10 Dumbest Things In Harry Potter And The Cursed Child
Did we really need a crossover between Harry Potter and Back to the Future?
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is riddled with problems. As impressive as the effects are when witnessing the live performance, the story is far below the standard of the other Harry Potter books.
There’s just no getting away from the fact The Cursed Child feels like fan fiction. From start to finish it’s littered with ludicrous story beats, some of which contradict the established rules of the Wizarding World.
What’s more, many of the returning characters behave in ways that go against the essence of their personalities. Sure, people change over time, but some of the character decisions in The Cursed Child simply don’t feel right.
This would be somewhat understandable if the play had been exclusively written by Jack Thorne and John Tiffany, but J.K. Rowling is also credited with writing the story. Given how much care Rowling took in crafting the narratives of her original novels, it’s odd that she allowed such a lacklustre plot to be brought to life.
Whilst The Cursed Child isn’t devoid of merit, even the most dedicated Harry Potter fans couldn’t resist rolling their eyes when they first read the script...
10. Hermione Is Minister For Magic
Hermione Granger is one of J.K. Rowling’s greatest creations. She’s intelligent, hardworking, and undergoes a considerable change throughout her time at Hogwarts.
As brilliant as Hermione is, she’s an odd choice for Minister for Magic. In the early chapters of The Deathly Hallows, she quickly shoots down Rufus Scrimgeour’s suggestion that she should consider a role at the Ministry. Indeed, she responds by saying she ‘wants to do some good in the world’.
As such, it seems strange that she would change her mind and pursue a career as a politician. Given her exceptional talent, Hermione is more than capable of taking on a multitude of roles in the Wizarding World.
It was simply a wasted opportunity to not give her a more interesting profession.
9. The Prophecy About Voldemort’s Return Comes From Nowhere
Prophecies are some of the worst clichés in fantasy books, but at least the prophecy in The Order of the Phoenix had an origin. In The Cursed Child, however, the prophecy about Voldemort’s return comes from nowhere.
In the closing stages of the third act, Harry, Hermione, Ron, Ginny, and Draco all investigate Delphi’s room in the hope of discovering the truth about this mysterious witch.
They quickly discover a written prophecy concerning Voldemort’s return, and immediately after, the third act ends with no explanation about the origins of such a prophecy.
The prophecy concerning Harry in The Order of the Phoenix was much more detailed. Rowling made it clear who delivered it, who it was witnessed by, and where it was stored.
The prophecy in The Cursed Child, therefore, is a letdown. It would have been much wiser to have removed this part of the story altogether.
8. Harry’s Terrible Parenting Skills
Whilst it’s important for characters to have flaws, Harry’s parenting skills are embarrassingly poor.
Even before Albus started life at Hogwarts he had an enormous amount of pressure put upon him simply due to his name. Both Harry and Ginny were more than a little foolhardy to name their son after the greatest wizard of all time.
Harry demonstrates his lack of judgement still further when he tells Albus he wishes he wasn’t his son. Sure, such a pronouncement comes after a heated argument, but it’s still an unforgivable thing to say.
To top it all off, Harry also prevents Albus from seeing Scorpius Malfoy – his only school friend. He even goes so far as to give Professor McGonagall the Marauder’s Map to stop the pair of them meeting up in secret.
Given Harry is meant to be a noble and courageous figure, these actions contradict the core of his character. Why Rowling was happy to keep these moments is anyone’s guess.
7. Transfiguring Harry Into Voldemort
During the final act of The Cursed Child, our heroes travel back to 1981 to rescue their children and prevent Delphi from telling Voldemort not to attack one-year-old Harry. In their attempt to accomplish the latter, Harry is transfigured by the others to look just like Voldemort.
Again, the central issue here is the lack of continuity. Throughout the original series, the only failsafe way to turn into someone else was by drinking Polyjuice Potion.
Granted, Ron is transfigured to look different in The Deathly Hallows when the main trio rob Gringotts. However, Rowling made it clear that he still looked similar to his original self. In other words, his appearance was altered, but he didn't physically transform into somebody else.
As such, the transfiguration used at the end of The Cursed Child stretches the established rules of Rowling’s world way too far.
6. The Trolley Witch Is More Than Just A Trolley Witch
The trolley witch was a sweet, calming presence in the original series. Her grand collection of sweets and snacks was always a key part of every student’s journey to Hogwarts.
Sadly, the writers of The Cursed Child decided to develop the trolley witch for the sake of a cheap gimmick.
When Albus and Scorpius attempt to flee the Hogwarts Express by jumping off the roof, they are momentarily delayed by the trolley witch. For reasons that aren’t entirely clear, her hands become claws and her pumpkin pasties are used as grenades against the two boys.
Whilst the practical effects during the live performance salvage this scene, it’s still a ridiculous story beat. It’s almost as if the trolley witch is some form of mutant or demon rather than a kind lady who wants to sell sweets.
What’s more, her transformation doesn’t add anything to the story, and as such, the writers should have simply removed this bizarre moment.
5. The Lack Of Continuity With Time Travel
The Prisoner of Azkaban was a terrific book, but the use of the Time-Turner opened up a lot of plot holes. Far from clearing up the matter, The Cursed Child only makes things more confusing.
For reasons that are never clearly explained, Theodore Nott was able to create two Time-Turners whilst working under Lucius Malfoy. Both of them could travel back years at a time and then transport the user to the present again. The one difference between them was that the prototype only allowed the user to spend five minutes in the past before they were returned to the present.
Crucially, neither were the same as the one from The Prisoner of Azkaban, which could only go back a few hours and had no compacity to return the user to the present.
To make things even more confusing, The Cursed Child also introduced several alternative timelines. Indeed, much of the story felt like a parody of Back to the Future.
In fairness, the Time-Turner is the centre point of The Cursed Child, so it isn’t something that could have easily been removed. Yet this still doesn't explain why the writers chose to go down this avenue in the first place.
4. Albus And Scorpius’s Manipulation Of The Triwizard Tournament
Albus and Scorpius’s adventures through time are littered with ridiculous story beats, the worst of which is their manipulation of the Triwizard Tournament.
The two boys believe the way to stop Cedric Diggory's death is by preventing him from winning the tournament with Harry. Rather than going straight to the Third Task, they make their mission more convoluted by interfering with the first two tasks in the hope of reducing Cedric’s headstart into the maze.
Despite the fact the dragons are in an enclosure, the pair of them somehow manage to get close enough to deprive Cedric of his wand by using Expelliarmus. What’s more, not one of the surrounding students or staff members seem to notice a jet of red light flying towards Cedric.
Their manipulation of the Second Task is even more laughable. After obtaining some Gillyweed from nowhere, Albus and Scorpius use a conveniently-sized pipe in Moaning Myrtle’s bathroom to gain access to the lake and cast an Engorgement Charm upon Cedric.
Both of these scenarios are contrived and unrealistic. The more you think about them, the more ridiculous they seem.
3. Draco’s Timely Reveal Of A Second Time-Turner
Of all the plot conveniences in The Cursed Child, this is the worst one.
After multiple ventures into the past and several alternative realities, Albus and Scorpius find themselves trapped in 1981 without any means of returning to the present. The two of them then send a message into the future via a combination of Harry’s blanket and a substance known as Tincture of Demiguise.
This alone is rather far-fetched, but the story sinks even lower when Draco conveniently reveals he has a spare Time-Turner. This pronouncement is followed by a feeble explanation involving Theodore Nott and Draco’s father that raises more questions than it answers.
Given how naturally the original stories flowed, such a manufactured story beat feels totally out of place.
2. Cedric Becomes A Death Eater In An Alternative Timeline
The death of Cedric was one of the most emotional moments in Harry Potter. It was tragic to see such a kind and honourable person die so young. Unfortunately, The Cursed Child is a complete insult to Cedric’s character.
Following one of Albus and Scorpius’s adventures with the Time-Turner, Cedric ends up becoming a Death Eater in an alternative reality and kills Neville Longbottom. By extension, this meant Nagini (a Horcrux) was never killed and Voldemort was never defeated.
The reason for this change is that Cedric’s humiliation in the Triwizard Tournament made him join the Death Eaters. In addition to making no logical sense, this is also a complete betrayal of Cedric’s character.
It’s a miracle such a plot point wasn’t scrapped immediately. Even casual Harry Potter fans know Cedric is a fundamentally good person who would never join Voldemort.
1. Delphi Is The Child Of Voldemort And Bellatrix Lestrange
Delphi is a mysterious figure throughout The Cursed Child. As the narrative progresses, it becomes increasingly clear that there is more to her than she's letting on.
At the end of the third act, it is revealed she is the child of Voldemort and Bellatrix. Such a plot point reeks of fan fiction. It’s the kind of material a ten-year-old would make up after having just seen the movies for the first time.
Given that Voldemort was meant to be an almost inhuman character, it simply doesn’t make sense for him to have been seduced by Bellatrix.
What’s more, it’s also incredibly unlikely. Bellatrix would have been in her mid-forties when Delphi was conceived, and Voldemort would have been in his early-seventies. As such, the chances of pregnancy were almost impossible.
It would have been much better if an established villain in disguise had tried to bring back Voldemort using the Time-Turner. This would have made more sense and provided the opportunity for an authentic, believable plot twist.
Why Rowling didn't immediately reject this idea is anyone's guess.
What do you think of The Cursed Child? Leave your thoughts below in the comments thread.