10 Worst Times Hard Rock Bands Changed Singers

You go where the talent is... and all the talent that was in this band has just left the room!

By Keith Christensen /

At the front of any good rock band is an awesome vocalist. Whether it's looks, charisma, energy, or just sheer talent, the frontman has to connect with the fans and audiences the most. When the voice of your band is gone, many times the fans will go with them.

Advertisement

Changing any members of a sacred line-up is difficult. The unfortunate truth is that groups can switch out guitarists, bassists, keyboardists, and drummers and the fans will hardly notice. But sometimes, changing the frontman doesn't work out so well...

There have been success stories, of course, with groups able to find fame after switching singers like adding Corey Taylor to Slipknot or the groups that had already made it big but were forced to transition vocal duties such as ACDC.

But other times, switching singers really did NOT go over so well...

10. Flyleaf

Flyleaf was one of the most prominent mid-00's bands with a female vocalist. Lacey Sturm came in a tiny package with a massive voice that helped propel the band from Texas onto the mainstream rock charts. Singles such as "I'm So Sick", "Fully Alive", and "All Around Me" put the group on the map.

Advertisement

Together the group was flying high, going on multiple tours, and released three albums. Then in 2012, it was announced that Sturm would be leaving Flyleaf to concentrate on her family life. The rest of the band continued on and recruited Kristen May who had previously sang for the band Vedera.

They would only release one album, 2014's Between the Stars. Although released with mostly positive reviews, the album was thought to be more pop-rock and lost the edge that Sturm brought to the band. May seemingly had more commercial appeal, but there was a growing feeling that she never really belonged in the band and by 2016 she had stepped away, also citing family as the reason.

Meanwhile, Sturm started her solo career and released Life Screams in 2016. The album would go on to outsell Flyleaf's 2014 effort. You can also catch her guest vocals on Breaking Benjamin's re-release of "Dear Agony".

9. Stone Temple Pilots

Formed in the late 80's, STP were one of the pioneers of the grunge movement in the 90's. They found massive success with their 1992 debut, Core. Throughout the decade, STP with frontman Scott Weiland churned out albums and radio hits...despite Weiland's infamous drug abuse. Touring in support of their 1996 album Tiny Music...Songs From the Vatican Gift Shop, Weiland would enter rehab and they had to cancel the remaining '97 dates.

Advertisement

The rest of the group went to work with Dave Coutts singing and performed under the title "Talk Show". With one album (considered a commercial failure) the group disbanded. In 1998, Weiland rejoined STP and they released the No. 4 record which was well received. After one more album, the group again split ways with Weiland joining with members of Guns-n-Roses to form Velvet Revolver. The DeLeo brothers aka bassist and guitarist for STP tried forming their own supergroup called Army of Anyone but the project resulted in only one album.

From 2008-2013, STP was on and off with Weiland back in the fold but 2010's self-titled album would be the last time he would finish a record with them. In 2013, the rest of the group went to work with Linkin Park's Chester Bennington and although he was named an official member, they only managed the 2013 EP High Rise before Bennington announced he would be stepping down to concentrate on Linkin Park in 2015. By 2017, both Weiland and Bennington had died.

In 2016, the members of Stone Temple Pilots announced they would be doing online auditions for a new singer. Jeff Gutt, of X-Factor fame, was later chosen. Together they've released 2018's self-titled album and the 2020 acoustic album Perdida which have been written off as mostly generic. Gutt is doing his best Weiland impression, but it's noticeable that they've lost the edge and excitement of their original frontman.

8. Adema

Adema is a band that tends to be forgotten about and lost in the shuffle of the many mid-level nu-metal groups from the early 00's. Their biggest claim to fame was that they weren't even the biggest band out of Bakersfield, CA...that distinction would go to their frontman's brother's band: Korn.

Advertisement

Singer Mark Chavez is the half-brother of Jonathan Davis. Adema debuted in the summer of 2001. They found immediate success with the self-titled album off the backs of its two lead singles "Giving In" and "The Way You Like It". Together the group would release a follow up EP Insomniac's Dream and then another full length record in 2003, Unstable.

"Unstable" would be the best way to describe the band's next few years as guitarist Mike Ransom and Chavez began having conflicts so bad they wouldn't even speak to each other on tour. Ransom took off in 2003 and Chavez would leave Adema the next year. The remaining members began running through a cycle of replacement vocalists and guitarists.

Starting in '04-'05, they added vocalist Luke Caraccioli and released Planets with Tim Flukey handling all guitar duties. The album got mediocre reviews and Caraccioli would leave by the end of 2005. Next, Adema recruited two members from the band Level. Vocalist Bobby Reeves and guitarist Ed Farris contributed to 2007's Kill the Headlights, an album that wouldn't even reach the Billboard 200. Farris and Reeves stepped away in 2009 as Ransom and Chavez had interest in returning, however after one tour, they left the group again.

Over the next eight years, Fluckey himself stepped up into vocalist duties and that resulted in the 2013 EP Topple the Giants which is really only famous for its terrible album cover.

7. Quiet Riot

Although the Los Angeles rockers became known for their massively successful Metal Health album in 1983, Quiet Riot had actually been formed a decade earlier by legendary guitarist Randy Rhodes. He formed the original line-up with bassist Kelly Garni, drummer Mildred Pierce, and vocalist Kevin DuBrow. Brought in for his energy and enthusiasm, DuBrow was not well liked by his bandmates. Tensions between him and the band caused Garni to drunkenly threaten to attempt to murder him after Rhodes refused to fire DuBrow. Garni was the one who ended up fired.

Advertisement

The band would record two albums with Randy Rhodes and they were only officially released in Japan. Rhodes was unhappy with the direction of the band and left to be in Ozzy's new band. Without their virtuoso guitarist, Quiet Riot floundered through the LA music scene and ultimately disbanded.

DuBrow, with permission from Rhodes, reformed Quiet Riot with bassist Rudy Sarzo. After Rhodes' death in '82, the group almost didn't continue, but ultimately landed a US recording contract and released the album that would make them famous. Their cover of "Cum on Feel the Noize" was the first metal track to land in the Hot 100. After their next two albums couldn't replicate the success of Metal Health, DuBrow grew frustrated and began lashing out and the band fired him in 1987.

His replacement was Paul Shortino who had previously fronted the band Rough Cutt. In 1988, they released the album Quiet Riot IV (or as Shortino later dubbed it QR). While it was favored a bit more positively by critics, the album was again another commercial disappointment and the band split to work on different projects. This led DuBrow to go to court to reclaim the Quiet Riot name.

With the band legally his, DuBrow and Quiet Riot went on to release 6 albums, including the re-mixed compilation album The Randy Rhodes Years. DuBrow died of a cocaine overdose in 2007. The remaining members have released 3 albums and worked with 6 different singers (including American Idol's James Durbin.

6. Skid Row

For the record, there have been two separate bands named "Skid Row". We're not talking about the original Irish band from the 60-70's. We're focusing on that hair metal group that caught fire in the late 80's on the backs of massive singles like "18 and Life" and "I Remember You" while having one the prettiest men in rock, Sebastian Bach, fronting the band. Skid Row secured the rights to use that name and released their debut in 1989.

Advertisement

Going in a heavier direction, they released albums in '91 and '95. While they still sold well, Slave to the Grind and Subhuman Race didn't have big radio hits and never reached the lofty heights of their debut. Despite positive reviews from critics, members of Skid Row decided Sebastian Bach didn't help them fit in with the new grunge era that was taking over. Bach also wanted to group to open for a KISS tour while the rest of the band insisted they were "too big" to be opening for anyone. And so in 1996, they kicked him out.

- Skid Row was an opening act for the 2000 KISS Farewell Tour. -

Unable to secure a new frontman in the following years, the group went in different directions but reformed in 1999 with Jonny Solinger taking over vocal duties. After extensive touring, they released their first full length studio album Thickskin in 2003.

Then Revolutions per Minute was released in 2006. Receiving mixed to negative reviews, the new material further separated their sound as they now emulated the current crop of post-grunge acts of the early 00's. In 2013, Skid Row began work on the United World Rebellion trilogy. It was planned to be two EP's and one full-length album, but Solinger was fired in 2015.

For a brief period in 2015 they worked with Tony Harnell before replacing him with Dragonforce's JP Theart. Theart was named the official singer for Skid Row in 2017 and they're currently working on releasing the third piece of United World Rebellion.

5. Mötley Crüe

Mötley Crüe...you know them, their exploits are infamous. Few groups can make Guns-n-Roses look like angels, but the Crue were chaos incarnate. With a reputation like theirs, there would be a few spouts of spectacle and drama.

Advertisement

After living like kings in the 80's, singer Vince Neil was out in 1992. Neil claims that he was fired while bassist Nikki Sixx stated that he quit. Vince got to work on a solo career and released albums in '93 and '95.

In the meantime, the rest of Mötley Crüe continued to work on a new album, as they had just signed a $25 million deal with Elekra Records. They secretly started contacting and auditioning new singers, not wanting the label to find out and pull out of the deal. Nikki Sixx had been a fan of the work that John Corabi had done with his band The Scream and eventually he was brought in as a replacement.

What resulted was Mötley Crüe's self-titled album. A whole new direction for the band, as they combined their glam metal roots with Corabi's contemporary grunge and alternative sound. For the first time, Sixx was not alone in writing the lyrics and with Corabi handling rhythm guitar duties, Mick Mars was able to experiment more than ever. The band also concentrated on staying clean and sober while in the recording process. The record only went gold, which for a band coming off of five platinum albums was considered a failure.

Panic set in and ultimately Corabi himself suggested that Vince Neil should rejoin the band. He was fired and Neil was back in the fold by 1997.

4. Iron Maiden

In a move that puts Iron Maiden on "Best Times Hard Rock Bands Changed Singers", they replaced their original singer Paul Di'Anno with Bruce Dickenson in 1981. Fast forward 12 years, after 7 albums and multiple massive world tours, Dickenson stepped away to work on solo material.

Advertisement

After an extensive search, the group settled on Blaze Bayley as the replacement. His band Wolfsbane had opened for Iron Maiden on one of their tours. Chosen because his vocal style was nothing like Dickenson, it ended up being one of the main reasons he's not thought of as highly as his predecessor. They released 1995's The X Factor and (for them) it was a commercial disappointment. They toured for the next few years until releasing their next album Virtual XI in 1998.

By this time critics were already writing off the bad as finished and Virtual XI did them no favors. It would be their lowest selling album, failing to reach the one million mark - something Iron Maiden had done with every one of their records to date. Bayley was fired in 1999 as the group realized he wasn't connecting with their fans and his voice just couldn't really keep up with trying to match Dickenson's material when performing it live.

Bruce Dickenson returned to the band permanently in 1999 and fans rejoiced, their 2000 album Brave New World was a critical and commercial success.

3. Genesis

Again, another group that made a miraculous recovery when switching singers. Genesis is well known for seamlessly transitioning from Peter Gabriel to Phil Collins on vocals. What is less talked about is twenty years later when Collins quit the band himself. Needing a change in direction and wanting to work on other projects he announced his departure was amicable.

Advertisement

Unsure whether to disband after 25 years of making music, the remaining two members went ahead and started auditioning new singers. They settled on Ray Wilson of the Scottish band Stiltskin, and made the announcement in 1997. Calling All Stations was released later that year. The album was rather successful in Europe where it even reached #2 in the UK. However, it was poorly received in the United States and a North American tour would end up canceled due to poor sales and lack of interest from the fans.

That would be the last studio record from Genesis and the group split from Wilson. In the years since, they have done a few tours with Collins returning, though it's not likely there will be any new studio recordings.

2. Van Halen

In most fan's eyes, there are two forms of Van Halen...the classic David Lee Roth fronted era and the "Van Hagar" era. There is however, a third era that is often forgotten about from the late 90's.

Advertisement

After falling out with Roth, then Hagar, then Roth again, Van Halen recruited Gary Cherone of Extreme to be the third frontman. They immediately got to work on 1998's Van Halen III. While they scored another #1 spot on the Billboard Mainstream Rock Chart, the album was ultimately a commercial and critical failure.

The group went on a massive world tour in support of III and returned to work on another album with Cherone in '99. The project never saw the light of day as Cherone would step away from the band citing "musical differences" although surprisingly it is said that there was no animosity between the two parties as had been with Hagar and Roth.

Cherone moved on to other projects while the Van Halen brothers have re-united with both Hagar and Roth to differing levels of productivity, stability, and drama.

1. Black Sabbath

Similar to Van Halen, Black Sabbath is most known for two distinct eras in their history: the Ozzy Osborne years and the Ronnie James Dio years. Upon further review there is a whole hell of a lot more forgotten Sabbath vocalists.

Advertisement

The classic line-up of Tony Iommi, Bill Ward, Geezer Butler, and Ozzy formed in the late 60's. Ozzy first tried stepping away in 1977 to pursue a solo career and was briefly replaced by Dave Walker. Though Osbourne would return shortly after, he was officially fired in 1979 because of his substance abuse and replaced by Rainbow's Ronnie James Dio. After two albums and successful touring, he left to form the band Dio.

The remaining members of Sabbath went back to work in the studio, this time with former vocalist from Deep Purple, Ian Gillan. They recorded 1983's Born Again and Gillian stepped away after its release. In 1984, Ron Keel was tapped to be the next singer, but left before an album could be put together. David Donato was next in line, but was out before the end of the year.

In 1985, Iommi was the last original member left and decided to pursue his own solo career and began working with another Deep Purple vocalist in Glenn Hughes. Seventh Star was released in 1986, but Iommi was put under studio pressure to release the record as another Black Sabbath album. Hughes would suffer an injury and was replaced by Ray Gillen.

Gillen left during the recording of 1987's The Eternal Idol, now with Tony Martin coming in to record vocals. Martin managed to last through two more albums having sang for 1989's Headless Cross and 1990's Tyr. Dio returned in 1991, though briefly had a falling out with Iommi over who would handle the drums for 1992's Dehumanizer. Martin was again brought back to record two more albums, 1994's Cross Purposes and 1995's Forbidden (which included a guest appearance from rapper Ice-T). When the last album was panned by fans and critics, Black Sabbath eventually made their long-awaited reunion with Ozzy Osbourne in 1997.

Advertisement