The mad scientists of 20th century thrillers have got nothing on us. Bringing a corpse back from the dead? Lame. Aversion therapy? Child's play. The scariest stuff to occur in a lab doesn't come from horror movies or gothic novels. All you have to do is hand out a few doctorates and then throw funding at every single scientific proposal that your new Dr Jekyll can come up with. Unfortunately, that's pretty much what used to happen a few decades ago. We might live in a cotton wool society now but the code of ethics that researchers have to follow is only a relatively recent development. And seriously, some of the stuff that went on in the laboratories of the previous century turned out to be much more than kooky little experiments. People were traumatised, injured and, in some cases, killed. Still, it was all in the name of science, which obviously makes it totally okay.
9. Animal Drug Addiction Experiments
By the late 1980s, neuroscientists had conducted literally hundreds of disconcerting addiction experiments on monkeys and rats. Common practice involved teaching the animals to self-administer drugs (typically cocaine) using a lever, resulting in disturbing addiction-like behaviours. In some studies, the drug lever eventually offered access to alternatives such as food, water or mates. However, drug-addled Rhesus monkeys opted for a fix of coke every single time until they starved themselves to a presumably euphoric death. Addicted lab rats would even walk across electrified grids in order to get a dose of Charlie, and were willing to withstand a much higher voltage to access the drug than to reach their food. Worst of all is that the findings of these rather cruel studies are probably completely invalid. A 1980 paper shows that these behaviours only occur in rats that are kept tethered in small laboratory cages. Rats that were raised in a special enclosure dubbed Rat Park (chockfull of food, hamster wheels, mates and probably a couple of PS4s by the sounds of it) were force-fed water laced with opiates for two months but had a preference for plain water as soon as it was made available to them. In contrast, rats who had lived in jail-like cages their whole lives became heroin addicts at the drop of a hat. Todays life lesson: prevent your kids from doing drugs by installing a hamster wheel in the garden.
8. The Three Christs of Ypsilanti
Its neither a Shakespeare play nor a Bible-themed vigilante hit squad. Its actually the brainchild of Dr Milton Rokeach who thought it might be a bit of a lark to put three mentally ill people in a hospital together, all of whom had the unwavering delusion that they were Jesus Christ. The theory was that if each man could understand that the other two were clearly fantasists, they might begin to question their own beliefs for the same reasons. The case study lasted a stonking two years and the three patients stuck to their guns throughout, never faltering from the belief that they were the one and only Jesus incarnate, despite their cohabitants claims to the contrary. Initially, the men simply argued over who was the true Messiah but struggled to find a compromise. Eventually the disagreement descended into physical fights but finally an uneasy stalemate was reached. In short, each man discounted the other two as being delusional psychiatric patients or mindless robotic corpses that were being controlled by machinery. To put it simply, there was only one Jesus and they all remained stalwart in their beliefs that they and they alone were the real deal. Its a shame really: if one Christ can feed 5000, a few dozen more could have put a serious dent in the global food crisis.
7. Milgrams Obedience Experiments
In 1963 Dr Stanley Milgram became known forevermore in the world of pop psychology as that bloke who made people electrocute each other. In actual fact, his study examined whether the Nazi atrocities of the 1940s were simply a result of servicemen doing as they were told. Cheerful stuff. All participants were assigned the role of teacher and told that they were administering electric shocks to another volunteer (the learner) located in the other room. The shocks incremented by 15 volts and were marked with labels such as Strong Shock and Danger: Severe Shock (pictured). However, the final three were simply marked with some ominous looking X symbols. As the voltage intensified, the learner would scream, bang on the wall, complain about his dickie heart and eventually fall silent and yet, despite feeling incredibly uncomfortable, 65% of participants went all the way to the full 450V shock with little persuasion from the experimenter. One participant became so stressed by the thought that he was electrocuting someone to death that he had an epileptic fit. Of course, there wasnt really any learner receiving the shocks. A tape recording was used instead, and you cant kill a tape recording. To cap it all off, it turns out that the experiment might not have been as fruitful as first thought. It became apparent that the experimenters coerced the participants by insisting 25 times or more that they should continue. Furthermore, the study was repeated dozens of times and, in many cases, the obedient murderers were in the minority. It might well be that Milgram made hundreds of people temporarily think they were cold-blooded killers and didnt even have anything to show for it, despite his initial claims.
6. Elephant On LSD
Usually an unethical psychological experiment is carried out because the potential findings are too fascinating for researchers to resist. However, every once in a while, some lunatic comes along with a PhD and just does something awful for no discernible reason. In this example, that lunatic is Dr Louis Jolyon Jolly West. In 1962, he decided that he was going to inject a bull elephant with LSD to see what would happen. Just another day at the office. He theorised (with very little evidence) that it might induce what is known as the elephants musth state; an annual period of extreme aggression characterised by an increase in testosterone. A dart was fired into the rump of a three tonne bull named Tusko, delivering a ludicrously high dosage of LSD. Tragically, Tusko did nothing more than trumpet loudly and collapse into convulsions. The researchers fought to revive him by administering similarly excessive amounts of barbiturate and thorazine but sadly he died less than two hours later. What infuriated critics of the study was that the entire design seemed completely unfounded. A recreational LSD dosage for humans is approximately 0.2mg to be taken orally (not that Id know) and upscaling this to an elephant gives you 9mg. However, for some reason, Tusko was given 297mg via injection 33 times as much. Incidentally, a much more controlled study in 1984 found that LSD does make elephants kind of grumpy but definitely does not induce musth, so good job Dr Jolly.
5. Elliotts Eye Colour Experiment
Following the death of Martin Luther King Jr. in 1968, Iowan teacher Jane Elliott sought to show her class of white, middle class 8-year-olds what life was like for 1960s black children. Needless to say, some of the children didnt exactly have a good day at school. She divided her class by iris colour and began implying that the blue-eyed children were superior students. Initially, the brown-eyed kids refused to believe her but she soon persuaded them by pretending that the higher levels of melanin associated with blue eyes were scientifically linked with greater intelligence. Subsequently the brown-eyed children stopped objecting, even when Miss Elliott and the blue-eyed kids chastised and bullied them. They were forced to sit on the back rows and had to use a different water fountain. The blue-eyed children were given extra portions at lunch, an additional five minutes of playtime and were praised for their good work. Miss Elliott even encouraged the blue-eyed students to ignore their brown-eyed peers in the playground and not let them join their games. Most shockingly of all however, the intellectually inferior brown-eyed children ended up performing worse on maths tests than the blue-eyed kids. In fact, the blue-eyed group actually did even better on the tests than on a normal day. The kids only had to make it through six hours of what most black people of the era were subjected to for a lifetime but it goes without saying that this experiment would never be allowed today.
4. Schizophrenia Medication Experiment
Sometimes an experiment with the best intentions can find itself in unethical territory simply by lacking foresight. This was the case with a 1991 study into schizophrenia medication at the University of California, Los Angeles. Experimenters were interested in how schizophrenic patients would cope without medication. Half of the voluntary participants were switched from their regular doses to a placebo. However, the patients and their peers had not been warned of the potential effects. Either that or the experimenters were finishing every other sentence with What could possibly go wrong? and didnt even see the dangers themselves. The participants were told to inform the study leaders if there was a significant return of symptoms, at which point they would be removed from the study and some high intensity medication would be administered to help them recover. However, significant return turned out to be a disastrously subjective term. As a direct result of the experiment, one patient wound up threatening to murder his parents. Worse still was the case of Tony LaMadrid who leapt from a sixth storey classroom after a period of suicidal feelings. Evidently the experimenters got a tragically unexpected answer to their question.
3. The Case of David Reimer
In 1966, Canadian twins Bruce and Brian Reimer were taken to hospital for routine circumcisions but, due to a medical accident, Bruces penis was damaged beyond repair. The boys parents became worried for his long term psychological wellbeing and took him to see Dr John Money, an expert in gender identity. Dr Money suggested that Bruce should be given a sex change and raised as a woman, though critics believe he was more concerned with comparing the effect of nature and nurture on gender identity. Identical twins would make a perfect case study, so there are doubts as to whether he really had Bruces best interests at heart. Bruce became Brenda and continued visiting Dr Money for psychological tests for the next ten years. Reimer claims that at these sessions Money would force the twins to engage in disturbing sexual rehearsal play in which the two were instructed to remove their clothes and get into various inappropriate positions. In early adulthood, Reimers parents finally told him the truth about his past, as he was suffering with conflicting feelings regarding his gender. He then had a reverse sex change and became David but committed suicide at age 38, two years after his twin Brian took his own life also. All in all its a tragic case that could have gone very differently if the patients wellbeing had been the number one priority.
2. Zimbardos Stanford Prison Experiment
One of the most infamous psychological experiments of all, Professor Philip Zimbardos Stanford Prison experiment is not only disturbing in its very nature but also gives us a horrifying peek at what could be lurking within every one of us. A prison-like environment was constructed in the basement of Stanford Universitys psychology building and participants were divided into guard and prisoner roles. The guards were brought to the prison and given wooden batons, khaki uniforms and shades to hide their eyes. A day later, the prisoners were publicly arrested from their own homes without warning, taken to the basement jail, strip searched and dehumanised by being given identical smocks and ID numbers instead of names. Despite Zimbardo instructing that the prisoners should not come to any physical harm during the study, the guards attacked them with fire extinguishers on the second day because they had barricaded themselves in their cells. One had to be released after screaming and crying uncontrollably only 36 hours after his arrest. For the next few days, prisoners were kept in appalling conditions, especially those who did not obey orders; guards confiscated their mattresses, forced them to be naked and replaced their toilet rights with a bucket in each cell that disobedient prisoners werent allowed to empty. The two week experiment was called off after just six days of alarming psychological and physical abuse by the guards, with Zimbardo concluding that we all have a totalitarian prison guard within us and all it takes is a pair of shades, a sense of authority and a dehumanised victim.
1. The Case of Little Albert
In 1920, Dr John Watson experimented with the formation of fear and phobias in human babies. That sentence alone should be setting off your unethical psychology alarm bells at this point. The one and only unfortunate baby that Watson got his hands on for this experiment was a nine-month-old who was assigned the pseudonym Little Albert. The basic idea of the study was to expose Albert to a number of stimuli including a rabbit, a dog, a monkey and a white rat. If ever Albert reached out to touch the rat, the experimenters would swing a hammer at a metal bar dangling just above his head. The hammer made a very loud noise which invariably upset Albert. Subsequently, the child developed a phobia of the rat; crying and attempting to crawl away when it was brought out. Over time, this phobia seemed to extend to all sorts of white or furry stimuli including dogs, rabbits, cotton wool and even Father Christmas beards. Worst of all, Albert was removed from the experiment before Watson could attempt to reverse the effects. There might not have been any fatalities with this one but theres got to be a special place in Hell reserved for doctors who teach babies to fear Santa.