10 Most Shocking Unsolved British Crime Mysteries

Just who was Jack The Ripper anyway?

By Tom Mankin /

Discovery Channel

The war between crime and justice has been waging since the dawn of man. Crime drama is one of the most popular and varied genres of television and literature and sees fictitious crimes neatly solved in storylines that satisfy the audience. Real life crime is not so simple and unfortunately crimes do go unsolved and criminals do get away...

Advertisement

10. Who Put Bella In The Wych Elm?

Wikimedia Commons

The first unsolved crime on this list involves the murder of an unknown woman whose body was found inside a hollow Wych Elm in 1943. The macabre discovery was made by four teenage boys, Tommy Willetts, Fred Payne, Bob Farmer and Robert Hart, who had illegally entered the estate of Hagley Hall in Worcestershire to poach for eggs.

The boys were climbing the large tree as they believed it was a prime location to find to find birds nests but their hunt instead unearthed a skull and a mystery that remains unsolved to this day. The police were alerted and their subsequent investigation found nearly an entire skeleton incased within the tree. Forensic investigation identified that the skeleton as having belonged to a woman of around 35 years old who had been dead for at least 18 months. The woman€™s skeleton wore a gold wedding ring and had its mouth stuffed full of taffeta, which led the coroner to conclude that murder by asphyxiation was the likely cause of death.

Advertisement

Eerily, she was also missing a hand which was later found buried nearby and prompted locals to speculate that there may have been a link between the murder and a black magic ritual. As the discovery was made during the second world war, the investigation into the murder and the identity of the woman was heavily hindered by the great volumes of missing person reports experienced by the police. The case soon went cold but was not forgotten with the graffiti message of €˜Who Put Bella In The Wych Elm€™ reappearing from time to time in the around the area of Hagley Woods.

9. Jack The Ripper

FOX

Perhaps the most infamous of all unsolved crimes, the story of Jack the Ripper is known universally and has inspired countless plays, books and films. The Ripper mainly targeted women who worked as prostitutes in the Whitechapel area of London during a period that spanned from April 1888 to February 1891.

Advertisement

A total of eleven murders were reported to the Police during this time with at least five of these being confirmed as the work of Jack The Ripper. The Ripper€™s confirmed victims all had similar wounds having had their throats slit and the lower area of their abdomen ripped open. All of these woman were murdered close to or on a weekend and all happened under the cover of night. The mutilations to the victims became increasingly terrible with each death with some of the later victims even having organs removed and taken from the crime scene.

There have been many theories and suspects as to who the Ripper was ranging from a doctor who specialised in back street abortions to ludicrous allegations against the author of Alice in Wonderland, Lewis Carroll. Despite a thorough investigation at the time and continued interest in the case, it is probable that the true identity of Jack The Ripper will remain known only among his victims.

Advertisement

8. The Murder Of Florence Nightingale€™s God-Daughter

Wikimedia Commons

Florence Nightingale Shore was the god-daughter of the famous €˜lady with the lamp€™ who worked as a nurse in Sunderland, England. Florence was born in 1865 and attended boarding school in York before completing her education in Belgium. She then relocated to China where she worked as a governess for three years before returning to England and training as a nurse.

Advertisement

The life of a victorian nurse was not easy and Florence would have been expected to work long hours for just £10 a year plus board. In 1920, Florence boarded a train traveling to Sussex where she planned to meet friends for a short holiday at St Leonard€™s. While aboard she was attacked and severely beaten, dying from her injuries just days later. A nationwide investigation was launched with an unnamed man in a brown suite becoming the lead suspect in the case. Unfortunately, despite the police€™s best efforts to try and find Florence€™s killer and bring them to justice, both the reason behind the attack and the identity of her attacker remain a mystery.

7. Abduction Of Elizabeth Canning

wikipedia

Elizabeth Canning was an eighteen year old maid who claimed to have been abducted in a case that dived London society in 1753. Her story went that she had been grabbed by two men who forced her into a carriage and took her to a brothel eleven miles away in Enfield. The brothel was overlorded by a sinister madam named Mother Wells, who Elizabeth claimed tried to force her to become a prostitute. She refused and as a result found herself locked away in the attic with nothing but a jug of water and bread crusts to live on.

Advertisement

Elizabeth also reported that an old gypsy woman named Mary Squires was staying at the brothel and had stolen some of her clothes to sell. After nearly a month of imprisonment, Elizabeth was able to escape through a window and made her way back to London where she reported her tale. Following her story, Mother Wells and Mary Squires were both arrested and tried at the Old Bailey. Wells was found guilty of running a brothel and sentenced to be branded as penalty. Squires was found guilty of theft and sentenced to hang but the Lord Mayor Of London, Sir Crisp Gascoyne did not believe that she was guilty and intervened. Squires had a reputable alibi in the form of a priest who claimed that she was in Dorset at the time of the supposed theft. The mayor appealed the case to King George II who granted Mary Squires a pardon in light of her alibi.

In a sudden twist of events, Elizabeth Canning found herself charged with intentionally swearing a false oath for which she was sent to prison at Newgate. The case of Elizabeth Canning divided society with some people believing that Elizabeth was innocent while others believed that she had fabricated the story to cover up a secret pregnancy or abortion. However, exactly who was telling the truth in the case was never fully uncovered and remains unsolved to this day.

Advertisement

6. The Pitchfork Murder

Wikimedia Commons

The next entry on our list is a vicious tale of murder seasoned with a hint of black magic. On Valentine's Day 1945, 74 year old Charles Walton left his home in the village of Lower Quinton to complete a hedge trimming job. His body was found several hours later laying under an oak tree on nearby Meon Hill by his concerned niece and neighbours.

Advertisement

Walton had been pinned to the ground by his own pitchfork before being stabbed multiple times and severely beaten. In the wake of Walton's brutal death, rumours circulated that the murder had been carried out by practitioners of witchcraft and black magic. Detective Chief Superintendent Alec Spooner gave these rumours credence and followed them up as a lead. Spooner discovered that the area of Meon Hill had links to stories of evil and witches dating back to the Stone and Iron ages.

Furthermore, the case also bore an uncanny resemblance to the murder of an accused witch who had been pinned to the ground and stabbed seventy years prior. The police investigation was hindered by the peculiar fact that the villagers of Lower Quinton would not speak about the events of the murder, probably due to superstition surrounding the nature of Walton's Death. The case's leads soon ran cold and any hard evidence for a less supernatural motive failed to materialise. A seance was even preformed on Meon Hill in 1952 in a failed attempt to shedding some light onto the mystery.

Advertisement

5. The Disappearance Of King John€™'s Treasure

Wikimedia Commons

King John, fondly remembered as 'the Bad' was King of England from the 24th December 1166 until the 19th October 1216. During this time he acquired a great deal of wealth through both heavy taxation and inheritance. He was so attached to his money that he even used to take it with him when he travelled, a habit that would end in tears. In 1216, King John was travelling through an area of south-east England known as 'The Wash', named for its marshes and dangerous quicksands.

Advertisement

While there, he fell ill and made the decision to return to Newark Castle. King John raced ahead taking the longer but safer route around the outskirts of the marshes. His soldiers were instructed to meet the King at the castle bringing the King's personal possessions with them. However, they never arrived and King John never saw his beloved treasure again. It is reported that the soldiers attempted to take King John's carts directly through the marshes and were drowned. The carts containing his mass riches, including the crown jewels, were also lost.

The location of the carts and the treasure remains unknown and sits at the heart of one of history's greatest ongoing treasure hunts. While strictly speaking not a crime, the fact that nobody saw what happened to the treasure has led to wide speculation as to the true nature of its disappearance, many of these being criminal in nature. Theories range from theft to the King using the treasure for security on a loan and then faking its loss in the marshes.

Advertisement

4. The Murder At The Priory

Wikimedia Commons

Charles Bravo was a barrister from a respected family who lived at The Priory in Balham, London. Bravo died in 1876 from antimony poisoning which pointed directly to murder. This mystery caused a stir in well-to-do Victorian London as nearly all members of the Bravo household were considered suspects from his housekeeper to his wife, Florence.

Advertisement

The murder was considered so scandalous that women and children were banned from attending the inquest into what happened. Bravo was reported to have been been a controlling and violent bully towards Florence and one theory is that she poisoned him because of this. Another theory exists that Bravo was actually planning to murder his wife for unknown reasons and purchased the antimony himself. This version of events ends with Bravo accidentally causing his own death by consuming the poison after mistaking it for toothache medicine.

3. The Murder Of Marion Gilchrist

Wikimedia Commons

Eighty-six year old Marion Gilchrist was beaten to death during a robbery at her Glasgow home in 1908. Gilchrist was in possession of jewellery that would be worth nearly £280,000 today but this was left untouched as her attacker was disturbed by a neighbour and made off with only a brooch. The murder led to a false accusation and a miscarriage of justice with the real killer getting away and remaining unknown. The police thought they had a lead after a pawn ticket for a brooch surfaced that they believed linked the case to a man named Oscar Slater.

Advertisement

Slater was already known to them as a gangster and suspected pimp and he was put on trial, found guilty and sentenced to death for Gilchrist's murder. A sentence that was later commuted to life imprisonment. Further examination of the case worked to persuade many that Slater was in fact innocent including many influential figures including Sherlock Holmes author, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Further inquiries into the case proved that Slater was in fact innocent and he received the equivalent of £270,000 in compensation for the trial.

2. The Peasenhall Murder

Wikimedia Commons

The story of the Peasenhall Murder reads like an elaborate game of Cluedo. Just before midnight on the May 31st 1902, a servant girl named Rose Harsent was stabbed to death during a thunderstorm at a country house in Peasenhall, Suffolk. Examination of Rose's body led to the sad discovery that she had been six months pregnant at the time of her death. It was alleged that the child's father was a married preacher named William Gardiner who was subsequently arrested and tried for Rose's murder.

Advertisement

After two inconclusive trials, Gardiner was served a writ of nolle prosequi that allowed him to walk free but didn't serve as a formal acquittal. This makes Gardiner one of only a handful of people to have been tried for murder in Britain and never receive a verdict. Nobody was ever formally charged with the murder of Rose but evidence strongly points to Gardiner. Another theory exists that it was in fact Gardiner's wife who murdered Rose in a fit of jealous rage.

1. The Seal Chart Murder

wikipedia

Caroline Mary Luard was shot and killed at her neighbours secluded summerhouse in Kent on the 24th August 1908. On the day of the murder, Mary had accompanied her husband, Major-General Luard, on an afternoon walk with their dog. The couple parted ways at the gates of their neighbour's summerhouse; Mary needed to return home as she was expecting a friend for afternoon tea while her husband wished to carry on to retrieve his golf clubs from his Golf Club's clubhouse.

Advertisement

After retrieving his clubs, Major-General Luard returned home to find his wife's friend still waiting for her. Worried about her whereabouts, the Major-General set out into the woods to search for her. He eventually found her laying dead on the verandah of the summerhouse, her purse and rings missing. Suspicion for the murder fell to the Major-General who later threw himself in front of a train in despair. The true identity of Mary's killer may never be known but speculation has suggested that she was killed and robbed by a man named John Dickman. Dickman was convicted of a similar murder the year following Mary's death in which he robbed and killed a man on a train.