8 Heinous Scottish Criminals - And Their Crimes
Which lawbreakers, villains and rogues hail from Caledonia - and what did they do?
Unofficially dubbed “The Best Wee Country in the World”, Scotland is well known for its rugged natural beauty, the world-famous whisky it produces, and having weather and a national football side that always seem to let you down whenever you start to believe that something good might be happening.
It has a long and storied past of culture, music and traditions that are very much its own. It has also had its fair share of those who have been on the wrong side of the law. Its history is filled with men and women that rebelled against the system and broke the law to further the ends of their countrymen and nation. People who are writ large across the tapestry of Scottish history - William Wallace, Rob Roy and Katy Barlass.
They are not the subject of this article. Instead, these are people from the modern era who committed crimes with no grander moral agenda or to try and overthrow an oppressive regime. Instead, these are people who broke the law, some of them in appalling ways, who just so happen to be Scottish.
Bear in mind that the following are not ranked in any way.
8. Dennis Nilsen
Subject of an as-yet unreleased drama starring David Tennant, Dennis Nilsen was a number of things throughout his life. He was an army cook, a member of the police force and a security guard. He was also a chronic abuser of alcohol and a serial killer.
His childhood was one of loneliness and isolation, compounded when he realised he was a homosexual and attempted to keep this hidden from all around him. Joining the army, he served as a chef over a number of postings around the world before moving down to London and joining the Metropolitan Police.
While in London, Dennis' mental state deteriorated further and a slew of failed romances with other men led him to believe he was not fit to live. From 1978 he is believed to have killed at least twelve young men. His usual method was to drink heavily with them and then end their life via drowning or asphyxiation.
Known as "The Kindly Killer" due to the way that he "cared" for the remains of his victims by washing and cleaning them, there are far more unsavoury details of his crimes available to anyone with a strong enough stomach to research further.
Sentenced to life imprisonment, he died in 2018 at the age of 72.
7. Angus Sinclair
The World's End pub stands to this day at the foot of the Royal Mile in Edinburgh, taking its name from a gate that stood in the city walls and marked where the "rest of the world" began. This gate was located immediately outside of the pub door and brass cobbles still mark its location.
What it is arguably most infamous for are the "World's End Pub Murders" in 1977, named because the two victims were last seen alive when leaving this location. Christine Eadie and Helen Scott were two 17-year-old girls that were raped and murdered and, bodies dumped six miles apart in East Lothian.
Despite no suspects being found at the time, when a Crimewatch episode covered the case in 2003 a number of phone calls were made to the police which later led to the arrest of Angus Sinclair. When he went on trial, due to much of the evidence being circumstantial, his lawyers managed to persuade the judge that there was no case to answer and he was formally acquitted.
The public outcry following this decision was enormous and amplified when it was let slip that Sinclair had previously been convicted of both murder and sexual crimes. The entire Scottish Law surrounding "double jeopardy" was altered and he was retried in 2014, receiving a minimum term of 37 years - the longest given in a Scottish courtroom.
6. Paul Ferris
Who Paul Ferris is and what he has done depends largely on who you choose to believe. He is a published author, a former business owner in the security field and the subject of the film The Wee Man. Prior to all these things however, he was alleged to have been a notorious, feared and extremely violent enforcer in the Glasgow underworld.
While he has only ever served a seven year stretch (as an adult) from 1998 for weapons charges and brief revisit for breach of bail, it was his earlier and more high-profile trial that caught the public's attention and threw him into the limelight. He was the defendant in what was, at the time, both the most expensive and longest trial in Scottish history.
The prosecution called witnesses that numbered into the hundreds, the trial took almost two months, the costs ran to over 4 million pounds... and in the end Paul Ferris was acquitted. He has been accused of two counts of attempted murder, drugs charges, weapons charges and more yet walked out of the court a free man.
He had initially worked for Arthur Thompson (now deceased) but had been accused of killing his son, Arthur Jr. (also deceased). His most famous and long-running feud was with Tam McGraw, who will be covered later in this list, but is also no longer with us.
Regardless of what you think of him, Paul Ferris is still alive despite his (alleged) line of work where there do not tend to be many old men.
5. Melissa Reid
The "Peru Two" was the name given to Melissa Reid and Michaella McCollum, two young women who were caught attempting to smuggle a substantial amount of cocaine out of the South American country. The twenty-year olds were found with the drugs inside of their luggage in August of of 2013 and convicted of drug smuggling, sentenced to more than six years in a Peruvian prison.
Why they were carrying such a large amount of the drug was initially murky as they claimed to have been forced into doing so by unnamed parties but pleaded guilty to drug smuggling. Melissa was released in 2016 after serving three years of her sentence while agreeing to be expelled from the country and returned to Scotland.
Her partner in crime, Michaella, cut a similar deal the same year and once back in Northern Island made the most of her new-found infamy. She wrote a book, took multiple interview opportunities and attempted to cultivate a celebrity lifestyle of sorts from her escapade. Melissa on the other hand has kept a low profile and has now even admitted that they both knew exactly what they were getting themselves in for, what was in the cases and the risks involved.
4. Thomas Hamilton
The name Thomas Hamilton may not be familiar to many but the atrocity that he committed in March 1996 shocked not just the community that it devastated but the country as a whole.
The Dunblane massacre is the deadliest shooting in UK history, claiming the lives of 16 children, one teacher and the gunman himself. The aftermath of this brutal act was the tightening of restrictions on the ownership of handguns in the UK where it is now nigh on impossible to have one on a personal gun license with very select exceptions.
Thomas Hamilton was considered "odd" by the community and despite being involved in the Scouts for a while, he was banned because people considered his behaviour and attitude towards the children worrying. He briefly ran a shop that failed and felt that he was being judged or ostracised based on these accusations.
After cutting the telephone cables, he entered the school with more than 700 rounds of ammunition for four handguns that he held entirely legally. After the murders had taken place, he committed suicide with one of his weapons to avoid capture.
A commemoration stone was placed in the local cathedral in 2001 to remember those who were lost.
3. Gary McKinnon
It can very easily be argued that what Gary McKinnon did to make him a criminal is far less harmful than any of the other entries on this list. If you believe what the American military say about him, it could be said to be the most deadly.
McKinnon is a systems analyst and computer expert who was arrested for conducting the "largest military hack in history" against various US agencies. They say that he forcibly broke into their systems remotely and caused nearly half a million pounds worth of damage. His hacking affected NASA, the Navy and the Department of Defence.
He insists that while he did break into their systems, he caused no harm, deleted no files and didn't introduce anything malicious. All he was doing was looking for proof that UFOs existed. His sincere belief was that one of these agencies had the proof and was holding it from the public.
After being interviewed on television, an autism expert phoned his solicitor, recognising some strong indicators and McKinnon was diagnosed with Asperger's. In addition to this, the repeated attempts to extradite him to America where he could face up to 70 years in prison led him to develop severe anxiety and depression.
The extradition was blocked for good in 2012.
2. Tam McGraw
Long term nemesis of Paul Ferris and noted name in the Glasgow underworld at the same time, Tam "The Licencee" McGraw was a feared figure in Scotland's largest city.
A man who was involved in crime from the start, he started out with petty thefts and robberies before standing accused of more serious crimes such as attempted murder. The way he always seemed to manage to avoid getting found guilty no matter what the situation has led to a persistent rumour that he was a long-term police informer.
He was a figure of note during the "Ice-Cream Wars" of the '80s (which are not as light-hearted or whimsical as they sound) and while he expanded his legitimate business interests and increased his wealth, he always seemed to maintain this near-magical ability to stay out of jail for the portions of it that were less legal.
Once friends, he became mortal enemies with Paul Ferris to the extent that he agreed to pay him a seven-figure sum in order to ensure no vengeance was sought when Ferris got out of jail. Increasingly paranoid, McGraw never went anywhere without bodyguards and took to wearing a bullet-proof vest.
He died in 2007 of a suspected cardiac arrest.
1. Peter Tobin
To this day, Peter Tobin remains at HMP Edinburgh serving a whole life order, where the assumption is that "life means life" : - basically he will never walk the streets a free man. And rightly so.
A serial killer and a dangerous sexual criminal, he has been assessed to be a legitimate psychopath by experts who have analysed him. While there are details of his crimes available to read, we will keep the descriptions and overviews brief. Much in the same way as Nilsen, research at your own peril.
He committed a serious sexual assault on two 14 year old girls before stabbing one and attempting to kill them both by turning on the gas in his flat. They survived and he went to prison for 14 years. Released in 2004, Tobin raped and murdered his next victim in 2006 and went back to prison, this time with a minimum sentence of 21 years.
When the garden of his home was dug up in connection with two missing girls from 1991, remains were found for both. Convicted of these two additional murders, his term was increased first to 30 years and then a full-life term.
Despite suffering major health issues, he is still alive today.