10 Players Who Probably Regret Joining Newcastle

Regrets... They've had a few...

By Jamie Roberts /

Playing in the Premier League in front of 52,000 loyal fans would be a dream come true for most professional footballers. Make the right impression at St James' Park and you'll go down in Geordie folklore - just ask Kevin Keegan's group of Entertainers if you need any proof. However, on occasions, a move to Tyneside has turned into a nightmare and for some their ill-fated spell with the club will be remembered for all the wrong reasons. Whether they were labelled a mercenary, showed a lack of commitment, or just never really clicked with the passionate supporters in the North East, certain players are likely to regret ever stepping foot on the hallowed turf. Over the years there have definitely been quite a few flops turn out in the black and white stripes, but which wish they never signed on the dotted line? Florian Thauvin must surely be regretting his decision to come to the North East last summer. The one-time fans' favourite at Marseille spent little over six months on Tyneside before returning to the South of France with his tail between his legs. However, as he found on occasions at Newcastle, he has been subjected to a torrent of abuse by his own supporters and he must wonder why it's all going so wrong, so quickly. But who else's poor decision making has led to fans loathing them, their names making the fans cringe, or worse yet, ruined their career?

10. Hugo Viana

Advertisement
When Sir Bobby Robson brought the Portuguese midfielder to Tyneside in 2002, big things were expected of the Young European Player of the Year. Viana came with a big price tag and a reputation of being very competent of picking out a long-ball pass - a bit like Jonjo Shelvey whose cross-field diagonal balls are currently winning rave reviews at the start of his Magpies career. However, unlike Shelvey, Viana wasn't used to the fast pace of the Premier League and he was often caught wanting too much time on the ball. It was clear in the early stages that his confidence was rapidly decreasing and Robson decided against awarding him a regular spot in the first team. When the player was selected for a starting berth, he regularly found himself being forced to play out of position, meaning his true qualities never really stood out for the Toon Army supporters. On the odd time Viana did flourish, Newcastle looked a very potent attacking threat - most notably against Feyenoord in the Champions League - but too often he would save his best for the European stage - a fact which would seal the manager's and fans' views that he probably wasn't cut out for England's top tier. His spell on Tyneside threatened to derail his career, but successful stints at Sporting CP and Valencia managed to steady the ship, although who knows just how far he could have gone had he chosen a different route. He just has to look at Cristiano Ronaldo's rise to the top and ask the question 'what if?'.

9. Jon Dahl Tomasson

He was being heralded as Europe's next superstar before his move to Newcastle in 1997 and went on to make 112 appearances for Denmark, netting an impress 52 times. So what went wrong for Tomasson on Tyneside? How come Kenny Dalglish couldn't get the best out of the Danish prospect? The 6ft-tall striker was making waves in his native country, scoring goals for fun at Koge and then Heerenveen, so his signing seemed to be an acute bit of business by the hierarchy on Tyneside. However, following Alan Shearer's injury early in the youngster's maiden - and only - season, the Dane found himself hoist into the position of Newcastle's main man - a role which came far too soon for the up and coming star. Following the excitement of making a real coup in the transfer market, Magpies fans soon became disillusioned with the youngster's presence in the team as well as his goal-to-game ratio and he finished his Newcastle United career with the poor stats of three goals in 23 games. However, Newcastle's loss turned out to be a host of other clubs' gain as Tomasson went on to have successful spells with several top European clubs, including Feyenoord and AC Milan, and become a household name in European football. It must have been a regret of his though that he never got the chance to return to the Premier League to show his true worth.

8. Luuk De Jong/Siem De Jong

The brothers have openly admitted a desire to play in the same team as each other and, had it not been for Luuk's disastrous loan spell at St James' Park, their wish could have came true. Instead, they ended up passing each other in the revolving doors on Tyneside. The first De Jong signing occurred at a time when the Magpies desperately needed some firepower in 2014. Having been keen admirers of the youngest of the siblings during his FC Twente days, Newcastle finally sealed a deal for Luuk after he struggled to impress in Germany with Borussia Monchengladbach. However, a severe lack of match practice and a tendency to play the forward out of position meant that his time with the club can be classed as a huge failure as the Dutchman failed to score a single goal in his 12 appearances for the club. Greater things were expected when Siem - PSV's club captain - joined Alan Pardew's regime. But once again it appears that the De Jong name is destined for failure at St James' Park as the playmaker struggles to break into Steve McClaren's team when he is actually fit. With Luuk shining once again in the Dutch league and European competitions with PSV, Siem continues to be a regular on the treatment table at St James' Park and he may look to follow his brother out of Tyneside in a bid to kickstart his career.

7. Remy Cabella

After seemingly cracking the French market, United's chief scout Graham Carr put Remy Cabella's name forward to the club's money men. A young, tricky winger with a bag full of skills who was knocking on the French national team's door sounded like a great bit of business for the club and Cabella swiftly made the switch to Tyneside. He came with a reputation of being able to light up a game and being a game changer in the mould of David Ginola. However, his lightweight physique made it far too easy for the Premier League's defenders to knock him off the ball without giving away a free kick - something Cabella was used to in Ligue 1. Despite glimpses of trickery - and approximately 300 step overs every match - it was clear that this was not a match made in heaven and after 31 games and a solitary goal - against Steve Bruce's Hull City - to show from his time at the club, Cabella was sent packing back to France. Although officially still on the books at Newcastle, the 25 year old will be hoping to make his move to Marseille permanent as soon as possible as he begins to find the form which earned him his great reputation in the first place. Whether the playmaker once more tries to crack the Premier League in the future remains to be seen, but it will take a lot of improvement on his behalf if he's going to showcase his talents in the 'best' league in the world.

6. Stephane Guivarc'h

After being part of a France squad that won the World Cup on home territory in 1998, striker Stephane Guivarc'h would have had his pick of clubs during that summer and there was delight on Tyneside when it was revealed he would be plying his trade in the black and white stripes of Newcastle United. Being able to say you had signed a World Cup-winning number nine soon created excitement on the city's streets and there was a real buzz among the Toon Army when thinking about his possible partnership with Alan Shearer. However, the hope of sucess never really got a chance to build into a reality and the man who had brought the striker to the club was given his marching orders. Out went Kenny Dalglish and in came Ruud Gullit with the promise of sexy football. From day one it was clear that Guivarc'h wasn't part of the Dutchman's plans and the talented forward was left to twiddle his thumbs on the sidelines. Expecting to be an integral cog in the Newcastle United machine, Guivarc'h was notably unhappy with the amount of playing time he was offered on Tyneside - a meagre four games - and soon jumped ship and headed north of the border in a £3.5 million deal with Rangers. Although he only made a handful of appearances for the Scottish giants before heading back to his homeland, the forward won the treble under Dick Advocaat, scoring the first goal in the League Cup final. Whether the Frenchman would have had a fairer crack of the whip if Kenny Dalglish had remained in charge at Newcastle we will never know, but his short stint in the North East is bound to have left a bitter taste in his mouth.

5. Dan Gosling

The midfielder made his professional debut at the age of 16 when he came on as a first half substitute for Plymouth against Hull City. He was quickly tipped for big things by then manager Ian Holloway and despite having a trial at Chelsea, the youngster secured a move to Everton in 2008 and his performances continued to win rave reviews. Despite claiming he didn't want to play for any other club, an injured Gosling couldn't agree new terms with the Toffees and moved to the Magpies on a Bosman. Injuries continued to plague his Magpies career and the once 'next-best-thing' found himself struggling for form and fitness, much to the frustration of everyone at the club. Finding himself playing second fiddle to the centre-midfield partnership of Tiote and Cabaye seemed to stall any potential progression, but it was after the Frenchman's sale when Gosling started to feel disillusioned on Tyneside. Not feeling he was getting a fair run in the team, Gosling was shipped out on loan to lower-league Blackpool and returned to the club in 2014 to see out the remainder of his contract. Surprisingly, his final few months saw him put together a decent run of games, but he knew deep down that his future lay elsewhere. Currently a regular fixture in Eddie Lowe's Bournemouth side, Gosling may look back at Newcastle as being a mistake, but at least he found love on Tyneside, even if it wasn't on the football pitch.

4. Sylvain Marveaux

The winger was a man in demand when he decided to end his five-year stint with Rennes. Involved in a very public battle for his signature, the Magpies beat Liverpool in the race to sign the left-sided midfielder in the summer of 2011 and Marveaux was expected to slot straight into Newcastle's starting XI to provide an injection of pace that would terrify the Premier League's defences. However, despite rubbishing claims that a move to Kenny Dalglish's men only broke down because of a failed medical, the Frenchman has spent a huge chunk of his five years on Tyneside on the treatment table and looks likely to be released when his contract runs out in the summer. When fit, Marveaux has struggled to make a breakthrough into any of the Magpies' recent managers' starting line-up and his found himself frustratingly plying his trade in the second string. Whether he would have had more success had he chosen to shun the North East club, no-one will ever know, but the 29 year old seems likely to see out the latter stages of his career back in France having been a major disappointment in England.

Advertisement

3. Patrick Kluivert

The former Dutch sensation has gone on record in the past to state his regret at joining the Magpies in 2004. In what can only be described as a move directed by the heart instead of the head, Kluivert admitted that the standing ovation he was awarded at St James' Park during his Barcelona days was the main reason behind his move to the Magpies, although the bumper pay-packet surely helped! A marquee signing under Sir Bobby Robson, the Dutchman's signature provided much excitement and anticipation of great things among the Toon Army faithful, but his best days soon seemed well behind him. Despite having turned the club from being relegation candidates to European contenders in his five years at the club, Robson was given his marching orders within months of Kluivert's arrival and the Dutchman was never able to settle into new manager Graeme Souness' starting XI. On the rare occasion he was given the nod to lead the Newcastle front line, Kluivert looked uninterested and off the pace - a back heel against Crystal Palace proving to be the only real standout moment in his time at the club. However, unprepared to take personal criticism on the chin, the striker blamed the undroppable Alan Shearer for his failings on Tyneside, claiming that Souness wasn't brave enough to go against the Geordie legend.

2. Hatem Ben Arfa

He was - and still is - a fans' favourite at St James' Park, so why would he regret his time at the club? Despite a great start at the Magpies which saw him score several outstanding solo efforts, the French forward's career on Tyneside began to sour as it came to an end under Alan Pardew. The manager obviously thought he was a luxury he could do without, whereas the fans were adamant the he should be the side's main threat. Seen as a bad apple, Pardew decided it was best for Ben Arfa to ply his trade elsewhere, and when nothing came of that, he found himself training with the under 21s - a move which clearly damaged Ben Arfa's own big ego. Believing he should be representing one of the world's top clubs, Ben Arfa's attitude has been his downfall throughout his career, but it's good to see him lighting up the French league once more with current club Nice as it would be a shame if his undeniable talent was hidden from the world.

When you become a club's record signing and are unveiled in front of 20,000 fans screaming your name, it can be forgiven that big things are expected. The pacy forward was a real coup for Freddy Shepherd and Newcastle United and it was seen as a fantastic bit of business for the club to pry the England star away from the bright lights of Madrid to start a new chapter on Tyneside. After an amazing career at Liverpool where he averaged over a goal every other game in his eight years at the club - he scored 14 goals in 11 games against Newcastle - the striker wanted a new challenge and headed to the Spanish giants. Despite never cementing a starting position, the striker still kept up his impressive goal-to-game ratio before deciding to return to England in a bid to keep his place in the national side for the 2006 World Cup. Little did he know that that decision would ruin not only his reputation, but possibly his career. Owen was unfortunate to suffer two serious injuries. However, after breaking his metatarsal and missing a large portion of his first campaign at St James', he recovered just in time for the World Cup finals - where he suffered a serious knee injury which would see him out of action for nearly a year. This caused friction with the Toon Army faithful who felt betrayed that he had put country before club and this caused an irreversible rift. His spell at the club continued to sour and Owen was labelled as a mercenary by fans before he ran down his contract in the relegation season of 2008/09. A match which looked like such a good fit turned out to be a nightmare for both parties and Owen's career never picked back up. Moves to Manchester United and Stoke City followed, but the frontman's playing time was severely limited before his eventual retirement.