Alan Pardew is a manager constantly under the microscope. Every decision, every word, every move is majorly dissected and scrutinised, predominantly on social media, by journalists and fans intertwined by their mutual fascination with Newcastle United. The 52-year-old's position as the Club's lone mouthpiece, a reluctant head of state, is an unenviable one and that is a fact we're unable to refute regardless of the disdain we harbour towards him. But on more than one occasion across his three-year tenure at St James' Park we've been left to question the wisdom of his judgement. Pardew's compendium of bad decisions as Magpies boss covers a frighteningly vast array of genres and lends considerable weight to the theory that he's hopelessly out of his depth in the Premier League meaning we've been left to bear the crosses of his many gaffes. Compacting his litany of indiscretions into a single list was a task we laboured over - there is nothing Pardew hasn't done at Newcastle - but we eventually came through to give you the 10 WORST decisions made by Alan Pardew as Newcastle manager.
10. Exchanging Wayne Routledge For Gabriel Obertan
Arguably one of Pardew's biggest oversights and a measure of his slipshod judgement was trading Wayne Routledge for the hapless Gabriel Obertan. Routledge was a mid-season acquisition by Chris Hughton during our brief sojourn in the Championship and turned out to be a shrewd addition to a squad lacking pace and incision from the right-flank; two qualities he brought in abundance to St James' Park. He even began the following campaign in the starting line-up but quickly faded from the first-team picture once Pardew had seized the reins from Hughton with Joey Barton preferred on the wing. Routledge was swiftly shipped off to Swansea for £1.5 million in the summer of 2011 and replaced by Obertan at twice the cost. We suspect Manchester United laughed all the way to the bank. And say Obertan has been an unmitigated failure at Newcastle would be an understatement. In three years on Tyneside he's made just 54 appearances and scored twice in contrast to Routledge who has racked up over a century of games for Swansea, found the net 12 times and assisted 20 goals in the same period. Doesn't take a genius to fathom why Pardew has been stripped of all authority on the recruitment side. The statistics, on this occasion, tell no lies.
9. Flagrantly Alienating Hatem Ben Arfa
Although Pardew stopped short of verbally pinning the blame on Ben Arfa for Newcastles damaging tailspin in 2014, actions will always speak louder than words.
Advertisement
The gifted but ultimately flawed French attacker was an underserving victim of Pardews desperate scrap for dressing rooms allies in the midst of our excruciating run of 14 defeats in 19 Premier League games. It was rumoured some senior players in the Magpies squad were unhappy at Ben Arfas continual selection in the team given his aversion to carrying out his defensive duties a fact the Magpies boss sought to manipulate that to his advantage.
Twice the pair exchanged heated words following the losses against Manchester United at St James Park and then away at Stoke, the scene of what is looking likely to be his final appearance for Newcastle. On both occasions Ben Arfa was limited to small cameos when the game was already gone. Prior to that double reverse he was hauled off at the break against Southampton after a half in which he barely touched the ball.
Advertisement
Pardew might not said it but he made his point loud and abundantly clear, never more so than when selecting Dan Gosling ahead of the 27-year-old. Ben Arfa was his scapegoat without just cause instead of harnessing his mercurial talents when we needed them most and the Toon faifthful werent swallowing it, not one bit.
8. Pardew Excuse Bingo
A tour de force in the field of mealy-mouthed excuses and an expert in spinning flimsy justification. You name it and Pardew has probably had the temerity to use it as a means to a convenient alibi in the final throes of last season.
Advertisement
Injuries, missing key players, the sale of Yohan Cabaye, pressure and fatigue were all favourites of Pardew's while he regularly wheeled out the line "On another day we could have won. I think some of the performances have been very very good, but sometimes the results dont always follow," which became a favourite of his during our post-Christmas meltdown. Perhaps his most risible excuse was pointing the finger at the local media for the 1-0 defeat at Stoke where he cravenly attempted to concoct a story that the North East press were out of control and their coverage was having a damaging impact on the players. It didn't wash with supporters, narked by the repetitive stream of platitudes that continued to frivolously spill from his mouth, who eventually resolved to amuse themselves and ridicule the Magpies boss in one foul swoop by partaking in a game of Pardew excuse bingo. We'll need to call upon that gallows humour again if we're to make it through another season unscathed with Pardew at the helm.
7. Constantly Jamming Square Pegs Into Round Holes
There is one phrase that will come to define Alan Pardew's incumbency at Newcastle when he's finally booted out of St James' Park; jamming square pegs into round holes. Pardew, himself, falls into that bracket as a manager ill-suited to the Magpies. On paper we possess a squad stocked to the gills with talented internationals and players capable of consistently challenging in the upper reaches of the Premier League with the subtle guidance of a tactically astute coach in the dugout. But what we've subjected to every Saturday afternoon for the best part of 18-months is a severely disjointed and imbalanced team of players selected in positions for which they are incompatible. Moussa Sissoko, for example, is the most pertinent example. Despite being a powerful box-to-box midfielder Pardew has attempted to convert him into an attacking no.10, operating just behind the striker, upon his arrival from Toulouse and last season stuck him on the right wing to limited success, subjugating his influence and development as a result. But the most laughable is Pardew's obvious shoehorning of Cisse and Ba into the same team with the former shunted out to the wing in order to accommodate his Senegalese compatriot and suffering terribly as a result in 2012/13. Deploying Davide Santon, a left-back, in central midfield against Chelsea at Stamford Bridge is also up there.
6. Prematurely Declaring Our Safety
Pardew rashly voiced his confidence that Newcastle were safe from relegation following a 2-1 victory over Stoke at St James' Park that took us five places and nine points above the Premier League drop-zone. "I think we're done now. We need seven more points to reach 40 but this team will get them," he declared afterwards with that true to form air of smug self-assurance. The moral of the story for Pardew was to never presume the outcome of an event which is still in progress. Two wins and a pair of draws from our remaining nine games meant we finished 16th in the table and survived by the skin of our teeth with our top-flight position only secured on the penultimate day of the season when we scraped a 2-1 win at already-relegated QPR. As the old expression goes; don't count your chickens before they hatch.
5. Acquiescing To An Ambition-less Philosophy
Any manger worth their salt, irrespective of the level at which they participate on the football pyramid, fosters the ambition of leading their team to a trophy. The primal desire to win and achieve success is in our DNA and the driving force behind our involvement in the game. But for the players and supporters of Newcastle United the prospect of winning a trophy is a distant fantasy so long as we have a manger willing to concur with the philosophy of a tyrannical owner who views cup competitions as nothing more than a nuisance. A fly that needs to be quickly swatted. In this instance we find it difficult to believe Pardew shares Ashley's indifferent attitude towards winning a cup having taken West Ham to within a whisker of winning the FA Cup in 2006. He knows that delivering silverware to St James' Park for the first time since 1969 would elevate him to hero status on Tyneside. He would've commanded more respect from the Toon faithful had he taken a stand against Ashley and made a compelling argument for Newcastle to sink their efforts into winning either FA Cup or the Capital One Cup. Even sending out a full-strength team in a cup tie would transmit the message that he is at least taking the cups seriously.
4. Dedicating A Win To Mike Ashley
"We are together and this win is for Mike Ashley and all Newcastle fans, because believe it or not, he is a fan." Pardew calamitously remarked in the aftermath of a 2-0 victory over Chelsea. If leading his team to a second straight Tyne-Wear derby defeat just a week earlier hadn't put Pardew at odds with disillusioned Newcastle supporters then the daggers were almost certainly drawn when he committed the cardinal sin of dedicating the aforementioned win to Ashley in his post-match press briefing. Not exactly the sagacious approach to repairing the turbulent and continually strained relationship he shares with the Toon faithful win but, then again, it is textbook Pardew to sour a morale-boosting win by making that kind of comment. Out-of-tune and completely oblivious to the current climate on Tyneside. Will there ever be a time where he doesn't put his foot in it?
3. Losing His Head At Hull
This has the potential to be one of the most shameless attempts to administer context to a headbutt in the history of the human race. Let's be honest, only Pardew would have the brass neck to rationalise such wanton behaviour from a Premier League manager even when the irrefutable evidence of his misconduct was beamed out to millions of startled viewers via television and social media.
Advertisement
"I did not mean any damage to the guy but I have moved my head forward. I tried to push him away with my head," he said.
Granted the skirmish was initially provoked by Hull midfielder David Meyler needlessly pushing Pardew as he retrieved the ball from the technical area and the headbutt was bereft of force, there was notable intent. His previous inability to exercise restraint is noted and for a 52-year-old man to acquit himself in that manner on the touchline was particularly nauseating.
Advertisement
Endeavouring to justify the act really took the biscuit and, irrespective of how apologetic Pardew was in the aftermath, it should have resulted in his expulsion to the dole queue instead of a Club enforced fine and a brief stadium ban from the FA's laissez-faire disciplinary committee.
2. Promising That Andy Carroll Wouldn't Be Sold
On his first day in the Newcastle hot seat, back in December 2010, Pardew fatefully proclaimed that Carroll would not be sold in the forthcoming January transfer window. This wasn't just a throwaway remark designed to placate an indignant supporters in the aftermath his contentious appointment as successor to Chris Hughton. It was a promise he committed too and a dangerous one at that. But as we already know, just over a month after making this pledge, Carroll traded his beloved black and white no.9 shirt for the red of Liverpool while Mike Ashley pocketed a mind-blowing £35 million for the Geordie striker and illustrated to us where the lines of authority were drawn at St James' Park. Pardew's reputation took a damaging hit as a result and established his position as a consenting subordinate to Ashley and his regime while the ramifications of his broken promise signalled the first fracture in his relationship with Magpies fans which has since developed into a irreparable chasm. True to type, however, Pardew sought to absolve himself of blame afterwards, saying: What can I say? We didnt force anybody to leave."
1. Accepting The Newcastle Job In The First Place
It speaks volumes that just 1.4% of the 1,000 people canvassed by the Chronicle in a poll asking who they wanted Newcastle to appoint as the successor to Chris Hughton voted in favour of Pardew. Supporters have rarely been so depressed under the tenure of a manager whose reputation has barely improved in the three years since he took charge at St James' Park despite impressively guiding the Magpies to fifth in 2011/12 and picking up the Premier League and LMA Manager of the Year awards. That being said we rode a huge wave of luck that season. But in the two campaigns since his stock has plummeted to an almost irredeemable level and there isn't a Toon supporter who wouldn't remortgage their house to accelerate the process of dislodging Pardew from his Tynesie throne. What exactly has he achieved here apart from turning an entire fan base against him? His lasting legacy at St James' Park will be the unwanted records - being the first Newcastle manager to preside over six-consecutive Premier League defeats - he has broken. And it's not so much hatred that we feel towards him, that is too strong a term, but more a profound sense of contempt for his sycophantic acceptance of the position as a yes-man to Mike Ashley. A frosty rapport, if you will.