10 Biggest NUFC Manager & Player Fall-Outs

From Souness and Bellamy to Gullit and Shearer, life has never been dull at Newcastle...

By Chris Waugh /

Newcastle United's 1-0 loss at home to Manchester United may have frustrated Magpies fans - but the result had been of far less importance at St James' Park that night then the return of one of their own. Jonas Gutierrez took to the field in in 65th minute, replacing Ryan Taylor, to complete a remarkable comeback having twice been diagnosed with testicular cancer. The spine-tingling ovation and applause he was greeted to from a 50,000-strong crowd showed the extent to which the Argentine's battle with the disease had captured the hearts of the Geordie faithful. Yet his post-match comments confirmed something to which he had already alluded months earlier - that former Magpies boss Alan Pardew had told him to find another club during the height of his illness. Speaking to Spanish paper Marca, Gutierrez revealed: "He (Pardew) told me to look for a team a moment after the second operation at the end of 2013. This hurt me a lot. You have to be more human and not only look at the football side and business." Pardew has not given his side of events so no-one can be sure exactly what occurred, but it appears midfielder and manager fell out during the now Crystal Palace boss' time on Tyneside. And this is nothing new in the history of Newcastle - from Sir Bobby Robson and Kieron Dyer to Ruud Gullit and Alan Shearer, the Magpies have been all-too-familiar with fallings-out between managers and players. So, here are the 10 biggest fall-outs between players and managers in Newcastle United's Premier League history.

10. Kevin Keegan And Xisco/Nacho Gonzalez (2008)

KK's "Third Coming" at Newcastle United saw the former England ace return as manager for the second time in January 2008 following the dismissal of Sam Allardyce - but it ended unceremoniously just eight months later. Keegan's second spell as Magpies boss did not see any "fall-outs" with players per se, but it saw a massive bust-up with the club's hierarchy over the incoming and outgoing transfers during the summer transfer window. With the disastrous appointment of Dennis Wise as "Director of Football", Mike Ashley seemingly undermined his first-team manager Keegan - who claimed the arrivals of Iganacio Gonzalez on loan from Valencia and Xisco in a £5.7million permanent transfer from Deportivo la Coruna were made completely against his own wishes. In October 2009, Keegan was eventually granted £2million in compensation for "constructive dismissal" - with the former Toon boss also arguing that James Milner was also sold under his nose to Aston Villa for £12million. The fall-out may not have been directly between a manager and a player, but Keegan's exit in 2008 was brought about by the presence of Xisco and Gonzalez in his squad.

9. Alan Pardew(/Steve Bruce) And Hatem Ben Arfa (2014)

There are few players in the world as talented as Hatem Ben Arfa - but the mercurial Frenchman was simply unable to keep his nose clean at St James' Park, leading to the termination of his contract in January. No-one on Tyneside should have been surprised by Ben Arfa's eventual antics - he purposefully engineered a move from Lyon to Marseille, and then went on strike at the latter in order to facilitate a move to Newcastle - but Alan Pardew, and formerly Chris Hughton, were able to get four seasons out of the playmaker before the inevitable unravelling of relations occurred. It was during the 2013-14 campaign when things really turned sour for Ben Arfa. Despite the Frenchman being a fans' favourite, Pardew had dropped him to the bench due to his severe lack of work-rate - and Ben Arfa responded by sulking in the stands. Ben Arfa then spent the remainder of the season piling on the pounds before he was forced to train with the Under-21 squad during the summer of 2014. Pardew allowed the Frenchman to go on loan to Hull City due to Ben Arfa's lack of "love and passion" for Newcastle - and the player responded by sending an open letter to the fans denying this. Just to make sure that everyone knew Pardew had made the correct decision, Ben Arfa managed just nine matches for Hull before Steve Bruce admitted the transfer had not "worked out" because of the player's "work ethic". With the original season-long loan deal terminated just halfway through, Newcastle decided to cancel Ben Arfa's contract. Such a waste of t

8. Sir Bobby Robson And Nolberto Solano (2004)

Nolberto Solano made more than 300 appearances for Newcastle during two spells in the North East - but his first period on Tyneside ended on a sour note after the Peruvian's relationship with Sir Bobby Robson deteriorated beyond repair. The right-winger had been an ever-present in Robson's exciting Magpies side who had qualified for the Champions League two seasons in a row, but after Solano left for Aston Villa in January 2004, he claimed a breakdown in his relationship with the manager had facilitated the move. Solano, upon returning to the club in 2005, said:
"It was a big wrench to leave Newcastle. My relationship with Robson was difficult in the end. "He changed his mind about me and I was not very happy with the decision he made to sell me. Bobby did not play me and did not tell me why. "I was not very happy. I needed the communication about why I was not playing. Bobby Robson said nothing to me."
Publicly the relationship seemed fine, but privately it appears Robson and Solano were not as close as many thought.

7. Alan Shearer And Joey Barton (2009)

Alan Shearer's 10-year association with Newcastle United as a player may have been an extremely happy one - but his return as a manager proved to be a disaster, with the Magpies relegated to the Championship on the final day of the 2008-09 season. Given eight games to save Newcastle from a perilous position, Shearer failed to win any of his first five matches - and in the last of those, Joey Barton was sent off for a terrible challenge during a 3-0 defeat to Liverpool at Anfield. Barton was suspended by the club "indefinitely" and fined heavily after reportedly brawling with Shearer in the changing room - allegedly the pair had to be pulled apart when the former Manchester City midfielder labelled his boss a "s*** manager with s*** tactics". Shearer had restored Barton to the Newcastle line-up for the first time in three months for the Liverpool match, and said afterward he had made a "mistake" in doing so and that the player's challenge on Alonso was a "coward's tackle". Despite the bust-up, it was Shearer who left following Newcastle's relegation and not Barton - who remained at the club until August 2011.

6. Graeme Souness And Craig Bellamy (2004)

Controversy tends to surround Craig Bellamy wherever he goes - and his time in the North East were no different. Reports had already surfaced during Sir Bobby Robson's reign that Bellamy had thrown a chair at then first-team coach John Carver while the club were travelling to face Real Mallorca in the UEFA Cup in 2004, but it was the player's relationship with Graeme Souness that proved most explosive. The two did not see eye to eye from the moment Souness arrived at the club, and it was a match at Highbury against Arsenal in January 2005 that finally ended their relationship. With Bellamy omitted from the squad, Souness first claimed the player had a hamstring injury, before contradicting himself after the game and stating that the striker had refused to play on the wing. Bellamy immediately gave an interview in which he claimed he would play "in any position" for Newcastle, but then he admitted he had threatened to fake an injury if he was made to appear on the right wing. Souness was livid and insisted "liars" like Bellamy would never play for the Magpies again. After finding Bellamy two weeks' wages (£80,000), Souness sent the forward out on loan to Celtic - but the saga did not stop there. Bellamy allegedly sent abusive text messages to Newcastle legend Alan Shearer and Freddy Shepherd's son Kenneth - with the Magpies' famous No 9 supposedly threatening to "knock Bellamy's block off" if the Welshman returned to St James' Park. There's never a dull moment at Newcastle United, is there?

5. Kenny Dalglish And (The Majority Of) The Entertainers (1997-98)

Kenny Dalglish's time at Newcastle has always been a mystery because his preceding managerial record at Liverpool and Blackburn Rovers were exemplary. However, a large reason behind Dalglish's failure was his decision to disband Kevin Keegan's "Entertainers" - a move which led to his subsequent fall-out with much of the Magpies squad. Popular players such as Peter Beardsley, Lee Clark, Les Ferdinand and David Ginola were shipped out by the Scot, who attempted to completely overhaul a squad which only needed tinkering with. The departure of Ferdinand in particular soured relations with the fans, with the veteran striker extremely happy on Tyneside before Dalglish appeared to effectively force him out of the door. Although there were no explosive "fall-outs" with players, Dalglish's heavy-handedness and desire to completely gut a squad that had twice finished second in the Premier League ensured his stay at St James' Park would be a short one.

4. Joe Kinnear And Charles (Insomnia) N'Zogbia (2008-09)

Joe Kinnear's farcical reign as Newcastle United interim boss during the dreadful relegation season of 2008-09 was typified by his ludicrous and embarrassing falling out with French winger Charles N'Zogbia. Nurtured through the youth ranks at St James', N'Zogbia was exciting but frustrating; he could excite with mazy runs and beautifully-whipped crosses, but he could also be non-existent for large periods of matches. And, during the 2008-09 season, it was obvious N'Zogbia was looking for a "get-out clause" - something which Kinnear duly handed to him on a plate. Following a defeat to Manchester City, Kinnear accidentally referred to N'Zogbia as "Insomnia" - and the player then responded by stating he would never play for the club again. Kinnear claimed N'Zogbia's antics just proved the winger was attempting "to engineer a move away" because all he had done was "mis-pronounce a player's name". N'Zogbia had already released a statement in December 2008 in which he said: "After four years at Newcastle, I want to reach a higher level of ambition. I don't think that is possible here." And, in the final hours of the January 2009 transfer window, N'Zogbia moved to Wigan Athletic in £6million part-exchange deal, with Ryan Taylor going the other way. Rarely has there been such an embarrassing episode in football - even at Newcastle United!

3. Ruud Gullit And Rob Lee (1997-98)

"Come in Number 37" is the infamous name of Rob Lee's autobiography - and it references the horrendous way in which the Magpies legend was treated by Ruud Gullit. The Dutchman arrived on Tyneside during the 1998-99 season and set about attempting to rid the club of its experienced players, and Lee was high up on the agenda. He forced Lee, Stuart Pearce and John Barnes to train with Newcastle's reserves, before refusing to give the former England midfielder a squad number for the 1999-2000 campaign. Lee's No 7 was instead given to new signing Kieron Dyer, who had arrived from Ipswich Town, and the veteran midfielder came close to leaving Newcastle. Lee recalled later: "It had become a case of who went first, me or Ruud. He didn't speak to me at all in the summer. The next thing I knew a message was passed to me that I should train with the reserves." However, Gullit's resignation just five games into the season ensured Lee outlasted the Dutchman - and he was quickly recalled and given the No 37 shirt by incoming boss Bobby Robson.

2. Sir Bobby Robson And Kieron Dyer/Craig Bellamy (2004)

In an interview just a few months after the passing of Sir Bobby Robson, Kieron Dyer and Craig Bellamy - both then at West Ham United - would shuffle awkwardly and look at one another when asked about the former England manager's final days at St James' Park. Both admitted they regretted their falling-out with the Newcastle United legend - and that Robson had almost immediately forgiven them, and continued to provide them with nigh-on daily advice until the day he died. Robson loved Dyer and Bellamy like they were his own sons, as he did the majority of the Magpies squad, yet the pair played a huge role in the eventual dismissal of Sir Bobby. Both players refused to play in positions Robson had asked them to at the beginning of the 2004-05 season, with Dyer in particular placing a death-knell in Robson's Newcastle coffin by reluctantly appearing off the bench on the right wing against Middlesbrough. Boro twice came from behind to draw against Newcastle, and Robson lost his job just a few weeks later - with many sources claiming Dyer and Bellamy's actions have proven he had "lost the dressing room". Few managers have been stabbed in the back so mercilessly by two players they defended so vehemently - and few have ever shown so much compassion to forgive. That says everything about Sir Bobby Robson.

1. Ruud Gullit And Alan Shearer (1999)

No list of Newcastle's managerial fallings-out would be complete with the addition of Ruud Gullit and Alan Shearer - a duel in which the 206-goal Magpies striker inevitably came out on top of. As has already been discussed, Gullit wanted to remove the experienced "old guard" at St James' Park and replace them with alternatives - but picking a fight with Shearer proved to be his undoing. Gullit originally rated Shearer but came to believe he had become "too comfortable" at St James' Park - and that the England captain was not pulling his weight for the side. Shearer had a large presence in the dressing room, though, and Gullit did not calculate how difficult a fight this one would be to win. Having dropped Shearer to the bench for the 2-1 home derby loss to Sunderland after weeks of goading his top striker, Gullit resigned the following day once the fans turned their back on him - with many afterwards referring to the team sheet the manager picked that day as his "own suicide note". Amusingly, Shearer and Gullit now appear regularly on BBC's Match of the Day - with the former goading the latter in recent weeks about his treatment at the club.