5 Guitarists That Could Replace DJ Ashba In Guns N' Roses

What we've got here is failure to communicate...

By WhatCulture /

Inevitably, Guns N' Roses guitarist DJ Ashba must now be referred to as former Guns N' Roses guitarist DJ Ashba. He joins a long list of axe-slingers to gain the "former" prefix, with everyone from Paul Tobias, to Slash, to Izzy Stradlin, to Buckethead, to Robin Finck, to Gilby Clarke joining and exiting the band over the years. There's been a huge number of guest guitarists too, including Brian May and Dave Navarro, meaning that guitarists are to GN'R what drummers were to Spinal Tap - disposable entities that change with the seasons. Ashba had a decent innings. He was with the band for about 6 years, touring several times, although - in typical GN'R fashion - he has yet to appear on an official studio release. Mainly because there hasn't been one since 2008's long-awaited Chinese Democracy. There's no doubt that Ashba's decision to leave (which is probably due to the band's inactivity) will hold up any potential music that they were working on yet further, but that doesn't mean that speculation hasn't already begun as to who his replacement will be. Assuming Ron "Bumblefoot" Thal stays (he has hinted that he may leave), Axl Rose has Thal and Richard Fortus (rhythm guitarist) filling two of the three guitar slots in the new band. So who would fit as the third member? Five gifted and intriguing options are pondered here. Sadly, the legendary Slash isn't included. Yes, he is the most important and influential guitarist that the band has ever had, but Axl has made it quite clear that a reunion with the top-hatted guitar god will never happen. These five, crazy and odd though each of them may be, are at least somewhat realistic. The idea of Slash ever returning to Guns N' Roses is nothing more than a pipe-dream, sadly.

Advertisement

5. Zakk Wylde

The first name on the list is also the most unlikely. Zakk Wylde, best known as Ozzy Osbourne's guitarist, is one of the hardest players and, despite the harshness of his tone, has a tremendous ability to write really beautiful and emotional solos. Just check out his most famous solo track In This Rive, a balladic tribute to his deceased friend Dimebag Darrell. Many GN'R fans are against the idea of Wylde joining the band because of his more-metal-than-thou look and the heavy nature of his sound, but there is no doubt that he has talent. He's also reportedly got a good relationship with Axl Rose and hooked up with the band during the recording of Chinese Democracy. Sadly, the fact that he rejected the opportunity to be with them full-time back then makes it unlikely that he'd jump at the chance now, but he would certain amp up the band's sound and complement Bumblefoot and Fortus very nicely.

4. Dave Navarro

Dave Navarro, founding member of Jane's Addiction and former guitarist with The Red Hot Chili Peppers, is another who contributed to the Chinese Democracy sessions without actually becoming an official member of the band. He is even featured on the 1999 single Oh My God. His virtuosity and very impressive resume makes him a popular choice with GN'R fans, and both stylistically and in terms of his stage persona he actually shares a fair amount in common with DJ Ashba. Bearing in mind that Axl already has an exceptional rhythm guitarist in Richard Fortus, thus ruling out returns for the likes of Gilby or Izzy, Navarro could be the perfect figure to reintroduce the sexy rock and roll swagger back into the GN'R aesthetic. Sadly, Navarro may have burned his bridges as far as GN'R is concerned. Rumours regarding the reason for him never becoming a permanent member in the 90s suggested that his well-documented drug issues made him too erratic to join the band full-time (imagine that - someone too self-destructive even for Axl!). Navarro seems to have cleaned up his act recently though, so don't be too shocked if Axl considers him for the third slot.

3. Robin Finck

In the eyes of many fans of GN'R's post-Use Your Illusion lineups, Robin Finck was THE most important member after Axl Rose. Employed during the late 1990s after Axl developed a love of Nine Inch Nails (with whom Finck was the live guitarist), Finck's surreal cybergoth image and quirky, imperfect playing style granted the band an unpredictability that clashed wonderfully with the perfectionism of its leader. He's divisive, with many hating his treatment of Slash's classic solos, but he certainly made an impact. GN'R had always thrived on imperfection, with its drunken or stoned classic members' frequent live mess-ups giving them a reputation as a gang of punks. Finck's oddness continued that respected reputation for a DIY approach, even as Chinese Democracy became a huge budget affair. He has been in and out of the band on several occasions over the years, leaving in both the early and late 2000s, so his reliability is an issue. However, Axl clearly liked his playing enough to welcome him back more than once - could it happen again?

2. John 5

Every time that GN'R have needed a new guitarist over the past 10 years or so, former Marilyn Manson and current Rob Zombie guitarist John 5 has been one of the names at the top of most GN'R fans' wish lists. With good reason: he is one of the most technically gifted guitarists not just in contemporary industrial rock/metal, but in the whole of rock music today. He fits the mould perfectly. Axl has long had a fascination with industrial-sounding music (check out Oh My God, Silkworms, Shackler's Revenge...), which is the most natural environment for John 5 to thrive in, and his presence may encourage Axl to re-evaluate some of the more experimental sounds that he toyed with and eventually predominantly discarded in the late 90s. But John 5 is more than just a one-trick pony. His solo material displays an emotional style that rivals even that of Slash, and he is undoubtedly a more capable joint lead guitarist than Ashba. While his image may be slightly off-putting for more conservative GN'R fans (coated in make up, a shock of white/silver hair, goth clothing), it's nothing weirder than some (Finck, Buckethead) that have come before and been immensely popular.

1. Buckethead

There is no question about it - Buckethead, the white-masked, nunchaku-wielding, KFC-bucket-hatted giant that lives in a chicken coop and only speaks through his hand puppet Herbie - is the most memorable non-Axl member that GN'R have had since Slash left the band. That is, of course, partially due to his rather recognisable image. However, it is also because he is technically superb, and arguably defined the sound of Chinese Democracy more than anyone aside from Rose himself. Buckethead is best known as a shredder and is pretty much the fastest around, which is one reason why he has come in for criticism from some fans that prefer a slower approach. It's also why many question whether he would fit back into the lineup that he left in 2004, given the enduring presence of fellow speedster Bumblefoot. The fact is, though, that Buckethead is far more eclectic stylistically than he is given credit for. Check out his odd experiments on the intro/verses of Shackler's Revenge, his excellent performances throughout Madagascar and Prostitute, or his gorgeous album-stealing solo on Sorry for proof that Bucket can do the lot. There's also his wide-ranging solo career, which has seen him excel at practically every guitar style imaginable, or his genre-flipping work in bands like Bill Laswell's Praxis. He could complement the more blues-y styles of both Fortus and Bumblefoot immaculately. Most fans would welcome Bucket back into the fold. Some might even prefer his return to the next-to-zero-percent-chance of Slash rejoining. Either way, his presence would provide a much-needed boost to the new band, although the unsavoury nature of his departure (since forgiven by Axl) may have closed the door on any reunion. If you're reading this, Buckethead, come back. GN'R needs you. Oh, and bring your buddy Brain along too - he's still the best drummer the band has ever had.