Every Billy Joel Album Ranked Worst To Best

From The Stranger to Glass Houses, which of the Piano Man's records is the best of the best?

By Aidan Whatman /

Billy Joel is one of music's most well-known songwriters, able to balance a wide range of musical genres and tackle big, socio-political themes. During his time as a recording artist, he released thirteen albums, all of them bestsellers. Since his final album was released, he has remained a top-draw live act, selling out stadiums just as he did in the 80s.

Advertisement

Despite this enduring popularity, though, there's always been something underrated about him. Everybody knows he rocks as a pianist, and some of his melodies are instantly recognisable classics, but with his turbulent personal life and the fame of his contemporaries (think Bruce Springsteen or Elvis Costello), Joel's abilities as a lyricist often go underpraised.

Over his albums, the Piano Man fused funk with soul, pop with rock, and classical music with jazz, all the while telling great stories, painting vivid pictures and maintaining his fiery, rebellious persona. His lyrics spoke to the masses, the loners, the rebels, the romantics and the dreamers, and though not all of his albums were perfect, all offer something that few musicians have ever been able to fully emulate.

With all that in mind, here are all of Billy Joel's albums ranked worst to best.

13. HONOURABLE MENTION: Fantasies & Delusions

Before we get into the bulk of Joel's work, it's worth giving a shout-out to his last album, Fantasies & Delusions. Released in 2001, the album features an array of classical compositions written by Joel and performed by pianist Richard Hyung-ki Joo. There are no lyrics, no raging rock ballads and no flashy pop songs.

Advertisement

Despite this, Fantasies & Delusions is a wonderful album, perfect for those nights when you want to listen to something relaxing in the background. It's not bursting with character like the majority of Joel's other work, but it does give an insight into just how accomplished a songwriter and music composer he really is.

12. Cold Spring Harbour

Cold Spring Harbour was Joel's first studio album. Released under Family Productions and Columbia Records, the album was marred with technical issues, and upon its release the whole thing was far from what Joel had intended. The music was clunky and unimpressive, and his vocals were poorly dubbed, making him sound far too high-pitched and out of character.

Advertisement

First released in 1971, the album was eventually remastered in 1983, fixing the record's many bugs. But even with the long-awaited polish, there is still something lacking from the album. The music, whilst featuring some great piano work, is still not quite up to par with what Joel would achieve on later records, and the production still features a fuzzy overtone that distracts from Joel's lyrics.

Despite these issues, it's worth noting that Joel was only twenty-two when Cold Spring Harbour came out, and if you can get passed the production, his musical sensibilities already show a man in complete control of his talent. The album also features "She's Got a Way," which remains one of Joel's most popular songs. It's just a shame they messed it up during its initial release.

Best Songs: She's Got a Way, Everybody Loves You Now

11. Streetlife Serenade

Joel's third studio album, Streetlife Serenade came during a difficult time in the young songwriter's life. He had spent the last few years in LA, where he had recorded his first two records, and by the time 1974 came along, he was sick of the west coast lifestyle and ready to return to the bustling state of New York.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, this leads to some problems with the album, which basically plays like an angry series of rants and complaints about Los Angeles. The song "Los Angelenos" in particular shows a man bitter and homesick, and for the most part he struggles to escape his negativity and really lean into the stronger, more thoughtful aspects of the album.

The best track on the record is probably "The Entertainer," a witty and well-crafted look at the life of a musician and how difficult it can be to make the album you want without upsetting the producers or the fans. Even with this song, though, the album falls a touch flat, too full of cynicism for the melodies and social observations to be properly enjoyed.

Best Songs: The Entertainer, Roberta, Souvenir

10. The Bridge

Released in 1986, The Bridge is yet another of Joel's albums that hits some snags due to the singer's pessimism and unsubtle attacks on the people and places he doesn't like. This is especially true of the final track, the bitter "Getting Closer," which sees Joel attack his old producers and complain about his contract with Columbia Records.

Advertisement

On top of this unavoidable anger dampening the feel of the record, The Bridge also finds Joel attempting to embrace the synth-pop sounds of the 80s, and as a whole it just doesn't work with Joel's typical sound.

The record, overall, is bit of a bump in Joel's discography, but keeps itself from the bottom spot thanks to the Ray Charles-featuring "Baby Grand" and the wonderfully jazzy "Big Man on Mulberry Street." The Bridge shows Joel as disillusioned and angry, and regardless of whether such emotions were warranted or not at the time, none of his negativity helps the finished product.

Best Songs: Baby Grand (feat. Ray Charles), Big Man of Mulberry Street, Modern Woman

9. The Nylon Curtain

Wanting to create an album with more melodic tones and refined lyricism, Joel spent more time than ever focused on making his vision come true with his eight record. By Joel's own standards, he succeeded on all counts, as he considers The Nylon Curtain to be his best work, and the record he is most proud of.

Advertisement

Many see the record as a passion project, as well as a tribute to The Beatles and the recently lost John Lennon. The lyrics are sombre but hopeful, and the fusion of jazz and pop still holds up today. Each song features a new tone and a new theme, showcasing Joel's ability to move so easily between genres and mix-up the songwriting formula.

The record opens with the brilliant "Allentown" and features the epic "Goodnight Saigon," an ode to the soldiers who fought during the Vietnam War. The second half of the album may not be as strong as the ambitious first, but all in all The Nylon Curtain is a great slice of music joy.

Best Songs: Allentown, Goodnight Saigon, Pressure

8. River Of Dreams

Joel's second-to-last album, River of Dreams is a rock-heavy effort bursting with spirituality. From the opening chords of the socio-political anthem "No Man's Land" to the spiritual melodies of the title track, the album adopts a much more mature and serious tone than Joel's other records, with many songs referencing environmental issues and themes of love and pain.

Advertisement

Many listeners consider River of Dreams to be one of Joel's weaker efforts, with emphasis often put on how his voice doesn't mesh too well with the rock sensibilities running through the record. Looking at the album as a whole, though, this doesn't seem too fair an assessment. Not only does Joel's voice work with the tone of the record, but the whole thing listens like an artist who is at peace with his career and ready, perhaps, to move on.

River of Dreams was the last album Joel sang on, and was released back in 1993. After its release, he took to touring, deciding he had said all he needed to say and had nothing left to prove. Listening to the album, that shines through on every track.

Best Songs: No Man's Land, River of Dreams, All About Soul

7. Storm Front

Marking a striking change in Billy Joel's backing band's line-up, Storm Front was released in 1989 and saw the singer reach for new heights. More unfiltered and honest than ever, the album features the epic "We Didn't Start the Fire," an anthem that chronicles the ups-and-downs of politics and pop culture from the 1940s until the year the album came out.

Advertisement

Opening with the hair-metal inspired "That's Not Her Style" and featuring one of his more underrated tracks with the brilliant "The Downeaster Alexa," Storm Front finds Joel reaching for a more modern sound, and pulling it off with almost every track. The only blip on the record comes courtesy of "I Go to Extremes," which sounds as though he's reaching too far out of his comfort zone in an attempt to be different.

Still, by this point in his career, Joel has already done it all, from jazz to soul, funk to rock, pop to synth, and Storm Front paints a portrait of an artist who just wants to have some fun and mix things up, perfectly comfortable with taking risks.

Best Songs: We Didn't Start the Fire, Leningrad, And So It Goes

6. Glass Houses

Glass Houses marks the biggest risk Joel ever took with his career, but also one of his biggest ever personal victories. With the 70s done and dusted, Joel decided to mix his softer style with the rock and punk sounds that had began to dominate the music scene. With the New Wave genre in his corner, he released an album that almost defied genre, and showcased all of his best attributes.

Advertisement

From the melodic tones of "You May Be Right" to Joel's assessment of the music scene in "It's Still Rock and Roll to Me," Glass Houses is not merely an answer to punk-rock culture, but a seamless fusion of the New Wave sound with Joel's own brand of pop.

"It's Still Rock and Roll to Me" still stands as the best on the album, but praise also deserves to fall to "All for Leyna," a catchy piece of storytelling that marries Joel's excellent lyricism with his new sound without issue. Glass Houses, all told, is the closest Joel ever got to making a pure rock album, and the results are to die for.

Best Songs: It's Still Rock and Roll to Me, You May Be Right, All for Leyna, Through the Long Night

5. Turnstiles

Despite only being his fourth album, 1976's Turnstiles is one of Joel's very best records, and sees an artist completely at ease with testing the waters, pushing the boundaries of what he can do in the studio and attempting to craft something that few on the scene were willing to try at the time. It came out just before he really blew up, and promises ever bigger things.

Advertisement

Turnstiles is full to bursting with every genre Joel ever tackled, from the almost bluesy "New York State of Mind," the exciting "All You Wanna Do Is Dance" and the thoughtful anthems "Say Goodbye to Hollywood" and "Angry Young Man."

Every track offers something fresh and new, and you can tell just from hearing it that Joel is ready to hit audiences with something big - find his sound, settle into his comfort zone and really let loose. Turnstiles may not be as refined as what was still to come, but when there's this much variety to enjoy on one album, that's really not a problem.

Best Songs: New York State of Mind, Say Goodbye to Hollywood, Angry Young Man

4. Piano Man

Ignoring the legal difficulties that marred both its production and release, Piano Man was Billy Joel's second album, and should really have been the one to launch him to superstardom. In hindsight, at least. At the time, it sold well and got him noticed, but it would't be for another four years before he really reached the masses.

Advertisement

Even with its anti-climatic reception, though, Piano Man has emerged as one Joel's most popular records, a musical extravaganza that perfectly balances his already fantastic lyricism with his spotless abilities behind the piano.

The title track might just be Joel's most well-known song, and is a fine example of how enduring his music has proven to be. "Captain Jack," meanwhile, allows Joel to break all the rules and rock out a seven minute anthem of teenage angst and his observations of drug addiction in his old neighbourhood.

Piano Man marked a major improvement from his debut effort, with more mature songwriting and better production ensuring that Joel was sure to end up as one of the musical giants of the generation.

Best Songs: Piano Man, Captain Jack, You're My Home, Travellin' Prayer

3. An Innocent Man

Written as a tribute to the music he had grown up with as a child, An Innocent Man married Joel's sublime knack for powerful lyrics with the sounds of James Brown, Sam Cooke and all of his 50s idols. Bursting with heart, the record is perhaps Joel's most truly happy and relaxed, as he later said about it: "I felt like a teenager all over again."

Advertisement

The album allowed Joel to tap into how free he felt after his divorce, and how successful he felt having recently won a slew of Grammys and sold millions of copies of his other work. The result is a light, focused and often moving record, showing Joel in his best state emotionally and his most comfortable musically.

An Innocent Man features the timeless "Uptown Girl," the ingenious "The Longest Time" (which features no instruments, only Joel's harmonies and some finger-snapping), and the striking title track. It also features all that makes Joel such a great musician - an eye for storytelling, risking new styles, and of course letting loose on the piano as only he can.

Best Songs: Uptown Girl, The Longest Time, An Innocent Man, This Night

2. 52nd Street

Just when you thought Joel had done it all, he went ahead and released 52nd Street, his sixth studio album, which came complete with yet another attempt at a new sound and some of the singer's most iconic and affecting tracks. A jazz album mixed in with Joel's unmistakable pop sound, the record is as catchy, powerful and unforgettable as anything he's ever done.

Advertisement

Winning him two Grammy Awards and solidifying him as one of the most intriguing figures in music, 52nd Street has Joel belting out the classic "Big Shot" and the anthemic "My Life." The sound he has here is better than ever before, and inclusion of jazz (look no further than trumpet solo on "Zanzibar") makes the whole record one of the most interesting things Joel's ever done.

52nd Street has it all and then some, displaying Joel's abilities as a songwriter and a musician willing to push himself for his art, with seamless results.

Best Songs: Big Shot, Honesty, My Life, Zanzibar, Until the Night

1. The Stranger

The Stranger's release saw Joel go from moderate success to worldwide mega-star almost overnight. He won numerous awards, the record became the best-selling album ever produced by Columbia Records, and to date every song remains an absolute classic. Right from the get-go, The Stranger proves to be as good as it gets.

Advertisement

The album features the romantic "Just the Way You Are," the deeply affecting "Vienna" and the ultimate of Joel's epic anthems, "Scenes from An Italian Restaurant." Scenes is not only Joel's favourite of his own songs, but is often the stand-out track during his live performances, and with its spotless production, pop-rock fusion and timeless lyrics, it's not hard to see why.

The Stranger is Joel's most perfect creation, an album rich with ideas, philosophical musings, romance and heart. Each song compliments the one that came before it, and considering it was made back in 1977, it has aged like fine wine. Albums don't get much better than this, and The Stranger stands as living proof of just how great Billy Joel is as a songwriter.

Best Songs: The Stranger, Movin' Out, Just the Way You Are, She's Always a Woman, Vienna, Scenes from an Italian Restaurant.

Advertisement