9 Scientific Ways To Tell When Someone Is Lying
And it's not by checking if their pants are on fire.
We're all liars. You might as well admit it now, because if you've genuinely never told a lie then there might actually be something wrong with you.
Statistics suggest that, on any given day, you might be lied to anywhere between 10 and 200 times.
Studies at theUniversity of Massachusetts have shown that the average stranger will have told you three lies within 10 minutes of meeting you ... and you will have done exactly the same. That's okay though, because as many as 82% of these lies will go undetected.
You've gotten very good at it over the years, you practically came out of the womb lying - babies as young as six months have been found to fake cries and actively deceive their parents to get attention. By the time kids reach the age of six, they'll be telling a lie around once every 90 minutes and, what's more, they'll be beginning to grasp how to make it believable.
Despite their prevalence, most people will only be able to correctly identify a liar 54% of the time - only slightly better than guessing. This is due to a lot of our perceptions and instincts of how liars behave (e.g. body language) are incorrect.
So howdo you spot a liar?
8. Why We Lie
To catch a liar, you've gotta know your enemy.
There's a paradox at the heart of lying.We claim to hate it and we hate being lied to but, as the statistics show, we all do it.
Lying about ourselves, first and foremost, is generally a way of closingthe gap between our imagined selves and our reality. Sometimes you might lie without even thinking about it, you might say that you're taller than you are, you might lie about your weight, you might exaggerate your interest in old school hip hop. Objectively, you can be pretty sure that this information is not going to impact anyone else's life in a dramatic way, it's more a way of weaving an identity for yourself.
It is also thought that lying is an inherent part of our evolution.
There are definite benefits to being able to lie well. As highly social creatures, the ability to manipulate others will serve you well and, ultimately, lead to evolutionary success (that's bonking to you and me). Being able to do selfish things and get away with it is just always going to be too tempting.
It's not all about getting one up on each other, however, as lying serves an important role in group communication and cooperation.
Being able to judge the expectations of others and adapt your behaviour accordingly, even if that means telling a couple of porkies, can lead to social success and even better cooperation. It can get us out of awkward situations, protect others and even forge friendships.Sometimes it's not always the best idea to completely speak your mind.
That said, sometimes we really do need to sort the fact from the fiction, but how?
7.Use Some Technology
We all know by now that polygraph lie detectors are pretty unreliable.
They work by monitoring, amongst other things, a person's heart rate, blood pressure, respiration and skin conductivity (i.e. how much they sweat) in order to detect their stress levels. The idea is that a person will be more under stress when they're lying than when they're telling the truth.
They have a drawback, however, in that the readings are all relative to some baseline "control" readings taken in response to truthful questions (such as your name or date of birth), making them easy to fool.Although it's difficult to suppress the autonomic reactions when telling a lie, it is possible to fake them when telling the truth. This will mean that if you try to actively produce a stress response when answering the truthful questions, they will match the lies and you'll get off scot free.
For this reason polygraph test results are not admissible in a court of law.
Your perjury days may still soon be over as scientists are working on a much more reliable MRI lie detector. Certain parts of the brain, including key parts of the frontal, temporal and limbic lobes, light up when a person is lying. Because lying is such a complicated thing to do, as opposed to truthful recall, these results are much more difficult to skew or fake.
It is, however, a little impractical and costly to fire up an fMri machine every time you suspect your kid might have been smoking in the park. Luckily, there are a few ways of sniffing out liars that don't involve millions of dollars worth of medical equipment.
6. They'll Use "Minimal Self Referencing"
One of the more striking linguistic clueswhen someone is telling whoppers is that their use of personal pronouns will go through the floor.
Listen to the way people talk most of the time and you'll notice that we use the words "I" and "me" with almost nauseating frequency. However, when a person is lying, their language will suddenly become impersonal.This is them subconsciously distancing themselves from the lie.
They might also tell the tale from another person's point of view, something that is pretty uncommon amongst truth tellers. In a (probably apocryphal) motor insurance claim, a man described his accident like this:
"The telephone pole was approaching. I was attempting to swerve out of the way when I struck the front end."Notice that the telephone pole was the active participant in that sentence, not the dude running into it. Now, this person wasn't completely lyingper se, but theyweresubconsciously attempting to misrepresent what happened.
Now, in full-blown fibbers this might be even more prominent. They might switch completely from first person ("I didn't kill your fish") to second person ("you don't kill other people's fish") or even third person ("people don't kill other people's fish"). Thisremoves the liar from the equation altogether in an attempt to divert attention away from them.
5. They'll Be Overly Negative
Another indicator that someone might be lying to you, is if they seem to be more annoyed about it than you are.
Liars tend to be more negative. It is thought that this is a result of their subconscious guilt "leaking" out. Liars rarely feel good about having to lie and this negativity translates into their story.
It also has the added effect ofmaking it seem as though they're as upset about the situation as you are. For example, instead of saying "sorry I'm late, bad traffic", they might plump for a more colourful option such as "the f***ing buses are a f***ing nightmare, I hope they hang whoever came up with that traffic layout", they might be lying to you. Alternatively, they might need some anger management therapy.
Speaking of colourful language, it turns out that liars tend to swear more. It is thought that this is due to the cognitive energy that it takes to lie. As the brain is occupied by fabricating a porkie, people find that they are less able to monitor their behaviour and language in other ways.
4. They'll Oversimplify
Constructing a fictional world in which it is definitely not your fault that the car has a big dent in it, is actually pretty difficult, so a lie will often be much simpler than the truth.
The good thing about the truth is that the details are already there in order to be recalled. When you're telling a lie, these details have to be invented, which is much harder work for the brain, and so the first instinct we have is to keep it simple.
This not only requires less initial work, but allows the liar to keep on top of the details and avoid being tripped up.
It is also thought that liars will use fewer "exclusive words". These are words such as "except", "without" and "but" that indicate that indicate details that have to be considered andthen excluded. To include irrelevant information in a lie makes it too complex.
Another slightly counter-intuitive marker will be if somebody is sticking to their story a bit too faithfully. Contrary to popular belief, the stories of truth-tellers are more likely to vary from telling to telling as different details are recalled or discarded. However, a liar will have rehearsed their story almost down to the word and will be unlikely to deviate from the party line.
3. But They'll Use Convoluted Phrasing
Despite the simplicity of a liar's story, they actually more likely to tell it in a convoluted way.
Basically the difference between truthful and false stories is that the truth will havecomplexcontent, presented simply. A falsehood will have simple content, presented complexly.
When we're lying, particularly if we're kinda doing it on the fly, we become acutely aware that there are awkward holes and inconsistencies. We will be inherently uncomfortable with what we are saying and will therefore attempt to make it, not only richer, but perhaps more confusing.
This increases that chances that the listener will allow some of it to go flying over their head and it can even give you a bit of wiggle room and thinking time if somebody asks you to clarify a detail.
It does, however, make you look shady as hell.
2. Forget What You Know About Body Language
A lot of the perceptionsout there about a liar's body language is pretty misguided or sometimes just straight up wrong.
Some of them are influenced by our instincts. For example, we're inclined to think that a liar will fidget and act shifty, however, it has been shown that liars actually stiffen their upper body when telling tall stories. We also think that they might avoid eye contact, perhaps to avoid allowing you a little peer into the windows to the soul, but actually, liars will often maintain a slightly creepy level of eye contact in an attempt to seem genuine and open.
Other little cues to look out for are an altered blink rate (faster or slower) and a lowered vocal tone. Liars might point their feet towards an exit or even place a barrier between you and them, such as a coffee cup or by placing a bag on their lap.
One of the more sinister cues to look out for is something that is known as a "duping delight". Although a lot of the hype around "microexpressions" is, by and large, a load of dingos' kidneys, there is a case for being able to spot "emotional leakage" in a liar.
Although we might expect liars to be stressed, sad, nervous or fidgety, the thing to look for is actually a display of relief or happiness. Once the lie is over and you appear to have bought it, the liar will feel a sense of relief and you might see a twitch of a smile flash across their face. Take a look at a video of Diane Downs, who shot her own children and claimed that a stranger had done it, to see a not-exactly-subtle case of duping delight.
1.But Overall...
The thing is about all of these little cues and clues is that they're just potential indicators rather than proof. So you think someone might be lying to you, but how do you actually catch them out?
Direct confrontation mostly leads to the person shutting down and going on the offensive. It also gives them carte blanche not to give you any more details and is frankly pretty counter productive.
A technique used by professional interrogators is to get their detainee to repeat their story backwards.For a person who is telling the truth, it is actually easier to tell a story backwards than to start from the beginning.Liars, on the other hand, will have most likely only rehearsed their story in chronological order.
This is a pretty effective way of bringing out inconsistencies, as opposed to simply getting them to repeat it, which will give them more opportunity to get the "facts" straight.
However, this is probably a bit of a weird thing to do in most social situations.Here, a better idea might be to ask them an unexpected question about their story, forcing them to make a snap decision and potentially lodging their foot in their mouth.
If you thinksomeonemight be lying aboutwhere they have been, for example, you could asksomething like "Oh right, did you get held up much by those roadworks?". Now they have to make a snap decision whether to go along with your imaginary roadworks (proving that they weren't actually there) or not.
If they dispute the existence of the roadworks, they might just be telling the truth (and now you have to feel bad for doubting them). You can smooth the whole situation over with something like "ah, they must've gone then" and no one need know what a distrustful git you are.
Try not to be too judgemental though, because the probability is that one of the next things out of your mouth will be a fib too.
Want to write for WhatCulture Science? Click here to find out how you could get paid to write about what you love.Hey, you. Yeah, you. You want some more science?Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitterfor your next fix.