. Pity we can't get Diamond Head in, too, but wouldn't it be nice if the Hall recognised at least one of the two "heads" of proto-thrash? The original Motörhead, umlauts and all, was a trio of rockers desperate to do something new with the genre. They were the first band of their kind, a hard rock Frankenstein monster with Little Richard's heart, Dick Dale's feet, and Lenny Bruce's brain. They were thrash metal before such a term had been thought of, speed metal in every sense of the word. Their biggest hit "Ace of Spades" is just as immediately recognisable as "Smoke on the Water," albeit a bit more shall we say, upbeat? Lemmy Kilmeister - the band's leader - has soldiered on for decades, leading various lineups into the present day. He has has guested on songs by Slash and Dave Grohl, showing that even now the master has much to show his students. He also co-wrote Ozzy Osbourne's No More Tears album, which resulted in a much larger audience for his own band. (They both did their own versions of the song "Hellraiser," but Motorhead went one further, producing a music video that featured Lemmy beating horror-villain Pinhead at cards.) Documentaries and biographies of Lemmy's life have cemented his legacy of hard work and love of music, and a spot in the Hall wouldn't get him to slow down but it would be a kind gesture to a band that influenced nearly every band that's heard them.
2. Ice-T
Tracy Marrow was an ex-soldier and criminal when he heard the song that changed his life. He was already a fan of early rap bands like the Sugarhill Gang, and had even tried his own hand at rapping, but it was Schoolly D's "P.S.K. What Does It Mean?" that turned Marrow into Ice-T, the inevitable amalgam of Johnny Cash and Gil Scott-Heron. Sire Records signed Ice-T after its head, Seymour Stein, compared his confessional style to Bob Dylan's. Rhyme Pays, the first hip-hop album to feature a parental advisory label, went gold, immediately proving the theory that Tipper stickers actually helped sell the very records the PMRC wanted banned. He was asked by Dennis Hopper to write the theme song to Colors, a film about Los Angeles cops dealing with gang violence, a subject close to Ice-T's heart. He began to act in films like New Jack City, paving the way for future rapper-actor hyphenates. He started a hardcore punk/metal band in Body Count, whose song "Cop Killer" sparked moral outrage from vice president Dan Quayle and professional dung-stirrers like the NRA (that's how you know it's a great song). The racially-tinged backlash prompted Ice-T to compare himself to writers and filmmakers who portray acts of violence - also proving that many of the higher-ups don't know the difference between punk and hip-hop. Ice-T is perhaps best known as a TV cop now (oh, the irony), but his scar on the music industry can't be ignored. The Hall has inducted rap bands before, recognising early hip-hop's contribution to pop music and culture. It only makes sense that the poet-laureate of vice and criminality get in.
1. Faith No More
Even today, there's no one quite like Faith No More. From their snotty "We Care a Lot" salad days, to the epic peak of The Real Thing, to their inevitable, 'too-good-to-last' breakup, they defied convention, being as much alternative show 120 Minutes to rock-lovers Headbanger's Ball. The band used a multicoloured palette like no one had in popular music, always surprising listeners by mixing pop, metal, rap, techno, country, soul, and even a film score. It should have sounded like spam, but worked perfectly and signalled the rise of alternative rock into the mainstream. They were the single most exicting thing to happen to music in the late eighties and early nineties, lighting the way to change until their breakup in 1998. It's a shame they haven't recorded a new album, there were dozens of imitators in their wake, prompting the most recent lineup to reunite for some live dates a few years ago, before all reverting back to quiet since then. Faith No More weren't as accessible as Jane's Addiction or the Red Hot Chili Peppers, but they were far more interesting musically, the vanguards of the avant garde. We'll even forgive them for inspiring nu-metal if they can just put out one more album.