7 Ways Alternative Medicine Tricks You Into Thinking It Works
"We couldn't get into Medical School, so now we make it up as we go along"
Alternative medicine, the fluffy sounding oxymoron that has more layers than an onion wrapped in paper mache, has amazingly wiggled its way into everyday conversation.
An umbrella term that includes "treatments"
such as Acupuncture, Chiropractic, Homeopathy, Reiki, detoxing, Naturopathy and
essential oils (to name a few) – it seems not a day can go by without my ears
bleeding at having to listen to a co-worker, a family member or a friend
discuss the latest and greatest wallet-draining waste of time they have engaged
in.
Alternative medicine is multi-billion dollar industry, one that is entirely comprised of severely underqualified people who missed out on medical school, acting the role of a healthcare provider, dispensing either untested or proven ineffective materials that act as medicine. It’s an industry that is unregulated and actively attempts to exempt itself from the same standard of rigorous scientific testing, its counterpart Medicine is mandated to adhere to. As the name cleverly implies, alternative medicine is the alternative to medicine – it's not medicine, it’s not based in science and lacks evidence to support even the fundamental ideas of many of its practices.
What's an industry to do when it has no science, no facts, and no clue?
Let’s take a look.
7. It Makes You Feel 'Special'
Here's a not-so-revelatory newsflash: While science has provided us with a vast knowledge of chemistry, biology, and anatomy and provided us with the medical technology to have doubled our lifespan - science doesn't have all the answers. If it did, it would stop. Science not having all the answers, means medicine doesn't have all the answers and the alternative medicine industry recognises this as a hole it can take advantage of.
It doesn't really matter what country you reside in, most hospitals and clinics are understaffed, overworked and lack the resources to cope with the ever increasing amount of patients. Physicians have 15-20 minutes to talk with a patient, diagnose the problem (or refer them for testing) and to get them out in time to finish their paperwork so they can be ready for the next appointment.
The wait is long and the time with the doctor is short, and for frustrated people with management-only illnesses, alternative medicine can hold a seductive appeal
On the flip-side: Alternative practitioners offer displays of empathy and understanding. They can offer longer appointments where they will talk to you and build a rapport so you feel calm and listened to. They promote a "holistic" system of treatment which takes into account everything about your life rather than just the symptoms and you may leave their office feeling like FINALLY someone is listening.
By the time you leave the office of an alternative practitioner - you don't care the treatment sounds magical or implausible. You don't think about scientific facts or chemistry or the laws of physics - you may not even know about them, all you know is that you feel good and unlike scientific facts, feeling good is an emotion most people understand.
Once you trust someone and that person makes you feel you've found a friend and not someone being paid to treat an illness, it's hard to acknowledge the glaring flaws.
6. It Creates 'Goodies' And 'Baddies'
Fact: Pharmaceutical intervention can come with side effects. Nearly everything on this planet regardless of its origins will come with a side effect.
While those side effects are
tightly monitored and heavily documented by pharmaceutical companies, they can be off-putting to someone with a chronic illness
and several different types of medication.
This is where clever marketing and the capitalisation of scientific ignorance begins, you've just had your first session with an alternative practitioner – you feel like someone cares. Now, they've told you there is a better way than all that medication. A path away from chemicals, an "all-natural way".
For those of you that don't know, the Appeal To Nature fallacy is a logical fallacy where the entire planet is pigeon-holed into "Good" or "Bad" - everything "Natural" is good and everything created in a laboratory (i.e: chemicals) is "Bad". Those who employ this fallacy conveniently forgot that:
1. Everything is chemicals.
2. The origin of a compound is not an indication of its safety.
3. Poo is natural.
The fallacy is used to create a false dichotomy between nature and science and serve as a way to keep scientifically illiterate people scared and confused.
Appeals to Nature are a waste of time, especially seeing as the "naturalness" of a substance doesn't determine whether it's harmful or not. Using this form of black and white "Everything natural is good and everything chemical is bad", equates to "Arsenic is always good because it's found in nature but Aspirin is always bad because its chemical name is Acetylsalicylic Acid and it's made in a laboratory" - completely forgetting Aspirin is derived from the bark of the willow tree and being near large concentrations of Arsenic is a terrible idea.
It's useful to remember that everything can have harmful effects if given in a large enough quantity – there's a reason why the fundamental premise of toxicology is "The dose makes the poison".
If it seems like the livelihood of someone depends on them scaring you about "chemicals", it's probably because their livelihood depends on you being scared.
5. It Confuses 'Safe And Gentle' With 'Pointless'
<iframe width="480" height="270" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/HMGIbOGu8q0?feature=oembed" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>The bread and butter of the alternative practitioner is the idea that practices such as Homeopathy, herbal remedies, and Reiki are "safe and gentle"; conveniently leaving out the part where Homeopathy is magic ghost water and Reiki is the practice of paying money to have someone not touch you.
Often used as a means to demonise evidence-based medicine, this misguided attempt at a positive marketing tactic neglects to mention due to the lack of regulation of the industry and lack of scientific testing.
Alternative medicines are sold without quality assurance, without testing and without documentation of what they contain and most importantly, what they don't. Some remedies have been found to contain no trace of anything advertised on the bottle.
For many forms of alternative medicine such as Reiki or remote healing (where a person claims they can heal by thought alone from a faraway place), they are falsely promoted as being "safe and gentle" due to the lack of side effects, instead it's best to remember the only reason they should be considered "safe and gentle" is because they literally do nothing.
4. It Gives You The 'Easy Way Out'
It's hard to gain trust and support from the people whose wallets you want to empty when what you're trying to peddle lacks, not only logic, but also common sense. Treatments full of meaningless buzzwords such as "natural", "clinically proven", "organic", "immune boosting" and "activating compounds" sound science-like which helps build an illusion of credibility for a consumer base who have little or no scientific education.
Appealing to people who cannot understand that sometimes there are things in life that cannot yet be cured, or people who want quick fixes to their problems also helps to fill in the holes left by the absence of anything that resembles fact. Screw going to the gym every day when I can buy a 30mL bottle of flower "essence" boiled in Vodka for $45.00 from a mummy on the Internet with a "degree" in Naturopathy.
Because
buying a concoction containing unknown species of flower, boiled in booze in
someone's kitchen which is promoted using unsupported claims such as: "It
contains essences to let go of addictive behaviours and break bad habits. It helps you address emotional blockages due
to dysfunctional family behaviour patterns and helps you clear personal
emotional blocks which have resisted previous clearing", doesn't sound
like a total f*cking scam at all.
Alternative practitioners aren't entirely dumb though, mostly they understand they can't do complex surgery or treat injuries that would land you in the emergency room, however, an illness that will resolve on its own is apparently fair game. The human brain is an amazing pattern recognition tool and it's easy for an alternative practitioner to falsely attribute their glorified placebos as the reason you no longer have a cold. Especially, when we so often confuse correlation and causation. It is important to remember that a placebo making you feel good, isn't the same as actually being healthier.
3. It Uses The Placebo Effect To Its Advantage
Feeling better and actually being healthier are two different things, a person can still have an illness while reporting they feel okay – they're still sick, they just aren't showing or feeling any symptoms of their illness. This phenomenon is known as the placebo effect and for many people, feeling better is perceived as being healthier, therefore - no longer sick.
Alternative medicine is an industry built on exploiting the placebo effect especially with illnesses that resolve on their own. Practices such as Acupuncture and Chiropractic have been shown to be no more effective than the placebo effect at treating muscle/skeletal-related conditions, while treatments such as Homeopathy and Reiki flat-out can't work for eliminating diseases. Homeopathy violates the laws of Chemistry and Physics, and Reiki – well, if not touching someone was the cure for cancer, than not giving a handjob gives the best orgasms on the planet. (Note to self: Stop waving at my co-workers.)
The placebo effect is an interesting phenomenon, one that isn't fully understood, however, it does have a vital role in the creation and study of pharmaceutical treatments. New drugs are tested against placebos (which are often in the form of sugar pills or a saline solution) to assess how well the drug works up against something that is known to have no physiological effect on the body. The perceived "healthier feeling" of the placebo effect has also been found to be experienced by people who expect a treatment to work – regardless of whether that treatment can work.
Alternative medicine is like a kid who does no study for a test, cheats off their neighbour and successfully tricks the teacher into thinking they're super smart, the magic ghost water that is Homeopathy isn't going to cure a stomach-ache – it's not even going to cure your thirst but when a customer expects it's going to work, experiences the placebo effect and perceives themselves as being healthier long enough for the stomach-ache to resolve on its own – game, set, match. All of the credit and all the money for doing nothing.
Which brings me to my next point..
2. It Uses Conspiracy Theories To Frighten You
Appeals to Nature and cries of "safe and gentle" products paint a nice soothing picture of the alternative medicine industry - full of rainbows and unicorns, unlike the picture the industry paints of science and medicine - scary with big words and harsh sounding chemicals.
When your practice lacks science and you're scrambling to deflect from that; if feel good emotions aren't enough for a doubter to part with their money, a scary conspiracy theory never fails.
The biggest lie ever told by the alternative medicine industry is that "Big Pharma" is only in it for money and profit – ignoring that the homeopathic industry alone is worth 1.05 billion euros in the UK, $5.35 billion is India and approximately $300 million - $20 billion in the US. Unfortunately the flaws in healthcare systems in some countries have paved the way for alternative medicine to act like a knight in shining armor with Big Pharma as the Big Bad Bogeyman that is out to harm everyone.
One of the more dangerous tactics used by alternative medicine practitioners to get consumers through their doors is the idea that pharmaceutical companies are deliberately making everyone sick because people ignoring the fact that many countries have socialised healthcare systems has worked out pretty well so far. Alternative medicine brings in big dollars – just like pharmaceutical companies, however unlike pharmaceutical companies, the alternative medicine industry has exempted itself from the rigor of scientific testing – all while demonising science in the name of profit.
While this serves as a nice way for practitioners to gain more customers, it has also resulted in a lowered herd immunity and an increase in preventable diseases. Believing conspiracy theories over science-based evidence can lead to other devastating consequences such as an increase in people neglecting medication that can help them in favour of mysticism, placebos and pseudoscience. When people neglect their medication, they get sick, end up in hospital needing science to clean up the mess created by the alternative medicine industry – creating even more of an overworked healthcare system, thus perpetuating the cycle.
1. It Makes Itself Untouchable By Going 'Beyond Science'
An entire industry built around practices that have either been proven to not be able to treat illness or have no evidence supporting they can treat illness is problematic, to say the least. There is no evidence for the mystic "Qi" or Meridian lines of acupuncture, no support for the claims that adjusting your spine can help cure diabetes and there's no evidence that tiny bottles of magic flower booze can do anything – not even get you drunk at a reasonable price.
The alternative medicine industry creates problems, the largest of all being the false dichotomy that there is an alternative to medicine – alternative medicine doesn't really exist, there are medical treatments and practices that have supporting evidence and then there's everything else. If a practice that was once in the sphere of alternative medicine is proven effective at treating illness – it would cease to be an alternative to medicine and become medicine! Fancy that.
Unfortunately, correcting the misconceptions and discussing the problems created by the alternative medicine industry using science isn't going to hold weight with someone who either doesn't value it or doesn't understand it. Amazingly those same people who distrust medicine will have no issues putting untested concoctions in their mouths on the reliance and trust of people who have never seen the inside of the lecture hall, never opened a textbook and think the first link in Google equates to "research".
We live in a society which silences criticism with cries of "But if that's what they believe, who are we to interfere?" Beliefs don't have a place in evidenced-based medicine and they shouldn't be used as guidance when it comes to a person's health. Evidence-based medicine deals in fact, not mysticism and definitely not fluffy sounding supernatural pseudoscience because here's the thing – just because you really want something to be true, doesn't make it so.
You could write for WhatCulture Science! Click here to find out how you could get paid to write about what you love.
If science gives you the warm fuzzies, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter to stay up to date.