6 Times Things Got Heated On The Joe Rogan Experience

Joe Rogan can talk to almost anyone, but it isn't always smooth sailing.

By Adrian Bishop /

When Joe Rogan first sat in front of a webcam with fellow comedian Brian Redban back in 2009 to record the first episode of the Joe Rogan Experience he likely had no idea what it would become.

Advertisement

More than 10 years, 1400 episodes, and 200 million downloads a month later, Rogan has cemented himself as podcast royalty. The American comedian and MMA commentator's show has hosted a wide variety of hugely influential guests from the worlds of sport, comedy, politics, film, technology, and more.

In that time Rogan has hosted some incredible conversations that leave listeners feeling enriched and inspired at the end of the show, and also some that have had fans the world over trying to avoid awkwardly belly laughing while listening out in public.

However, despite the comedian's laudable ability to regularly adapt to match his guest's sense of humour and speaking styles, every now and then there's an episode where the conversation doesn't mesh quite so well.

Whether it is from an ill-timed joke, a timekeeping issue, or a fundamental disagreement in principles, sometimes sparks fly and Rogan can't help but let his emotions show.

6. Andrew Hill PhD

Sometimes it's clear when Rogan is going to clash with someone on the podcast, other times everything can be going swimmingly until something sets off Joe's bullshido detector in which case the vibe can change pretty quickly.

Advertisement

In this instance, Rogan is almost two and a half hours into a fruitful and interesting conversation with scientist and lecturer Andrew Hill PhD, with the pair talking about a wide-ranging array of subjects including addiction and the neuroscientific ramifications of substance use.

All good so far. But then Hill directs the conversation towards one of Rogan's wheelhouses, in this case with a discussion of martial arts. Hill mentions that as a practitioner of the Japanese art of Aikido, he is less than impressed with fellow Aikidoka Steven Seagal's lineage of technique.

Rogan humours Hill's observations for a short time before the pair begin discussing the efficacy of the martial art as a whole. Joe states that while he respects Aikido he doesn't think it is a very effective art:

Well, I don't understand Aikido that much so I'm sure you would know more than me. To me, it looks cool flipping people around, looks like you'd have to cooperate, doesn't look like it would work. I think if you shot a double on him and got a good grip and your hands squeezed he's going for a ride.

The pair continue discussing Aikido when Hill mentions that the founder of the art, Morihei Ueshiba, was so proficient that he could cause people to fall over without touching them by manipulating their balance. This sends Rogan's scepticism through the roof and the pair go on to watch a video of an Aikido master get repeatedly submitted by a skilled grappler that illustrates Rogan's point that it would prove largely ineffective when pitted against practitioners of other, more practical, martial arts.

The conversation remains on the subject of the martial art for a total of around 15 minutes before Joe mercifully decides to move it elsewhere as the pair conclude an otherwise good-natured and insightful episode.

5. Brendan Schaub

Okay so technically this discussion did not take place on the Joe Rogan Experience and was instead an episode of Brendan Schaub and Bryan Callen's podcast The Fighter and The Kid. However, as it was filmed in the JRE studio, Rogan steered the conversation throughout, and it was the only episode on this list that led to someone involved literally changing careers, it is definitely worthy of inclusion.

Advertisement

When this episode was broadcast Brendan Schaub was just three days removed from his fight with Travis Browne at UFC 181. Schaub was defeated in the fight after being dropped by a stiff uppercut and eventually finished with a barrage of ground and pound in the first round.

The defeat marked Schaub's fourth knockout loss in the previous five years and throughout the podcast, Rogan made no attempt to hide the fact that he was concerned for his friend's future well-being if he continued to compete in mixed martial arts.

The conversation would get more uncomfortable as Rogan went on to tell Schaub that, in his opinion, Schaub was not capable of becoming UFC champion and that he would be better off focusing on his ventures outside the cage:

The reality of your skillset and where you’re at now, I don’t see you beating the elite guys, I don’t see you beating Cain Velasquez. I don’t see you beating Junior Dos Santos. I don’t see you beating Fabricio Werdum.

Schaub countered by saying that while he appreciated his friend's concern, it's easy for Rogan to tell him to give up his career when its not his livelihood at stake.

I think it’s easy for you to sit there, with, whatever, $12 million in the bank and say, ‘Oh, you need to stop doing this,’ It’s easier when you’re set and you don’t come from that background and you’re going home to your wife and kids and $6 million mansion and say ‘Stop doing this and do podcasts for the next 40 years'.

Though brutally awkward at times, the conversation highlighted a lot of the debates that rage in high-level combat sports where athletes have to ask themselves if it is worth risking their health long term in the pursuit of success and glory, particularly when many don't have a secondary occupation to fall back on.

This podcast did inspire positive change however, Schaub took Rogan's advice on board and did not compete in the Octagon again. In the years since, he has gone on to become a successful podcaster and comedian in his own right.

4. Eddie Bravo

Eddie Bravo is Brazilian jiu-jitsu royalty. He famously defeated Royler Gracie by submission in 2003 to become one of the first American's to score a victory over the Gracie family in competition. He is also the founder and head instructor of 10th Planet Jiu-Jitsu, a variation of BJJ that Joe Rogan holds a blackbelt in.

Advertisement

However, in recent years it has not been Bravo's wealth of grappling knowledge that fans of the JRE have come to know him for, but rather his fondness for conspiracy theories. Normally Joe likes to indulge his friend in his unconventional theories but on JRE #948 Bravo decided to wax lyrical about his newest, and possibly most bizarre, fascination: the flat earth theory.

The podcast started normally enough, with Rogan, Bravo, and Brendan Schaub talking about the UFC. As is often the case, the conversation then meanders through a variety of topics when, at around an hour and a half into the episode, Bravo begins his patented conspiracy talk.

Predictably the discussion only degenerates from this point as a visibly irked Rogan attempts to repeatedly question Bravo about the reasoning for the total rejection of mainstream science.

A microcosm of the whole episode can actually found in a 40-second fragment that takes place during the final half-hour of the episode.

Rogan: They don't learn astrophysics, they don't study all these things it's hard to learn. The entry barrier is f**king huge! If you wanna study physics, I can barely pay attention to it! I listen to these books on tape and I have to go back over them, three, four times just to understand a paragraph, trying to figure out exactly what the f*ck they're quantifying. They're talking about really intense sh*t that thousands of people have been working on in conjunction! They all feed off each other's innovation, there are so many people working on these things Eddie. The idea that they are all in on some kind of a giant global lie is insane!

The camera then cuts to Bravo looking entirely dismissive.

Bravo: Yeah, yeah, ... that's what everyone thinks

You know the conversation is really coming off the rails when even normally silent JRE producer Jamie Vernon cannot help but get involved towards the end of the podcast in an attempt to call Eddie out on his BS. Bravo remains steadfast in his skepticism however, and the episode ends on a slightly awkward note.

3. Brian Redban

Before Young Jamie was the JRE's resident technician and the undisputed crown prince of pulling things up there was Brian Redban. Redban was an everpresent throughout the early years of the podcast, often interjecting at the most inappropriate of times with his own brand of controversial humour.

Advertisement

While occasionally hilarious, this proved a surefire way to completely derail a conversation as evidenced by an argument with Bill Burr in the early years of the podcast where the stubborn Redban abjectly refuses to consider Burr's reasoning leading to a near half-hour of mind-numbingly repetitive quarrelling.

Redban also performed regularly as a standup comedian during this time and would often use the podcast as a platform to discuss his progress in the profession. The problem was, this didn't always come at an appropriate time, and when he mentioned a glowing review from a comedy promoter towards the end of an episode with Justin Foster in 2013 an argument broke out between Redban and Rogan.

After several years of spending an inordinate amount of time together making the podcast on a regular basis, the friction between the pair is palpable and they go back and forth like an old married couple. It seems Rogan initially mistook Redban's pride in his comedy as being braggadocious, and the discussion does not improve from that point on.

Credit to Justin Foster for sitting quietly while the argument continued back and forth, occasionally trying to steer the ship back to the original discourse, like a child caught in the crossfire between warring parents.

This episode would mark the end of Redban's tenure as JRE producer after more than 400 episodes, but in recent years he has begun once again to appear semi-regularly showing that time heals all wounds among Rogan's comedy clique.

2. Steven Crowder

Steven Crowder is a conservative political commentator and comedian. Not only do those two things make him similar to many of Rogan's guests over the years, but Crowder had also actually appeared on the JRE before back in 2015. Therefore conventional wisdom would state that the pair would enjoy a good conversation on episode 917.

Advertisement

Which is exactly what happened, until Joe asked what at the time seemed like a fairly innocuous question:

What's your bias? If you had to go 'god damn it maybe I went too far down this road, if I could just relax one aspect of my dialogue' what would it be?

Alas, much like Andrew Hill before him, Crowder proceeded to reference a topic that is very near and dear to Rogan's heart: marijuana.

The problem with the discussion that followed was that its very premise was flawed. Crowder had stated that Marijuana was one of the few subjects that he did not want to discuss, which Rogan took as him being anti-legalisation and what started as a discussion devolved into heated debated and finally metastasised into an all-out argument.

The conversation wasn't helped by the fact that both men had been drinking and that JRE producer Young Jamie interjected on several occasions to provide sources that supported Rogan's positions during the discussion. Add to this Rogan's predilection for jokingly using slurs to insult his friends that Crowder didn't take kindly to, and you have the recipe for an auditory disaster.

To his credit, Rogan took to Instagram following the episode to apologise for his role in the argument and to insist that he and Crowder were still friends regardless.

Well, this one went off the rails for a while. First of all, I genuinely like Steven as a person, and although I might not agree with him about everything I think he's a good man. During the podcast we got into the subject of marijuana and by that time we (especially me) were quite a bit drunk and didn't exactly handle the conversation really well. Steven gets attacked online quite a bit, and it certainly wasn't my intention to have him on my show to argue with him. At the beginning of the show it seemed to me that we weren't being conversational as much as we were going off talking points so I suggested a few drinks as a social lubricant. We disagreed about weed, and judging by my personal level of regret after his reaction I'm sure I fucked up. I take 100% responsibility for it going off the rails, and I'm truly sorry if it upset any of you that listened to it or watched it. We managed to pull it back together at the end, but of course the sh*tty parts are all you or I will focus on for a while. My humblest and most heartfelt apologies. I do my best with these things but I, like all of us, am flawed.

1. Brian Dunning

The majority of the incidents discussed in this list have come out of the blue as part of the conversation going awry or a contentious topic for debate being brought up. However, when author and producer Brian Dunning featured on the JRE back in 2014 the tone of the podcast was set from the moment Joe concluded the pre-show advertisements.

Advertisement

The source of the heated atmosphere that is evident from the outset of this episode can be traced back to an article Dunning wrote in 2008 in which he included Rogan in a list titled Ten Most Wanted: Celebrities Who Promote Harmful Pseudoscience.

The episode starts with the pair discussing Dunning's inclusion of Rogan in his writing while reading his list out loud before stating "God this makes me sound like an !*$%". Despite the provocation, Rogan remains remarkably calm throughout the discussion in which Dunning repeatedly gets caught out for the hypocrisy of criticising Rogan for discussing ideas that he doesn't completely understand while doing the same thing.

A particular high point of this conversation comes when Dunning asserts that there is no need for exogenous supplements because "The reason you poop and pee is that you make more [nutrients] than you need". Rogan is quick to completely debunk this objectively unscientific statement.

Not bad for a pseudoscientist...

Unlike the other guests on this list, it appears that the pair have not reconciled since their conversation. In a follow-up blog post, Dunning claimed that while he harboured no hard feelings towards Rogan the feeling wasn't mutual.

Before proceeding, I want to be clear that there is (for my part at least) not the slightest bit of bad blood between us. [UPDATE: Unfortunately that didn't last long. Joe's last emails to me after the appearance, and after I wrote this, consisted only of obscenities. -BD]

Joe was quick to respond to Dunning's update on Twitter:

Hey, @BrianDunning are you dishonest or just delusional? http://abload.de/img/screenshotvbsi9.jpg… either way I hope you get well soon.
Advertisement