10 Terrible Songs By Perfect Rock Bands
When Everything Went Wrong.
The golden age of rock and roll always had those few bands that seemed to be a cut above the rest. As the genre was just coming into its own, these were the artists that were leading the charge into the next generation, having a bold new sound that no one had ever heard before or taking the basis of what rock and roll was supposed to be and taking it that much further. Their track record might seem spotless, but everyone has those few songs that they don’t want to talk about either.
For every all-time great song that these artists have in their arsenal, these songs give you the exact opposite, taking the sounds of rock and roll and turning them into a parody of itself. There’s more than one way to write a bad song though, and each one of these songs seem to go in the wrong direction in their own unique ways. Sometimes the artists might be doing some sort of zany experiment that just didn’t quite work out the way they wanted to. Other times though, this is where the sound that you know and love starts to turn a corner, either trying to sell out to suit the masses or going down some road that no one was asking them to go down.
And let’s not forget about drug abuse either, with some of these coming from the era when narcotics were running rampant, leading to songs that were written while artists were…let’s say chemically impaired. You can’t appreciate the good without the bad though, and some of the classics that these artists have made feel that much brighter knowing that they have something like this under their belt.
10. Rock and Roll Doctor - Black Sabbath
No one is going to dispute Black Sabbath’s influence on the world of hard rock. Even if they never really identified with metal, the scary edge that they infused into their sound is what turned the genre into the giant everyone knows today, from Ozzy Osbourne’s bellowing voice to Tony Iommi’s terrifying riffs.
That was the early days of Paranoid, and the later Ozzy years get more than a little bit spotty. Although Ozzy usually has a lot of unkind words to say about his final album Never Say Die, Technical Ecstasy is where things really started to go haywire, with Rock and Roll Doctor being a contender for one of Sabbath’s corniest songs.
While the guitar work is still great (I mean, it’s Iommi), the lyrics are nowhere near the menacing stuff we expect from Sabbath, sounding like some parody of old school rock and roll. It also doesn’t help that Ozzy cannot sell this for the life of him, trying to play it straight but coming off like he doesn’t understand what he’s saying half the time. Sabbath might be one of the best hard rock bands in the world, but if Spinal Tap played this song, no one would have batted an eye.
9. Little By Little - Radiohead
For most Radiohead fans, there are great Radiohead albums and Radiohead albums that just have some rough edges. Even though Pablo Honey may have been a little too indebted to the kind of grunge rock that was popular at the time, it still had some highlights like Creep that seem to have lasted. As for the King of Limbs, this is where things start to get just a little bit spotty.
While there are some good ideas on Radiohead’s 8th record, Little by Little is a good indicator of everything that’s wrong with the album in concept. The idea of mixing the art rock aesthetic with loops sounds like a great idea in theory, but this is where we hit a brick wall, as both genres clash into each other and sound a lot more robotic than they intended.
As much as Lotus Flower and Codex may have had a decent balance of every style, you can hear the band struggle to find their groove on this song, with Thom Yorke sounding lost half the time. If you’re going to incorporate something as strange as loops, you have to commit to the gimmick 100% before you end up with this.
8. Zombie Zoo - Tom Petty
The road to Tom Petty’s solo record was a long time coming. He had seemed like a solo act for most of his career, but every album he released until this point still had major contributions from the other Heartbreakers, until Jeff Lynne let him run wild and do whatever he wanted. While that led to classics like Free Fallin and I Won’t Back Down, even Petty admitted that the closing track was far from the best he had.
Having more of a comedic tone, Zombie Zoo is a more goofy affair than what Tom was probably intending, talking about some girl who just seems to work a meaningless job day by day and walking around like a walking zombie every day. Some of the lines get a chuckle and guest star Roy Orbison sings well enough, but it feels more like a joke than a proper ending to the album, making the other songs feel a bit lackluster by comparison.
Considering a legend worked on it though, this feels more like a Traveling Wilburys B-side that somehow managed its way onto the proper track listing of the album. Since Tom had written an amazing song around this time called Waiting for Tonight that would surface years later, how was this the one that made the cut?
7. Iron Gland - Alice in Chains
Alice in Chains’ Dirt sounds like it was pure pain from beginning to end. The sessions might have been fine, but hearing Layne Staley pour out his soul about his heroin addiction makes you feel like you’re being pulled into Hell as you listen. This is the ultimate drug fueled darkness, so why the hell did they think that we needed a bit of humor sprinkled in?
As you make your way through the ugly side of the record, Iron Gland comes on sounding like a weird acid nightmare that you never wanted to go on. Originally written as a joke take on Black Sabbath’s Iron Man, the rest of the band found Jerry Cantrell’s riff really annoying, asking him to never play it again if he just recorded it on the album.
There are some living legends on here though, as Tom Araya from Slayer lays down some screams for the back half of the song to make it sound tortured. If it wasn't a proper song, this would make for at least a decent interlude between tracks, almost like you’re hearing the final gasps of a struggling addict begging to be set free from his demons.
6. Fountain of Lamneth - Rush
Even for a genre like prog rock, jumping into a Rush album can be complicated. Neil Peart was always known to be on the verbose side, and a lot of the band’s best work involves heady concepts that tend to go on strange tangents over the course of 9 minutes. That’s fine if it works, but Fountain of Lamneth almost cost the band their record deal.
After their first ambitious song By Tor and the Snow Dog, this is one of the goofiest stories that the band would ever write. Spanning across nearly 20 minutes, the tale here is a man making his life mission about finding this fountain that may grant him enlightenment. We get a whole dissection of this guy trying to find this fountain only to realize that it was just a normal fountain at the end.
Once you hear the end of the song, you can’t help but feel disappointed that all of those 20 minutes was building up to a story about nothing. No fans showed up for this either, which meant Rush had to dig a lot deeper before coming up with 2112. You can’t fault them for their ambition, but if you’re going to make a song that’s 20 minutes, we better get somewhere.
5. Hot Dog - Led Zeppelin
Led Zeppelin have always been known to borrow some of their tracks. It doesn’t take a rock scholar to know that the band didn’t actually write the song Dazed and Confused and that Robert Plant and Jimmy Page owe a lot more to people like Muddy Waters and Willie Dixon to create songs like Whole Lotta Love. Zeppelin were always indebted to the classics, but the rockabilly sound doesn’t really suit them.
While In Through the Out Door had Zeppelin progressing with synthesizers and different textures, Hot Dog has got to be one of the goofiest songs they’ve ever made, sounding more like something that Elvis Presley would have made if he wasn’t trying. The song isn’t terribly written or anything, but you also have to remember the kind of Zeppelin that we were working with.
After Physical Graffiti and testing their limits with what could be done with rock and roll, why are you going back to the goofy sounds that were happening before? Even if this album wasn’t their best, this was bound to divide the fanbase, as if Zeppelin were coaxing off of nostalgia. In Through the Out Door gave us a peek at what an ‘80s version Zeppelin could have been, but this one song is where they started to regress.
4. Stupidmop - Pearl Jam
As Pearl Jam’s star began to rise, Eddie Vedder was getting more and more uncomfortable with his star power. While he definitely had love for every kid who actually connected with his music, the jock crowd that identified with his music rubbed him the wrong way, leading to him bowing out of interviews and refusing to release music videos. That didn’t stop the band from growing, until we got one of the biggest curveballs yet on Vitalogy.
For all of the great songs that appear on this album, they were definitely going through some stuff on this record, almost like they’re venting for half the runtime. Although the end of the album closes nicely on the ballad Immortality, the album still has 8 more minutes for Stupid Mop to yuck things up. There’s no real genre to put on a song like this, being composed of recordings that Eddie made off of his TV of people jabbering about nonsense and the band trying to play in the background.
There might be a lead guitar fill here and there, but the majority of this song just makes you wonder whether the guys in the band are okay instead of actually listening to it. Vedder remained proud of it though, calling it one of the most moving tracks on the entire album. That’s fair, but that doesn’t stop most of us from wanting to hit that skip button whenever it comes on.
3. Escape - Metallica
By Metallica standards, Master of Puppets may be the closest thing that they have to a perfect album. The Black Album may have had some of their biggest radio hits, but this is where everything really came together, with heavy riffs and keeping a strong sense of melody throughout like Orion or Welcome Home Sanitarium. Ride the Lightning can easily join that company as well, if not for the one song that broke up the flow.
Working out of a studio in Denmark, the band finally had all the tracks for what they thought was a tight 7 song experience, until Lars Ulrich got word that they needed to record one more song. Rolling over for their label, Escape is the sound of one day’s work, with Metallica trying to write the thrash metal version of a crossover rock song. Although you can definitely hear influences from Thin Lizzy in here, they can’t help but go back to their heavy roots, turning it into a completely different song for the heavy breakdown.
Even though this is far better than something like St. Anger, the band don’t seem to want to be here on this song, like they’re scraping something together as the tape rolls. They may have been committed to original material, but if they replaced Escape with their cover of Diamond Head’s Am I Evil, we may be looking at the best thrash album the band ever made.
2. Numb - U2
During the mid ‘90s, there was no one who could really touch U2 anymore. Even though grunge should have logically killed them, embracing the ironic side of the music business gave their entire career a second wind, cashing in by making songs that were a lot more jaded about what life as a rock star was supposed to be. It was a good time to be experimenting, but one of the first singles from Zooropa left us with no real hook.
While the idea of handing the mic off to someone else in the band may have been their way to spice it up, you can’t really call what the Edge does singing per se. For the better part of 4 minutes, most of Numb consists of Edge speaking like some mechanical robot, almost going for a sort of industrial tinged mood with some of the lyrics but not really having the same attitude behind it.
The idea may have been to make him sound artificial, but it doesn’t make it any fun to listen to, especially when Bono’s backing vocals come in out of nowhere. It gets even stranger when you see the music video, with the Edge just being shuffled through some of the weirdest scenarios imaginable before the song just abruptly ends during the fade out. Zooropa might not be a lot of people’s favorite U2 album, but when you have an opening single like this, the odds are already stacked against you.
1. Revolution 9 - The Beatles
The Beatles’ entire career was always about being ahead of the curve. Their lovable moptop period may have been fun, but the Fab Four always had plans to move further, making one innovation after the next and creating some of the greatest album experiences that rock and roll had ever heard. The White Album definitely belongs in that company, but some of the experimentation tended to go a little too far on the back half of the record.
Around the time they were taking a retreat in India, John Lennon became more interested in the avant garde thanks to his new friend Yoko Ono, which blossomed into this alternate version of Revolution. While most people were already familiar with the single rock version of the song and even the subdued acoustic version, Revolution 9 is a jump off the deep end in terms of experimentation, being a sort of sound collage that both John and Yoko worked on together.
While George Harrison was originally supportive, this track is the exact opposite of what you come to the Beatles for, being 8 straight minutes of everything from a man randomly saying the phrase ‘Number 9’ to different noises strung together and Yoko saying phrases into the microphone for no reason. The idea behind this song may have been to create a revolution inside your mind, but it reads more like a musical horror story.