10 Rock Band Reunions That REALLY Didn't Work

Coming Together with a Clunk.

By Tim Coffman /

Time is not always kind to some of our favorite artists. Even though you might exist like a band of brothers every time you take to the stage, it’s hard being with the same people over and over again and hoping to strike the same magic that you had at the beginning of your career. It’s the nature of the beast for bands to grow apart, but it’s also a little bit worse to see them try to put things back together.

Advertisement

As much as all of us may have gotten a nostalgia buzz from every one of these albums when they came out, they have not really held up to the standards that each of these acts had set up for themselves. In between trying to get every band member on the same page or making sure that everyone was still on speaking terms, each of these albums feels like trying to make lightning strike twice in the exact same location and coming up short.

That’s not to say that every one of these albums are absolute trash or anything. Across all of these records, there are at least a handful of songs that come close to capturing what they were capable of in their heyday, but more often than not the whole thing ends up looking way too shallow for anyone to really take seriously. Rock and roll is supposed to be all about passion, but most of these records felt like they were just forced into existence half the time.

10. Hell Freezes Over - Eagles 

The entire appeal of the Eagles when they were first starting out was just how laid back they were from their contemporaries. At the height of the political unrest of the '70s and people still up in arms about the Vietnam War, songs like Take It Easy and Peaceful Easy Feeling gave us the confidence that everything was going to work out. While it eventually did, we had to continue on without the Eagles coming with us.

Advertisement

Or did we? During the '80s, the band originally fell out pretty hard because of a sparring session that happened onstage between Don Felder and Glenn Frey, where Felder was getting frustrated about not getting paid. Things had seemed to smooth over around the '90s though, with the arrival of classic rock radio playing the band's music 24/7 and exposing a whole new generation to Hotel California.

As if the title wasn't a dead giveaway, Hell Freezes Over just points to how unlikely this was to happen, but it wasn't going to stay happy for long. In between a handful of decent tracks added to what is essentially a live album, the old habits came creeping back in again, as Felder got more frustrated about not getting an equal share of the royalties from every show and quitting the band again before they could reach a proper agreement. You can call it unfair if you wanted to, but when you have as many classics as Don Henley and Glenn Frey have under their belt, you can definitely tell who's really steering the ship.

9. Everything Must Go - Steely Dan

No one is ever going to call Steely Dan the edgiest band in the world or anything. Despite their love and boost from people like John Mulaney, this is about as middle-aged sounding as rock and roll can get, with songs that feel like they're meant to be listened to on a yacht in the Virgin Islands with a drink in your hand. You can't knock them for musicianship though...but you can knock them for their songcrafting.

Advertisement

After spending nearly a decade away from each other, Donald Fagen and Walter Becker never were able to put the pieces back together for the classic Steely Dan sound, with their newer efforts sounding like the more stale type of yacht rock and just feels tired after a while. As much as their material may have been laid back back in the day, they did at least change it up by having some killer guitar solos or telling seedy stories about drug dealers. You aren't going to find too much of that on their farewell record Everything Must Go, but that's just scratching the surface of what's wrong here.

Since the album before Two Against Nature already sounded bloated and somehow took a Grammy away from Kid A by Radiohead, this is even slower than that, sounding like a band desperately trying to push themselves and always coming up short. Steely Dan are definitely worthy of a Grammy nod, but this album just sounds too tired to care anymore.

8. American Dream - Crosby Stills Nash and Young

Neil Young has never minced words about doing whatever the hell he wants to do. As much as his music can be a bit difficult to navigate from time to time, you have to admire the man's dedication to his muse, always looking for something else to excite him, even if it means plunging himself into a ditch in the process. He is a man of his word though, and seeing his old bandmate get clean was enough for him to go back to Crosby Stills and Nash one more time.

Advertisement

After years of excessive behavior, David Crosby had finally gotten clean on here, leading to the first major CSNY album in decades. This should have been fantastic news, were it not for the fact that most of the band seem to be on totally different creative pages. Going through every track on here, it's hard even deciphering what they're trying to be, as they tear through songs that sound like Fleetwood Mac at one minute and then Don Henley the next minute.

Even songs that have a more poignant bent to them seem to be undercut by the production as well, like the song This Old House being overblown to hell and Crosby's song Compass barely having a hook that you can latch onto for more than a minute. Seeing how Neil was about to go on a run for the ages and turn himself into the Godfather of Grunge, this just sounds like he wanted to fulfill his promise to rejoin for Crosby's sake and then get the hell out of there.

7. Other Voices - The Doors

It was going to be impossible for the Doors to continue on without Jim Morrison at the helm. While he might not have been the most impressive singer in the world, The Lizard King's stage presence and poetic approach to lyrics were irreplaceable, and any other singer coming in would have been a smack in the face to any Doors fan. So the rest of the guys didn't attempt to replace Morrison, and then made everything worse on Other Voices.

Advertisement

Though a lot of these songs existed as jams from back when Jim was alive, the lack of his charisma just makes the whole band sound tired, especially with Ray Manzarak not being the greatest singer to fill Jim's shoes. Just when you think a song like Tightrope Ride could work in some capacity, the whole thing is undercut by giving you nothing but meat and potatoes rock and roll, which makes most of these songs feel a lot longer than they actually are.

Even if you thought that Morrison's writing was a bit too esoteric back in the early days, it definitely beats a song like I'm Horny I'm Stoned, which feels like one of the more meatheaded songs to come out of the Summer of Love era of rock and roll. There have been many great Doors songs that will go down as classics for rock and roll, but when you take Jim out of the equation, these guys basically just become another lousy jam band.

6. A Different Kind of Truth - Van Halen

The entire fallout between David Lee Roth and Van Halen has been the stuff of rock legend ever since the '80s. While Roth was known as the good time spirit of the band since the day he joined, his insistence on sticking to the formula led to massive tension between the group, ending with Van Halen ditching him for Sammy Hagar right at the height of their fame. Those bridges seemed to be burned for good by the '90s, but the next decade saw a rock and roll miracle occur.

Advertisement

Although A Different Kind of Truth has Eddie's song Wolfgang subbing in as the bass player for Michael Anthony, this was supposed to be the triumphant return that we were all waiting for, only for everything to sound really off. While you can blame a lot of this on the fact that Dave is not the screeching singer that he was back in the day, a lot of the songs aren't really fleshed out either, with Tattoo feeling way too corny and others going on way too long.

For most of the hardened Van Halen fans, the lack of Michael Anthony's harmonies is also a big disappointment, but the whole album isn't really a total loss. This is not going to go toe to toe with the best Roth era albums or anything, but considering the colossal failure of Van Halen III, this is Van Halen going out on their own terms and making one last record for us.

5. Endless Wire - The Who

There's a good case to be made that the Who could have called it quits after Keith Moon passed away. Though Pete Townshend may be the mastermind behind every single song, the kind of manic energy that Moon the Loon brought to every song he played was never going to be equaled, so why would they try to mess with perfection? They did continue on though, and it seemed fine up until we reached Endless Wire.

Advertisement

While carrying on without Moon might have still been understandable, not having bassist John Entwistle in the mix either on this album just makes the Who feel like a shell of themselves. It might be admirable that Roger Daltrey has been able to hold on to his aggressive vocal approach, but some of these songs are definitely not at the level that they should be, either because of lyrics that are a bit too on the nose or Pete Townshend just singing like he doesn't really want to be in the studio that day.

And as much as the bonus disc might include the kind of epic song cycle that made the Who so special back in the day, it's hard not to see it more as a crowdpleaser than an actual heartfelt song or anything. We still have the voice and the man that has written it all on here, but there's no real artistic values behind a record like this other than remind you that the Who exists.

4. The Endless River - Pink Floyd

As rock entered the '00s, fans had made their peace with the fact that Pink Floyd were never going to make music again. The real golden age of the band seemed to end once Roger Waters left the fold, and the band even made a point to say that they weren't going to be reuniting after their Live 8 performance in 2005. David Gilmour did decide to carry on though, and it made for some of the best audio Nyquil that you will ever hear.

Advertisement

Before you even get into the Endless River, it was at least put together for the right reasons. Much like Wish You Were Here was a tribute album to their fallen bandmate Syd Barrett, this one is made as a tribute to their keyboardist Richard Wright, who had passed away a few years prior. While their hearts were definitely in the right place here, picking up where the Division Bell left off back in the '90s wasn't really what the hardcore fans of Floyd were looking for, especially when over half of the track listing is an instrumental project.

Though the golden era of Floyd would probably be able to get away with writing a classic album that's nothing but instrumentals, there's not really much to salvage on here, sounding a lot closer to the ambient music that you would listen to while you wait in a doctor's office. Floyd may have had the final say on their career here, but after years out of practice, they seemed to trade in their hard hitting songs for rock and roll ASMR music.

3. Neighborhoods - Blink-182

There's a good chance that most millennials lost a bit of their childhood the minute Blink-182 broke up. Coming out of the pop punk scene, these were the kind of bratty teens that were supposed to stay best buds until the end of time, only for Tom DeLonge to cut things off cold in an email to the rest of the band. There was a lot of bad blood there for years, but something changed after tragedy struck.

Advertisement

In the wake of Travis Barker's terrifying plane crash, the band reunited at the Grammys and decided to cut the BS and make a new album. And when you heard the first sounds of Up All Night, it felt like it could work, taking the more hard edged sounds they were working with on their self titled and making something closer to alternative rock than a pop punk record. The chemistry was still there for sure, but the passion behind the project seemed to burn out fairly quickly.

From the sounds of songs like Fighting the Gravity, Tom was still into the more atmospheric sounds he was getting with Angels and Airwaves, and it became impossible for the band to compromise anymore, only putting out the EP Dogs Eating Dogs before Mark and Travis had to ask Tom to leave so they could focus on music. Though the Matt Skiba era of the band has been decisive among Blink fans, take comfort in knowing that the band is at least working and not sitting on their hands while they wait for Tom to get his sh*t together.

2. Led Zeppelin

It would have been completely understandable for Led Zeppelin to die the minute that John Bonham passed away. Bonzo was the beating heart behind the band, and his signature swing and style was not going to be equaled by anybody, leaving the band to pursue solo projects for the rest of their career. When Zeppelin did come together for a few shows though, fans were ecstatic. This was the reunion we hoped for, dreamed for, and one that we never actually got to see.

Advertisement

In the wake of Zeppelin's music getting a resurgence with the masses, the plan was for the guys to play a few shows at the O2 arena in London, with Jason Bonham covering for Dad behind the drum kit. And from what we can see from the live clips, they still have their chops between them, with Robert Plant sounding a lot more seasoned in his old age and Jimmy Page matching him for stage charisma as they tear through songs like Rock and Roll and Ramble On.

Just when it looked like we were about to get a full tour with this new version of Zeppelin, Plant called it off, saying that he didn't really feel comfortable continuing on outside of those few dates. As much as people may have been bummed, this might have been the best thing to do to make sure Zeppelin remains a pure memory for rock fans. These songs have become the Holy Grail for fans of hard rock music, and the last thing that you'd want to do is to tarnish the legacy of what you already built.

1. Psycho Circus - KISS

As KISS stumbled their way into the '80s, they had slowly started to outgrow the kind of makeup clad superheroes that people loved a few years before. The look of MTV had pop starlets and hair metal bands strutting their stuff on MTV as well, making the Demon and StarChild personas look more like a Saturday morning cartoons than something that you'd want to take seriously. Once the makeup came off (and replaced with a different kind of makeup), KISS entered the next chapter of their career and left the superheroes behind.

Advertisement

When the tides started to shift again in the '90s, KISS found themselves getting a lot more exposure for their early work, while also having a great Unplugged performance bringing back their old bandmates Peter Criss and Ace Frehley. All the pieces were there, and suddenly the original '70s version of the band were back in action, donning the makeup again and going on world tours to give their fans the greatest show on Earth all over again. That's what was going on in the press...but a different story happened with Psycho Circus.

Though some songs on here like the title track capture the same energy that the band had in the early days, the rest of the band have been outspoken about how compromised this record was, with only one Ace song added into the mix, Gene Simmons and Paul Stanley doing the lion's share of the writing, and even having sessions musicians play the drums and guitars on over half of the project. The wild rock and roll family may have seemed like they were back together again, but you have to remember that the Spaceman and the Cat are here in name only.

Advertisement