10 Players Sir Alex Ferguson Was Completely Wrong About

The venerable Scot isn't right ALL the time...

By Joseph Dempsey /

As Louis van Gaal prepares to take charge of his first Premier League game as manager of Manchester United next Sunday, one of Sir Alex Ferguson's biggest mistakes will be staring him right in the face. Last summer, after announcing his retirement following a glittering 26 years in charge of the club, Ferguson was allowed to hand-pick his successor in David Moyes and it didn't work out. Moyes was sacked after just 10 months and many football experts questioned the wisdom of the decision thereafter. The venerable Scot should not have been given so much influence in selecting his replacement and no other business in the world would afford such a luxury to a former employee. It may well have been a rare instance of Ferguson being wrong about something, but there have been others - particularly when it comes to former players. Down the years, the Scotsman has made a number of dubious decisions, be it signing a player and later regretting it or missing out on the opportunity of landing a future star of the game. There wasn't much Ferguson was wrong about during a near-three-decade career that saw him win virtually everything, but we have managed to put together a list of 10 players he was completely wrong about, and here they are. Click 'next' to get started.

10. Mark Bosnich

Following the departure of Peter Schmeichel in 1999, Manchester United spent a well-documented six year spell searching for an adequate replacement for the Great Dane before landing on Edwin van der Saar in 2005. Their search took in a number of flops before then, including Mark Bosnich. Bosnich actually had two stints at United. He graduated from the club's youth academy in 1990, and made three appearances before his registration with the club was cancelled the following year. The Australian shot-stopper spent time at his native Sydney United and Aston Villa over the following years before getting the call to return to Old Trafford in 1999 as Schmeichel's replacement. However, as with the majority of his goalkeeper signings during this period, Sir Alex Ferguson got this one wrong. Bosnich's second spell at the club was a disaster and would last just 12 months before United turned to Fabian Barthez, and he quickly found himself as third choice at the Theatre of Dreams. His performances were called into question, as was his attitude and even his weight. Ferguson said of Bosnich in his explosive 2013 autobiography:
€˜Mark Bosnich was a terrible professional. We played down at Wimbledon and Bosnich was tucking into everything: sandwiches, soups, steaks. He was going through the menu. I told him, €œFor Christ€™s sake, Mark, we€™ve got the weight off you, why are you tucking into all that stuff?€
Bosnich only lasted a season at United after returning to the club and moved to Chelsea in 2001. However, he developed a $5,000-a-week cocaine addiction and became a recluse, going into semi-retirement until re-emerging in 2008 with Australian side Central Coast Mariners.

9. Frank Lampard

Manchester United once had the opportunity to sign a young Frank Lampard, and Sir Alex Ferguson scouted him during his early days playing for West Ham United, but stopped short of sanctioning a move before later going on to say he doesn't consider the Chelsea and England midfielder to be "an elite international footballer". Lampard joined the Blues instead of the Reds after leaving West Ham and became a club legend, making 648 appearances for the Londoners and breaking Bobby Tambling's long-standing all-time goal-scoring record by netting 211 times to become Chelsea's top scorer. And Ferguson said he could have played at Old Trafford instead. He admitted last year:
"Lampard has been unbelievable. I don't think a midfield player will be able to do that figure again. It's quite phenomenal. Like Bryan Robson, he has had a great knack of timing his runs into the box at the right time. John Wark was another one at Ipswich. The other things is I can't remember Lampard ever being injured. When he's not been playing it's because they thought he was past it. The guy has had a great career. I must say we looked at him when he was at West Ham as a young player and I maybe regret not having done it. Where else could I get 200 goals?"
However, in another interview in 2013, Ferguson criticised Lampard and perhaps explained why he didn't bring him to United all those years ago. He added:
"Lampard, for me, was a marvellous servant for Chelsea. But I didn't think of him as an elite international footballer."
This is surely a harsh criticism considering Lampard has played in two Champions League finals - against United in 2008 and Bayern Munich in 2012 - and even won the competition with Chelsea two years ago. The midfielder has also been capped 106 times at international level by England, and is one of only eight players to have earned a centenary of caps for the Three Lions. This one has to go down as another judgment call Ferguson got wrong.

8. Eden Hazard

Another Chelsea player Sir Alex Ferguson was wrong about is Eden Hazard. Manchester United were interested in signing the skilful winger in 2012 during his days playing for Lille but baulked at his valuation, with Ferguson believing he wasn't worth the money. The Blues paid a reported £34 million to beat United to the punch in landing Hazard two years ago, and since then the attacking midfielder has gone on to shine for the Blues, scoring 14 Premier League goals last season and being named as Chelsea Player of the Year for 2013€“14. However, astonishingly, Ferguson didn't think he was worth the money. He said shortly after Chelsea's capture of the Belgian international: "There is a borderline in terms of what you would think is a good signing for United. I see some values on players, like Hazard for instance. To me it was a lot of money. He's a good player, but £34m?

"In the Hazard deal, Chelsea paid the agent £6m. The (Samir) Nasri situation was the same. It's all about what you think is value for a player. I am not envious of those deals at all. We placed a value on Hazard which was well below what they were talking about."

Advertisement

Even more astonishing is the fact that United ended up signing Shinji Kagawa instead, with Ferguson saying at the time that he thought the club were better off signing the Japan international over Hazard. He continued: "So if it doesn't work, well we're not worried about that. We think we've got good value in (Shinji) Kagawa."

Kagawa of course has been something of a flop since moving to Old Trafford and has been used sparingly by both Ferguson and his successor David Moyes, making only 18 Premier League appearances last season. United paid a reported £17 million for Kagawa and in hindsight, surely it would have been worth paying that extra few million to land Hazard instead.

Advertisement

7. Paul Pogba

Paul Pogba started the early stages of his career at Manchester United as a product of the club's youth academy and graduated into the senior set-up in 2011. However, he would only make three appearances for the Red Devils and left to join Juventus, where he has since flourished into one of the world's best young midfielders. Sir Alex Ferguson revealed he let Pogba move to Italy because he felt the player had disrespected the club. The Scot once said: "It is disappointing. I don't think he showed us any respect at all, to be honest. I'm quite happy that if they carry on that way, they're probably better doing it away from us." However, there are two sides to every story and you could make the case for United disrespecting Pogba. In a game against Blackburn Rovers in December 2011, the Reds were hit by an injury crisis and were short on midfield players. Instead of deploying Pogba, Ferguson instead left him out of the side and played Park Ji Sung and right-back Rafael. This, as the story goes, was the final straw for Pogba, who knew then that he had to leave to get more playing time. Ferguson's decision to sell Pogba rather than give him more opportunities than the three he was awarded in the senior side backfired. The midfielder is arguably one of the game's best young players at present after scoring seven Serie A goals last season and has since been tipped with moves to Chelsea and Real Madrid.

6. Gabriel Obertan

Manchester United have made a number of great French signings in the past. Fabian Barthez, Patrice Evra, 'King' Eric Cantona... but one Frenchman who didn't go down quite so well at Old Trafford is Gabriel Obertan. Obertan signed for the club in 2009 from Bordeux with Sir Alex Ferguson heralding his latest recruit after the winger scored in pre-season by saying: 'Goals always help players of course, and when they are forwards in particular. There is a goal in Gabby, there is no question of that.' He was right, there was a goal in Obertan - if he meant it in a literal sense. The midfielder scored only one goal for United during a forgettable two-season spell, and that came in the Champions League against little-heard-of Turkish side Bursaspor. There was 'a goal in him' when he was eventually sold to Newcastle as well, with the player having managed only one in the Premier League since joining the Magpies in 2011. Obertan was one of the worst signings of the Ferguson era and can only be remembered as being a flop. He is still chipping away trying to find a breakthrough in English football with Newcastle but so far he has been as poor at St James' Park as he was at the Theatre of Dreams.

5. David Beckham

Sir Alex Ferguson's relationship with David Beckham is infamous and there are a number of well-worn-out tabloid stories that resulted from Beckham's 11-year stay at Old Trafford. Ferguson now-memorably kicked a boot at the midfielder's head in 2003 that ultimately triggered his departure to Real Madrid and while Sir Alex was clearly wrong to do that, he was also wrong to question his dedication and commitment to the game. In the early 2000s, Ferguson and Beckham's relationship started to show signs of wear and tear, particularly when Beckham began to take an interest to other pursuits outside the world of football. Ferguson reflected in 2009: "He was never a problem until he got married. He used to go into work with the academy coaches at night time, he was a fantastic young lad. Getting married into that entertainment scene was a difficult thing €“ from that moment, his life was never going to be the same. He is such a big celebrity, football is only a small part."' Questioning his dedication to the game was surely a harsh criticism. All you have to do is watch replays of his last ever game as a professional footballer to see how much playing football meant to Beckham. After Paris Saint-Germain's 3-1 win over Brest last May, the midfielder left the pitch in tears knowing his playing career was over, having joined the French club earlier that year. Saying "football is only a small part" of his career did Beckham something of a disservice.

4. Gerard Pique (And Ryan Shawcross)

Gerard Pique is a famous example of players Manchester United should never have sold. But you can also argue United should have sold him sooner. Pique joined the Red Devil's youth academy after moving from Barcelona's La Maisa. He made 12 appearances for United during a four-season spell in the senior set-up before returning to Barca in 2008. There, he has become a global superstar, and one of the best centre-backs in the business. Ferguson was wrong to let him go - as Pique himself is only too keen to remind the Scot whenever he sees him - while Sir Alex also got a few other things wrong during this period. Unbeknownst to Ferguson, Pique was growing homesick in England and longed for a return to his native Catalonia. Not realising this, Sir Alex let young prospect Ryan Shawcross join Stoke City so that Pique could continue his development at Old Trafford. The former United boss explained:
"It always grieves me when I have to release a young player of great potential and Shawcross certainly fell into that category. He had the misfortune - though he perhaps doesn't see it that way considering the success he has had with Stoke - of coming through along with a number of other young defenders. This was the era of Gerard Pique and we kept him at Ryan's expense, only I didn't know that Gerard was growing homesick and, soon after, he was telling us he wanted to go back to Spain."
After sanctioning Shawcross's departure to the Potters, Ferguson then lost Pique to Barcelona. And the Scot admitted had he known Pique was getting itchy feet, he would have kept Shawcross. He continued: "He has prospered with Barcelona, as we know, and, if I had known he wanted away then, we would have kept Ryan Shawcross."

3. Jaap Stam

Manchester United signed Jaap Stam in 1998 and the centre-back went on to become a staple of United's defence, making 80 league appearances for the Red Devils over a three-year period and memorably helping them win the Champions League in 1999. However, his stay at Old Trafford was short-lived following a public falling out with Sir Alex Ferguson. Ferguson was reportedly furious with allegations Stam made in his autobiography 'Head to Head' in which the defender appeared to implicate United in a tapping-up storm by alleging Ferguson's approach to buy him was done without the permission of his former club, PSV. Sir Alex sold the powerful centre-half to Lazio soon after. However, the Scotsman has since admitted this was a mistake. At the time of the sale, Stam was 29 and Ferguson thought he had got his best years out of him. He said: "At the time he had just come back from an achilles injury and we thought he had just lost a little bit. We got the offer from Lazio, £16.5m for a centre-back who was 29. It was an offer I couldn't refuse. But in playing terms it was a mistake. He is still playing for Ajax at a really good level." After moving to Lazio, Stam went on to play for Italian giants AC Milan and Dutch side Ajax, winning a Coppa Italia, Supercoppa Italiana and the KNVB Cup during his three respective spells at either side, proving that he still had plenty of gas left in the tank at the time Ferguson decided to wash his hands of him.

2. Bebe

Bebe's move to Manchester United in 2010 was a strange one. Strange because Sir Alex Ferguson had never seen him play before, and only met him the day before the transfer. Ferguson signed the striker based purely off the advice of then-assistant manager Carlos Queiroz and must have wished he'd made the effort to properly scout the Portuguese forward because he was a flop at Old Trafford. The striker only made two appearances for the Red Devils and spent much of his time flogged out on loan, having stints with Turkish side Besitkas and Portuguse outfits Rio Ave and Paços de Ferreira. He was eventually handed a reprieve from his United hell and sold to Benfica earlier this summer having scored only two goals for the Manchester club. This is proof that it really does pay to scout your players and Bebe himself admits this one never worked out, and even accused Ferguson of wrecking his career at United. He said: "When I arrived I went into the room and saw Ferguson was looking at me. He told me to cut my hair, it will look better. So I cut it the same day. In the next training session he didn't recognise me.
"I went past him many times and he didn€™t know me. He didn€™t speak much but I didn€™t understand much. He has a difficult accent, so I understood nothing. He called me €œBaby€. After I told him it wasn€™t like that."

1. Juan Sebastian Veron

If you're wondering just how poor a judgment it was to sign Juan Sebastian Veron, you need only look at the 50 worst transfers in the history of the Premier League list by The Times. Veron became the most expensive player in British football history when he completed his £28.1 million move from Lazio to Manchester United in 2001 €“ but left the club with his reputation in tatters.

Advertisement

The South American had difficulty adjusting to the fast-paced nature of the English Premier League, where he was not afforded the time on the ball he had been accustomed to in Italy, and scored just seven goals in 51 appearances for the club. United manager Sir Alex Ferguson came to his defence on a number of occasions €“ notoriously with his foul-mouthed tirade against the player€™s critics €“ in which he blasted:

"He is a f***ing great player. And you're all f***ing idiots."

Advertisement

Even by Ferguson's standards this is a remarkable outburst. If Veron was a great player, he certainly didn't show it in England. He was sold to Chelsea after just two seasons and again flattered to deceive at Stamford Bridge, where he fell away with injury problems and made only 15 appearances for the Blues.

What do you think are Sir Alex Ferguson's 10 biggest player mistakes? Let us know in the comments thread, below.

Advertisement