Despite the numerous controversies which still exist in the sport of MMA and more specifically its premier promotion the UFC today, anybody who has been a fan since the days of Royce Gracie, Don Fry and Ken Shamrock will know just how far the sport has come. Gone are the days of the post-fight battle royals between the trainers, the plans to have the Octagon surrounded by a moat filled with crocodiles and when the rules didnt prohibit Keith Hackney from smashing Joe Sons testicles. Now all bouts are sanctioned by a governing state athletic commission, all fighters are required to take part in thorough random drugs tests and a unified set of rules prevent potentially dangerous attacks like kicking the head of a grounded opponent. Since those early days the UFC has transformed from a spectacle to a legitimate, bona fide sport. The change undergone in the last decade has been profound but, nevertheless, MMA is a sport involving people who are fallible and so controversy is inescapable. With every month that passes a new subject of debate will emerge in the MMA world after all, its what keeps MMA journalists in a job. Some are laughable, others are genuinely troubling and some are still hotly debated years after they happened. Here are the 10 Biggest Controversies In UFC History...
10. Ranked Fighters Released
The UFC is widely regarded as the best promotion in all of MMA and with good reason by and large all of the worlds greatest fighters, from the 125-lb Flyweights to the 265-lbs Heavyweights, compete in the UFC. This is why when a highly ranked fighter is suddenly released from the company it is all the more shocking. This recurring controversy struck again recently when Jake Shields (29-7-1) was suddenly dropped by the UFC. The 35-year-old had lost only once to Welterweight title contender Hector Lombard and prior to this he had been riding a three fight winning streak, which included wins over the likes of Tyron Woodley and Demian Maia (both of whom are considered top-10 ranked fighters). Fortunately, an assembly of other MMA promotions recognised Shields obvious quality and he had his pick of the many offers he received to fight elsewhere. Other notable fighters who have inexplicably been cut from the UFC include Yushin Okami, Jon Fitch and Melvin Guillard.
9. UFC 151 Cancellation
UFC 151 was scheduled to take place on the 1st of September 2012 in Las Vegas, Nevada. The card featured notable fighters such as Dennis Siver, Jake Ellenberger and John Lineker while the main event was set to be a championship bout between UFC Light Heavyweight champion Jon Jones and long-time contender Dan Henderson. However, 8 days before the event it was announced that Dan Henderson was injured with a partial MCL rupture and was not able to fight. The UFC tried to seek a replacement in the form of former middleweight challenger Chael Sonnen. Jones declined to fight Sonnen on such short notice, adhering to the advice given by coach Greg Jackson. If youve watched The Ultimate Fighter, youll be aware that Dana White loves people who are willing to fight anyone at any time, so this didnt sit well with the boss at all. He even went as far as to say that Jackson and Jones murdered the event. Ouch.
8. Bang Ludwigs X-Second Knockout
Way back in 2006 the UFC were putting on one of their early Fight Night events, UFC Fight Night 3. One of the bouts set to take place that night pitted Johnathon Goulet against Duane Bang Ludwig. The first punch of the fight thrown by Ludwig was the last as it sent Goulet crashing down, face first, into the mat. As fans at home and in attendance could see the fight clock stood at around the 4:56 mark when referee Mario Yamasaki stopped the fight, making it last all of 4-seconds. However according to the official timekeeper the fight was stopped after 11 seconds. In reality the fight quite clearly took only about a third of this time. After much discussion on the subject Keith Kizer of the Nevada State Athletic Company declared they were unable to overturn the time stamp on Ludwigs victory. Despite this many people regard Ludwig as the owner of the fastest knockout in UFC history and are appalled that the kickboxing-master shouldnt be given the credit he deserves.
7. Tito Ortiz Removed From LHW Records
Dana White is fairly notorious for having arguments with his employees. Randy Couture, Roy Nelson and even veteran referee Big John McCarthy have all been on the receiving end of a lashing from the UFC Presidents venomous tongue. Perhaps the most well known verbal sparring partner of his is former Light Heavyweight champion Tito Ortiz. These two bitter rivals used to be close friends White was even Ortizs manager once upon a time. Unfortunately, they fell out over a financial disagreement and Tito defected to another promotion. Their bickering has never ended however, with Ortiz once wearing a t-shirt to a weigh-in sporting the slogan Dana White is my b*tch. There were also rumours of a boxing match between the pair so you can tell they were still on rocky terms (pun not intended). Until recently this rivalry was confined to sly jibes made during press conferences, but at UFC 172 it reared its ugly head once again. After Jon Jones worked his way to a decision victory over Glover Teixera, a graphic emerged on the screen stating Jones held the record for the most wins in UFC Light Heavyweight history with 14. The inescapable issue here was that Ortiz had 15. Outraged fans and fighters alike took to Twitter to express their outrage that a fighters legacy could so easily be destroyed and removed from the record books. Even Ken Shamrock, the man who once threatened to knock Titos blonde locks black, was disgusted at dastardly Danas newest attempt to undermine Ortiz.
6. Rousimar Palhares
We have already discussed fighters being unjustifiably cut from the UFC roster but if ever there was a man who deserved to be given the boot it was Rousimar Palhares. We say given the boot, but Palhares actually received a lifetime ban at the end of 2013. The Brazilian is one of the few mixed martial artists who not dissimilar to a WWE wrestler has built up a reputation for having an actual finishing move. Of his 16-career-wins, an impressive 13 have come through his horrifying heel hook submission. While this is all perfectly legal as per the unified MMA rules, Palhares fights with such intensity that he very rarely lets opponents go when they tap-out, forcing the referee to pry their ankles out of his ridiculously strong grip. This is clearly extremely bad conduct with any submission technique but leg-locks of any kind are particularly dangerous. A moment can be the difference between walking out of the cage and sustaining a career-ending injury. It is for this reason that leg-locks are banned from most amateur MMA promotions. After Palhares was dropped from the UFC he was quickly snapped up by the World Series of Fighting where he now resides as the Welterweight champion after beating Steve Carl with yet another heel hook. Even on this occasion there was a small delay between the referee grabbing him and Palhares actually stopping the hold.
5. Stance On Marijuana
The blame for this controversy must be firmly placed on the shoulders of the athletic commission. Fighters who are tested and found to have any trace of marijuana in their system are treated in the same way as those found to have been using performance enhancing drugs. Regardless of the stance you personally take on marijuana, in no way should partaking in it be considered as punishable as using steroids to cheat. A notable case which involved this controversial stance on the drug was a year ago at UFC 159 when Pat Healy tested positive for marijuana after his win over Jim Miller. Not only did he have the victory which would have been the biggest of his career stricken from his record but he was also forced to surrender the $65,000 Fight of the Night bonus and $65,000 Submission of the Night his come-from-behind victory was rightfully awarded.
4. Grease-Gate (UFC 94)
UFC 94s main event saw the companys first ever super-fight as active Lightweight Champion B.J Penn challenged active Welterweight Champion Georges St. Pierre for his 170-lbs belt. The two had fought three years prior in what was essentially a #1 contenders bout and George had outworked and outconditioned the super-tough Penn en route to a nail-bitingly close split-decision victory. The two legends of the sport had a score to settle and would meet again this time as world champions. To say that anticipation was high for this fight would be understating it. Leading up to the fight it was believed that if Penn was able to get St-Pierre down to the mat and utilise his off-the-chain Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu game he would eventually catch the Canadian in a submission, while if Georges was able to keep it on the feet his superior athleticism would let him out-strike the Hawaiian. The fight went much the same way as the first fight B.J Penns suspect fitness was overwhelmed by the high intensity nature of GSPs fighting and eventually he was forced to retire at the start of the fifth round. After the fight, B.J Penn very publically accused Georges of cheating, suspecting the reigning Welterweight champ of having greased himself up before the fight to ensure that he was able to slip out of Penns submissions. It didnt end with unsportsmanlike accusations though Penn took his case to the state athletic commission who eventually ruled that Georges was innocent.
3. Testosterone Replacement Therapy
TRT has been at the centre of many MMA discussions recently. Many people argue that it gives the user an unfair advantage as it is designed to delay the effects of natural male aging. It has also been speculated that TRT is as bad as using steroids. Notable names in MMA such as Dan Henderson, Chael Sonnen and, most prolifically Vitor Belfort have all been given passes for TRT by the respective state they were fighting in. Recently, after much campaigning by UFC President Dana White, the use of TRT has been made illegal in MMA. This meant that fighters who had been on TRT for a long time would have to ween themselves off it as going cold turkey could be dangerous. Some speculate that this resulted in Vitor Belfort having to withdraw from his hugely anticipated title fight against Chris Weidman as he wouldnt be able to appear TRT-free by the date of the fight. However, this is just speculation and has not actually been confirmed by Belfort himself. The question is how much does TRT influence an athletes performance? The fact remains that while TRT may have affected his appearance, TRT did not make Vitor Belfort throw a head kick which almost decapitated Luke Rockhold. Also these men may be using TRT for personal reasons, so how far do you delve into someones private life before allowing them to fight?
2. Fallon Fox's Transgenderism
Though not at this time on the UFC roster, the Fallon Fox-saga is an intriguingly controversial case whose impact has quite evidently filtered through to the UFC. Fox is the first and only transgender MMA fighter, originally born Boyd Burton in Toledo, Ohio. Fox underwent gender reassignment surgery in 2006 and made her pro-MMA debut as a featherweight in 2012. As if the notion of a transgender fighting against someone born a woman wasnt controversial enough, Fox was also guilty of not disclosing her transgenderism initially, only making the information known after her first two fights. As you might expect, this subject has proven to be highly controversial, not only in the MMA community but also in the wider sporting world. UFC fighter Matt Mitrione was suspended for the strong views he expressed on Fox, stating that he believed she possessed a huge advantage over female fighters. The UFCs colour commentator Joe Rogan was equally dismissive, highlighting how mens natural reflex and bone density advantages meant that even with the surgery and hormonal therapy Fox had undergone, she still had an unfair advantage over female competition.
1. Dana White, UFC President
Dana White is a walking controversy who seems to get gradually worse as time goes on and his ego expands. Theres always some form of controversy surrounding the UFCs president. This is the man who regularly responds to haters on Twitter with quips such as f*@k you clown and look at you with your 2 followers. He is well known for having long standing arguments with his employees, as mentioned in a previous entry. Some of his more recent controversy has come from his views on Cristiane Cyborg Justino. As many people consider Cyborg the only real threat to Ronda Rouseys Bantamweight belt, they are keen to see the Brazilian drop down a weight class and fight Ronda in the UFC. Dana has other plans though. Hes been known to bring up her failed drug test early in her career as a reason for not hiring her despite having rehired Josh Barnett who has failed an inordinate number of drugs tests. He has also advocated Ronda Rousey referring to Justino as an it and even said the woman looks like Wanderlei Silva in a dress despite having reprimanded the aforementioned Matt Mitrione for making offensive comments about transgender fighter Fallon Fox. These are just a few things that come out of the presidents mouth (littered with his trademark F-Bombs, of course) on a daily basis. While it is undeniable that White has helped transform the sport and made it what it is today, it has to be acknowledged that he is the most controversial figure in the world of MMA.