For a decade Led Zeppelin dominated the music scene. The brilliant musicianship of the four members allowed the band to innovate and delve into a dizzying amount of musical genres without fear of reprisals from their fans or a loss of musical quality. With such a legacy behind them, it is often surprising that the band only had eight albums since their mark on music seems to indicate so much more. With that in mind however, it is often difficult to attempt to weigh up and compare the albums to each other due to the mind boggling differences between them all. Is the beautiful folk rock of Led Zeppelin III as good as the sprawling epic that is Physical Graffiti? Does the simple direct blues rock affair of Led Zeppelin surpass the genre-hopping Houses of the Holy? Read on, and find out... By the way, Coda does not count, as it was a compilation. Just so you know.
8. Presence (1976)
Presence is an album that divides Led Zeppelin fans in that it is a direct retreat from the epic, experimental nature of albums such as Led Zeppelin IV, Houses of the Holy and Physical Graffiti. Instead of souring soundscapes and a multitude of instruments, Presence gets back to the vocals/guitar/bass/drums combo that Zeppelin began with. Whether you like this or not will depend on if you found the last couple of Zeppelin albums self-indulgent and full of moments that were ripe for Spinal Tap parody, or whether you thought of them as four great musicians spreading their wings. As you can see by where I ranked this album, I tend towards the latter category. Having said all that, this is not to say Presence is a bad album. There is a real defiance to most of the music, possibly due to a lot of the difficult circumstances it was recorded under - with Robert Plant in a wheelchair and Jimmy Page having to produce the whole thing in about 18 days - an amazing turnaround. 'Achilles Last Stand' is a real gem and nothing of the album really reeks. It's just that it could be said to lack some of the ambition of the other albums.
7. In Through The Out Door (1979)
The last Led Zeppelin record is somewhat hard to judge in a way in that it seems like a transition record much like Led Zeppelin III. However, while Led Zeppelin III's importance can be easily measure by the impact it had on later albums as Zeppelin opened up their horizons, In Through the Out Door would be known as the band's last album - rendering the idea of ascertaining its importance kind of futile. While Presence saw Zeppelin retreat to a guitar focused heavy rock ouvre, In Through the Out Door sees John Paul Jones take over from Jimmy Page as chief songwriter and with that comes a much heavier reliance on keys and synths. In Through The Out Door is also a strangely funky album compared to Presence with songs like 'In The Evening', 'Caroselmbra' and 'South Bound Saurez' showing Jones' talent for groove. 'All My Love' was Robert Plant's song for his dead son Karac, which has been somewhat criticised as being a little too saccharine for Zeppelin, but overall In Through the Out Door was an album that could have opened up new horizons for the band.
6. Led Zeppelin (1969)
The first album that not only put their foot in the door, but smashed the door into splinters - Led Zeppelin's first album is a raw, heavy set of blues-influenced songs that refuses to relent. Exhibiting the mercurial musicianship of Page ('Black Mountain Side'), Plant ('Communication Breakdown'), Jones ('Dazed and Confused') and Bonham ('Good Times Bad Times') the album was so different from anything that had been released up to that point. While the album is rooted in the blues, one can already see the roots of the versatility that would soon become the band's trademark. Whether it was the folk guitar of 'Babe I'm Gonna Leave You', the frenetic guitar riffs of 'Communication Breakdown' or the majestic organ of 'Your Time Is Gonna Come', Zeppelin already had the ambition beyond being just another blues rock group. One of the greatest first albums of all time.
5. Houses of the Holy (1973)
This is possibly the most unfair ranking of them all. I truly love Houses of the Holy - not just for its songs but for the fact that it was the album where Zeppelin began to let loose a bit. Instead of all the songs being about mysterious Lord of the Rings references and nods to blues legends, Zeppelin dabbled in reggae with 'D'yer Maker?' (showing their capacity for awful puns) as well as James Brown in 'The Crunge'- a track which showed just how well John Paul Jones and John Bonham could work as a rhythm section. Add to that possibly the most unabashed love song that Zeppelin ever recorded in 'The Rain Song' (apparently a reaction to a conversation that Jimmy Page had with George Harrison- in which the Beatle told him that Page didn't write any ballads) as well as the Jones showpiece 'No Quarter' and there is plenty to put this album amongst the best that Zeppelin ever recorded.
4. Led Zeppelin II (1969)
I have no doubt that some will be bewildered that I put Led Zeppelin II so low on the list. This is after all, the album that has 'Whole Lotta Love', 'The Lemon Song' and 'Heartbreaker' on it. If there was ever an album that shows Zeppelin's sexy side, it is clearly this one. The band is still on top form and the all the songs are incredibly tight and easy to listen to- from the first pulsing riff of 'Whole Lotta Love' to the pastoral folk of 'Ramble On' to the bluesy harmonica of 'Bring It On Home'. And let's not forget 'Moby Dick'- where John Bonham gets to stake his claim for the best drummer in rock history. The fact is, for many bands, if they had released Led Zeppelin II, there would be no contest, it would be No. 1 with a bullet. The fact that it has come in No. 4 is testament to the brilliance of the four men behind its inception.
3. Led Zeppelin III
Led Zeppelin III is the transitional album that saw the band take its first big steps from being known as a hard blues rock band who were brilliant musicians, to a versatile group of songwriters who were prepared to delve into a number of different genres of music. This wouldn't become immediately apparent, with the first track 'Immigrant Song' showing the raw power that the band could still bring to the table. However, the next track; 'Friends' shows a new turn of Arabic inspired music with string arrangements and Bonham on other percussive instruments besides his drum kit. Later on the band covers the classic folk standard 'Gallows Pole', with Jimmy Page bringing his banjo skills to the fore and 'Tangerine' and 'That's the Way' show how much impact the band could make with acoustic instruments rather than electric ones. Robert Plant has called it their most important album and it is hard to argue with him. An underrated gem.
2. Led Zeppelin IV
Led Zeppelin IV would be the top album of all time for many fans, let alone the top Zeppelin album and it is easy to understand why. From the brilliant driving riff that drives 'Black Dog' to the sweet mandolin trills of 'Battle of Evermore' to the centrepiece that is 'Stairway to Heaven', there isn't really one song here that one can't place as being mediocre. Everything is just firing on all cylinders and there's no doubt that the marriage of the heavy rock of the first two albums has meshed perfectly with the softer aspects of Led Zeppelin III. I could go on, but there is really no point. From the wispy, intimate beauty that is 'Going to California' to the bluesy, swampy groove that underpins the epic 'When the Levee Breaks', the album is simply amazing.
1. Physical Graffiti
Yes, Physical Graffiti is No. 1 for the simple reason that out of all the Zeppelin albums it manages to encompass almost all facets of their music. Whether it be folk ('Bron-Yr-Aur), hard blues ('In My Time of Dying'), band tributes ('Down by the Seaside' - a tribute to Neil Young - as well as 'Trampled Under Foot' which nods its head to Stevie Wonder), goofy fun music ('Boogie With Stu') or just plain sexy music ('The Wanton Song'). However, with all that in mind, it is 'Kashmir' which is the true centrepiece of the album- a track which sees all four band members bring everything they have to the table to compose something which is truly epic and more ambitious than anything that they have crafted before. Whether it be the driving guitar riff of Page, the soaring vocals of Plant, the incredible drumming of Bonham or the surrounding storm of strings arranged by Jones, 'Kashmir' epitomises the best of Zeppelin, as does Physical Graffiti.