12 Most Underrated Metal Albums

The dark gems that have fallen through the cracks.

By Tom Morgan /

When Black Sabbath released their self-titled debut in 1970 - year zero for metal - they opened a portal to a whole other world of artistic expression. Musicians could now explore the visceral, transgressive, and downright evil in whatever manner they chose to express themselves, and did so in droves.

Advertisement

Metal has a truly global appeal, with scenes for the most niche of subgenres cropping up in the most unexpected of places. This means that there’s a huge wealth of under-heard material out there and it’s only expanding. In 2018, TuneCore discovered that metal was the fastest growing genre of music, meaning that there’s only going to be a lot more of this already overstuffed genre that will inevitably fall through the cracks.

But just because something doesn’t get widely recognised doesn’t mean that it inherently has no worth, many reasons exist for why a music release can become underrated. Its creators could have been deemed ahead of their time, or were in a period of creative flux during its creation. The sub-genre itself could be misunderstood, meaning anything released under its framework gets tarnished along with it. Or the band may simply have produced so much content in their career, that whole albums go by unsung and under-listened to.

This list contains albums that fit into all of those reasons and more. Twelve bands, some well-known, some not so much, who’ve released an album that deserves greater mass recognition that it currently receives.

12. Napalm Death - Diatribes

Napalm Death are a British institution, up there with Black Sabbath and Iron Maiden as one of the country’s greatest metal exports. They rose to prominence in the late eighties playing a form of short, fast crust-punk known as ‘grindcore’. This made the band a cultural curiosity that were loved by some and disparaged by many.

Advertisement

Fortunately, time has been kind to Napalm Death. The band now produce albums of extreme metal beauty packed with fleshed out songs, relentless heaviness and relevant politics. There was an era, however, where the band seemed to be in a state of creative limbo. When Diatribes was released in 1996, it landed with a whimper, with fans admonishing the band for supposedly moving too far away from the sound that made them (in)famous in the first place.

Diatribes is the sound of a band figuring themselves out, experimenting with new ideas, and charting a course for their future. The album contains some brilliant songs, such as lead single Greed Killing, where the band ambitiously synthesise their harsh vocals and frantic drumming with some very '90s alt metal riffing.

It all holds up extremely well today, and deserves a re-evaluation, not just for its unsung quality, but for its importance as a creative stepping stone for Napalm Death’s future career.

11. Floor - Self-Titled + Outtakes

The aesthetics of doom metal are well-known to any metalhead. Down-tuned guitars, lengthy songs and weighty atmospherics are all among the signifiers of this most funereal of music genres. Florida’s Floor, however, threw all of these out of the window in their quest to find a new spin on the iconic sound.

Advertisement

Everything about Floor’s ‘Self-Titled + Outtakes’ screams 'idiosyncratic’. The band hail from sunny Miami, not a location particularly conducive to doom metal’s gloomy worldview. Only one song on the album exceeds three minutes, the band keep each one tight and focused, in keeping with their self-defined ‘doom-pop’ sound. There’s even little trace of doom metal’s usual lyrical preoccupations with the occult, drugs and nihilism, in its place instead are cheeky, irreverent and often joyous melodies.

Guitarist and vocalist Steve Brooks went on to form Torche, who have achieved much wider success and further refined Floor’s doom-pop aesthetic. However Floor deserve a lot of credit for laying down the foundations and for influencing a whole string of bands who wanted to play down-tuned, sludgy riffs, but without the requisite self-seriousness and apocalyptic despair.

10. Lamb Of God - New American Gospel

Before they become one of the breakout stars of the New Wave Of American Metal, four fifths of Lamb Of God’s ‘classic’ line up played together in the metallic hardcore act Burn The Priest. When they signed with Prosthetic Records, their debut album New American Gospel was released under the new name but ejected none of the previous band's punk spirit and raw ferocity.

Advertisement

It’s a relentless and intimidating body of songs with sharp songwriting and production that manages to be engaging in spite of itself. The album is as raw as a scraped knee, particularly by Lamb Of God’s later standards when they would go on to do brilliant work with Devin Townsend and Josh Wilbur. The drums crack like rifle rounds, the guitars are fuzzy and feral, and Randy Blythe’s screams as if buried in a shallow grave.

The craftsmanship on display is far from Lamb Of God’s finest, but in terms of pure, raw ferocity, New American Gospel has rarely been topped over the last few decades. The album has unjustly fallen by the wayside the further Lamb Of God have risen in prominence, perhaps because it’s so much less palatable than their later, more polished work.

However, if you want to hear the sound of a smart young band lunging for the world’s jugular vein, New American Gospel is begging for your time.

9. Wolves In The Throne Room - Black Cascade

Black metal is a much misunderstood subgenre. The abhorrent behaviour of some of its earliest proponents has tarnished the whole scene, meaning that a certain conception of what black metal ‘is’ has become ingrained in our cultural psyche. In fact, there’s much nuance and shades of light and dark to be found within this strange and often fascinating corner of metal.

Advertisement

A lot has been made about ‘ambient black metal’ and how true it is or isn’t to the core, original values of the genre, with the people who care about this sort of thing being as equally criticised for their complaints. Black metal is as free as any other subgenre and its expansion of aesthetic choices and influences is something to be praised, not lambasted.

Black Cascade proves that ‘ambient' bands like Wolves In The Throne Room are a force to be reckoned with, writing lengthy but deliberate tracks that are heavy as anything produced in the early 90s Scandinavian wilderness. Criticism of the band stems from the their rejection of black metal staples such as satanic imagery and corpse paint, childishly decrying them as ‘hipsters’ because they’ve dared to think differently. Black Cascade deserves a wider appreciation, at the least because it will help move black metal away from these retrograde notions of genre.

8. Slayer - Divine Intervention

There’s a reason Slayer are Slayer. The thrash legends have never put out a bad record, stubbornly refusing to follow trends or fashions by sticking to their tried and tested formula. The sound they defined on 1986’s Reign In Blood is as close to metal perfection as is possible, so the band have rarely strayed from this particular left handed path.

Advertisement

On their first album without drummer Dave Lombardo, Slayer bravely push replacement Paul Bostaph’s playing to the forefront of the mix, where the tight, precise double-kick drumming becomes almost oppressive like the panicked beat of a heart ready to explode from your chest. Elsewhere, the chromatic riffs and dive-bombing solos are as punishing as ever. Tom Araya even manages to one up Slayer’s own high-standards of lyrical transgression with 213, a genuinely grim song inspired by serial killer Jeffery Dahmer.

Divine Intervention isn’t Slayer’s most fondly remembered album, perhaps because it came right after that incredible one-two punch of Reign In Blood and Seasons In The Abyss. But it more than holds its own against those two classics, and deserves to be remembered as one of this iconic band’s most accomplished works.

7. The Ocean - Anthropocentric

This list includes few comparably recent albums, mostly because it usually takes a degree of time and space away from a release for it to be deemed underrated. However, The Ocean’s Anthropocentric has been included because it's the finest work of an immensely talented band who have, thus far, found major worldwide success elusive.

Advertisement

The German band have put out record after record of ambitious work, of which Anthropocentric is their glorious high point. A metaphysical, complex work, it features weighty thematic concerns critiquing fundamentalist Chrisitanity, using the ideas of Dostoyevsky, Galileo and Nietzsche. Beneath all the philosophy and history are an intelligent and often straight-up fun body of tracks, post-metal epics and mathcore bludgeons that add up to fifty minutes of near-perfect progressive metal.

Despite playing festivals across the globe and touring with established acts, The Ocean have never received the recognition they deserve from within the metal subculture. They have the potential to become much more than just cult favourites, and a rediscovery of Anthropocentric seems the best way for this to be achieved.

6. Tad - Inhaler

Tad are a hugely underrated metal band. They toured with Nirvana, recorded with Steve Albini and were discovered by Sub Pop, but never went on to achieve the same success as others bands who’d forged similar career paths. 1993’s Inhaler is their greatest achievement; eleven down-tuned, fuzzy headbangers that prove both consistently engaging and slyly transgressive.

Advertisement

The true sound of grunge was never Nirvana’s quiet/loud anthems or Pearl Jam’s passionate stadium rock. It was the sludgy misery of Alice In Chains, the eccentricities of The Melvins, Mudhoney’s superfuzz ugliness. Wild, country outsiders who listened to Flipper and Big Black and sang about serial killers. Tad are a wonderful example of the grim, dirty side of a genre that was supposed to encompass just those things, but quickly became this uncontrollable cultural behemoth.

Tad are one of the great early 90’s alternative metal bands, much earthier and more sinister than the jazz-trained, urban Helmet, with whom their sound shares some similarities. Inhaler is their finest achievement, a hugely underrated album that stands on its own, away from the more-famous genre to which Tad were intrinsically linked.

5. Metallica - St. Anger

A deeply controversial album, St. Anger continues to generate the ire of metal fans today, seventeen years after its release. Much-maligned for its lack of solos, odd production choices and perceived substandard songwriting, St. Anger has few defenders, or apologists, as some will call them.

Advertisement

The general consensus is that Metallica have never matched their ‘classic’ run of albums between 1983 and 1988. This idea of what Metallica are ‘supposed to be’ has become ingrained in the popular consciousness, and as a result, St. Anger, with its lack of so much of what made those albums great, is often used as the definitive example of why Metallica are an inferior prospect compared to the titans they once were.

This might be true, but is also hugely unfair on the band, who’ve spent the intervening years between St. Anger and now trying to rectify for its mistakes. These recent albums have turned out mixed results, and are the sound of a band who’ve spent too long listening to their fans instead of forging their own latter-day career path. The result is a failure to progress as a band, all because they tried too hard to please their fan base.

St. Anger is the sound of a band closely observing the zeitgeist and trying their own take on it. Whether or not the result is to your liking, St. Anger is an album that’s among Metallica’s darkest and most ambitious, and deserves some form of appreciation, instead of its apparent fate as a metalhead’s punchline.

4. Gorguts - Considered Dead

The Quebec death metal scene is underrated enough in itself, producing quality bands such as Cryptopsy, Kataklysm, Despised Icon, as well as Gorguts, the most revered and accomplished of them all. Their 1998 album Obscura is one of the most challenging and uncompromising works of art ever produced in any genre, let alone death metal, and is the shining jewel in their glittering discography.

Advertisement

But their 1991 debut Considered Dead is also close to faultless, deserving of the highest praise possible for it's white-hot, technically-proficient traditional death metal. Playing with all the confidence of an experienced, established band, Gorguts seemed to have already mastered old school death metal on Considered Dead, with its thunderous riffs, note-perfect vocals and evil aesthetic hitting each of its gory targets with ruthless accuracy.

Conspicuously absent from many lists of greatest death metal albums, Considered Dead is a phenomenal achievement, one that would give Gorguts the confidence in their abilities to deconstruct their sound and genre when they came to writing Obscura. For its importance in the development of this iconic band, as well as being a near perfect example of its subgenre, Considered Dead deserves to be recognised as one of the greats.

3. Disembodied - Diablerie

There is a whole wealth of contemporary bands that owe a huge debt to Disembodied. Specifically, the nu-metalcore acts such as Code Orange, Knocked Loose and Vein, who took the vicious, angular aspects of Disembodied’s music and piled atop their own layers of contemporary bleakness and savagery.

Advertisement

Diablerie was the first of only two full-length albums released by the band during their original lifetime, but its roots have spread far across the heavy musical landscape. Although Disembodied are often classed as a hardcore punk act, there’s very little in the musicality of Diablerie that could be classed as ‘punk’. The album rarely exceeds that of a mid-tempo stomp, preferring to opt instead for mean, punishing buildups and breakdowns, with guitars that sound like Sepultura jamming with early-My Dying Bride.

Disembodied deserve an audience beyond the slam-dancing hardcore kids. Their music is intense, nihilistic and doomy, far removed from the amphetamine-charged, often empowering drive of traditional hardcore punk. With its progressive stylistic fusion and bleak worldview, Diablerie appears more and more ahead of its time with every day that passes.

2. Entombed - Uprising

Though perhaps best known as the defining band of the first wave of Scandanavian death metal, Entombed have accrued a varied back catalogue that veers wildly through differing metal subgenres. The band quickly moved on from conventional death metal, and by their third album were coining the sound now known as ‘death ‘n’ roll’.

Advertisement

By 2000’s Uprising, Entombed had perfected this blend of harsh vocals, buzzsaw riffs and d-beat drums. It all feels like a culmination of their previous albums’ experimentations, and the band truly sound like themselves for the first time since the early albums. The production is also really sharp, which given that more than a few of Entombed’s records feature some poor technical execution, is a minor triumph.

Like many underrated albums, the easiest way to measure Uprising’s worth is by counting the debt of influence so clearly owed to the album. The whole mid-00’s hardcore/southern rock fusion scene seems to have sprung from Uprising, traces of its DNA can be found in bands such as Cancer Bats, He Is Legend and Every Time I Die, whose guitarist Andy Williams has mentioned the album as a favourite.

The roots of Uprising have travelled far, yet it's never bloomed in the way Entombed’s early work has.

1. Iron Maiden - Brave New World

One of the most iconic bands to ever grace the metal genre, Iron Maiden have become a globally-loved institution thanks to their relentless touring and consistently strong musical output. Their ‘third act’ of their career has seen the band achieve enormous success, all of which couldn’t have happened if Maiden hadn’t continued producing quality albums such as Brave New World.

Advertisement

Following a minor creative slump in the 1990’s, Maiden reintroduced Bruce Dickinson and Adrian Smith, two members of their ‘classic’ line up, into the fold for 2000’s Brave New World. The result was an album that’s easily their finest since 1988’s Seventh Son of A Seventh Son, the final masterpiece of their incredible ‘classic’ run of albums.

Everything about it works, to the point where it achieves a level of song-by-song consistency that surpasses even some of those famous early full-lengths. One of Maiden’s greatest tricks has always been their ability to make complex, lengthy arrangements feel elegant and enthralling, which they demonstrate here on tracks such as Dream Of Mirrors and the lovely closer The Thin Line Between Love And Hate. The shorter tracks are also equally fantastic, with The Wicker Man in particular becoming a fan favourite.

Iron Maiden are one of the greatest metal acts of time, and Brave New World is their unsung masterpiece, that, whisper it, may just be their greatest achievement.

Advertisement