10 Song Meanings Everyone Gets Wrong
Taken WAY Out of Context.
All music can be subjective. Even if you think that your favorite band is one of the greatest bands to ever walk the Earth, chances are there’s someone else who thinks that whatever they’ve done is a stain on the music world. If you think that taste is subjective though, just imagine what it’s like actually trying to dissect what a song means.
Even though you might have the perfect version of what your favorite song is in your head, the only person who’s really going to know is the songwriter themselves, and it’s anyone’s guess as to whether they will want to actually talk about what their song is about. In terms of these songs though, there have been countless fans going around with the wrong idea.
As much as some of these songs should be a dead giveaway from the titles, the actual writer has come forward to say what their intent really was…and it turns out that we were miles off. From some classic underground songs to the greatest hits that have ever been created, everyone seemed to take these songs out of context, and ended up singing along to tracks which involve everything from death to abuse. Every artist likes to speak their mind through music, so just make sure you know what you’re getting yourself into when you start singing along.
10. Song 2 - Blur
For as much as Britpop may have been raging back in England, it took a while for most of that excitement to get translated over to the States. It would be a while before Oasis had even cracked the album charts in the US, and even modern classics like Bittersweet Symphony seemed to be relegated to just one hit wonder status outside of their home country. Blur were a bit more eclectic than their peers, and Song 2 made Yanks sing along with a song that was actually making fun of them.
Having had some experience in the rock scene well before Britpop started, Damon Albarn had already felt a little bit jaded about the new form of alternative rock that was happening at the time, almost taking the kind of angst that Kurt Cobain was tapping into and trying to make their own knockoff version of it. Almost to make fun of it, Song 2 is exactly that, creating a track that means next to nothing and was all about trying to do a pastiche of the kind of alternative bands that were cluttering up the radio at the time.
And the little goof totally worked as well, becoming one of the bigger breakthroughs that the band had stateside despite having no creativity in the name of the song and openly mocking the intended audience. Radio rock didn't care about that though. They were too busy chiming in on the WOO HOOs to really pay attention to anything else.
9. Semi Charmed Life - Third Eye Blind
And speaking of meaningless singalong chorus, we have to bring up the power of Third Eye Blind's 'doot doos' in Semi Charmed Life. Despite not having any real words in it, hearing that hook has etched this song into the brain of every single '90s kid to walk the Earth, no matter if they can't keep up with the rapid fire verses. When you actually take a look at that lyric sheet, it might be for the best that you don't know what the verses are about.
Just like some dark pop songs before it, Third Eye Blind wrote the catchiest melody that they possibly could to hide the horrors in the verses, as Stephen Jenkins talks about the seedier side of living in the California sunshine. It might be home to the City of Angels, but Jenkins' tale is a lot closer to street level, talking about guys who are questioning their life choices now that they're turning tricks and getting hopped up on crystal meth every day to just function properly.
The chorus might just seem like a generic throwaway line about being bored, but if this guy doesn't get over his semi charmed life, chances are he's going to end up face down in a gutter somewhere with no real hope for survival. This is the kind of stuff that is almost metal levels of lyrical intensity, tied together with a song that wouldn't feel out of place in a Christian youth group playlist.
8. Swimming Pools - Kendrick Lamar
Throughout every project he's taken on, Kendrick Lamar has never minced words about the struggles that he has gone through living in Compton. This is a man who has had to go through Hell to get to where he is today, and he's counting his blessings every day that his demons never got the best of him. He does need a reminder every now and again though, and Swimming Pools is practically a bait and switch listening to it in your headphones.
Going through the actual chorus, this is probably the closest to a drinking song that Kendrick has ever done, from the glassy eyed 'DRINK' before every chorus to Kenny talking about turning it up a notch by diving into a swimming pool of liquor. So how the hell did Kendrick turn this around and make it into an anti-drinking song? Because outside of the chorus, this entire song is about the dangers that liquor can bring into your life, from Kendrick's family struggling with putting down the bottle to a separate verse where Kendrick has his own conscience talk him out of going too crazy.
Then again, maybe Kendrick making a song like this was more about sending out a message about alcoholism, even if it had to be masked as a standard drinking song. If anything, this was just Kendrick taking the reins of what his music was going to be. He might have been inching closer to pop music this time, but he was going to do in on his own terms if he had to.
7. Good Riddance - Green Day
There's a good chance that over half of Western civilization has had to slog through Green Day's Good Riddance at some point in their lives. Even if you couldn't name another Green Day song or even a rock song in general, chances are this has been the soundtrack to many a graduation ceremony, with lyrics about moving on to the next chapter in your life. If you listen to what Billie Joe Armstrong is saying though, this is a lot more salty than you probably realized.
When Billie was writing the tune, he was actually going through a pretty nasty breakup with his girlfriend, and this song was his way to let out his frustration. Listening back to the lyrics with that in mind, the whole thing feels almost sarcastic coming out of his mouth, telling her to capture the memories while she can before everything crumbles to pieces. Since this was an acoustic ballad, this winding up on Dookie wasn't going to work, leading to it being shelved and given a string section for Nimrod.
Even when Billie hears the song these days, he's shocked at just how calm he sounds with everything, saying that it took everything he could to actually sound level headed on a song like this. Those who don't know any better focus on the Time of Your Life subtitle of the song, but you have to remember that the proper version is called Good Riddance for good reason.
6. Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds - The Beatles
There's a good chance that no one can really get to the bottom of what most psychedelic songs are going on about. Most of the trippy rock songs of the '60s you could safely assume were written while under the influence, so it would make sense that you could only understand these songs if you were a little bit buzzed yourself. Which is strange considering that one of the more celebrated songs of the psychedelic period had nothing to do with drugs at all.
While most of Sgt. Peppers marks the point where the Beatles really started to experiment with the power between Abbey Road Studio's walls, John Lennon first came up with the idea for Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds from his son after school one day. After taking a break from the studio, John had noticed a drawing that his son Julian had done of one of his classmates named Lucy, with the title Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds. Loving the imagery of his son's work, Lennon set about making an Alice in Wonderland like fairy tale, with newspaper taxis and marmalade skies taking you off into another land.
That's not what the papers wanted to hear though, noticing very quickly that the main words in the title seem to spell out LSD, which Lennon always refuted when asked about it. Then again, this is a song that can kind of go both ways though. If it's actually about the drawing, it's a nice piece of tone painting, but if it's about drugs, you're in for one of the most intense trips you've ever experienced.
5. Wonderwall - Oasis
Every joker who has ever tried to woo someone at a bar or tried an open mic normally has to get around to playing Wonderwall at least once. It almost seems like a rite of passage for people to cover the Oasis classic, having a simple chord progression and Liam Gallagher's booming voice going on about some girl who might be the one that saves him. Seeing how Noel Gallagher was dating his fiance Meg Matthews at the time, it would safe to assume it's about her, right? Wrong.
Having the original title Wishing Stone, Noel had actually written this song long before he and Meg were even an item, until the press seemed to jump on it once What's the Story Morning Glory came out. Even though Noel has always been a bit cagey on what all of his songs are about, he did peel back the curtain just a little bit on this one, saying it's about an imaginary friend that will one day be able to save you from yourself.
He also doesn't hold anything back about the press blowing things out of proportion either, saying that their insistence on this song being about Meg forced him to lie to his wife about the song's origins. You can see why he would go along with it though, right? If you have your wife hearing that one of your greatest hits is written about her, it's hard to really reel that back.
4. Born in the USA - Bruce Springsteen
You can't script a better ambassador for American music than Bruce Springsteen. Even though The Boss has had a bit of a spotty catalog throughout the years both with and without the E Street Band, he always remains the example of what American rock and roll can be, with the same desire to beat the odds even when they're stacked against you. Bruce is definitely proud of his country, but that doesn't mean he necessarily supports every single thing that it's done in the past.
After doing different experiments on albums like Nebraska, Born in the USA helped launch the Boss into the '80s again, with a big single that people jumped on immediately as being about Bruce's flag waving pride for his home country. That couldn't be further from the truth though, as Bruce talks about the different horror stories that go on on the fringes of America, like the Vietnam soldiers who come home from war but left pieces of their soul on the battlefield, all while never getting the proper help that they need when they come back home.
There are even a few moments in the song where Bruce has to cut himself off because he's holding back so much emotion, but those glossy synths just make him look like Yankee Doodle Springsteen leading the troops into battle. So next time you listen to this song, just remember that chorus has more than a hint of sarcasm in it. The American Dream is what is sold to everyone, but they don't tell you how many miles you need to put on your soul to get there.
3. Something in the Way - Nirvana
Throughout every single Nirvana press junket, Kurt Cobain always liked to play into the idea that he was a bit of a misfit amongst the rock elite. While he never really enjoyed the kind of sudden fame that Nirvana had, he would always be willing to play into it, talking about the kind of creative eccentric that he was and how dire his life was before he became famous. Something in the Way might show how bad it got, but those who knew Kurt understood that he never experienced what happened in this song.
Since Nevermind was released, many have been led to assume that Something in the Way is an autobiographical song about Kurt living under a bridge and fending for food however he could before going into record. If you were to ask almost any of his friends though, this is a complete fabrication of what actually happened, with Mark Arm of Mudhoney saying that it wasn't true and the producers mentioning that the band crashed in hotels when making Nevermind. As Krist Novoselic tells it, the worst that it actually got was a spell during the Bleach era where Kurt lived in a car for a little while, but even then he still could have access to shelter whenever he wanted.
It's all about selling your aesthetic though, and millions of fans took Kurt at his word on this song, with one bridge in Seattle becoming a shrine to Kurt's memory, with fans leaving different tributes to him underneath it. If anything, this song is basically just the image that most people had of grunge in the early days: grimy, heavy, and emotionally in shambles.
2. Every Breath You Take - The Police
Every single Police album coming out in the '80s saw them inching that much closer to pop music. After becoming one of the biggest names in the late period of new wave in the '70s, hearing songs like Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic saw them toying with a lot more hooks this time around, all while making different sonic turns into the world of calypso along the way. Synchronicity was the true blockbuster album for them though, and Sting made one of the biggest songs of his career about a stalker.
Although the structure of Every Breath You Take is meant to sound intimate most of the time, most people forget that this is not a love song by any stretch. While there is some sort of protective nature behind a line like 'I'll be watching you,' Sting has made it a point to let people know that this is about a stalker as he gets more and more fixated on the object of his affection. If you listen to those lyrics, you never hear what the girl says, and hearing him watching her every move starts to feel pretty gross when adding every other detail about her everyday life.
You may think that the whole thing sounds intimate, but it's the kind of intimacy that makes Sting feel like he's right right outside your window with a pair of binoculars monitoring your every move. The narrator in this song might think that this is a love song, but the only thing that's going to be coming out of a song like this is probably a restraining order and a can of mace to the face.
1. Turning Japanese - The Vapors
It's no secret that there are a lot of people with dirty minds that populate the Internet. Rule 34 is most definitely a real thing, and chances are that a lot of songs have been taken out of context to be about something sexual in nature. This is NOT a new thing thanks to the Internet though. This has been going on since the dawn of time, and Turning Japanese is one of the most glaring examples of it.
From the minute that this song came out, people were automatically assuming that the Vapors were talking about something that was a little bit more NSFW than most other chart hits. Although the common belief is that the chorus line is a euphemism for masturbation, the band has always denied it. While it's easy to just shoot down the sexual suggestions in the lyrics though, we still don't have a clear explanation as to what any of this song is about.
Going through every line, you can definitely get themes about losing your identity and this man fawning over a girl in a picture, but that's about all you're going to get here. Almost to toy with us even further, the Vapors have also said that the whole song doesn't even have anything to do with Japan, despite using the Oriental style riff at the start of the song. At this point, you almost start to understand why people are going with the masturbation theory. Because that's the only way that this new wave classic is going to make any sort of sense.