10 MMA Fighters Who Never Reached Their Full Potential

Not every fighter lives up to their potential.

By Charles Morrison /

One impressive performance and you can become an overnight star. Everyone knows your name and believes you could potentially go down as one of the greatest of all time.

What happens when a fighter does not achieve the level of success they are capable of? For some it can be due to a lack of motivation and training, injuries, others it can be due to addictions, some even due to their inability to stay on the right side of the law.

Advertisement

Combat sports are dangerous, not just for the obvious violence factor but due to the immense pressure and stress put on each fighter. To be hyped up so much by the fans and media sounds like a dream, but it also makes every fight like walking a tight rope whilst someone is throwing knives at you. One slip up can cost you your career. Not tapping to a heel hook, there you go, a shattered knee and the potential of never fighting again. Getting caught with a punch out of nowhere and getting knocked out, the hype fades and you no longer have the sponsors and following you had before. 

There is such an incredible pressure on fighters to succeed that many fighters have taken to drugs, anti-depressants and pain killers. For others the story is more a self tragedy of not training as much as they should have, mostly due to having natural talent.

10. BJ Penn

"The Prodigy", perhaps comes as a surprise to some to see on this list, due to the fact he is arguably the greatest lightweight to have ever graced the Octagon. He achieved a lot more than most fighters did, but did he "reach his full potential", no.

Advertisement

People started calling him “The Prodigy” because of his fast rise to BJJ Stardom, winning the World BJJ Championships with 3 years and a few months of training. He really is one of the greatest fighters of all time, world class Jiu Jitsu, fantastic boxing - Freddie Roach once claimed Penn was the best striker in MMA. 

Penn held both the Lightweight and Welterweight titles in his UFC career, beating the UFC Hall of Famer Matt Hughes to take the Weltweight belt. Penn is fearless when it comes to fighting, even fighting former UFC Light Heavyweight champion Lyoto Machida at 205 pounds (50 pounds heavier than normal), losing a decision. However his disregard for fighting at his natural weight class is arguably the downfall on his career. 

Often barely training for fights, ballooning up in weight between fights, leading to him taking fights at Welterweight against opponents lesser in skill but far superior in size. This ended in some one sided beatdowns.

It leaves the question, just how great could Penn have been with the right dedication and training?

9. Paulo Filho

Where to start with Paulo Filho? A domanitive force in PRIDE and the WEC, racking up an impressive 16-0 records before defending his WEC Middleweight belt in a rematch against Chael Sonnen. He failed to make weight, making the fight a non title fight. So when Sonnen dominated and won the rematch he still didn't capture the belt. Filho was one of the most dangerous Jiu Jitsu artists in MMA and also carried great power in his striking.

Filho suffered from horrific substance abuse, being hospitalised numerous times. He also suffered bouts with depression too. The Brazilian even appeared to be talking to himself at one point in his rematch with Chael Sonnen. After failing to engage and putting on an incredibly poor performance against Sonnen, Filho was was given another chance when he came from behind to beat explosive strike Melvin Manhoef at Dream 10. Filho racked up a few wins after that against mid level opponets before entering his biggest slump yet around 2011, only managing 1 win in 7 fights. Filho was scheduled to face Mamed Khalidov at KSW 17 but withdrew from the fight.

All in all, drug addiction, depression and mixing with the wrong people lead to the eventual downwards spiral of Filho's career. But MMA fans can only dream of what the ultra talented Brazilian may have achieved if these vices had not taken control.

Advertisement

8. David Terrell

"The Soul Assassin" David Terrell was one of the most promising prospects in MMA. A black belt under the great Ceasar Gracie, with a solid wrestling background. Terrell lost his MMA debut but then progressed to go on to a 5 fight win streak, including wins over the tough Joey Villasenor and an fantastic 24 second knockout victory over Olympic wrestling powerhouse Matt Lindland. This immediately propelled Terrell into the spotlight, where he was matched up with the late Evan Tanner for the vacant Middleweight title. Terrell caught Tanner in a tight guillotine, Tanner then went on to TKO Terrell late in the first round. In an interview with Sherdog, he stated the loss affected him a lot and he felt suicidal after the defeat.

Advertisement

Terrell was plagued by recurring injuries, his next fight did not come until over a year later. When the fight came he submitted Scott Smith via Rear Naked Choke. Terrell was then scheduled to face Yushin Okami at UFC 62 but withdrew due to a sinus infection. The fight was then re-scheduled for UFC 66, Terrell also withdrew from this fight due to an elbow injury. Finally he was scheduled to face Ed Herman at UFC 78 but you guessed it, withdrew due to injury. The UFC released The Soul Assassin in 2008.

Terrell trained with a great team who produced the Diaz brothers, Jake Shields and Gilbert Melendez so the sky really was the limit for him. Unfortunately injuries ruined the chances of seeing just far he could go.

7. Lee Murray

"Lightning" Lee Murray, infamous for his actions, surprisingly more so due to his antics outside the cage. A big British Middleweight, Murray stood at 6ft 3" and has some fantastic power in his punches, he was no slouch on the ground either. Murray amassed a 8-1-1 record on his way to a title shot for the Cage Rage Middleweight belt. This included victories over tough brawler Jorge Rivera and one of the legends from the NHB MMA days, Jose Landi-Jons. Murray would face Anderson Silva for the belt, however the fight nearly broke out at the weigh ins as Silva and Murray went head to head and shoved each other, nearly starting a mass brawl. Murray went on to lose the fight via decision.

There is also the infamous story that Murray knocked out UFC legend Tito Ortiz outside a club in London is 2002 with a 5 punch combination. Ortiz denies this story but MMA trainer Pat Miletich and UFC legend Matt Hughes have said they witnessed it and it really happened.

On 28 September 2005, Murray was hospitalized after being stabbed in a brawl during the birthday party of British glamour model Lauren Pope. Just when you thought it was crazy enough, Murray was arrested for his involvement in the biggest cash robbery in British history (Securitas depot robbery). After fleeing to Morocco, Moroccan police arrested Murray in 2006. His initial sentence was 10 years, it was extended to 25 years in 2010.

Murray was a fantastic fighter with the potential to be up there with the elite, unfortunately he couldn't keep on the right side of the law to find out.

Advertisement

6. Kevin Randleman

It's sad looking back on Kevin Randleman's career and seeing the talent that has gone to waste. When he broke onto the scene in 1999 to fight Maurice Smith, it was no comparison to the classic Standup Vs. Ground matchups we were used to seeing. Randleman showed he was light on his feet and incredibly powerful on the ground as he dominated Pat Smith. After beating Smith, Randleman was in a war with MMA legend Bas Rutten, losing a controversial decision. The fight did showcase the potential of Randleman though.

Randleman's bottom game was exposed by Couture as he was taken down, mounted and finished, looking like he had never trained to fight off of his back. He was then knocked out by the legendary Chuck Liddell. Randleman racked up some impressive wins in his career, against the likes of Renato Sobral, Pedro Rizzo and Mirko Cro Cop but also lost to a lot of fighters he should have beat. Randleman's problem was staying at the Hammer House training camp during his career and not moving on. He ended being a one dimensional wrestler with a big left hook but never fixed the huge holes in his Jiu Jitsu and never tightened up his stand up. This lead to losses against the likes of the smaller Sakuraba, the great Fedor Emelianenko and fantastic striker Cro Cop all by submission.

With improved stand up and an evolved Jiu Jitsu game, Randleman could and should have gone down as one of the best of all time.

Advertisement

5. Jason Miller

Jason "Mayhem" Miller, one of the most colourful personalities to ever grace MMA, which turned out to be a bad thing as the years went on.

Known as the host of "Bully Beatdown" Jason Miller was a tough Middleweight with a terrific grappling game, brilliant chokes and crafty positioning. Holding notable wins over Denis Kang, Robbie Lawler and Tim Kennedy alone shows Millers skill and potential. Famously involved in the 'Strikeforce Brawl' involving the Ceasar Gracie team when after his win at Strikeforce: Nashville when he called out for a rematch with Jake Shields. It all ended in a big scuffle and ultimately Miller being 1 or 5 suspended for the incident. Miller eventually left Strikeforce and took on the legendary Kazushi Sakuraba at DREAM 16, submitting the already over-the-hill fighter in the first round. The UFC see a chance to capitalise on Miller's entertaining characteristics booking him opposite Michael Bisping to coach TUF 14. They 2 were involved in numerous arguments during the season but Bisping dominated Miller during their fight where Miller's cardio looked very poor. Then followed a decision loss to C.B. Dolloway.

Miler was involved in numerous incidents after this, a strange appearance on the Ariel Helwani show and numerous run ins with the police. Including his arrest this year after a stand off with the police.

If Mayhem had commited more time to training and less time to breaking the law we could have seen a very dangerous grappler and a solid top 10 fighter, no doubt.

Advertisement

4. Cole Konrad

A name a lot of casual fans will be familiar with is Heavyweight wrestler Cole Konrad. A winner of a gold medal at the 2005 Pan-American Championships, he also won the NCAA wrestling championships in 2006 and 2007 at 285 pounds and finished third at the 2006 World University Championships at 120 kilograms.

Konrad make is professional debut in 2010, winning his first 2 fights on the regional scene before being signed by Bellator MMA. Training with Brock Lesnar, a lot of hype surrounded Konrad and many expected great things. After 2 wins in Bellator, Konrad entered the Season 3 Heavyweight tournament, beating Rogent Lloret and powerful Polish grappler Damian Grabowski to earn his place in the final for the Bellator Heavyweight Title. Konrad dominated the fight with Neil Grove, winning via keylock in the first round to become the first ever Bellator MMA Heavyweight Champion. Konrad's first fight after winning the belt would be a 'non title fight' against MMA veteran and poweful puncher Paul Buentello at Bellator 48, a fight in which Konrad took a clear unanimous decision. Konrad would then dominate heavy hitter Eric Prindle to make the first defence of his Heavyweight title. According to his coach Greg Nelson, Konrad only trained for 1 day for the fight.

Konrad retired from MMA competition on September 12, 2012 to become a full-time commodities broker. Leaving many people questioning how well he could have done if he hadn.t Dominating opponents with such little training, Konrad could have become UFC Heavyweight Champion if he had continued.

Advertisement

3. Brock Lesnar

A true freak athlete.  An NCAA Division I Champion at 285lbs, Lesnar was destined for greatness. Lesnar found fame when we was signed to the WWE in 2002. He became the youngest ever WWE Heavyweight Champion. After his departure from the WWE, a brief stint with NJPW and a MMA debut win over Min-soo Kim, it was announced that at UFC 77 that Lesnar was signed to fight Frank Mir at UFC 81.

There was a huge buzz around the MMA community, could a WWE superstar make an inpact in the UFC? Usually the answer to that would be no, but with such a strong wrestling background and due to his freakish size and strength, some believed he could make it to the top. Lesnar formed his own gym (DeathClutch) in which catch wrestling legend Erik Paulson was his main MMA coach. Lesnar lost his debut to Frank Mir via submission but went on to dominate PRIDE veteran Heath Herring, UFC legend Randy Couture (for the UFC Heavyweight title) and demolish Frank Mir in a rematch. He then suffered a brutal beating at the hands of Shane Carwin but came from behind to submit Carwin in round 2.

Following that he lost his title to current champion Cain Velasquez in a one sided affair. Lesnar was out for a year due to diverticulitis, a stomach disease. Upon his return he faced K-1 Champion Alistair Overeem, getting hit with a huge body kick and getting finished with punches. Lesnar started MMA late in his life, never fully developed his striking and it showed when he curled up an backed away whenever he was tagged. But if Lesnar had started MMA in 2002 and trained with a diverse camp he could have still been ruling the Heavyweight division to this day.

Advertisement

2. Adlan Amagov

Another fighters on the list that most casuals may not have heard of, but Adlan Amagov was a straight up beast. One of many incredibly talented fighters to come out of Chechnya (Russian Rebublic), Amagov has a background in Combat Sambo, training with the famous Emelianenko brothers. Amagov made his MMA debut in 2007 to the now UFC Heavyweight contender Oleksiy Oliynyk but then went on to build an 8-1-1 record before making his US debut in 2011 with Strikeforce. Amagov tore through Anthony Smith in his debut, setting him up against current UFC Welterweight champion Robbie Lawler for his next fight.

Despite getting hit with a flying knee from Lawler and subsequently losing that fight, Amagov showed some great promise. "Borz" demolished Keith Berry in his next fight before the UFC bought out Strikeforce and therefore Amagov's contract. After an impressive victory against Chris Spang his next challenge in the UFC was slick submission specialist T.J Waldburger. Amagov showed incredibly balance to stop Waldburger's takedowns and progressed to finsh him in such brutal fashion it left you fearing for Waldburger's health.

The hype was in full swing and rightly so. Amagov was expected to face Jason High at UFC Fight Night 35 but withdrew due to injury. After more than a year of absence from the sport, BloodyElbow editor Karim Zidan stated that Amagov had "no interest" in returning to MMA, and that he wants to "watch his kids grow up and is tired of cutting weight".

Sadly, we'll never get to see just how well Amagov could have done, but in many people's opinions he looked like an eventual title contender.

Advertisement

1. Dominick Cruz

https://cdn2.vox-cdn.com/fan_shot_images/218546/11.gif

There may be none more tragic than Dominick Cruz, and it's through no wrongdoing of this own. A simply incredible athlete, Cruz has a great wrestling background, was tactical whenever the fight hit the floor and had some of the best boxing paired with footwork in MMA. Cruz ripped his way through the regional scene, compiling an impressive 9-0 victory before facing WEC and UFC mainstay Urijah Faber in the WEC, who held a brilliant 17-1 record at the time. 

Advertisement
Faber won that fight via guillotine choke in the first round, however it was a lesson for Cruz who then went on an 11 fight win streak. 7 of those in the WEC, winning the Bantamweight title from Brian Bowles who defeated Urijah Faber, defending it against Joseph Benavidez and again againt Scott Jorgensen. Due to the UFC absorbing the WEC divisions and fighters, the title defence against Jorgensen also won him the very first UFC Bantamweight title. Cruz would go on to dominate Urijah Faber in a rematch for the UFC Bantamweight title and then current UFC Flyweight Champion and top 5 P4P fighter Demetrious Johnson. In December 2011, Cruz was selected to coach the The Ultimate Fighter: Live against opposing coach Urijah Faber. The rubber match between Cruz and Faber was expected to take place on July 7, 2012 at UFC 148. However, Cruz was forced to pull out of the bout citing a torn ACL. On December 3, 2012 it was revealed that Cruz underwent another ACL surgery after complication from the inital surgery, he was expected to be around for around another 9 months. Finally Cruz was scheduled to make a return in February 2014 in a title unification bout with the interim champion, Renan Barao. However in January bad luck struck again and it was announced Cruz had torn his groin and was out of the fight. At long last Cruz finally made it back to the cage, beating Takeya Mizugaki easily and impressively in the first round at the end of 2014.
The nightmare had ended, so it seemed. Cruz was to face current Champion T.J Dillashaw for the title. You couldn't write it, Cruz tore his ACL in his other knee this time as was sidelined until 2015. Cruz' career may not yet be over, everyone hopes for a return, but there is no doubting all these injuries have plauged his career and he will not reach the levels he would have before. Which is sad, considering we may have been looking at the best fighter of all time.
Advertisement