10 Ridiculously Good Third Albums

By Ben Timpson /

The third album has long been seen as a difficult hurdle for a band/artist to successfully clear. Usually having been together for years before recording a debut and therefore have enough material to fill the first couple with tried and tested, great songs. When it comes to record number three, the well is often dry. The following is ten examples of a big middle finger to the dreaded, "third album curse". There already exists a million articles in cyberspace on such wonderful third albums like 'III' by Led Zeppelin, 'Master Of Puppets' by Metallica, 'Reign In Blood' by Slayer, 'OK Computer' by Radiohead etc, so please appreciate my slight deviation from the usual suspects. Maybe you will discover something new with the selections I have made. Also, please feel free to comment and leave suggestions of your own, I welcome your opinions and, I will maybe gain some musical education too. I present these in no order, other than placing them as I felt I was ready to write about them.

10. Unwritten Law - Unwritten Law 1998

When San Diego's punk band Unwritten Law released their third full length release, they decided to self-title it because of a new sound that saw them go from an-above-average skate-punk band, to a great SoCal punk influenced, Rock and Roll machine. They would fully complete the transformation four years later, on the stellar, 'Elva', which is one of the most engaging and versatile Rock records ever released. In 1998, it was all about this one though. The album keeps the hyper speed of earlier outings, 'Blue Room' and 'Oz Factor', on tracks like 'Harmonic', 'Coffin Text' and 'Close Your Eyes', but are ultimately, tighter and played with oodles more confidence and ability. You also have energetic tracks that aren't quite as fast that the "law" seem to excel at, such as 'Teenage Suicide' and 'California Sky', both being huge fan favorites. The band always had incorporated loads of melody, from the word go, but they perfected it here and wouldn't look back on using it as their finest asset. Singer, Scott Russo, had really grown into his voice by this point and was now a larger-than-life presence. This collection also saw a new found groove come into being, on the likes of 'Lonesome', and Underground', that gave the band a facet that was absent previously. The beautiful 'Cailin' (an ode to Russo's daughter of the same name) is the albums center piece and has a shimmering, summery and almost dubby feel, kind of like Marcy Playground, Sprung Monkey and Sublime all mixed into a refreshing, fruity cocktail. 'Before I Go' is equally as gorgeous, but also, much more reflective and sultry. It is the summer night to 'Cailin's', summer day. The hidden track, tagged on at the end, '418' is a surprise and shows the band becoming more and more diverse, with its mystical and hypnotising quality. Brandon Boyd and Mike Eizinger of fellow San Diego superstars, Incubus, guest here, with Boyd even adding some didgeridoo to proceedings, it really works. This album raised UL's profile massively and also was the beginning of their two way love affair with Australia, that endures to the present day.

9. In Utero - Nirvana 1993

"Teenage angst has paid off well, now I'm bored and old!" This is the album that Kurt Cobain had always wanted to make. It had taken the runaway success of world-changing second album, 'Nevermind', to show him what he really needed to see, and the result was these painfully frank, and at times, hard to listen to twelve tracks. Enlisting Steve Albini, to produce the record was in reaction to the very polished sound that Butch Vig and Andy Wallace had produced and mixed respectively, on 'Nevermind'. Cobain, deliberately wanted to make a much rawer sounding album whilst taking listeners to more extremes than had been explored on the aforementioned. He wanted the poppier songs to be poppier and the harder songs to be, well, just that. What was important was getting a really live sound. Albini and the band had set the goal of getting all the recording done in two weeks, so as not to over analyse everything, and just capture the right takes. The drums are a huge factor in getting the desired sound, choosing not to use the close mic-ed drum tracks, and using the room ambient room mic recordings only. It works a treat and really makes the whole sound, much more organic. Tracks like Serve the Servants, Scentless Apprentice and Very Ape all sound brilliantly edgy and real. The new approach to recording makes the softer songs, Heart Shaped Box, Pennyroyal Tea and All Apologies, sound much more human and poignant. There was discontent from the label, Geffen Records, that was rumored to be an underlying disappointment at not getting another 'Nevermind', but David Geffen himself stated to the media - "Of course, we'd release anything the band submitted to us." There is a real Punk Rock atmosphere that was definitely lacking in the predecessor's sonic sheen. Pleasing that Cobain got to deliver this great, third album, as less than seven months later, he was found dead.

8. Kids In Glass Houses - In Gold Blood 2011

Who? Why? I'll tell you why - This album is an absolutely cracking rock record. That's it. No message, no revolutionary affect on music, just engaging Rock songs, played by five lads from Wales. The band appeared to have been their own worst enemy in some ways. Allowing themselves, with their first two albums, to be painted into the pop-rock corner, championed mainly by early to mid teen-aged girls, that is also trying to be escaped from by the likes of You Me At Six and Deaf Havana, among others. Whether or not they meant this is irrelevant, as now they refused to do what was expected of them. Before it's release, 'In Gold Blood', claimed to be (by singer, Aled Phillips) "a concept record, a big, grown-up record. It's going to document a jourey." Although it was critically well received, with writers acknowledging the band's progression and obvious maturing and a healthy push by label, Roadrunner, it all failed to translate on a commercial level. The album seemed to shed KIGH the same amount of fans that it gained them. The outgoing ones couldn't grow with the band and the incoming ones were different, older, more appreciative of this new found, big Rock dynamic. It was a brave gamble and one that didn't pay off as well as one listen through the eleven tracks, demonstrates it should have. They now weren't boy-band-with-guitars enough for some but still had that stigma attached to their name for the more, "serious" music fan. For those that don't care and just love great music, this album is a great reward. 'Animals' was the lead single and is a raucous call to arms, with a swaggering riff, cocky vocal delivery and full of stadium sized attitude. The addition of soulful, black female vocals just shows that the band were out for maximum delivery. Elsewhere, the addition of brass and rumbling, dirty bass lines, Slash-like guitar solos peppered throughout the songs shows the band had been looking to timeless, classic rock records for inspiration. If, for example, Queens of the Stone Age had released this, it would have been heralded as the second coming. The band still managed to be a healthy live draw, but it was on the same circuit they have been frequenting for the last couple of album cycles, when it should have been arenas. Check your pre-conceptions at the door, listen without prejudice and tell me you don't feel the same. The music industry is a nasty business and this just adds to the many injustices.

7. U2 - War 1983

Against a backdrop of unrest and warfare, U2 reacted with their third album, which was much more direct and harsher, both lyrically and musically, than their first two outings, 'Boy' and 'October'. It proved to be a pivotal decision in the band's development and legacy. In an interview with NME, Bono said at the time, shortly after recording the album - "War seemed to be the motif for 1982," adding that "Everywhere you looked, from the Falklands to the Middle East and South Africa, there was war. By calling the album War we're giving people a slap in the face and at the same time getting away from the cosy image a lot of people have of U2." Guitarist, The Edge added - "It's a heavy title. It's blunt. It's not something that's safe, so it could backfire. It's the sort of subject matter that people can really take a dislike to. But we wanted to take a more dangerous course, fly a bit closer to the wind, so I think the title is appropriate." Opening song "Sunday Bloody Sunday" (written about the ubiquitous trouble in Northern Ireland) is all staccato drums (reminiscent of machine gun fire) and call and response vocals that still is very affecting and acts as a very sobering few moments in their live set, where it remains an ever present. Other highlights include the sublime 'New Years Day', with that keyboard riff and the choppy love song, 'Two Hearts Beat as One'. 'War' captures the band at the pinnacle of their Post-Punk phase and the album's fourth track 'Like A Song...', addresses those that criticized the band for not being "Punk" enough and, in turn, missing the point of what Punk Rock was originally meant to be all about. Bono felt those that the song was aimed at were more about what the movement had been dressed up as, rather than what its true intent and freedom was. Very clever indeed. Not a flawless album, (that would come in the shape of the following years, 'The Unforgettable Fire') but a fantastic third album nonetheless.

6. Silverchair - Neon Ballroom 1999

Now, this is a truly great example of what a third album can mean to a band. After releasing the hugely successful but very derivative duo of 'Frogstomp' and 'Freak Show', the three band members were at the tender ages of fourteen and sixteen respectively. They were basically, a baby Nirvana, with perhaps a slightly more metallic edge. Band leader and songwriter, Daniel Johns, wanted the Aussie band to finally come into their own, and on 'Neon Ballroom', they really did. Still raging in places, but with a controlled dexterity, fragile and delicate with a menacing underbelly, in others. The key words here are focus and identity. Incorporating strings and keys was a masterstroke, as well as the more mature arrangements. 'Dearest Helpless' shouldn't work, but really does. Perhaps in the hands of their younger selves, it would have been a train-wreck, but not here. Johns is a notorious self-loather and it was often cringe-inducing, the way he broached this subject matter on the previous two albums but here, he nails it. 'Do You Feel The Same' is the sound of a troubled artist, as opposed to an angst ridden adolescent. The onset of his anorexia is shrewdly dealt with, in 'Ana's Song' (Open Fire). On the surface, it seems like a tangled ode to a female, when really it is his disease he is talking to. 'Miss You Love' is another leap forward, further demonstrating that the band don't need aggression and distorted guitars to be compelling. There are some rockers though, that are way more effectual when surrounded by the more diverse direction. 'Satin Sheets' is the heaviest track that bears the Silverchair name and displays a harsh edge to his vocals that, for the most part, are on the lush and soft side, on 'Neon Ballroom'. Such is the gulf between this album and the previous two, that the band feel this is their debut, proper.

5. The Offspring - Smash 1994

Well this release smashed (yup, I went there) the third album curse in devastating style. In 1994, something weird happened. Californian Punk Rock became big business. That year saw the release of 'Dookie' by Green Day, 'Stranger Than Fiction' by Bad Religion and 'Punk In Drublic' by NOFX. These albums have all never been matched commercially by their writers and never will be. No one really knows why this explosion of Skate-Punk/Pop-Punk took off in that year, but one thing is for sure, the quality of each of these releases had something to do with it. Also released, by four long haired skater/surfer dudes from Orange County, that year was the daddy of them all, 'Smash'. This album is still the biggest selling record ever put out by an independent record label, it currently sits at 16 million units shifted, worldwide. That is a ridiculous amount of records by anyones standards, not to mention these snot-nosed adrenaline heads. The label, Epitaph records, (owned by Bad Religion's guitar player, Brett Gurewitz) actually couldn't make enough copies to supply the demand for a good period of time after release. They even had to rent more warehouse space in downtown L.A. to house the dozens of pallets of tape, CD and vinyl copies of the record. The release itself is such a shot to the arm and it still sounds as fresh as a daisy almost twenty years later! The huge singles, 'Self Esteem', 'Come Out and Play' and 'Gotta Get Away' are all full of Southern Californian Punk Rock melodies and attitude, but it is on the album tracks that the really special material can be heard. Opener 'Nitro', makes the laziest slacker want to grab his deck and tear up his neighborhoods streets. 'Genocide', has such a memorable lead line that acts as the songs hook that you just cannot get it out of your mind, until you go out of your mind and have to listen, again and again. The band also turn their hand at some modern Ska-Punk with the quirky, 'What Happened To You'. The album isn't boneheaded at all though, with topics being, for the most part, pretty dark and hopeless, delivered from an average, Californian kid's point of view. That, after all was what they were at the time. They touch on such subjects as, victimization, gun crime, depression, pollution and other socio-political hot buttons. The magic is in their choice of chord progressions. Not complicated at all but with just enough nous about them to stir the emotions and give you that feeling that only Skate-Punk can. It is aggression, adrenaline and strong melody all dealt with, speed and urgency. Dexter Hollands one-of-a-kind voice is the bands ace card though. He has just has the perfect tone and range for this type of attack. Although they would make some fantastic records after 'Smash', they have never managed to sound as hungry and discontented as they did here. Maybe because after this record, they all became very, very rich.

4. Faith No More - The Real Thing 1989

So you've released two albums, carved yourself a niche, earned respect from your peers and are enjoying some moderate success, what next? Well how about you sack your unique, but vocally limited, very erratic singer, get in a complete unknown with a voice that can do anything and has charisma leaking out of his pores, hone your sound and become one of thee most influential Rock bands ever, right? That is pretty much exactly what FNM did. First two albums, 'We Care a Lot' and 'Introduce Yourself' were solid examples of funk-fueled Metal, much in the same vein of early Red Hot Chili Peppers, but infinitely better. (Sorry RHCP fans, but it's true.) Producer Matt Wallace was recruited again for co-production and mixing duties and what a job him and, then guitarist, Jim Martin did. In a sonic, and musical sense, 'The Real Thing' was so far ahead of its time. This album isn't quite as schizophrenic as the releases that succeeded it but still has many different sounds and moods across the eleven tracks. The album bursts into life with the magnificent 'From Out of Nowhere', which was also the first single. The synth riff is a face-melter and keys player, Roddy Bottum, is living proof that, when done right, there is very much a place for keyboards in Rock and Metal. 'Epic' is the monster-hit that was chosen as the second single and propelled the album sales upward with a sharp trajectory. The accompanying video clip is one of the most iconic music promo's ever made, still enjoying heavy rotation to this day. 'Epic' can still close Rock club nights with a full dance-floor. That is pretty mind-blowing.Of course, this is where the band included their glorious version of Sabbath's 'War Pigs', and a better cover of the inventors of Heavy Metal, you will not find. The bat-s**t crazy, 'Surprise! You're Dead!', is a real showcase for new boy, Mike Patton, to flex his considerable vocal abilities that would just get better and more versatile over time. The first of his soft, loungey croon would be heard on the slow-burning title track and then even more so on the laid back, jazzy curtain-closer , 'Edge Of The World'. Jim Martin, Billy Gould and Mike Bordin are exceptional on guitar, bass and drums respectively, all showing their strengths and somehow making the whole thing cohesive. FNM on paper are a group of musicians that should just not work this well together, at all. As history has taught us though, it really does. This record gave the band the success and breathing space to go even more eclectic on next album, 'Angel Dust' that saw the band become mega-stars.

3. The Cult - Electric 1987

Riding high off the back of seminal second album, 'Love', which has that song on it, The Cult could've carried on with the Goth-Rock direction they did so well but decided to strip all the textures and threw away the delay and chorus guitar pedals and pay homage to the likes of AC/DC, Ted Nugent, Led Zeppelin etc, with a balls out Rock and Roll record. This was Billy Duffy's baby and the guitar-slinger is the star of the show with his no-nonsense power chords and blues-influenced solo's. Ian Astbury's voice works so well over this style of material and allows the self-styled, "Wolf Child", to put on his best faux-American accent. The rhythm section of Stewart and Warner do their best Rudd/Williams impression, keeping it solid and tight for the two showmen to flaunt their wares. Aesthetically the band overhauled themselves too, in came cut off denim jackets, Led Zep tees and cowboy boots. The black was toned down and any velvet and lace, done away with. Choose any track, they're all as great as each other, perhaps marginally overshadowed by 'Wild Flower', 'Lil' Devil' and 'Love Removal Machine'. There is a cover of 'Born to be Wild' too, as if to further cement their new direction. It is the weakest track here, by some way, with Astbury particularly sounding unconvincing when singing someone else's song. Nevertheless the rest of the album is excellent and America was broken. The band, are later this year, playing the whole of 'Electric' on their 2013 tour, like they did previously with 'Love'.

2. The Charlatans - Up To Our Hips - 1994

This record might be seen as a strange choice as it is hardly one of the most talked about in The Charlatans' fairly extensive back catalog, but that doesn't take away from the fact that it is a superb third album and a worthy inclusion. 'Up To Our Hips' is one of those rare, transitional albums that a band sometimes needs to make, and at the same time, make a decent collection of tunes too. This takes the baggy, semi-shoe-gazey leaning of albums one and two, and mixes it with the more rocking, swaggering brit-rock vibe that was to come on subsequent releases. Upon its release, it was was seen as a product of a band struggling to find their place in the post-Oasis world of British guitar music. 'Definitely Maybe had turned, introverted, floppy fringed young men into urchin-haired, slack jawed idiots, Shed Seven had arrived as the Yorkshire version of the Rolling Stones, Blur had gone from Baggy, arty types to Mod like lad-Rockers over night and Ride were trying their hardest to be the Byrds. The Charlatans just went and did what felt natural and wrote ten great indie-rock songs. Taking only what was necessary from the slightly too wistful 'Between 10th and 11th' and injecting a bit more balls, without trying to be overly macho. The balance was perfectly struck and the Midlands outfit managed, in the process, to write some perfect, summery, guitar led pop tunes like 'Jesus Hairdo' and 'Can't Get Out Of Bed', that filled indie-club dance floors for the rest of the nineties. The more dreamy, spaced-out elements of the band were still intact on tracks such as 'Come In Number 21', 'Patrol', and the title track. Vocalist, Tim Burgess gives much more convincing performances when singing over songs of this ilk. Late Hammond organist, Rob Collins is a shining light, stamping his identity all over this album, whether its with long, drawn out chords, or little percussive flourishes. As time wears on, this album has gathered many more plaudits than when it was first unveiled. A truly great example of a third album, where you just keep your head down and put a great record out instead of chasing trends. It was the work of a band progressing, slowly and steadily.

1. Poison The Well - You Come Before You 2003

If ever a bad needs to come back to life, it is these Floridians, and fast! Modern hardcore has become a worthless genre, much more about style than substance, and all about false emotions. Poison the Well did what they did and, oh boy, did they mean it. Debut, 'The Opposite of December' is seen as one of the most important albums in the evolution of heavy music, not to mention the evolution of Hardcore and Metalcore. Always innovators, never followers, much like Thrice, Dillinger Escape Plan, Thursday, Refused, Champion and Eighteen Visions, who all each spawned their own micro-genre's within Hardcore. Sad that only a couple of those still remain active, and just one still releasing new music. More bands than not, nowadays, are not commentating on the world we live in, but are looking inward, but so much of it comes off as insincere and trite. Frontman and vocal-monster, Jeff Moreira was so good at addressing personal issues without any hint of bullshit posturing. Here, is where he went from really good, to a master. The band also changed tack a little bit from their previous approach, embracing more influences and expanding their pallet, without straying too far from what had made them so initially revered. The only one of the band's five full length releases to appear on a major record label, many feared the worst and prepared for a dumbed down, more accessible record. Not only did the band do the exact opposite, they produced a career best at the same time. Bringing in the Swedish production duo that had helped birth the Refused masterpiece, 'The Shape of Punk to Come' , they channeled into their, for-the-throat metallic-Hardcore approach, some Post-Metal influences from the likes of Cult Of Luna, Neurosis and Isis, which was really what made the difference. Moreira still switches effortlessly between bear-like screams and his commanding, convincing singing, in perfect sync with the music underneath. Never a band with simple arrangements before, here they mix things up even more, with different time signatures and tempo's, but not once does anything sound disjointed, or, bolted on for the sake of it. The guitar tones are warmer and less scooped, having a more mid range but no less brutal result. Chris Hornbrook's exceptional drumming is pushed up in the albums overall mix, to really power the songs along. Picking out highlights is extremely difficult as the quality doesn't dip at any point over the piece. Some obvious examples of the difference to what had come before would be - 'Meeting Again for the First Time', 'Apathy is a Cold Body' and 'Sounds Like the End of the World'. There is lots of, almost uncontrolled rage, plenty of melody, even hooks which they'd always had in spades. This album, perhaps not as influential of the debut and, even the hugely underrated, 'Tear From the Red', is a fine example of stepping up to the challenge the third album poses and surprising everyone, whilst raising your profile and cementing your legacy as trail-blazers.