Every Wings Album Ranked From Worst To Best

Backed by Wings Paul McCartney sometimes soared and sometimes fell to Earth.

By Chris Chopping /

The 1970s was a difficult time to be a former Beatle. Each member of the band had successes but they also had various missteps and setbacks.

Advertisement

It’s hard to imagine the pressure. There was still an expectation to deliver Earth shattering masterpieces but they no longer had three freakishly talented mates to help lighten the load.

Paul McCartney responded by trying to go back to basics. He formed a new band with his wife, hopped in a van and toured the nation’s student unions as if trying to build himself up from nothing again.

To his credit he did manage, once again, to drag his new group to chart success, becoming a stadium rock behemoth in the process. That said, it must be a little easier when you’re already a famous millionaire rockstar.

A rotating cast, together in some form or other for nearly a decade, Wings released seven studio albums. Some of them barely sound like the same band. The rough and ready Wildlife is a world away from the careful arrangements and expensive productions on Venus and Mars. Nor is it a case of different but equal. As we’ll soon discover, some Wings are better than others.

7. Wings At The Speed Of Sound

McCartney was determined that Wings At The Speed Of Sound would show Wings off as a real band and not just the backing group/vanity project of a former Beatle. The album featured a songwriting credit and/or lead vocal for every band member. A nice idea in theory but in practice it was a bit of drag for fans who just wanted a collection of new Paul McCartney songs.

Advertisement

Real band or not, if your bassist is established as one of the best songwriters ever and one the world's finest pop vocalists, probably let him write and sing the songs. Paul wrote Hey Jude. Why are you giving up album space for Linda McCartney to warble Cook Of The House complete with the sound of real bacon frying on the backing track?

All that being said, Macca's contributions aren't his best this time around. Songs like She's My Baby or Warm and Beautiful feel strangely flat and uninspired. The only indispensable track here is the clever, self referential Silly Love Songs. The album's other hit, Let 'Em In, is a decent production disguising an empty song.

6. London Town

London Town isn’t a terrible album but nor is it a terribly good one: a collection of largely mid tempo, keyboard heavy, functional pop songs that you won’t rush to switch off or be be in any particular hurry to hear again.

Advertisement

With A Little Luck is the obvious stand out, Backwards Traveller and Cuff Link are likeably eccentric and Michael Jackson would later cover Girlfriend with a more convincing falsetto. At the other end of the spectrum, rockabilly number Name And Address is pretty ropey and Famous Groupies is deeply skippable.

There’s nothing much wrong with London Town but no reason to put it any higher on this list.

5. Red Rose Speedway

You might think a star of McCartney’s magnitude is above studio meddling but in the early '70s a series of critical and commercial disappointments left him having to compromise.

Advertisement

After underwhelming sales for Wing’s debut LP Wildlife, EMI insisted the band be billed as Paul McCartney & Wings this time around, in case people didn’t spot the group’s famous bass player.

They also made Paul edit a proposed double album down to a single disc. Red Rose Speedway lost a couple of its most striking songs in the process. The released version is uneven and heavy on ballads. Producer Glyn Johns was so unimpressed by the band’s music and lack of discipline in the studio that he quit part way through the recording. The record is also weighed down by the schmaltzy albatross that is My Love.

Still, if you can look past the soppy, saccharine hit there’s still plenty to enjoy. Not least the upbeat and whimsical Get On The Right Thing, a deep cut that deserves much more love. Elsewhere, Little Lamb Dragonfly is a wistful highlight.

It’s telling however that the best thing recorded during the entire session was Live and Let Die, which was written for the Bond film of the same name and not even considered for RRS.

4. Wildlife

Wildlife is a rough, scrappy album of sloppy jams and gentle love songs with twee vocals. It’s also an underrated gem that probably sounds better to modern ears than it did at the time.

Advertisement

It was recorded and released in 1971, arriving in the wake of George Harrison’s All Things Must Pass and John Lennon’s imagine. Comparisons were inevitably drawn.

Harrison’s album featured legendary producer Phil Spector’s famous 'Wall of Sound' production style and Lennon’s, while less overblown, also had Spector at the helm. By contrast Wildlife felt half-baked and unfinished.

Hindsight plus years of twee pop and lo-fi indie bands allows us to reframe the album’s rough edges and sappy vocals as aesthetic choices rather than creative misfires.

The worst thing here is Bip Bop which sounds like an outtake from T-Rex’s early acoustic incarnation and one that they would’ve been right to drop.

Everything else is at least charming and for the most part delightful.

3. Back To The Egg

By all accounts Paul McCartney was tiring of the Wings experiment by 1979. Presumably he was fed up of constantly having to recruit new drummers and guitarists. He would soon be experimenting with synthesisers on his own, finding an enjoyable autonomy making the tracks that would become McCartney II.

Advertisement

By rights Back To The Egg should be the last gasp of a band in terminal decline. Instead new guitarist Laurence Juber and some more contemporary sounds breath new life into a band attempting to move with the times.

The band tried to bring a spontaneity to the recording sessions with songs like To You and Getting Closer benefitting from a spiky New Wave inspired energy. Elsewhere McCartney displays his typical stylistic restlessness from the hard rock of Old Siam Sir to the synth soul of Arrow Through You and the ridiculously overblown Rockestra Theme.

Not a bad final statement from a band that for Macca had simply outlived its usefulness.

2. Venus And Mars

Band On The Run’s success seemed to help McCartney locate some self belief that was missing on the first couple of Wings albums. Venus and Mars is a supremely confident record, for better and (slightly) worse.

Advertisement

On the one hand the album is filled with gems like the aching soul pop of Call Me Back Again or the airy title track.

On the other, the expensive, polished production sometimes feels a little too slick and perhaps it’s overconfidence that led Paul to make a couple of the slightly naff, off-putting choices of which he is sometimes guilty.

One is the slightly jarring supervillain interlude in the middle of the otherwise great Rock Show. Another is the decision to close the album on a cover of the theme from cheapo British soap Crossroads.

Still, overlook the odd blemish and this is largely a very good album indeed.

1. Band On The Run

The bands masterpiece. Fans of RAM know Paul McCartney had already put out a genius post-Beatles record but with Band On The Run he proved he was still capable of a commercial and critical hit.

Advertisement

The album is packed with strong melodies and sounds much more confident than Wings' previous albums. You wouldn’t guess that two band members quit the day before the group flew to Lagos to record. Or that the original demos were lost after the McCartneys were mugged in the street.

The album bounces between styles and moods, the title track’s mini song suite setting the tone. We move from there to the sparkly glam romp Jet, the lilting pop of Bluebird, through ear worm singalong Mrs Vandebilt and on to the gnarley riff of Let Me Roll It and so on.

The album finishes on the insanely catchy Nineteen Hundred And Eighty Five complete with lyrical and musical callbacks to preceding tracks.

Wings would record some great music both before and after this record but Band On The Run is the undeniable sound of a pop master firing on all cylinders.

Advertisement