PJ Harvey - Ranking Her Albums From Worst To Best

10 studio albums, two John Parish-collaborations, four entries in 1001 Albums to Hear Before You Die, four Mercury Award nominations with two wins, and an MBE...you need to listen to PJ Harvey.

By Andrew Simon Noel /

It€™s hard to find a female who€™s had as much of an influence on the musical world in the last 20 years as PJ Harvey. Sure you€™ve had Madonna and Britney Spears in the pop world, Bjork in the alt-rock world and Lady Gaga from whatever world she came from, but in my mind none top the Goddess that is Polly Jean Harvey. In her musical career, she€™s released 10 studio albums, two of which are collaborations with John Parish, had four albums in the book 1001 Albums to Hear Before You Die, been nominated for the Mercury award four times (twice of which she€™s won, making her the only artist to have), and been awarded an MBE. She is a legend in the rock world, so much so she was considered by the surviving members of Nirvana to fill Kurt Cobain€™s shoes at a reunion concert. So it is my pleasure to be ranking PJ Harvey€™s albums from worst to best, revelling in her fantastic musical legacy, from the punky Dry to Let England Shake, the album that left a former Prime Minister quivering in his suit.

10. A Woman A Man Walked By

Harvey and Parish€™s second collaboration in 2009, A Woman a Man Walked By is perhaps one of Harvey€™s more traditional alt-rock albums. While many of the tracks on the album are enjoyable, most notably €˜Leaving California€™ and €˜Sixteen, Fifteen, Fourteen€™, there isn€™t that force of nature that is present on so many other PJ Harvey releases. It€™s by no means to say the album is bad, but feels restrained. It€™s clear this was produced before Harvey took the drop and went for something completely different; that would eventually become Let England Shake. Until then, A Woman A Man Walked By stands as one of Harvey€™s more tame releases.

9. White Chalk

From the opening piano chords and Harvey€™s trademark vocals, it€™s very tempting to think of White Chalk as the soundtrack to a Victorian Ghost story. From her ghost like appearance on the cover, to titles like €˜The Devil€™ and €˜Silence€™, there is something very sinister, yet beautiful about this album. Harvey learnt to play the piano whilst recording the album, so many of the songs are based around the instrument, with very little bass, guitar or even drums. Harvey€™s vocals are so quiet and high, it€™s almost like she€™s echoing a little girl singing, which adds to the story behind the album. White Chalk is by no means an easy listen, but what Harvey sacrifices in easy listening she makes up for in depth.

8. Dance Hall At Louse Point

Harvey€™s first collaboration with John Parish opens with the tender and haunting €˜Girl€™, which sets the tone for the rest of the album. Dance Hall at Louse Point is musically mellow, with a high presence of acoustic and soft electric guitars, however like most PJ Harvey releases, these burst out into spontaneous moments of passion and power. These moments are almost like echoes from Harvey€™s previous release To Bring You My Love, and act like a precursor to her later release Is This Desire? Dance Hall at Louse Point, while musically pleasant, almost feels like Harvey holding back, and while this may be the case, still has its moments of musical magic.

7. Uh Huh Her

After the critical and commercial success of Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea, it took Harvey two years to write and record it€™s follow up, Uh Huh Her. This album is a true solo album, with Harvey playing every single instrument on the record. A departure from the more radio-friendly tone of her previous album, Uh Huh Her consists of slightly heavier songs, accompanied with songs which could almost be considered skits, barely exceeding a minute in length. Elsewhere, Harvey€™s dynamic vocals are as varied as ever, switching from soft and gentle in €˜Shame€™ to screeches in €˜Who the F***?€™ While often a passed-over album, Uh Huh Her still has classic elements of PJ Harvey.

6. Is This Desire?

After 1995€™s breakout To Bring You My Love, many people were disappointed with the follow up, 1998€™s Is This Desire? It seems a shame really; while the album doesn€™t contain the chunky rhythms of her previous release, Is This Desire? gives us a disturbing and experimental look into Harvey€™s music. Basslines are distorted beyond belief, lyrics are almost spoken, and ghostly synths echo through the halls of each song. Elsewhere, songs like €˜Catherine€™ and €˜Electric Light€™ are softer, slower numbers, often with only one or two instruments involved whilst Harvey€™s voice carries the songs forward tenderly. On the whole, Is This Desire? is by no means a bad album; it shows just how different Harvey can be, still producing deep, meaningful songs.

5. Rid Of Me

If people had thought Dry was raw and provocative, they were in for a shock when Rid of Me was released. Inspired by one of her favourite albums, Surfa Rosa by Pixies, Harvey brought in Steve Albini to produce the album. Harvey€™s screams and growls are prominent in this album, not only from her voice, but from guitars, bass, and even a string section, each contributing a unique noise to the production . Like Pixies, Rid of Me ranges from deafening to quiet as a mouse in a split-second, notably in €˜Legs€™, the title track, and even her cover of Bob Dylan€™s €˜Highway 61 Revisited€™ in which Harvey gives a crazed, lo-fi twist to. All this makes Rid of Me Harvey€™s grittiest release to date.

4. Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea

Sometimes considered to be Harvey€™s magnum opus, Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea is a lyrical love letter to New York City, and won her first Mercury Prize (the second being Let England Shake). Her Poppiest, and perhaps most upbeat album, was tainted by disaster after having to accept her Mercury Prize over the phone, watching the Pentagon burn from her Washington D.C. hotel in the aftermath of 9/11. But even 14 years after its release, it€™s easy to see why this album gained so attention. After the experimental Is This Desire?, Stories' is refreshing and at times exceedingly beautiful, notably in the penultimate track €˜We Float€™, and €˜This Mess We€™re In€™, which she duets with Radiohead front man Thom Yorke. This album made an everlasting mark on pop music.

3. To Bring You My Love

Widely considered Harvey€™s breakout album into the mainstream, To Bring You My Love is a dark, brooding album, which differed lyrically and musically from her previous releases. Recruiting Flood to help with the album, and the producer€™s previous work with Nine Inch Nails and The Smashing Pumpkins really comes across in the sound of the album. Musically, Harvey sounds closer to heavy metal than alternative rock, and her use of voice manipulators adds to the mysterious aura around such songs as €˜Down By The Water€™ and €˜Long Snake Moan€™. It's an essential part of the PJ Harvey discography.

2. Let England Shake

The year is 2011. The economy is terrible, conflict still rages in the Middle-East and Tony Blair appears in front of a court regarding his part in the invasion of Iraq. Let England Shake could not have dropped at a more appropriate time. Harvey€™s last full album oozes political undertones, making references to both Middle Eastern conflicts and World War One, as well as performances that had left Gordon Brown shifting uncomfortably in his chair. There are all sorts of influences pulled from her previous releases; the piano-based songs from White Chalk, her trademark howl found on Rid of Me, all tied up neatly in an almost musically perfect protest piece.

1. Dry

Harvey originally burst on to the alternative scene in 1992 with a raw, punky debut, which remains as provocative and daring to this day. Harvey€™s feministic undertones come across in tracks like €˜Oh My Lover€™ and €˜Sheela-Na-Gig€™, as well as €˜Dress€™ - perhaps the strongest track on the album - whose driving beat sends the listeners blood pumping. It€™s clear without a doubt, that Harvey poured her heart and soul into this album. It is her as a young, aspiring artist who wanted to make the best record she could. Kurt Cobain loved this album, it featured on his Top 50 Albums Ever list, and it€™s not hard to see why. With its lo-fi attitude and gritty vocals, it's a classic post-Nevermind album if there ever was one. It is for all these reasons and more, that I believe Dry to be PJ Harvey€™s best album.