The second album. A difficult proposition for any band, particularly one that has found immediate success with their debut and are under immense pressure to record and release a follow-up before the hype disappears; surpass your debut and keep your fans, disappoint them and you are nothing more than a flash in the pan. With that in mind, this article selects six albums that are generally considered colossal failures and catastrophic missteps from bands or artists that had shown such promise. We've all experienced that feeling where you have found your new favourite band and are highly anticipating their sophomore effort only to rush to the record shop (these were buildings which sold actual hard-copies of music, crazy eh!) race home, play the thing and realise you've been duped. Faced with either a carbon copy of the first album or simply a lack of originality and invention, all the facets that made you love the debut have been removed and replaced with a tired, commercialised sound that sounds like a record company suit with dollar sign for eyes has written the majority of the record himself. A sadly crushing realisation all of us have probably had the misfortune to experience on more than one occasion. At the start of their career, a band can often be given the freedom to hone their craft, forging a set of perfect songs which have been meticulously rehearsed, adapted and primed to hit with maximum impact only to be told they have approximately 2 weeks to write and record the follow up. We envy no band who have found themselves in this ridiculous situation. Many of the artists on this list have come back with a third album which rights the wrongs of the second but this list is concerned with those albums that epitomise the phrase 'difficult second album syndrome'. Let the inevitable backlash commence....
6. The Stone Roses - Second Coming
One track that can at least be recommended: "Ten Storey Love Song". This is what The Stone Roses should sound like and would have been right at home on the Roses immense debut album. The bands extraordinary self-titled debut, released in 1989, made an immediate impact in the UK, kickstarting a British rock/pop revival which has afforded them legendary status. The band waited five long years to release a follow up so in this case record label pressure couldn't be to blame for the tepid response. Instead, the band themselves seem to be their own worst enemies - believing their own hype - its called the Second Coming for one - and trying to remodel themselves as the new Led Zeppelin; something that could never be possible with Ian Brown as your singer. Morphing from a band writing delicious Rock-Pop anthems such as the gloriously infectious "Waterfall", into a 1970's inspired, fuzzy, Blues-Rock beast was a strange move. Its not that they couldn't deliver, their playing had improved significantly (five years of practice will do that) its that when they did decide to return they found a musical environment significantly altered; Blur, Oasis and Radiohead were the new kings and The Stone Roses didn't quite fit the profile. In comparison to their debut, Second Coming is not an accessible album. Opening track "Breaking Into Heaven" takes over four long minutes to get going, testing your patience and practically screaming pretentiousness in your face. Gone are the joyous three minutes of guitar-pop perfection, replaced with a band who seem content to record their jam sessions instead; not without merit, but confusing nonetheless. Heavy, dirty riffs feature predominantly, dominating the majority of the album ("Driving South", "Tears", "Love Spreads") but experimentation is also rife. The Funk-Groove of "Daybreak" is exciting and different and "Begging You" feels like a precursor to the Neo-Dance-Psychedelia that The Chemical Brothers embraced just a few years later; stone-cold proof that The Stone Roses were still influential. The softer touch that characterised their eponymous debut does occasionally make an appearance. "Your Star Will Shine" is a Folk-Rock ballad which recalls the majority of songs found on Led Zeppelin III and "Ten Storey Lovesong" winds the clock back 5 years. Second Coming is certainly not without its merits, in fact it is a pretty strong album but in comparison to their debut and the expectation heaped upon them on their return, the result may have been five years in the making but it wasn't necessarily worth the wait. The one band who seemed capable of destroying all competition only succeeded in destroying themselves, a third album has never materialised. As the dust has settled, time has been relatively kind to Second Coming.To repeat; it is not a bad record - just not what the public expected or perhaps wanted at the time. In hindsight, when you have recorded an album as outstanding as their debut did The Stone Roses ever really stand a chance? It's no surprise they imploded in 1996, only recently reuniting as part of the now-burgeoning nostalgia market.
5. Franz Ferdinand - You Could Have It So Much Better
One track that can at least be recommended: "Do You Want To". A Kraut-Disco stomper which recalled the addictive dance-floor energy of "The Dark of the Matinée" from the bands debut. The title says it all, and we really did have it so much better on Franz Ferdinand's debut which took the UK by storm in 2004 (has it really been 10 years already?). Just a year later Franz Ferdinand released their second album and perhaps they should have let these songs mature for a little longer, as label pressure to capitalise on their instant success seems very likely here. You Could Have It So Much Better is not a bad album, far from it. It was also a hit, so why is it included here? Franz had been everywhere, their videos on constant rotation, their songs played in every club around the country and in all honesty, perhaps we needed a break; maybe some time to miss them, ready then to welcome them back with open arms. It felt like the equivalent of the in-laws coming round for the weekend and then surprising you by staying on for another week. You may feign delight but in reality you have had just about enough of them. Neither as immediate or as infectious as their debut and practically screaming of overkill, You Could Have It So Much Better could have profited from a delay, a chance to let the public soak up their great debut before unleashing their follow-up on an audience which would then have been ravenous for more. As it was, it all felt like too much, too soon. It's a shame, because obviously - it could of been so much better.
4. The Darkness - One Way Ticket to Hell ...and Back
One track that can at least be recommended: "One Way Ticket". Rock cliches may be reeled off at an astonishing rate (the use use of cow-bell, Justin Hawkins discussing his drug problems) but its undeniably infectious and a reminder of the quality of the debut. Hard-Rock was given a swift kick in the knackers when The Darkness arrived high-kicking and screaming in 2003. Blessed with a proud 'English-ness' not heard since the likes of Blur's "Parklife" and clad head to toe in soft-bits-revealing catsuits, the UK finally had a band who embraced the kind of Hard Rock/Rock-Opera shenanigans the likes of which hadn't been seen since the glory days of Queen. The Darkness' debut was awesome, took everyone completely by surprise and was a slab of pure unadulterated fun; 80's spandex and star-jumps, updated for the 00's. Then came the follow-up. The riffs were kinda there, the humour was kinda there but the public's appetite was not. Maybe it was too close to the blueprint laid out by their massive debut but the magic contained on Permission to Land's 10 tracks seemed strangely dialled down. "Is it just Me" may have a riff which Status Quo would have rejected for being too simple but the chorus redeems it; built for arenas and a rollicking good sing-along. "Hazel Eyes" on the other hand is frankly terrible, painful to listen to at times and blatantly straining to be humorous and quirky. The rise and fall of the band, seemingly led by Justin Hawkins' drug and alcohol issues was hard to watch. They had promised so much but the fall from grace was swift and scathing. It took seven years for them to recover (literally in Justin Hawkins case, who is now sober) and release a third album, but the moment had passed.
3. The Strokes - Room On Fire
One track that can at least be recommended: "Reptilia". The Strokes stick to the formula but in this case the 'if it ain't broke, don't fix it' attitude seemed appropriate. Sometimes a band arrives with a buzz bigger than a giant mutated bumblebee and New York's Garage-Rock darlings The Strokes did exactly that when they released their debut Is This It in 2001. Unassailably cool, they effortlessly made an enormous impact, helping to usher in a Garage-Rock revival and a follow up was awaited with bated breath but when Room On Fire landed the disappointment was palpable. The Strokes were given only three months of studio time to record the album, label pressure rearing its ugly, dollar-obsessed head yet again. Subsequently, what we got was This Is It, Mk II. Seriously, it's that similar. There was no deviation and apparently no inspiration; just a carbon copy of the debut. Guitarist Nick Valensi has even stated that "the album would've ended up a lot better if we'd had another couple of weeks", an admission which suggests even the band knew this release was sub-standard and rushed. It's a shame that only the room and not the band were on fire as this second album was more of a damp squib than a raging inferno.
2. Terence Trent Darby - Neither Fish Nor Flesh
One track that can at least be recommended: "This Side Of Love". Stripped-back and experimental, "This Side Of Love" is the one true highlight salvaged from a quagmire of pretentious mediocrity. What the chuff happened to Terrence Trent Darby? Blessed with an outstanding singing voice that could rival Prince and Stevie Wonder, his debut yielded three Top Ten UK hit singles and then two years later he released what can only be described as an ego-dominated abomination. To say his sophomore album, Neither Fish Nor Flesh was not well received would be an understatement of biblical proportions. Stupid random title aside, 12 songs of relentless, pretentious posturing led to any goodwill Darby had garnered disappearing quicker than a cold pint of beer on a hot summers day. Not that this was necessarily a surprise, when Darby released his debut it was amidst a whirlwind of publicity - created primarily by him - who had stated his debut was better than The Beatles Sgt Pepper's album! That's some statement; better back it up matey. Hampered with a cumbersome subtitle (A Soundtrack of Love, Faith, Hope & Destruction), it was clear from the song titles alone that we were in for a bumpy ride; "I Have Faith in These Desolate Times", "It Feels So Good to Love Someone Like You", "To Know Someone Deeply Is to Know Someone Softly". Here were songs so breathtakingly self-involved, Darby practically flushed his career down the toilet in one fell swoop - which is the only thing that can happen when you release a complete turd of an album.
1. Hootie And The Blowfish - Fairweather Johnson
One track that can at least be recommended: "Old Man & Me (When I Get to Heaven)". It's ok. It's got guitars and singing and stuff. In the face of Grunge's all conquering dominance, Hootie and the Blowfish's 1994 debut was a blessed relief, a return to folksy, radio-friendly (albeit extraordinarily safe) soft-rock brimming with melody, hooks and broad appeal. Grunge's self-loathing angst had become boring and music fans' responded to Hootie's positive sounds in their millions; 15 million of them to be precise. And then came the follow-up. It was...ok. Well, it was pretty bland really, like a piece of dry toast... that's gone mouldy. Admittedly, Hootie and the Blowfish were never the most exciting of bands in the first place and perhaps they really did say all they needed to say on that monumentally successful first album, but perfect timing appears to primarily be accountable for their debut's impact. People were already bored of 'safe' when they returned just two years later, and when all your songs start to sound the same you're in big, big trouble. The world had moved on and Hootie didn't appear to have the pace to catch up, inevitably the front-runners became also-rans. Which other bands dropped the ball in spectacular fashion when it came to following up on their debut? Let us know in the comments!