Ranking Game of Thrones Books: From Best To Worst

By Pallavi Gulati /

A Song Of Fire And Ice Series : From Best to Worst I would have thought that my Game of Thrones withdrawal would pass by now, what with the show having ended its 3rd Season almost two months ago. But the cravings have still not gone away and having already rewatched all three seasons, the only thing left to do that would satisfy them is rereading the books, something a lot of people seem to be doing to pass the time. The only hard part was deciding which to read first. They're all masterpieces of fiction but even the most die hard fan must acknowledge that some are better than others. It's a debate that goes on in a lot of forums and in a lot of people's heads, including mine. Finally, I was able to compile a list of rankings, from worst (or least favorite. Remember, they're all amazing.) to best (or most favorite). Without further ado, let's begin.

5. A Feast For Crows

I find that most people agree with me in this one particularly, though the lower end of the list changes depending on the person. But a lot of people who read A Feast For Crows after reading the three books prior and waiting 5 long years for this one, were disappointed. And it's not hard to see why. Whereas the books right before, A Storm of Swords, was full of action and adventure with great stories for the most loved characters, A Feast For Crows seemed to be in a lull where nothing much really happened. Sure, a lot of the point of view characters heard of interesting things happening across the Narrow Sea or far away, but nothing really seemed to be happening to them and that was this books biggest problem. The Cersei chapters, which were a large chunk of the book, showed her doing nothing but creating one problem after another. The same could be said of the Sansa chapters and a lot of Samwell's. There wasn't much momentum pushing the story forward, which is a big problem for a book thats a thousand pages long. Some of this was necessary set up for future books, but a lot of it really wasn't. None of it was bad, but a lot of it was pointless. Another issue people took with the book was the lack of any chapters for Jon, Tyrion, and Deanery's. These are probably the most beloved characters still alive in the books and a book without them playing any major part felt very much lacking. However, there were some highlights that made the book enjoyable. It did feature a lot of development for Jaime, showing him maturing into a much better person and a successful leader. Him handling the Siege of Riverrun, among other things, was genuinely exciting and added some adventure to a book that was otherwise mostly setup. Let me reiterate, none of it was bad setup and most of it prepared for the exciting things that were set to come down the road for the characters. Still, people didn't wait five years for setup and the book, while still good, is easily the least favorited of the series.

4. A Clash Of Kings

If you ever needed proof that George R.R. Martin is a great writer, here it is. Of the five books in the series, the four books that got the four top rankings on this list are books that I can say I'm genuinely in love with. Even ranking five is a book that is good and that I really enjoy. But every book this point and beyond is a book that I consider outstanding and ranking came to liking one slightly better than another. If the lack of action in A Feast for Crows ever bothered you, then you could always go back and read A Clash Of Kings. This was the book that really set the ball rolling after the execution of Ned Stark in the first book and feature the bulk of the action that takes place in the War of Five Kings. The magic really comes out as Deanery's dragons take flight, Stannis takes the Lord of Light for his god and with his Red Priestess, and one of the five kings finds out just how powerful magic is. Between the brotherly squabbling of Stannis and Renly, the King in the North, Theon taking Winterfell, and the Battle of Blackwater (especially the Battle of Blackwater), this book was action packed from beginning to end and really displayed the finesse of many of the characters, but especially Tyrion. Seeing him go from just Tywin Lannister's dwarf son to the very cunning Hand of the King who almost single handedly saves Kings Landing was a sight to behold. This, combined with the growing strength of the Northern army and the Stark children's adventures all across Westeros guaranteed this as a book to remember. Tyrion acting like a boss was just awesome and getting to see Theon take power for the first time only to have it immediately slip away due to his own stupidity was a treat. While it did have a few low points like Deanery's just wandering around Qarth without much purpose or result, it was still an epic read.

3. A Dance With Dragon

Now, if you didn't like this book very much, let me just say that I understand where you're coming from. However, I absolutely loved this book. It wasn't perfect and some of the things that promised to be the most exciting parts of it were cut from it and moved to the next book, but it was pretty damn epic. I don't personally like the fact that the Battle of Winterfell and Maureen were moved into the next book when reports say that they were ready for this one but were cut for page count. Still, even without those, this was a pretty masterful book. There's not a single part I disliked. Jon becoming Lord Commander and trying to do that job effectively while dealing with both the wildlings and the Others was great to read and see. Seeing Davos go to White Harbor and bargain with Manderly, and plot with him was great. Seeing the tension build at Winterfell as the barely allies of Roose Bolton try to resist the urge to kill each other was my favorite part. Watching Tyrion go across the Narrow Sea and make his way to Deanery's as well as Deanery's try to deal with ruling Maureen wasn't the best, mostly because a lot of Tyrion's stuff felt like filler. And while a lot of people say that Deanery's was unbearable in this book, I think it actually did a very job of showing how very hard it is to be a leader and even someone who has the best intentions has not guarantee of getting good results. Still, she was annoying. Almost every character got a chapter in this book and that was great because getting to hear and see a little bit of everyone is what made these books so good to begin. While this still had a little bit of that too much set up problem that plagued A Feast For Crows, what made it stand apart was that it was interesting, exciting, tension-filled setup. By the end of the book, I was practically dying to know how things would turn out at Winterfell, if Davos would find Rickon, what would happen to the Wall, and what would happen at Maureen and Kings Landing. The only thing I could think when I finished it was where was the next one.

2. A Game Of Thrones

This book is perfect and no one will ever dissuade me of that opinion. In terms of tension, in terms of action, in terms of the characters, the setting, the attitudes and the risks it took, this book is perfect. This was one of the first books in epic fantasy to take the characters that are normally the sidekicks and make them the heroes. Bastard son Jon Snow, dwarf Tyrion Lannister, whole new types of characters were created here. And while many people say Ned getting caught was rather predictable, no one can say the way his life ended was. All the actions of this book have later repercussions and while all of the characters aren't exactly likable, they're all interesting. Subtle set up for things that will come later is all over the place. Jaime's hatred of the Starks (particularly Ned), the kidnapping of Tyrion, the attitude of Renly, Jon's treatment at the wall. This book is the one that introduced us to the Starks and made us fall in love with them so that when the sword fell near the end, there wasn't a dry eye around. Even people who say Ned was stupid to act the way he did bawled when he died. Because even if he wasn't always the smartest man around, he was honorable, and people could love him for that. That was also the moment that the audience realized that anyone was expendable. A lot of books make this claim, but this is one of the very few that holds itself to that. It made the readers genuinely fear because when their favorite character got in trouble, there was absolutely no guarantee that they would come out. Building that kind of tension is very hard to do, but Martin did it here and created a whole new world, full of different people, cultures, and places that continues to captivate millions 20 years later.

1. A Storm Of Swords

If A Game of Thrones is perfect, then there really is no way to describe A Storm of Swords, considered the best book almost undisputedly by most fans. This book had everything. If A Clash Of Kings was action heavy and A Game of Thrones was plotting heavy, then A Storm of Swords had just the right amount of both. It really pushed the bounds of fiction in a lot of ways. The complete turn around of Jaime Lannister into one of the most beloved characters is something only an amazing author could do. The now infamous Red Wedding which offs more than half the characters was the kind of thing that made me literally throw the book against a wall, scream, but pick it up five minutes later. The wedding of Joffrey and Margaery, the wedding of Sansa and Tyrion, the escape of Sansa, the Trial of Tyrion, the Battle for the Wall, Tywin being a badass, Olenna Tyrell, Arya and the Hound, Bran and the warg, Jaime and Brienne and the Bear, all of it came together in a literally perfect book where one epic event happens right after the other and the audience can't wait to turn the page. I can honestly say I have never read a better book. This is just a perfect book and if you haven't read it or any of the books in the series, then you should, because you're missing out.