Alternative/acoustic rock band Toad the Wet Sprocket released "New Constellation," their first studio album in 16 years, this week, so I thought it might be a good time to stroll down '90s memory lane and look at their impressive catalog of work, but instead of focusing on the hits ("All I Want," "Fall Down," "Good Intentions," etc.), I thought it might be more interesting to talk about their lesser known songs. In the early '90s, while everyone else was listening to Soundgarden and Pearl Jam, I was listening to Genesis, Pink Floyd, Styx, and other oldies but goodies from the classic rock genre. There really wasn't a modern band I was a fan of until Toad the Wet Sprocket came along. When I originally heard "Walk on the Ocean," their first big hit, on the radio, I thought, "This doesn't sound like anything else right now" (how I later felt about Blind Melon's "No Rain"). I remember asking my sister at dinner who sang the song so I could go to the record store (remember those?) and buy the album, and when she told me "Toad the Wet Sprocket," I thought she was having a seizure. Either that or it was the most ridiculous band name I'd ever heard before (and probably since), which makes sense for a name that was inspired from a Monty Python sketch. Thankfully, she wasn't having a seizure, but I remember hating the band name so much, I almost didn't buy the album because of it. Thank God I changed my mind. Not only did I grow to love "Walk on the Ocean" more, but it wasn't even the best song on the album, "Fear." I bought their remaining albums afterwards, and the band ultimately became my fifth favorite band of all timebehind Pink Floyd, Genesis, Radiohead, and The Flaming Lips, in that order. But even though it's only 5 on my list, I'm able to relate to Toad's songs more than any other band. The lyrics are so true to my life, it's uncanny. It's almost as if lead singer/songwriter Glen Phillips followed me around for a few months and literally wrote songs based on my life. And as if the songwriting wasn't enough to turn me onto this band, Glen's singing voice is in the exact same key as mine, and his lost-little-boy delivery echoes my mentality; I often feel like a confused 12 year old not exactly sure where to go next. Here are just a baker's dozen of songs from Toad's catalog that I can eerily relate to (in no order)...
1. "Way Away"
The first track off their debut album, "Bread and Circus," this song reminds me of the experience of living in New York (or any crowded city, really): "Line of people to pass you by/posing sympathy with their whitewash eyes." It's also emblematic of my antisocial tendencies: "Urge to run away from the crowd/and mourn all alone." I think the best line though is, "Small talk hangs like a dirty cloud/saying nothing real but deafening loud." To put it another way, it seems everywhere you go, there are obnoxiously loud people barking at you but saying nothing of significance. It's like Shakespeare's famous line, "(Life) is a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing." I think that's true for most of America, and it was certainly true for the loud, in-your-face bands of this song's era. Toad's soft, almost gentle folk rock was the antithesis to that, and fans like me lapped it up.
2. "Torn"
I find this song to be one of the most accurate depictions of depression, and since I used to suffer with bouts of depression myself, I can write this with some level of authority. Over mournful chords, Glen attests, "I feel nothing/besides this pain." Then he asks, "Am I two souls?/One hard, one whole?" In other words, during depression, there's the part of you that bristles and hardens to the outside world to withstand the pain (the aforementioned "hard soul"), but it's not really you. The real you is inside and crumbling. Then later, "Am I real?/I don't want to feel anything anymore." Depression can become so crippling, it gets surreal. You sometimes don't know what's real anymore, not even yourself.
3. "Throw It All Away"
This song is every hoarder's nightmare. I'm not saying I'm a hoarder, but I can relate to holding onto things from my past for just a little too longbe it physical objects or figurative ones. "Help me to empty out this house," Glen sings, "all I've gathered all these days/and thought I couldn't do without/and throw it all away." It's also about letting go of the past or one of your past selves, something I can painfully relate to: "Take the dreams that should have died/The ones that kept you lying awake/when you should've been alright/and throw 'em all away." This song also probably has my favorite symbolic imagery of their entire catalog: "Tear up the calendar you bought/and throw the pieces to the sky/Confetti falling down like rain/like a parade to usher in your life." Beyond the inspiring lyrics though, I think this song illustrates how expert Toad is at creating little musical nuances. Glen sings the title line differently almost every time, but it's always appropriate, whether it's slightlyand purposefullysped up off tempo or dragged out in the end like a prayerful release.
4. "There Comes a Time"
As I wrote before, Glen's vocals often come across as a lost little boy, and that's never plainer than on this rarely heard track that was never officially released on an album. (I downloaded it from a concert performance.) He sings about the reality of leaving your safe and comfortable but closeted home life behind and entering the Real World: "There comes a time in life/Pull on your coat and go outside/Taste the vinegar, you'll find bitter life." In other words, it's a coming-of-age story we all experience at one point in our lives: that dreaded moment of growing up. Still, if you never leave the house, you also won't share in life's pleasures: "Taste a second time/A sweet surprise, a sweet surprise." That's the two-sided nature of living, I suppose.
5. "Don't Go Away"
Everyone has heard countless breakup songs before, but to me, this is the ultimate one. It's the breakup song to end all breakup songs ("Don't go away/I can't be the same without you"). When I first heard it, I had just gone through a breakup myself, and the line, "But I told you things that I wouldn't dream of telling anyone," absolutely slays me. I find it so true that when you're in the thick of a relationship, you reveal certain sides of yourself you would never dare reveal to the rest of the world. Those secrets are part of what makes your relationship special in the first place. But then, much like the doomed love story he's narrating, the song itself breaks down in the end, with the guitars wailing painfully while Glen literally pleads with his lover over and over: "Don't go away! Don't go away!" Pathetic? Perhaps, but I've never heard a truer song about lost love.
6. "Something to Say"
This song probably explains my temperament more than any other: "He's got a thing about losing control/Carries it a mile just to see how far he'll go/He brushes up his chops as he tries to fake a smile/A friend indeed, but what I need/is someone to stay awhile." Also, the way Toad describes the lead character's anger issues is a mirror match for my own: "He's got a way with his anger/a way he lets it show/like a smoldering smoke/when the fire's left the coals." In other words, if I'm angry at you, I'm not going to scream and shout, but you'll still know I'm upset.
7. "Inside"
To me, this is a continuation of the themes of "Something to Say," especially the chorus: "For all my life/It lay inside/for all my life." Probably the most interesting thoughts I have are the ones I don'tor can'tsay; they're simply ineffable.
8. "Windmills"
This song breaks my heart, not least of which because it's a heavy indictment of my fantasy life: "I spend too much time/raiding windmills." The imagery is obviously borrowed from "Man of La Mancha." (The album this song is from, which is incidentally my favorite Toad album, is even titled "Dulcinea," the female lead from that musical.) It makes me question my reasons for constantly daydreaming, for writing stories that no one will ever read, or for even continually writing for WhatCulture. Is anyone reading this?
9. "Brother"
This song is the answer to the unasked question, "Where's your brother?": "I find my brother in there/deep in my heart." In other words, you can't see him, but he's there. I don't think Glen Phillips also lost his brother like I did, but it sure sounds like it. Commenting on his own newfound mini-celebrity (at the time, anyway), he sings, "I often feel like the prodigal son/Take all I need/Giving back none." For me, I'm able to relate to this line because of the guilt I felt for being the one to survive and live my life, almost like I took his, which is obviously ridiculous, but feelings don't always make sense. Later he sings, "We have a bond/that nothing can change." True, not even death.
10. "Fly From Heaven"
This song is really about Jesus, but to me, it's sort of an unofficial prequel to "Brother," as Glen describes the shady circumstances surrounding his disappearance: "They took my brother/They ripped him from me/to twist his words as they did his body." It certainly seemed that way to me when my brother was hospitalized with a bunch of nurses and doctors who misdiagnosed him. And the chorus is pure wishful thinking: "But if he's all you say/would he fly from heaven to this world again?" It's difficult for me to get through this song without tearing up a little.
11. "Woodburning"
The chorus to this song pretty much sums up all of high school for me: "Take the longest day/throw it all away/I can't stand it, but I can't do anything/Every day's the same/Nothing ever change/I can't stand it, but I can't do anything."
12. "Stories I Tell"
The first time I heard this haunting tune, I was struck with its simple message of writing to live and living to write, something I was, and to a certain extent still am, able to relate to a little too easily, since I've been writing since I was first taught my ABCs. Toad makes their case as master storytellers, as writing prose is their version of "hiding our heads in some shadow of home." Also, "I wasn't looking for heaven or hell/Just someone to listen to stories I tell." There was a time when musicians weren't in it for fame or fortune, just an outlet to express their craft.
13. "Nightingale Song"
Glen once told a reporter (I'm paraphrasing from memory here): "We made music for a very specific group of people. If you got us, you loved us; if you didn't, you didn't." This is a Toad fan's anthem: "We sing the 'Nightingale Song' alive/We might be different, but our hearts won't lie." Glen even used to invite a member of the audience to join them on stage and bang a tambourine for this song, leading many to plead: "Guess what? I've got a fever! And the only prescription...is more tambourine!" (I kid.) This song is probably the best representation of the band's philosophy. Even though Toad's popularity peaked during the early to mid-'90s, they weren't part of the grunge movement, but they were honest and true to themselves.