10 Rule Changes That Should Be Made In Sport

Sport needs more common sense, not just technology.

By Darren Plant /

At some point during our time watching or playing sport, we have all found ourselves challenging a decision that has been made by officials before an event has taken place or by referees in the midst of a match.

Advertisement

It can be infuriating when there is a considerable sense of injustice surrounding an incident and it probably contributes to why sport is so popular around the world but that has never stopped calls for changes to be made by the rule-makers in each sport.

Over the past decade, goal-line technology has been introduced in football and hawk-eye has been introduced at many of the tennis tournaments being played around the world but we are still some way away from having common sense prevail in all of the leading sports.

Some will argue that sport should remain in its purest form and that too much technology or too many amendments to current regulations are unnecessary but we have reached a point where every decision by a referee or official is being scrutinised.

With that in mind, we have compiled a list of 10 suggestions that would improve and bring more equality to sport should they be introduced in the future.

10. Players Timed Between Points In Tennis

Tennis players are supposed to have 20 seconds between points at Grand Slam tournaments and 25 seconds on their respective tours but we frequently see servers getting away with taking longer as they go through their own personal routine.

Advertisement

That should be deemed acceptable if the two players have just completed an exhausting 20-shot rally but not if either player has dominated the previous point.

Time-violation warnings are sometimes given out by the umpire but depending on the official, they can be enforced after the first warning or the third. There is little consistency and there have been examples in the past where it has generally been accepted that a couple of the biggest names in the sport don't fall foul of this rule as often as they should.

Players can be timed by umpires but the rules for going over the time limit are not strictly enforced. A clock that is visible to supporters would only encourage countdowns when players are close to exceeding the limit but a timing method should be introduced where umpires are made accountable when they give too much leeway to players continually breaking the rules.

9. Random Pairings For First Two Rounds In Golf

During the first two rounds of a golf tournament, you will generally see many of the top golfers in the world paired together in groups of three. This is done for both television purposes and to prevent attendees to the event being restricted when having to choose who to follow around the course.

Advertisement

A direct result of this is the rest of the field playing with fellow PGA or European Tour members that are not household names in front of a dozen spectators. The players in question may benefit from playing their game out of the public eye but that is not going to benefit them if they are at the top of the leaderboard on the Sunday.

Both tours have got it right with the rotation of tee times but changes should be made to how the pairings are formulated in order for every player to compete on a level playing field.

More often than not, a rookie or a relatively unknown player struggles during the latter stages of tournaments. It's unavoidable that pressure could get to them, but the golf authorities can go to lengths to avoid players having to deal with the increased attention in the company of the star names by giving them more opportunities to play alongside them in the early rounds.

This would not please television companies but players would develop at a faster rate and the same names wouldn't always feature at the top of the standings.

8. On-Court Coaching On The ATP And WTA Tour

In 2008, the WTA Tour introduced their on-court coaching rule where players could receive tactical assistance from their trainer during matches but it is a regulation that has not been adopted by the ATP Tour.

Advertisement

The traditionalists will argue that it is a rule that should be scrapped altogether while others will suggest that the ATP Tour should follow suit and allow the men to receive advice at the sit-down should they choose to accept it.

At a time when the argument over equal prize money has never been louder, shouldn't both Tours be going to lengths to make the rule the same for both the men and women?

We are not saying that a coach should be present at the side of a player - like in the Davis Cup and Fed Cup - but if players on the WTA Tour are having the option of advice, so should players on the ATP Tour.

Equality in sport - especially tennis - is a broad topic but it does not sit right if lengths are being taken in some areas and not in others.

7. Same Ring Size For All Boxing Matches

The dimensions of a boxing ring are rarely considered and discussed by the casual viewers of the fight scene but those within the sport will be aware that the size can sometimes be dependent on an agreement made during the negotiation period between the two fighters.

Advertisement

In the majority of cases, the size of the ring will be designed in favour of the 'A' side fighter and they will head into the bout knowing that it is to their advantage but shouldn't the various boxing organisations be pushing for all boxing rings to be of the same size, regardless of the fighters involved?

Bigger or smaller rings have the potential to throw up more entertaining and intriguing fights but it does not provide an even playing field if a fighter has spent his career developing a style that suits a certain size and a challenger potentially has to go into the most significant contest of his career at a disadvantage.

The texture of the ring surface should also be the same too. Would Tyson Fury have dethroned Wladimir Klitschko had he agreed to the spongy canvas that the heavyweight champion preferred? Probably not.

Changes are unlikely to ever be made in this area but boxing would be much fairer if they were.

6. Two Video Challenges Per Manager In Football

The use of video technology has been demanded in football for a number of years but we don't want the game to reach a point where every offside, disallowed goal or penalty appeal is being questioned and reviewed.

Advertisement

It seems inevitable that some kind of playback system will eventually be introduced but its use should be limited to two challenges per manager in each game.

Arguments have been made that the effective use of the hawk-eye system in tennis should mean that football can also make use of technology but the governing bodies must be aware that over-use will result in more problems than solutions.

If managers are only permitted to make two challenges per match, it would ensure that games continue to flow at their natural pace and discourage speculative challenges in order to waste a few seconds towards the end of a game.

If a manager successfully overturns a decision, they retain their number of challenges like players do in both tennis and cricket. Some incidents will be open to interpretation and a panel of three officials may be used to make the call but as long as only two unsuccessful challenges are permitted, there should be little change to the game as we know it.

5. No Catchweights In Boxing Title Fights

Catchweights are nothing new in boxing but they are becoming increasingly common in order for high-profile boxing matches to be made.

Advertisement

Seeing the best fighters in the world compete inside the ring cannot be considered a bad thing but when a bout is being made for a world title and both men have agreed to not meet the designated limit, it leads to the belt being devalued.

Saul Alvarez is the clearest example of a fighter who insists on competing at a catchweight. In 2015, he won the WBC middleweight belt at 155lbs - five pounds below the middleweight limit of 160lbs. The same was agreed for his bout with Amir Khan who agreed to move up from welterweight to take the fight.

In their clash in June 2015, Adrien Broner demanded that Shawn Porter drop several pounds in order for their non-title showdown to be made but it still didn't enable Broner to get the better of his opponent.

With the lucrative sums available to the top fighters, catchweights are likely to become more common at the highest level but rules need to be introduced where deals cannot be made to prevent opponents from weighing in considerably lower than the limit set by the division.

4. Stop Clock For Injuries And Incidents In A Football Match

When has there ever been any controversy in rugby regarding the amount of time that is added on at the end of a match? The reason why is because of the clock being stopped for stoppages in play and it is something that football could learn from going forward.

Advertisement

It's deemed "part of the game" when the ball is taken to the corner or hoofed into the stands so the clock should be allowed to run in these instances but we are talking more specifically when injuries occur and goals are scored.

The rule could be applied for substitutions too. Referees are supposed to add an extra 30 seconds but whether they enforce that ruling as strongly as they should is open to debate.

We are probably only talking an extra few seconds if they don't but those extra few seconds can lead to another passage in play should the ball be in either final third. If the clock automatically stopped for 30 seconds upon each replacement, there would be less controversy regarding how much added-on time should be signalled.

The art of deliberately wasting time can be as comical as it can be frustrating but rather than referees having to dish out yellow cards, let's take it out of the equation and start to stop the clock.

3. False Start Rule In Athletics

Once upon a time, athletes were able to commit a false start and get a second chance but soon after the turn of the Millennium, athletes were disqualified after moving out of their blocks before the gun and their dreams of a medal gone for another year.

Advertisement

Some will argue that it is part and parcel of the sport but after months of training, to be told you cannot compete in your chosen race because you moved a split-second too early out of your blocks is extremely harsh and it's time that the old rule was brought back with an amendment.

It's understandable that the governing bodies wanted to avoid farcical situations that could potentially see seven or eight false starts before the race got underway but bringing back the two-false-start rule with the condition that the whole field will be penalised after three failed attempts would work

It's not ideal and still penalises the athletes who remain in their blocks but a happy medium needs to be found. The harsh rules in place right now can lead to anti-climaxes - such as the one that saw Usain Bolt disqualified in the 100m final in 2011 - so it seems a no-brainer to try to protect each race by changing the current ruling.

2. Slow Play In Golf Penalised By Dropped Shots

One of the hottest topics of conversation in the golf world is the subject of slow play and while attempts are being made to speed up the action, more can still be done.

Advertisement

The European Tour introduced a revised policy at the start of 2016 but the punishment decided upon included fines that will not hit the bank balance of the top players. It effectively gives them leeway to take that extra few seconds to make a shot if they feel that the potential reward is greater than the punishment and that's not how things should go down.

Only the threat of dropped shots is going to speed up play. We've all seen the mind-numbing amount of time that Jordan Spieth has been taking over some of his putts of late and the methodical, twitchy procedure that Keegan Bradley adopts when lining up shots on the fairway but this has got to stop.

More players than Spieth and Bradley are guilty of this and both tours need to take a zero-tolerance approach in order to ensure players spend less time preparing their shots.

The European Tour have spoken about their desire for rounds to be played in 15 minutes less than is the current average but that will never be achieved unless they introduce penalties that every player will want to avoid.

1. Fourth Substitute In Football

Competitive football matches used to be played without the use of substitutions but over time, managers have been permitted to make as many as three changes per game.

Advertisement

That is generally considered to be an acceptable amount but given that the worldwide schedule is only growing more hectic, it is time for FIFA to permit the use of an extra replacement.

The main benefit of this would be to reduce injuries through fatigue. The more minutes a player features on the pitch, the greater chance of serious injury and it would allow managers more flexibility in how they use their substitutes when they are required to alter their tactics during a match.

Extra time could also be played with one less player battling through both the pain barrier and exhaustion in order to complete a game. There have been cases in the past where teams have given everything to deny their opponents over the course of 90 minutes but why should they be punished for their players being unable to last another 30 minutes?

No plans for such a rule have been made public but the topic of an extra substitute surely comes up in annual meetings around the globe. It's time for the trigger to be pulled on the idea.

Advertisement