10 Players Who Didn't Fulfil Their Potential At Liverpool

Talented unquestionably, but not exactly successful.

By Henry Jackson /

Liverpool have a long and illustrious history, and inevitably have produced some wonderful players over the years both in terms of homegrown talents - like Steven Gerrard, Robbie Fowler, Michael Owen and Jamie Carragher - and marquee signings - Kenny Dalglish, John Barnes, Sami Hyypia and Luis Suarez. The successes of that illustrious lot were unrivalled in the red of Liverpool, but they were not the only players to sign or come through the ranks on the crest of a wave of optimism and expectations. And sometimes, sadly, some of those players will fail. Anfield is a wonderful place to ply your trade, but the pressure that comes with it is enormous. The fans are among the most passionate, and the most loyal around, but they also demand a certain standard. If a player is bought for big-money then they inevitably expect to see them justify their price tag on the pitch. And if they fail to deliver then they are sure to know about it. Down the years there have been many players to don the famous Red shirt who have simply never lived up to their vast potential, or replicated the form they showed at their previous club. Whether it be a step up in quality, niggling injuries or a failure to cope with the aforementioned pressure, there have been many who have walked away from Merseyside with their reputation in tatters. Take a look at our ten Liverpool players who never fulfilled their potential.

10. Bruno Cheyrou

When Cheyou joined Liverpool from Lille for £3.7m in the summer 2002 he was famously dubbed the 'new Zidane' by then Reds boss Gerard Houllier. It's fair to say that this added pressure did the Frenchman no good, and he would go on to produce very little in his two seasons in a Liverpool shirt. The 2002/03 campaign saw the midfielder make a total of 29 appearances in all competitions, and he scored just one goal, against Spartak Moscow in the Champions League group stages. His game was simply not catered towards English football, with a lack of pace, power and work-rate seriously working against him. In that respect, he couldn't have been any different from Zidane. Cheyrou's final season at Anfield- 2003/04- at least provided Liverpool fans with a couple of glimpses of what he was capable of. A winning goal at Stamford Bridge against Chelsea and an FA Cup double against Newcastle at Anfield won him a couple of weeks worth of praise, but that was all. He was shipped out on loan to Marseille and Bordeaux by new Liverpool boss Rafa Benitez, in 2004/05 and 2005/06 respectively, before departing on a permanent basis to Rennes in the summer of 2006. There haven't been too many Liverpool midfielders who have arrived with a bigger reputation than Cheyrou in recent times, but barely any have been as ineffective as him.

9. Anthony Le Tallec

Le Tallec arrived at Anfield in the summer of 2003 - though the club actually signed him in 2001 but loaned him back to Le Havre for two seasons - as a hugely exciting 18-year-old. The Frenchman had been voted the second best player at the Under-17 World Cup and had also impressed at the Under-16 European Championship prior to that, and it was fair to say that much was expected of the attacking midfielder. Sadly though, he found it very tough to break into Houllier's first-team in his first season at the club, with the likes of Steven Gerrard, Danny Murphy and Vladimir Smicer, among others, ahead of him in the pecking order. He scored what would prove to be his only ever goal for Liverpool in a UEFA Cup clash against the mighty Olimpija Ljubljana of Slovenia in late 2003, and other than as a poor footnote in Liverpool's last most successful period, that's about all he's memorable for. Le Tallec's only other real moment of note in a Reds shirt came during their unforgettable march to Champions League glory in 2004/05, when he played a part in Luis Garcia's unforgettable strike against Juventus in the quarter-finals. That was as good as it got though, and having been deemed surplus to requirements by Benitez he was shipped out on loan to Saint-Etienne, Sunderland, Sochaux and Le Mans, before joining the latter on a permanent basis in 2008. He made a total of just 32 appearances for Liverpool.

8. Fernando Morientes

When Morientes arrived on Merseyside in January 2005 much was expected of him: he had been a top-class striker for Real Madrid throughout their 'Galactico' era, scoring 96 times in 226 appearances, and at 28 he should have been in his prime. He was seen as the man to come in and guarantee quality up front, with the likes of Milan Baros and Djibril Cisse failing to deliver goals on a consistent basis, but that proved somewhat over-optimistic. Perhaps it didn't help matters that the Spaniard was cup-tied for Liverpool's incredible Champions League triumph - he had already represented Madrid earlier that season - but he simply never hit the heights expected of him at Anfield. A terrific goal against Charlton Athletic in his fourth game for the club suggested he was starting to find some form, but he ended up registering just three strikes in 15 appearances that season. In 2005/06 Morientes was given plenty of first-team opportunities, appearing 45 times in all competitions, but again he was extremely disappointing, finding the net just 9 times and barely affecting one big game during his time at Anfield. Ultimately, he was solid to Valencia in the summer of 2006, having made no impact on the Premier League at all, and the fact that Peter Crouch became a more important player than him sums it up really, with no disrespect to the former England striker.

7. Stewart Downing

Kenny Dalglish bought Downing to Liverpool for £18.5m in July 2011, with many feeling it was a golden opportunity for the then 26-year-old to finally fulfil his potential. As it turned out, his two years at the club were utterly forgettable, and the vast fee the club paid for him looked overblown to say the least. If ever there was a player who looked daunted by playing for a club of Liverpool's stature it was the former Middlesborough man. He looked scared to try anything out of the ordinary on the ball, and his wing play became about as one-dimensional as it gets. 36 appearances in the Premier League in 2011/12 saw Downing fail to register a single goal or assist, despite playing in an attacking side, and along with Charlie Adam and Andy Carroll- more on him later- he was deemed a complete waste of money. Under Brendan Rodgers in 2012/13 the former England winger didn't fare much better, scoring just five times in 45 games. He perfectly epitomised the chasm between the Reds and those at the top of the Premier League table at that time, and finally joined West Ham in the summer of 2013 for a fee of around £5m, ending two of the most insipid seasons in a Liverpool shirt in the process.

6. Ryan Babel

Babel arrived at Liverpool from Ajax in 2007 at the age of 19, with some comparing him to Arsenal legend Thierry Henry in terms of style. Fast, skilful and with an eye for the spectacular, he was seen as the man to finally bring some flair in wide areas to the Reds' side under Benitez. Instead, despite occasional flashes of brilliance, Babel proved to be a hugely frustrating player with an inconsistent final ball and a poor work ethic, and simply never justified his £11.5m price tag. The Dutchman's unpredictable performances saw him consistently fail to land a regular starting berth, with less talented wide players like Dirk Kuyt and Yossi Benayoun often preferred. His winning of a crucial penalty against Arsenal in the 2008 Champions League quarter-finals, and goal a few minutes later, were the high point in a disappointing first season at the club. He continued to flatter to deceive over the next few years, thumping home the odd screamer but hitting 10 times more into the Kop End at the same time, and he started to become more and more of a squad player as time progressed, making just nine Premier League appearances in 2010/11. He left for Hoffenheim in 2011, having never got close to reaching his potential at Liverpool, and though by lesser players' standards his Reds career was far from a disaster, the amount of natural talent at his disposal made his time on Merseyside incredibly disappointing.

5. El Hadji Diouf

Houllier's decision to sign Diouf instead of Nicolas Anelka in the summer of 2002 still rankles many Liverpool fans, with the former Senegal international not only a huge letdown on the pitch, but also one of the most dislikable players to ever wear the famous shirt. His performances at the 2002 World Cup were, in fairness, very impressive - contrary to popular belief he had already signed for Liverpool before the tournament - but when he arrived in England he looked a shadow of the player that tore France to shreds in South Korea a month or two earlier. The then 21-year-old actually scored twice on his Anfield debut against Southampton, and everything looked rosy. Unfortunately he only scored one more league goal throughout the entire 2002/03 campaign. This led to Houllier using him as a right-winger, such was his ineffectiveness as a striker. His first season was otherwise remembered for a disgraceful moment against Celtic in the UEFA Cup, in which he spat at an opposing fan. The 2003/04 season - his last for the club - was even worse, as he failed to find the net in any of his 33 appearances in all competitions. Having been sent on loan to Bolton Wanderers the following season, he joined them permanently a year later, bringing an end to a terrible two years at Liverpool.

4. Andy Carroll

In fairness to Carroll, as soon as Kenny Dalglish smashed Liverpool's transfer record by bringing him to Anfield in January 2011, he was on a hiding to nothing. The big striker was not worth close to the £35m that the club paid for him, and unsurprisingly he failed to deliver. It's incredible to think that Luis Suarez was over £10m cheaper. Carroll cannot be devoid of criticism, however, and his performance simply weren't good enough for a player more talented than some give him credit for. He didn't make his debut until nearly two months after signing, with injuries curtailing his progress. It was to become a far too regular occurrence. A match-winning performance against Manchester City a month later, in which he scored two fine efforts, ought to have been the catalyst in getting his Liverpool career off the ground, but he never kicked on. He scored just four times in 35 Premier League appearances in 2011/12, with his lack of movement, heavy touch and injury problems making him more of a hindrance than anything. His FA Cup semi-final winning goal against Everton at Wembley did at least endear himself to Reds fans everywhere, but although he was always a fairly popular player, it was impossible to ignore just how ineffective he was. When Rodgers arrived in 2012 it was clear Carroll had no future at Anfield. His robust style was completely against the Northern Irishman's footballing philosophy, and having spent a year on loan at West Ham in 2012/3, he joined them for £15m last summer.

3. Robbie Keane

Keane's £19m arrival at Liverpool prior to the 2008/09 season was met with joy by many supporters. The Republic of Ireland legend had been a superb servant to Tottenham, and he was seen as the perfect man to partner Fernando Torres in attack as Benitez's men looked to win their first Premier League title. At 28 he was in his prime, and the fact he was a boyhood Red made it look like a match made in heaven. Incredibly, Keane spent just over six months at Anfield, in what has to go down as one of the most failed transfers in Liverpool's history. It took until his eleventh appearance in a Reds shirt to finally open his account, with the striker converting against PSV Eindhoven in the Champions League. He lacked a spark though, and the clever flicks and memorable strikes that he produced in abundance at White Hart Lane were nowhere to be seen. He eventually lost his place in the side, and with Steven Gerrard in sensational form behind Torres in a 4-2-3-1 formation there was simply no way back for him. His best moment during his short time at Liverpool was a thunderous effort against Arsenal at the Emirates, but it really was pretty much all the former Wolves and Coventry star had to shout about during a wretched period in his career. He moved back to Spurs in February 2009, but has never really looked the same player since his Anfield nightmare.

2. Alberto Aquilani

When Xabi Alonso left Liverpool in 2009, a gaping hole was left in their midfield. Benitez had to spend wisely and replace the brilliant Spaniard with a player of similar ability, but instead he signed Aquilani. The then 25-year-old arrived for £17.1m from Roma, but the fact he was carrying an ankle injury on arrival did not bode well. He didn't make his Reds bow until the end of the October, in a League Cup clash with Arsenal, as Liverpool's hard work from the season before was unravelling without a top class playmaker in the side. His first start for the club came in a critical defeat against Fiorentina in the Champions League, which saw them eliminated, and Aquilani did not impose himself on the game whatsoever. In total he made 26 appearance during the 2009/10 campaign, and you'd be hard pushed to remember one moment of significance he produced in that time. The physical and mental side of his game were a real weakness, and he looked incapable of bossing a midfield battle like Alonso did week in, week out. Upon Roy Hodgson's arrival in 2010 he was loaned out to Juventus for a year, then AC Milan for another 12 months. He returned to pre-season training under Rodgers in 2012, but he had played his last game for Liverpool. He joined Fiorentina for a fraction of what he had joined Liverpool for originally, perfectly highlighting just what a huge failure he had been.

1. Harry Kewell

During the 1990s and early 2000s, the Reds' achilles heel had always been the lack of a top class left winger. Since age had caught up with John Barnes and he'd moved more central there had been nobody of note out there. Cue the arrival of Kewell, who many felt was going to be sensational, and the final piece in Houllier's potential title-winning jigsaw. He had been the star man in a young, exciting Leeds United side, and his move was met with elation by almost everyone associated with Liverpool. What followed, however, was the best example of a player failing to fulfil their vast potential as you can find. He looked a shadow of his former self almost from day one, and having been given the highly regarded number seven shirt at Anfield he just didn't do it justice. His first season was far far disastrous, in fairness, with the winger scoring 11 goals in 49 games- a respectable return- but he was not impressive. The 2004/05 campaign was awful, however. He found the net just once all season, and he limped out of the Champions League final early on having done nothing to affect the game. Liverpool's unrivalled comeback against Milan in Istanbul will forever go down in history, but Kewell's ineffective evening rather summed up his whole Reds career. Despite the odd good goal and promising display in 2005/06, Kewell still had nowhere near the pace, confidence and influence he had in his Leeds days, and the fact he was still just in his mid to late 20s showed that age had nothing to do with it. Injury saw him leave the 2006 FA Cup final prematurely, as he missed out on playing a pivotal role in another huge game. Kewell then missed almost a year of football though injury, returning in April 2007, but he'd lost even more of an edge to his game by this point. He played just 10 league games in 2007/08, before sealing a move to Galatasaray at the end of that season. He had been an unbelievable disappointment on Merseyside, and finished with just 16 goals in 139 appearances. Which Liverpool player do you think most failed to fulfil their potential at the club?