Ranking Every Paramore Album From Worst To Best
Which Paramore album is the best and which didn't age so well?
Formed in 2004 and hailing from Franklin, Tennessee, USA, Paramore has been a part of the Punk-Rock scene, transcending the genre for almost 20 years. The band has been through many ups and downs, including many different line-up changes, but their current line-up of Hayley Williams, Taylor York, and Zac Farro might just be the best the band has been in years.
Former members Josh Farro, Jeremy Davis, Jason Bynum, John Hembree, and Hunter Lamb all contributed to the sound of the band. Farro and Davis have had a lasting impact on the band's sound and vision to this day and contributed the most during their time in the group.
With almost 20 years and five albums to their name, we at WhatCulture have decided it's about time to rank every single one of their albums, from worst to best. From 'All We Know Is Falling' to 'After Laughter' and everything in between, join us as we delve into the back catalogue of one of the best bands to come out of the 'Emo Scene', a band that has outgrown this title and become one of the best and biggest groups of the mid-2000s.
5. RIOT
RIOT! is the album that put this band on the map, but it isn't the best and honestly hasn't aged as well as other Paramore albums, or even records from the same time period. Despite this, that doesn't mean this is a bad album, with great singles and some hidden gems littered throughout this record.
'Misery Business' was the lead single for the band's sophomore effort and what a huge hit it was. This song blew up everywhere, making Paramore one of the biggest Pop-Punk-Rock bands on the planet and catapulting its frontwoman, Hayley Williams, into the limelight. The follow-up was the slower but equally as good single 'Hallelujah', while 'Crushcrushcrush' is one of the best tracks on this record, being one of the rocky ones on the album. It might not be as catchy as 'Misery Business' but lyrically and musically it is far superior. While 'That's What You Get' is a fun little bob that is still popular to this day.
The best tracks that should have been on the album but were instead included as bonus tracks are 'Lovesick Melody' and 'Decoy', while the cover of 'My Hero' by Foo Fighters is a track you need to seek out. 'Let The Flames Begin' and 'When It Rains' are fan favorites, while 'Fences' feels like a very special moment on the album, embracing a more theatrical style musically with its lyrics feeling like one of the most mature and well thought out by the group so far.
4. All We Know Is Falling
The debut album from the female-fronted punk-rock outfit was made quickly, in three weeks, and has a very raw feel to it, but that doesn't mean it isn't full of bangers. This album is a great introduction to the band and is filled with forgotten gems, mainly due to the fact that their second album, RIOT!, was their breakthrough hit. Bassist Jeremy Davis left the band early on in the recording of this record and this resulted in his departure being the main focal point of the lyrics.
Three singles were used to promote this record, 'Pressure', 'All We Know', and sleeper hit 'Emergency', which was well played on rock radio stations, introducing the world to one of the best bands to come out of the mid-00s Emo and Scene kid culture.
The ten-year anniversary edition included two tracks that fans love, 'Oh Star' written by Hayley Williams with Taylor York, and 'This Circle'. The last three tracks on the album are possibly some of the best the team of Williams and Josh Farro wrote during this time period. 'Conspiracy' was also co-written with Taylor York and leads nicely into 'Franklin', an ode to the band's hometown. The final track on the record is 'This Heart', which is a beautiful ballad that hints at real maturity and the songwriting team of Farro and Williams's ability to create well-crafted slow songs as well as loud thrashing anthems.
3. Paramore
A darker and heavier sound from the now three-piece, after both Farro brothers departed in 2010, as Paramore enter a new stage of their lives and into the Self-Titled Era. Hayley Williams stated that she was heavily inspired by the work of Blondie and Siouxsie and the Banshees during the writing process, which you can hear throughout the album.
This album had four singles, each one embracing a different tone of the album. 'Now' is a dark anthem about perseverance, while follow-up 'Still Into You' is the poppiest track on the record and one of the band's most popular songs. 'Daydreaming' is a slower song but a good solid ballad from the band that will get stuck in your head. Final single "Aint It Fun" does exactly what it says on the tin; it's fun, poppy, rocky and definitely something you want to dance to.
Lyrically the album is more mature than previous outings, with songs such as 'Proof' and 'Still Into You' going in-depth about being in love. 'Grow Up' highlights friendship and how sometimes you just outgrow the friends you had before. Opening track 'Fast In My Car' is a punky start to the album as a harder, grittier edge runs through the record, with moments of calm with songs such as 'Last Hope' and 'Hate To See Your Heart Break'.
'Anklebiters' wasn't an official single from the band but did get a music video, while the live version of 'Last Hope' from Reading/Leeds brought a new feel to the song. The extended version gave fans three new tracks and a re-record of "Hate To See Your Heart Break' with Joy Willimas, which is better than the original.
2. Brand New Eyes
Paramore returned from their critically and very popular predecessor RIOT! with a new maturity; a lot has changed in the lives of the five band members and it can be heard in the lyrics. To best describe this album would be the punk-rock version of Fleetwood Mac's 1977 hit album 'Rumours'. Hayley Williams and Josh Farro broke up between the writing of RIOT! and Brand New Eyes, allowing the band to enter the 'Rumours Era'.
With five singles and not a bad one in the bunch, Brand New Eyes has just been pipped to the post on this list. The first single 'Ignorance' is a loud, punk, and aggressive song that lyrically talks about the frustrations within the band. 'Brick By Boring Brick' is another heavy-sounding song that lyrically talks about fairytales and how getting lost in a world of your own can be dangerous. 'The Only Exception' is the ballad of the singles released and discusses the fear of lost love and how new love can change your perception of how guarded you need to be. 'Careful' is another ruckus punk-rock track that is filled with anger and frustration, while follow-up 'Playing God' explores how blind faith can be seen as hypocrisy.
The rest of the album is filled with mature sounds and lyrics that explore a group of friends who are burnt out and feel the mounting pressure of fame. 'Turn It Off' is one of the best tracks on the album, exploring wanting to turn off your feelings, not just about love but in relation to everything in general. Other standout tracks include 'Misguided Ghosts', 'Looking Up', and smash hit 'Decode'.
1. After Laughter
Their most recent album is full of '80s-inspired bangers with lyrics that talk about mental health and the disillusion of singer Hayley Williams' marriage. A true combination of a break-up record and a party album, 'After Laughter' was a welcome change of pace for the punk-rock outfit, allowing for the band to explore new sounds as they approach 30.
In April 2017 the band released the lead single, 'Hard Times', which became the party anthem of the summer, mixing '80s electro beats, Synth-pop, and New Wave with a declaration of hope in the hard times we all go through in life contained in the lyrics. 'Hard Times' definitely set the tone for the sound and feel of the album that was released that May. The other singles on the album, 'Told You So', 'Fake Happy', 'Rose-Colored Boy', and 'Caught In The Middle' were strong songs that were catching summer tunes, but still with that heart we all know and love from Paramore.
Sometimes the singles are the best tracks on an album, but not with After Laughter. Here, every song is a banger. The only down point is 'No Friend', but at the same time, you can't count it out cause it's possibly the most experimental the band gets on the record, and that's saying something. 'Pool' and 'Grudges' were written by all three members, Hayley Williams, Taylor York, and a returning Zac Farro; one being a heartfelt message to the man Williams would eventually leave while the other talks about the importance of friendship and the joy that comes from reuniting. 'After Laughter' is by far the best album Paramore has ever produced.