It's important to stress something from the outset here: we come to praise the Stones, not bury them. As a band the Rolling Stones have been responsible for some of the most amazing, timeless music ever recorded. But let's be honest here: they've also been responsible for a lot of not so great tunes as well, especially from the 80's onward. No rock group has sustained the kind of insane longevity that the Stones have (50 years and counting) and as such they deserve to be given a certain amount of slack. No one seriously expects Mick and Keith to crank out LP's of a quality level that they produced in the '60's. For one, they aren't those same people anymore, having had several decades of growth and experience between then and now. Are you the same person you were 40 years ago? Were you even alive then? So although their modern output is not nearly at the same level of their classic albums, it's kind of amazing that they even exist in any form at all in 2014. We should give the Stones a permanent critical pass just based on the albums in the Top 10 here: no other group has a stretch of records of such amazing honesty, depth and rock and roll passion. Still though, the lesser entries in their catalog when compared to their legendary albums can't help but look weak by comparison. And so, keep that in mind as we analyse the Rolling Stones album output: they can't all be winners. Here then, are the Rolling Stones studio albums, ranked from best to worst.
22. Exile On Main Street
Date Of Original Release: 1972 Key Tracks: Happy, Tumbling Dice, Just Want To See His Face, All Down The Line, Turd on The Run.... everything really. With near-universal fan and critical consensus, this is the creme de la creme of Stones albums, a double album overstuffed with classic tracks and a decadent, murky sound. Surprisingly, critical reaction at the time was fairly negative, with complaints about the "muddy-sounding" production, but the sonic murk covering these songs gives them an extra dirty sheen that suits them perfectly. Recorded while the Stones were in tax exile in France, this was the last time the Stones would operate at the peak of their powers. Exile is a drug-fueled masterpiece, that bands from Royal Trux to Liz Phair have aspired to emulate in their own work. It does seem strange that Mick Jagger himself has been quoted as saying "I don't particularly think it's a great album." For anyone with ears though, putting this up against anything the Stones recorded after 1990 leaves no question which is superior.
21. Beggars Banquet
Date Of Original Release: 1968 Key Tracks: Country Honk, You Got The Silver, Midnight Rambler, Sympathy For The Devil The initial sleeve, featuring graffiti covering a urinal, was deemed "too offensive" to release in America, so a substitute was devised, featuring the title in an ornate cursive font against a white background, like an invitation to a swanky party. And that invitation is one you should accept. The Stones definitely needed to rebound from the critical disaster of Their Satanic Majesties Request, and this succeeded as an amazing return to form. The Stones were at the beginning of an amazing creative hot streak in 1968, and this album has set a standard that no one, not even the Stones themselves have surpassed. "Midnight Rambler" is a richly detailed, vivid horror story come to life. "Sympathy" still stuns whenever you hear it with its amazing lyrics and gale-force singing. "You Got The Silver" is a great early solo take from Keith and a genuinely heartfelt love song. By ignoring rather than pandering to musical trends at the time (there's not a trace of "psychedelia" to be found here) The Stones give us an all-time classic.
20. Sticky Fingers
Date Of Original Release: 1971 Key Tracks: B*tch, Wild Horses, Brown Sugar, Sway Stellar design is a standout here with the classic, Andy Warhol designed sleeve featuring a black and white shot of Mick Jagger's crotch. Original versions of this record featured an actual, functioning metal zipper, which could operate to let you inspect Mick's bits. This is just a flat-out dirty rock and roll record, with a killer horn section on "B*tch" and "Can't You Hear Me Knocking". "Sister Morphine", a standout track originally intended for Marianne Faithfull, is a chilling anti-drug tale, and "Moonlight Mile" might be one of the prettiest tracks for a band not well known for doing "pretty". Even "Sway", one of the lesser known tracks here, lurches and wheezes with a strange noble grace that only the Stones could produce.
19. Aftermath
Date Of Original Release: 1966 Key Tracks: I am Waiting, High and Dry, Flight 505 A pivotal release in the Stones universe, this LP saw them abandoning the blues template and stretching their musical wings past the 3-minute pop song format, expanding "Flight 505" into a 10-plus minute jam, remaining to this day the Stones longest album track. "I Am Waiting" highlights Mick's heretofore unseen vulnerability, and was used to perfect effect in the movie "Rushmore". "High and Dry" is a leisurely harmonica driven blues ramble of the sort the Stones could knock off in their sleep. A very transitional record with few well known "hits" but among their very best.
18. Let It Bleed
Date Of Original Release: 1969 Key Tracks: Let it Bleed, Sympathy For The Devil, No Expectations, Gimme Shelter The Stones respond to the white-hot political tension of the late 60's with their final record that constitutes any kind of coherent political statement. "Street Fighting Man" is Mick basically saying, "I'd like to fight the power with you kids, but I'm just a singer in a rock band...what can I do?" "Let it Bleed", despite it's Beatle-baiting title, is a languid, bluesy stomp with a dirty edge ("You can cream on me" indeed). "Sympathy For The Devil" is still amazingly powerful and culturally resonant even with its constant overuse on television and movies, and "Gimme Shelter" is as good as it gets and a harbinger of the bad vibes to come in the form of Altamont ("Rape, murder...it's just a shot away"). They even touch on soulful balladry ("No Expectations") and country-flavored blues ("Prodigal Son"). The Stones would never again be as culturally relevant than they were in this white-hot minute.
17. Tattoo You
Date Of Original Release: 1981 Key Tracks: Waiting on a Friend, Hang Fire, Little T & A All traces of disco are now thankfully gone from this album as the Stones face a brand-new decade. They react by going back to basics again, resulting in a late-period classic. Keith's song "Little T&A" is the sort of sleazy sing-a-long in praise of loose women he excels at. "Waiting on A Friend" is a gentle shuffle with the lads, featuring an accompanying video that mostly features the Stones sitting on a front stoop, looking bored. This was before they really figured out what videos were (see entry 15 for more), but it's not without its sizeable charm. Great iconic sleeve too, featuring the band with extensively tattooed faces.
16. It's Only Rock N' Roll
Date Of Original Release: 1975 Key Tracks: It's Only Rock N' Roll (But I Like It), Time Waits For No One, Ain't Too Proud To Beg In which the Stones find themselves past their relevance as countercultural spokesmen in the apathetic 70's, but are still capable of producing solid records. 'Time Waits For No One" is a rare example of vulnerability, and "It's Only Rock N' Roll" is as good a mission statement as any band ever produced. "Ain't Too Proud To Beg" as a cover is perhaps a little too on-the-nose, but the band are clearly having fun here and the atmosphere is joyous. The rest of the 70's however, would not be as great for the Stones. This album stands as their last classic album of the era and would become the standard bearer for measuring the worth of future Stones releases ("Is it at least as good as "It's Only Rock N' Roll?"" every Stones fan asks themselves upon seeing a new album).
15. December's Children (And Everybody's)
Date Of Original Release: 1965 Key Tracks: Get Off My Cloud, I'm Free, As Tears Go By By this point the Stones had established themselves as the antithesis of the cuddly, parent-friendly Beatles: dark and threatening on "Get Off Of My Cloud" had never been seen from a pop group before. This is less an album than a random assortment of tracks selected for the US market, again filled with random covers (Hank Snow, Chuck Berry) but any album that contains both the landmark "Cloud" and the joyous "I'm Free" is pretty inescapably great. The back cover features some fairly pretentious poetry by Andrew Oldham (" In this world where minds have overtaken reason and thought is potential treason, the only message about this new ellpee is let's all live to enjoy it"). Sadly, in a few short years the Stones would be minus Jones, but on this record he shines with vitality, as do the other Stones.
14. Between The Buttons
Date Of Original Release: 1966 Key Tracks: Let's Spend The Night Together, Ruby Tuesday, Miss Amanda Jones Falling into that strange post-Beatles learn how to smoke weed but pre-Summer of Love hippy revolution time slot, this is a very solid album, but only a few individual songs stand out. There's some goofy poetry on the LP sleeve that you can chalk up to it being written in 1966. The Stones first dip into trippy, pastoral psychedelia, and it holds up quite well. For the first time the Stones approach the LP form as a whole rather than an assemblage of tracks, and as such there's a cohesive, lush mood that permeates the whole record. "Let's Spend The Night Together" and "Ruby Tuesday" are the obvious highlights, but "Miss Amanda Jones" is a great forgotten rocker, an offhanded potshot at a debutante type which is a template for many future Stones songs.
13. 12x5
Date Of Original Release: 1965 Key Tracks: Time is on My Side, It's All Over Now On this album the Stones take their first tentative steps away from being simply a R&B cover band, and towards being a fully-functional original rock band. It's not entirely succesful, but any album with "Time is on My Side" and "It's All Over Now" can't be that bad and ensures its placement in the Top 20. Again, this was only released for the US market and features tracks from their first EP's along with some single and B-side tracks. For American fans, this was the only available way to hear this material, some of which ranks with their very best.
12. Goat's Head Soup
Date Of Original Release: 1973 Key Tracks: Heartbreaker (Do Do Do Do Do Do), Angie, Silver Train For what it's worth, The Stones pretty much invented the "rock power ballad" with "Angie", all plangent violins and soft Mick in crooner mode. Sorry, Aerosmith. If you can get past the awful cover sleeve with Mick's face obscured by some kind of gauzy veil, this is a solid, underrated mid-period Stones album. High peaks are the relentless horn-laden assault of "Heartbreaker" and the smooth funk of "Silver Train". Keith also gets quite a pretty ballad in with "Coming Down Again", though it is a touch on the whiny side.
11. The Rolling Stones, Now!
Date Of Original Release: 1964 Key Tracks: Heart of Stone, Little Red Rooster, Mona Note: This LP was originally released in the UK, with various track changes, as "The Rolling Stones". This LP and #10 feature the Stones in their initial permutation as a solid R&B cover band. Your enjoyment of these records therefore hinges on how much you like the blues and R&B tracks being covered here. The Stones original mission was to take the American Chicago-style blues they loved so dearly and spread them to a wider audience. These two records represent the fulfilment of that mission. Chuck Berry, Willie Dixon and Jimmy Reed covers are given airing here, letting the listener know what one of those early Stones shows must have sounded like. This is the Stones at their most embryonic state, and though the original material is mostly generic sounding blues pastiche, the signs of their talent and greater things to come are all over these records.
10. England's Newest Hit Makers
Date Of Original Release: 1965 Key Tracks: Not Fade Away, Route 66, Tell Me Note: This LP was originally released in the UK with minor track changes as "The Rolling Stones #2". Like the previous entry, this is a collection of the Stones earliest material, but this album is notable for containing the very first Jagger/Richards composition, "Tell Me". It's not their best song, but as a tentative step away from being strictly a blues cover band and an attempt to do original material, it remains an important signpost for the Stones. Elsewhere, "Route 66" and "Not Fade Away" remain the standouts from another crop of blues/R&B covers.
9. Steel Wheels
Date Of Original Release: 1989 Key Tracks: Mixed Emotions, A Rock And A Hard Place, Continental Drift Remember all the "Steel Wheelchair" jokes that came out when this album was released? Even the Simpsons did one. Now consider that that was twenty-five years ago. Yes, you are old, and so are the Stones. But unlike you, this album has aged surprisingly well, with "Continental Drift" being a striking example of the Stones stepping outside of their typical template to great success - its world flavor, featuring the Joujouka Pipers, being reminiscent of something that Brian Jones might have concocted back in the hazy days of 1967. "Mixed Emotions" (or "Mick's Emotions", as some in the band might say) is great stadium rock, with a chorus just begging to be sung along to with a huge crowd. At this point the Stones are mainstream arena rock, but it's surprisingly good mainstream arena rock.
8. Undercover
Date Of Original Release: 1983 Key Tracks: Undercover of The Night, Too Much Blood On this album, the Stones discover that MTV is a thing that exists. They produced music videos in the past, like the "stuck in a washing machine" clip for "It's Only Rock and Roll", and the "hanging out on a stoop" clip for 'Waiting On A Friend", but here they show an awareness of the true potential of the form. Their video for "Too Much Blood", directed by Julian Temple, was famously banned for being "too violent". That's fair enough, if you think chainsaw fights and blood geysers are "too violent". Which is pretty ironic, as the song was intended to be anti-violence, but some can have difficulty with irony. Apart from the singles, there's not all that much of interest here, and the dated 80's production does the songs no favors. "Undercover Of The Night" is a bona fide Stones classic though, with topical political lyrics from Mick and a catchy chorus. We also get the obligatory reggae song in "Feel On Baby" and the leeringly sexist track in "She Was Hot". For the most part though, the Stones attempt to remain relevant in face of the ascendant media juggernaut that was MTV is a bit of a damp squib.
7. Black And Blue
Date Of Original Release: 1977 Key Tracks: Cherry Oh Baby, Memory Motel, Fool To Cry Remembered mainly for its reprehensibly sexist advertising campaign featuring a beaming model covered in bruises with the copy "I'm Black and Blue from the Stones.... and I love it!", this is another fair-to-middling LP with an OK reggae cover ("Cherry Oh Baby") and a couple of solid, well-written tracks ("Fool to Cry" and "Memory Motel"). Billy Preston again plays keyboards on some tracks so the album has a very funky 70's feel, especially on Preston's duet with Mick, "Melody". Their longtime guitarist Mick Taylor had left by this point, throwing the Stones into confusion and producing ridiculous, hectoring tripe like "Hot Stuff". It's also the Stones album with the least number of songs (a paltry eight.)
6. Emotional Rescue
Date Of Original Release: 1980 Key Tracks: Miss You, Emotional Rescue Known amongst fans as the "Stones Go Disco" album, this stinker features what is the all-time nadir of the Stones in the unbelievably awful track "Indian Girl" which plumbs new depths of clueless awfulness. Listening to Mick patronisingly intone "Little Indian Girl...where is your father?" in a pretentious drone will make you want to rip off your headphones. "Miss You" and "Emotional Rescue" aren't bad for what they are as late-to-the-party disco cash-ins, but this is the first time the Stones felt obligated to follow trends instead of create them, and it shows. Most of the tracks here are warmed-over outtakes from the Some Girls sessions, and most should have been left as such. The single track "Emotional Rescue" also sets a record for the most ludicrous Jagger vocal ever, his falsetto escalating into ridiculous histrionics on the chorus. Nice sleeve though, for whatever that's worth.
5. Satanic Majesties Request
Date Of Original Release: 1967 Key Tracks: 2000 Man, She's A Rainbow, We Love You* Intended to be the Stones answer to the Beatles Sgt. Pepper, this instead was a colossal failure. The Beatles had songs. The Stones only had headfulls of acid and unlimited studio time, plus a lot of famous friends who wanted to hang out in the studio and party while they were recording (including two of the Beatles). It should have been obvious how it would turn out. Yes, the cover photo is amazing, especially if you have one of the 3D lenticular copies, but the bulk of this record is a pretentious, overbaked mess, except for the always amazing "She's A Rainbow" which is bright hippie pop, "2000 Man" and "2000 Light Years From Home". Footnote: "We Love You" is their best song from this period, but it's not on this record. Go figure. Ridiculous Trivia Bonus Factoid: The original title of this LP was "Cosmic Christmas". Yes, it IS a good thing they abandoned that title.
4. Voodoo Lounge
Date Of Original Release: 1994 Key Tracks: Love is Strong In which the Stones react to the rise of grunge by... doing absolutely nothing. The music scene had undergone seismic changes by the time this album came down the pike, but you wouldn't know it by this stodgy, traditional affair. The Stones doggedly ignore all the musical trends exploding around them and produce this workmanlike disc, of which only "Love is Strong" has enough of the old Stones swagger to merit repeat listening. This tour lasted forever and made wheelbarrows full of money, encouraging the Stones to continue to record albums.
3. Bridges To Babylon
Date Of Original Release: 1997 Key Tracks: Has Anybody Seen My Baby, Saint of Me What is there that can be said about yet another late-period Stones LP? Not much, honestly. It's the second album in a row produced by Don Was, and as such continues the previous albums aesthetic mediocrity, with weak songs being buried in an ocean of overproduction. Some of the now-obligatory remixes released in this period by some fancy schmancy "electronica" DJ's manage to shock some life into these corpses of songs but that's hardly a recommendation. Even the much-ballyhooed (at the time) collaboration with the Dust Brothers on "Might As Well Get Juiced" is pretty nondescript. Really, you should know what to expect by now.
2. A Bigger Bang
Date Of Original Release: 2005 Key Tracks: Streets of Love, Rough Justice Quite possibly, this will be the last Stones LP, and maybe - just maybe - that's okay. Rolling Stone magazine fawned like always about it upon its release, but there's nothing to get too excited about on display here. This features a stripped down, back to basics sound inspired by garage-rock types as White Stripes and the like, but the songs still fail to register to the listener on any level. Credit should be given to Mick for an attempt at controversy with the track "Sweet Neo-Con", but the song is too toothless to be considered any real kind of provocation (and it comes nowhere near "Street Fighting Man"). Plus, Mick is far too old to try a cheeky line like "Now am I just one of your cocks?" in "Rough Justice". It basically sounds like a record you would expect rich senior citizens to make, or possibly your grandparents. The most interesting thing to say about this album is that during the tour, Keith Richards fell out of a coconut tree and broke his head. Why couldn't they have written a song about that?
1. Dirty Work
Date Of Original Release: 1986 Key Tracks: Harlem Shuffle, One Hit (To The Body) This is it, the bottom drawer of Stones albums, recorded in the mid-80's when the tensions in the band were at an all time high, and released shortly before the Stones entered a three-year hiatus. The seething animosity and bad vibes are everywhere on this album, from the song titles (Fight, One Hit To The Body, Had It With You) to the awful 80's sleeve design (check out those ice-cream colored suits they bought from the Miami Vice garage sale on the sleeve) and the overbearing, dated production by Steve Lillywhite (Hey Steve, you don't have to mix the drums all the way up in every song). It also must be considered that Mick was holding back any possible decent tracks for his solo album, so his songwriting prowess is on autopilot here. There are two redeeming features; the amusing "Harlem Shuffle" (never a good sign when the standout track on your album is a cover) and the single "One Hit", which at least has a decent riff to distinguish it. The rest is a tuneless, leaden mess, rightfully forgotten by the fans and the Stones themselves. How would you rank the band's albums? Leave your comments below.