10 Biggest FIFA World Cup Controversies

Safe to say England don't get much of the luck at World Cups.

By James Metcalfe /

With total attendance figures stretching past the forty million mark and a record audience of 3.5 billion at the last edition in Russia, the Fifa World Cup is the biggest and most prestigious sporting event in the world. Every four years, 32 of the world's best international sides converge in a country to compete in a group-to-knockout tournament with the potential of earning themselves a place in the history books.

Advertisement

With everything from securing number one hits on music charts, to fluctuating the rate of heart attacks in the countries that are competing, the World Cup has an influence that no other event can compete with, and so many legends of the game have earned their legendary status' through their feats at one of Fifa's most important competitions over the years.

However, with such a big stage set, there are plenty of opportunities for controversial moments to take centre stage. And, with 60 years of history and 21 tournaments behind it, the World Cup has truly shown that it is the master of producing said controversy. From scandals of bribery and corruption, to huge bust ups between stars on the pitch, here's our take on the top 10 biggest Fifa World Cup controversies.

10. Zidane's Headbutt

Zinedine Zidane was arguably the best player at the 2006 World Cup heading into the final. Already one of the world's most well respected faces prior to the tournament, Zidane really began to turn things on in the quarter-final tie against Brazil, almost single-handedly taking down a side that included the likes of Ronaldo, Adriano, Kaka and Ronaldinho.

Advertisement

Whilst his antics in extra time have become iconic now, Zidane's moments of controversy in the final actually began in the opening ten minutes. His France side were awarded a penalty which Zidane cheekily lobbed in off the underside of the crossbar, triggering a couple of outcries from the Italian defenders claiming the ball hadn't fully crossed the line.

Things would really flare up in extra-time however when Italian defender Marco Materazzi began trash talking Zidane's sister. In a sequence that has now become iconic in both World Cup and sporting history, Zidane jogs past Materazzi, the Italian defender says something to him, to which Zidane turns back round and leathers him in the chest with a brutal headbutt to the chest.

It turned out to be Zidane's final ever game within the sport, with it later being revealed that the Frenchman's controversial lashing out had arisen from Materazzi repeatedly making remarks about his sister.

9. 2014 World Cup Protests

Brazil might be the home of Samba football and the world's most successful side at Fifa World Cups with five separate triumphs over the years, but the homecoming of the tournament in 2014 was anything but harmonious.

Advertisement

Prior to the football even kicking off, the tournament was the target of several high-profile marches and protests, with Fifa even coming out and announcing that the opening ceremony would not feature any speeches for fear of booing or even a stadium revolt. For the poorer workers across the country, a World Cup investment was not seen as something the country should have been gunning for, and everything from officials to foreign reporters and television crew were subject to targeting.

These protests were given even more fuel when an unstable staircase at the Maracana Stadium, a monorail and an overpass in Belo Horizonte both collapsed and a stadium fire sadly claimed the lives of eight workers.

The protests continued right the way through the tournament, most notably breaking out furiously when Brazil lost 7-1 to Germany in the semi-finals, and the hosting of the 2014 World Cup remained a controversial talking point in Brazilian society even after the football wrapped up.

8. South Korea's 2002 World Cup Run

South Korea and Japan hosted the first World Cup of the new millennium in 2002 and both had surprisingly good runs in the competition. Japan topped a World Cup group for the first time in their country's history before eventually falling narrowly short against Turkey, however South Korea were the real surprise package.

Advertisement

The hosts topped a group containing Portugal, Poland and the United States with two wins and a draw, however things began to look a bit odd when they came up against the mighty Italy in the knockout stages. Despite boasting a side that contained the likes of Buffon, Maldini, Del Piero, Totti and Vieri, Italy found themselves on the wrong end of a suspicious penalty decision, numerous dodgy refereeing calls, an 88th minute equaliser and a golden goal instant elimination in extra time.

Flukey results can certainly happen in football, however South Korea raised even more eyebrows when they came up against another giant of a side in Spain in the next round. Again South Korea came up against a legendary team, and again the contentious decisions came flooding in. Spain had two goals ruled out contentiously and would eventually be knocked out via a penalty shootout, with Ivan Helguera having to be restrained from the officials afterwards. Speaking about the game, Helguera said:

"What happened here was robbery. Everyone saw two perfectly good goals. If Spain didn't win, it's because they didn't want us to win. I feel terrible about this game."

7. Luis Suarez Takes A Bite

Luis Suarez is not an individual afraid of having a little controversy hanging over his career. He has been accused of diving in front of officials in order to win some favourable decisions and has been banned for racially abusing opposing players in the past. However, there is one consistent stream of controversy that has followed Suarez wherever his career has taken him more than any other.

Advertisement

It all began in November 2010 when Suarez was with Ajax playing against PSV. During an altercation with Otman Bakkal, the Uruguayan striker was seen biting the PSV attacking midfielder, netting him a seven game suspension, a hefty fine and the nickname 'the cannibal of Ajax'.

During a 2-2 draw with Chelsea in April 2012, Suarez was at it again, this time targeting Branislav Ivanovic with a bit to the elbow. Another ban, this time of ten games, followed but Suarez wasn't done yet.

At the 2014 World Cup during a group stage game against Italy, Suarez bit one of his opponents for a third time. This time it was Giorgio Chiellini who was the unlucky recipient, receiving a bite on his shoulder following an off the ball altercation with Suarez. The Uruguayan was punished even harder this time, being banned from all football for four months following the incident.

6. Swiss Celebrations Against Serbia

Thankfully, the troubles and controversies that surrounded the preparations and hosting of the 2018 Russia World Cup largely vanished once the action kicked off, with the event quickly winning over plenty of the doubters soon enough with its stunning stadiums, welcoming atmosphere and memorable matches.

Advertisement

However, it was not totally exempt from some fiery moments over its duration, and the group stage match between Switzerland and Serbia arguably provided the most controversial of these moments when Swiss players Xherdan Shaqiri and Granit Xhaka brought out their double-eagle celebrations in their 2-1 win.

Both players posses Kosovar Albanian heritage, with the double headed eagle being the symbol of Albanian identity, and their celebrations were seen as a direct provocation towards the history between Albania, Kosovo and Serbia. Both players were booed by Serbian fans following the celebrations and a Fifa inquiry was held afterwards which resulted in fines of 10,000 Swiss Francs being dished out to the players.

Reaction on the world stage was naturally mixed. Both Kosovo's President, Hashim Thaçi, and Albanian Prime Minister, Edi Rama, were vocal in their support of the celebrations, however Serbian newspapers labelled the pair a 'disgrace', whilst some of their fans claimed they should have been subjected to bans from playing.

5. The Battle Of Santiago

Back in 1962, Football had a very different reputation than what fans of the sport might expect these days. Still very much seen as a game for gentlemen that was based around decency and respect, things began taking things for the shocking following the 'Battle of Santiago' between Chile and Italy in that year's World Cup.

Advertisement

With the event being hosted in Chile for the very first time, tensions between the two sides began mounting when some of the visiting Italian journalists described Santiago as being rife with "malnutrition, illiteracy, alcoholism and poverty." The reporters were eventually hounded out of the country and beaten up after being discovered in an Argentine bar across the border.

Everyone was bracing for a 'bloodbath' when the sides kicked off at 3pm on the 2nd of June, and spectators only had to wait 12 seconds for the match's first foul. English referee Kenneth Aston (who would go onto invent yellow and red cards after having to officiate this game without them) might have expelled two players off the pitch, with the first coming after just eight minutes, but he was utterly powerless to stop all of the kicking, spitting, swearing and punching going on during the game.

Humbert Maschio suffered a broken nose, police were called onto the pitch three times and the BBC reporter, David Coleman, later introduced the match as being: "the most stupid, appalling, disgusting and disgraceful exhibition of football, possibly in the history of the game."

4. Qatar Win The 2022 Hosting Rights

A controversy still fresh in people's mind and increasingly relevant as the competition's start date draws nearer and nearer, Qatar are set to host the 2022 Fifa World Cup, despite having never qualified for the competition in their entire history.

Advertisement

The influence and impact from the Middle East on Football in recent times is fairly obvious to anyone following the sport, and it has always brought with it substantial controversies. Despite claims from the Qatari representatives that the event will be a way of uniting the Arab world with the West, and those from Fifa that claim the country to be a more than suitable host, there have been a number of controversial issues surrounding the upcoming event.

Claims about corruption and bribery between the Qatari hosts, broadcasters and Fifa have emerged ever since the awarding of the tournament and the harsh climate of the country means that the traditional time of hosting the competition in the summer off-season is practically impossible.

Perhaps the most serious of controversies surrounding the 2022 bid is the long history of human rights abuses labelled against Qatar however. Labour rights violations, the lack of freedom of movement and democratic privileges and the persecution of LGBTQ+ and women communities have all been thrown at Qatar over the years, making the idea of letting a country with such allegations host a competition built around community and togetherness just somewhat controversial.

3. Graham Poll's Three Yellow Cards Vs. Croatia

Every football fan loves shouting at referees, it's practically part and parcel of being involved in the game at this point. Star striker misses a simple chance? Ref's fault. Captain pulls up with an injury? Wouldn't have happened if the Ref spotted that earlier challenge, etc. etc.

Advertisement

Sometimes however, referees really don't help themselves.

The 2006 World Cup group F game between Croatia and Australia was a crunch match in deciding who would progress to the next round along with Brazil, with one of England's best referees in Graham Poll taking charge as the referee. The score ended 2-2 with Australia progressing, however the controversy had already begun a while before Poll blew the final whistle.

It all started in the 61st minute when Poll issued Croatian defender Josip Simunic with a yellow card for a foul on Harry Kewell. He then gave him another one in the 90th for another foul. And then another one in the 93rd minute for dissent and pushing him away.

For those who can't see what's wrong with the sequence above, a player needs to receive a red card and be ejected from the pitch following their second yellow, something which Graham Poll seemingly forgot to do. The controversy cost Poll and his team a chance at refereeing in the later stages of the tournament, and the English referee retired from all international tournaments following the World Cup.

2. Frank Lampard's Ghost Goal

One of the oldest and grandest rivalries in the world of international football, England vs. Germany doesn't need controversy to make it a fiery affair. However, the fixture delivered one of the most infamous and controversial moments in World Cup history back in 2010 when the two sides met in the last sixteen.

Advertisement

Led by Fabio Capello, the Three Lions had been unconvincing throughout their group stage, were pretty heavy outsiders heading into the game and were blown away by the Germans in the opening twenty minutes. Miroslav Klose capitalised on some poor English defending to make it 1-0 before Lukas Podolski piled on the pain with a 32nd minute strike to double Germany's lead.

Though England probably deserved worse, they suddenly found themselves back in the game with a sudden Matthew Upson header out of the blue. The whole mood of the game shifted as England found themselves back in the game, swelling up the pitch with the ball at the feet of Frank Lampard on the edge of the box just two minutes later.

Every single person in the world watching the game then saw the ball cleanly hit the underside of the German crossbar, clearly bounce over the goal line twice before being picked up by Manuel Neuer. Fifa had famously been against the introduction of goal line technology before the tournament, and this controversial moment did more to bring technology into the game than any other before it.

1. Maradona's Handball Vs. England

If there's one moment of football worse than Frank Lampard's ghost goal to England fans, it's perhaps the most iconic and controversial moment in Fifa World Cup history.

Advertisement

Diego Maradona is easily amongst the very best players to ever grace the game of football, and was absolutely unplayable during the 1986 World Cup. The little Argentine either scored or assisted 10 of Argentina's 14 goals during their route to the trophy, with arguably his whole career summed up in their quarter-final game against the Three Lions.

In what had been a fairly tight contest, Maradona broke through the English defence with a mazy run through the lines before his pass was misplaced towards Steve Hodge. The English left midfielder miscued his clearance however, with the ball floating inbetween Maradona and goalkeeper Peter Shilton. The little Argentine forward lept like a salmon and punched the ball into the empty net, running off and encouraging his teammates saying: 'Come hug me, or the referee isn't going to allow it'.

Maradona would go onto score the goal of the century just five minutes later, but all the talk after the game was on this infamous moment. About the goal, Maradona simply said: '"un poco con la cabeza de Maradona y otro poco con la mano de Dios" ("a little with the head of Maradona and a little with the hand of God")'.

Advertisement