10 Rock Bands That Survived Major Line-Up Changes
Who needs to stick with the originals all the time?
It's always a heavy blow when a rock band loses a singer. Once you find the key voice of the group, what do you do when that voice is no longer present? Though many bands have carried on without their signature voice, what happens when you have multiple components of your band leave you hanging?
Building up a new band from scratch is always a difficult decision for musicians. These new components not only have to match the intensity of their predecessors, but also put their own unique spin on the band to keep the music from sounding stale. While lesser musicians would consider throwing in the towel after the departure of band members, these musicians make this drastic transition feel seemless.
Aside from just having new members, these changes in personnel have not only led to the band having greater success, but have also granted them greater success thanks to the shakeup of the songwriting formula. Together with this new lineup, these bands have able to carry on with their music while still saying firmly rooted in their signature sound. Even when these groups were considered down and out, they found ways to not only survive but to thrive and come back better than ever.
10. Panic At The Disco
Anyone who went through an emo period in the 2000's tends to speak reverently about Panic at the Disco. Even if you weren't into the Hot Topic friendly punk rock the band was playing, there was no escaping songs like "I Write Sins Not Tragedies" from being played everywhere.
As the band explored different styles though, tensions started to rise between the members after the album Pretty Odd. Once the tour cycle ended, both bassist Jon Walker and principal songwriter Ryan Ross abandoned the group. Though the band continued on for a while, all of the members tended to make their way out, leaving Brendon Urie as the only member of the band.
Instead of falling into obscurity, Urie has been able to make Panic at the Disco the perfect platform for his new artistic ventures. The songs still fall under the rock category, but everything is now done with extravagant arrangements that seem to call to mind the big band arrangements from the 20's if they were fed through an electronic lens.
With the band's last album Pray For the Wicked racing up the charts, Urie has shown his chops at being one of the greatest power pop musicians going right now. It's been a long time since the era of makeup and top hats, but the other side of the spectrum has been just as interesting with Urie behind the mic.
9. Foo Fighters
Foo Fighters were one of the greatest post-grunge bands that helped pull the rock community out of the doldrums after Kurt Cobain's death. Originally just a demo tape experiment, Dave Grohl eventually turned his ideas into a full-fledged rock outfit that created some of the best records of the 2000's. That being said, it wasn't an easy road getting there.
Since Grohl played everything on the band's first record, the assemblage of musicians led to some tensions during the early days of touring. Once Grohl entered the studio with the band for their sophomore release, he ended up re-recording drummer William Goldsmith's parts himself, leading to the drummer quitting in protest. After they acquired Taylor Hawkins, guitarist Pat Smear decided he had had enough and quit, leaving the band to make due with replacement guitarist Franz Stahl.
Everything seemed to be going well on tour, but the lack of creative cohesion during writing sessions led to Grohl firing Stahl after the tour cycle and hiring guitarist Chris Shiflett. After years of band dysfunction,Grohl finally had a lineup that made sense, which led to some of the band's greatest works from In You Honor to Wasting Light, the latter of which marked the return of original guitarist Pat Smear to the band. There may have been dark days for the Foos, but Grohl always found a way to overcome the greatest of adversities.
8. Motorhead
Throughout the early 70's, there was no stopping the Motorhead train. The raucous sound that erupted from this power trio signaled the beginnings of heavy metal while also having the no-frills attitude and speed of punk rock. Given the band's monstrous sound, it's crazy to think every incarnation of the band was usually just 3 people.
The beating heart of the band has always been Lemmy Kilmister, who put together the classic lineup of guitarist Fast Eddie Clark and drummer Phil Taylor on classic albums like Overkill and Ace of Spades. Though this lineup produced some of the most furious rock and roll ever laid to tape, the magic of the lineup quickly dissipated, which led to a revolving door of drummers and guitarists.
Many fantastic musicians joined the ranks of Motorhead from Brian Robertson of Thin Lizzy to former Saxon drummer Pete Gill, but the lineup reached its absolute pinnacle with the ferocious drumming of Mikkey Dee and the rock and roll swagger of Phil Campbell. The arrival of second guitarist Wurzel even led to the band expanding to a four piece for a brief period in the 80's. Throughout every new lineup, the quality of the music never suffered for it because Lemmy, quite frankly, is Motorhead.
7. Queens Of The Stone Age
The policy on membership for Queens of the Stone Age has been a bit complicated over the years. While many fans can count on a few members playing on the band's records, the only member who has been with the band through thick and thin has been lead songwriter Joshua Homme.
The band had somewhat of a consistent lineup at the beginning of the 2000's with Nick Oliveri and Mark Lanegan, but complications with other commitments and misbehavior led to them parting ways before the band's 2005 release Lullabies to Paralyze. Ever since then, guitarist Troy Van Leeuwen has been the only consistent member next to Homme.
Though there is a full band who tours each record, the actual album cuts of QOTSA's songs often feature an all star cast of Homme's friends in the music business. Across the band's last few records, everyone from Dave Grohl to Trent Reznor to even Elton John have made an appearance on a track or two.
The consistent inconsistency of the lineup has actually worked in the band's favor, with fans always clamoring to know which guest stars Homme will utilize next. Regardless of who's in the band, the actual music has always been just the right kind of sultry rock and roll to leave you aching for more.
6. KISS
When KISS broke out of the New York club scene dawning makeup, it really felt like the band were brothers in arms. Despite what some would consider silly stage gimmicks, you really got the impression that these guys were inseparable in their quest to become the biggest band in rock and roll. Once time and money get involved though, things tend to change.
As the band started floundering in the 80's, drummer Peter Criss left the group with guitarist Ace Frehley not far behind. This was more than a shock to the system; this felt like a death in the family for most KISS fans. Frehley's solos were often the greatest parts of KISS songs and Criss's gruff voice on songs like "Beth" gave the band their biggest hits.
Determined to carry on, Gene Simmons and Paul Stanley ended up drafting new drummer Eric Carr, whose hard hitting style introduced the band to a heavier sound on Creatures of the Night. With other guitarists floating through the ranks like Vinnie Vincent and Mark St. John, the arrival of Bruce Kulick gave the band one of its greatest lineups since their glory years. Though the band have had reunions with the original members over the years, the foundation of KISS seemed to be secure as long as Gene or Paul were leading the charge.
5. Megadeth
Once Dave Mustaine was sent packing from Metallica, he returned to California with an extra fury. Determined to make a band that could rival his former bandmates, he formed Megadeth with bassist David Ellefson. The original quartet was rounded out by Gar Samuelson and Chris Poland, but the fantastic riffs of the early years were destined to be shortlived.
Due to the drug problems of Poland and Samuelson, they were both sent packing with Mustaine hiring Jeff Young and Chuck Behler. After fluctuating with other members (including almost hiring Pantera guitarist Dimebag Darrell), the band reached a different sonic depth once they added guitarist Marty Friedman and drummer Nick Menza. The licks Friedman traded off with Mustaine made for some of the best Megadeth records from Rust In Peace to Countdown to Extinction.
Ever since the end of the 90's, the band have always had a semi-revolving doors policy on the guitarist and drummer positions. Fabulous guitarists like Chris Broderick and Kiko Loureiro have held the slot in recent years while the beat has been pounded out by absolute monsters like Shawn Drover and Lamb of God skinsman Chris Adler. The faces may not always be consistent, but each new lineup of this band always has a certain level of musicianship. Years may have passed since this band's beginnings, but Mustaine still has a desire to make Megadeth a true metallic powerhouse.
4. Deep Purple
When Deep Purple started to make their signature hard rock sound, they had some of the most accomplished musicians among their ranks. The infectious riffs from Ritchie Blackmore were only matched by the furious organ runs from Jon Lord. At the center of it all was vocalist Ian Gillan, whose stratospheric voice marked the beginning of the heavy metal screamer.
From the very beginning, the music was a group effort, with the musicianship of Blackmore and Lord being made into maniacal rock tracks by the partnership of Gillan and bassist Roger Glover. While the band's epic run included albums like In Rock and Machine Head, Gillan had had enough and quit in 1973, with Glover following suit.
With their core songwriting force gone, the band were at a crossroads in their career where they could continue on as rockers or call it a day. Finding their muse once again, the band hired bassist Glenn Hughes and vocalist David Coverdale, whose range not only paid tribute to the band's classics but also gave a bluesy spin on the band's newer material.
Since Hughes was also a powerhouse vocalist, much of the band's output during this time featured songs that were vocal team-ups between Hughes and Coverdale. The Gillan-Glover lineup of Purple may have produced the band's classic tracks, but the band's future with Coverdale and Hughes showed that they had a few more surprises up their sleeve.
3. Oasis
Whenever people talk about Oasis, 99% percent of the time the attention goes to the Gallagher Brothers. The sibling rivalry between Noel and Liam Gallagher has been well-documented throughout the years, but the band's tumultuous lineup has helped lead this band through many years of rock and roll debauchery.
From the very beginning, the band's lineup was rounded out by guitarist "Bonehead" Arthurs and bassist "Guigsy" McGuigan. Though the band had a bit of a rough patch finding drummers, the band finally hit upon the right guy when Alan White joined their ranks. After the band's disastrous album Be Here Now came out in 1997, both Arthurs and McGuigan parted ways with the group. While neither wrote the songs, Noel has been very vocal about their involvement as being the true spirit of Oasis.
Though the brothers initially made their 2001 album Standing on the Shoulder of Giants on their own with White, the band had new life once Gem Archer and Andy Bell joined in. Since both Bell and Archer were songwriters, the band were also able to reach for new sounds that were outside of Noel's typical songwriting tropes. The Gallaghers may be the true face of the band, but Oasis's ability to thrive has always come from the stellar musicians that have been working with Noel and Liam.
2. Fleetwood Mac
Given all of the attention the band has gotten in recent years, it's almost amusing to think of Fleetwood Mac's beginnings as a down and dirty rock outfit. Regardless of the band's recent output, the group's original sound was deep in the blues when guitarist Peter Green formed the band in the late 60's.
The band were true innovators in the rock world, with Green penning songs like "Oh Well" and even the original version of "Black Magic Woman," which became a rock classic once Santana recorded their version. After years of hard road work, Green left the band to pursue other interests, leaving the band without their main voice. The band acquired jazz guitarist Bob Welch for a while, but the band were floundering once again when Welch left before their self-titled record.
While cutting tracks at Sound City, drummer Mick Fleetwood was impressed by guitarist Lindsey Buckingham, who was working in another session. After being offered the job, Buckingham accepted the position as long as his girlfriend and songwriting partner Stevie Nicks joined as well. Together with songwriter Christine McVie, the band went on to create several hits and produced one of the all-time classic albums of the 70's in Rumours. For a band that were scrambling for the right lineup, Fleetwood Mac really hit the jackpot by scoring two of the greatest songwriters the rock world had ever seen.
1. Genesis
When it comes to keeping a lineup together, Genesis seemed to have the worst luck when it came to maintaining members in the 70's. After main songwriter Anthony Phillips left in the early 70's, the band soldiered on with the help of guitarist Steve Hackett and new drummer Phil Collins.
Though a few years with this lineup produced classics of the prog genre like The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway, lead singer Peter Gabriel quickly became dissatisfied with his place in the band and moved onto a solo career. Instead of finding a simple replacement, the band found out the greatest singer they had at their disposal had been among their ranks the whole time.
Once Phil Collins stepped up to the mic, the band had yet another captivating vocal presence to utilize. That didn't completely tide things over though, with Steve Hackett abruptly leaving the group after the band's first tour as a four-piece. Now down to a trio, Collins, Mike Rutherford, and Tony Banks were still able to carry on, as they released fantastic mixes of prog and pop on albums like Duke and Invisible Touch.
It's a testament to the strength of these musicians that even at half-capacity, they could still come through with some of the best music of their generation.