10 Worst Footballing Decisions Celtic Ever Made

We name and shame those responsible.

By Mark James Cassidy /

Celtic, just like any other club, has had its good and bad periods within its history. The wonderful 60s and early 70s era brought a European cup and runners-up medal and 9-in-a-row, but then the dark, grim 90s era saw the famous 9-in-a-row matched by those fiercest of rivals in the south of Glasgow. Some of Celtic's bad moments and poor periods are hard to pin down to a single moment, especially when the club is so used to winning throughout its history; happily the good moments definitely outweigh the bad. Nevertheless, there are times - certainly recently - when the club has made a decision that just hasn't worked out for the best. These include managerial problems, player signings, and debacles between the players and the board. Every Celtic fan can think of at least a few moments that if things had happened differently, it could have made the difference between winning the title or a cup, and these moments are usually down to decisions being made by the board and/or the manager. This is the list of the worst footballing decisions made by Celtic, lending to some annoying periods we endured, fallouts, and some missed opportunities.

10. Letting Scott McDonald Go

This was a very confusing decision that was actually shrouded with distraction as Celtic fans saw some of the busiest transfer periods of the clubs history. Tony Mowbray was half way through his stint as Celtic manager, and at 10 points behind leaders Rangers, he had to sign players in the winter transfer window. This was an exciting period for Celtic fans as they saw stars such as Robbie Keane as well as a few other names come in on loan. Of course, to make way for the increased financial pressure put on the club, they also needed to sell. But why McDonald? He had scored a total of 65 goals for Celtic, in 2 and-a-half seasons - an impressive tally. Yes, they had just signed Keane who was more than capable of matching McDonalds striking prowess, but he was only in on loan. McDonald had really established himself at Celtic, scoring some very important goals in Europe and consistently performing in the league, so it surely would have been easier to hold on to him and tell Kamara, who turned out to be a huge flop, not to bother? This was a desperate, short term attempted solution that totally backfired as Celtic were still not able to catch up to Rangers by the end of the season. They brought in a goal machine, yes, but Keane evidently needed time to settle into the team which resulted in his promised goals coming too late. McDonald was already performing consistently, and should have stayed.

9. The Bobo Baldé Debacle

Bobo Baldé was a player that you hated to love. Brought into the team during Martin O'Neill's tenure as manager in 2001, Celtic fans gazed with their jaws hitting the floor as a moving brick wall had basically just came into the Celtic defence ranks. He was a bit of a bomb-scare, creating some nervy moments and unforced errors, but made up for it by being such a huge presence in the 1st team line-up. He was even voted Celtic's player of the year in 2003, a vote in which 40,000 fans took part. Baldé experienced a series of health problems, including being diagnosed with malaria, and also suffered a couple of nasty injuries in a turbulent 2006-07 season. Baldé was a very expensive player to have stuck on the sidelines. When Baldé was close to full recovery in July 2007, everyone expected him to leave when Roy Keane, manager of Sunderland, was reported to have bid £1.5 million for the defender. Surprisingly Baldé exclaimed his wished to stay and see out his contract. It was then very strange to hear Celtic fans saying they'd seen him in the Gallowgate (a street of Celtic pubs and bars near Parkhead) watching the home matches! Baldé told the media that the manager said he was 6th choice centre back, but from an outsider looking in, it seemed to appear that Baldé had managed to engineer a way to get paid £35,000 a week and just sit back and relax until his contract was up. Whether he engineered it or not remains to be seen, but there was definitely something wrong going on. It's not clear what really happened here and who's to blame, but there's a bad decision in there somewhere, and the situation clearly wasn't handled very well by the club. If what Baldé said about being 6th choice defender was true, then I think most Celtic fans would class that as a huge mistake.

8. Playing Evander Sno On A Regular Basis

Remember Evander Sno? No? He was this Dutch guy who played for Celtic under Gordon Strachan, and the reason you don't remember him is because every time he got the ball he sent you to sleep. Evander Sno is known as one of the boring Celtic have ever purchased. Dubbed as a young prodigy, Sno was brought in by Strachan from Feyenoord in 2006, and was slotted straight into the starting line-up. He made a promising debut against St Mirren, but sustained a sincere lack of confidence when on the ball. When at home, Celtic fans regularly felt the need to actually shout instructions to him; he would receive the ball, and need at least 5 or 6 seconds to decide whether to pass or run somewhere with the ball, before being closed down by 3 or 4 players. He was perfect for slowing the game down, but Celtic is a club that is meant to entertain. Despite the clear frustration from the fans regarding Sno, Strachan continued to play him on a regular basis, and is one of the few reasons that the fans never truly warmed to Gordon Strachan despite the fact he was the first Celtic manager to win 3 league titles in a row since Jock Stein. Strachan was very sure of himself, but the fans didn't always see it that way - this being one of those cases.

7. Paying £4,000,000 For Marc-Antoine Fortuné

Back into the Mowbray era and onto a decision that quickly dampened the excitement behind Mowbray's appointment as Celtic manager in the summer of 2009. Fortuné was Mowbray's first signing, and the price of nearly £4 million paid for what seemed an average striker seemed to frighten Celtic fans a little bit. One of the rules when you buy strikers for Celtic - if you're going to spend big money on a striker, he better be at least a 20 goals-a-season man. If not, he's not even worth a penny to us. Henrik Larsson cost Celtic £600,000, and he bagged us over 250 goals in 6 seasons (7 if you include the year he broke his leg), so as a manager you should feel a lot of pressure to pull off the perfect striker signing. Fortuné has never been a striker that can do that, for any team in any league, and he played for a lot of clubs before joining Celtic, including West Brom, Lille, Nancy and Stade Brest. He is what you would probably call a 10 goal-per-season. Not worth £4 million, certainly not to us. The sentiment was then proven as that season, to no surprise, Fortuné only managed 10 goals in 32 appearances for Celtic, the signing has since been highlighted as the essence of Mowbray's incompetency and failure that season.

6. Letting Shay Given Go

This is a famous decision that has left every Celtic fan completely bewildered, and its easy to understand why. Celtic signed Given as a 15 year old in 1992 and the keeper played regularly as a youth team goalkeeper. It seems, however, that Celtic had no idea they had a future world class keeper in their ranks. Celtic deemed him surplus to requirements and let Shay move to Blackburn Rovers in 1994. He impressed Newcastle manager Dalglish while on loan at Sunderland, and he made his trip from Wear to Tyne which would proved to be his best career decision. Given is regarded as one of the best keepers in the history of the modern day Premier League. Given has always been a Celtic supporter and, during the later years of his time at Newcastle, frequently told the press of his aim to someday move back to the club he loves and live the experience he should have had in his prime. The problem was that the Irishman matured as a first team goalkeeper at the time when Premier League teams collectively produced their highest rate of inflation of players wages and transfer costs, and so Shay Given had become an expensive asset. It's such a shame that Celtic passed up the opportunity to experience the overwhelming joy that Given gave to Newcastle and their fans as a world-class keeper for so many years.

5. Signing Mo Bangura Instead Of Baba Diawara

The signing of Bangura is a classic example of the Board's reluctance to buy their top transfer targets in favour of cheaper options. In this case, out of Baba Diawara of Maritimo and Bangura of AIK, Bangura was definitely the cheap option. The excuse was that there was a visa problem with Baba Diawara, but when you combine the fact that Diawara commanded a fee that was £2 million higher than Bangura's and Lawwell's famously frugal approach to purchasing players, it's easy to draw your own conclusion. Despite being the bargain buy, Bangura still commanded a £2 million fee as well as a glowing reference from club legend Henrik Larsson. In the end, though, he had absolutely nothing to show for it. In every game he played for Celtic, only 11 of them in total, he scored 0 goals. Meanwhile, Baba Diawara was continuing to impress at his club Maritimo, scoring 10 goals in just 15 games for the Portuguese side. So what's the big deal? Clubs make bad signings all the time, what's so terrible about Bangura? As you'll read in one of my first articles, Bangura ended up having to play against Celtic while on loan from the club at Elfsborg. Celtic made a bad decision in its own right by trying to talk Bangura out of playing against them through the media, and the Celtic fans weren't too happy to see him play against them. At Celtic park in the return leg, there was a memorable incident culminating in Bangura feigning injury to try and get Kelvin Wilson sent off. Bad move. It's not often you end up paying £2 million for a striker, only for him to fail to score in any games and then end up trying to score against you.

4. The Current Lack Of Action In This Year's Transfer Market

This may seem a little early to place this in Celtic's historical screw-up moments, but things right now for Celtic look a little bleak when they definitely shouldn't. Celtic are in brilliant shape, but you wouldn't think so when looking at the team. My main target of scrutiny is Peter Lawwell. This man is on the end of every Celtic fan's lips at the moment as the Chief is deemed by many to be downsizing the club. Not what you want to be doing to Celtic. The evidence for this theory is actually quite strong, and the departure of Neil Lennon along with the lack of transfer activity since the appointment of Ronny Deila only emphasises the view point. Since Deila's appointment, Celtic have not spent any money on transfers (2 loan signings, and 1 free transfer). Ronny has recently proclaimed his disinterest in signing players on loan, and wants to do what Lennon and O'Neill successfully did - build a dynasty. So far, there seems to be no indication that Ronny has been given funds to work with. If Celtic fans were to openly address our Cheif Exec, it would read like this: Peter, you are so far making one of the worst cases of football decision making in the history of the club by holding back the huge amount of funds that the club has generated. From the past two seasons, with the sale of key players, as well as the Champions League revenue the club has made from participation and league prize money, the club has made a figure in the region of £75 million before tax and outgoing expenses. This figure is staggering for a Scottish club in two years. Give Ronny some money to spend, for crying out loud!

3. Bringing In John Barnes

Unfathomable. I wish I could leave it like that, but for everyones sake I will elaborate. Celtic's only saving grace in the 99-00 season was that they teamed Barnes up with Kenny Dalglish, who was appointed Director of Football. John was an apprentice manager, basically. It was his first coaching role, and Kenny was there to guide him through his debut season. Why on Earth was this allowed to happen at such a huge club like Celtic, who's job it is every single season is to win the league? Fans got a glimpse of the misery to come when they crashed to a 2-1 defeat to Dundee United in the third league game of the season. From here on Celtic were actually quite consistent, but their first meeting with Rangers is what seemed to be the turning point in their season. Celtic lost 4-2 at Ibrox. They then went on to lose against Motherwell, and another game against the Gers ended in a 1-1 draw. The gap between the two Glasgow giants was widening and staying wide, and Barnes' Celtic were never able to claw it back as Rangers continued to pull away. Barnes hit the brick wall when his side lost to lower league Inverness in the Scottish cup, which prompted the well known "Super Cally Go Ballistic, Celtic Are Atrocious!" headline. Barnes was sacked. King Kenny took over managerial duties from his apprentice, but Celtic continued to suffer tremendously in the league, despite Dalglish winning them the League cup in Spring. The team proved to be deadly going forward alright, as shown by Mark Viduka soaring at the top of the goal charts by the end of the season, but they were dreadful at the back. Celtic finished the season 21 points adrift of Rangers in second place. An appalling season. But that's what you get for appointing such a strange, amateur managerial system. Poor decision.

2. Bringing In Tony Mowbray

In Summer 2009, Celtic were searching for a new manager to succeed the ever successful Gordon Strachen. Celtic were on a high after winning 3 titles in-a-row, and fans were confident they would find an adequate replacement manager. On 9th June. Tony Mowbray was brought in from West Brom. Tony was received well by the Hoops fans, especially when he proclaimed his intention to get Celtic playing attractive football playing "The Celtic Way". Things started ever so well for Mowbray as he had a brilliant pre-season, winning the inaugural Wembley cup over Barcelona and Tottenham. However, a snag. He did this with Strachen's team. A few players inevitably left and Mowbray intended on building his own team for the season. Some of the signings Mowbray made were questionable. What raised the fans' eyebrows the most was paying £4 million for the distinctly average Marc-Antoine Fortuné (as detailed previously in this article). Eariy in the season, Celtic were chucked into the Europa League by Arsenal. That's not the bad part though, there's no shame in Celtic being knocked out by Arsenal, it was the Europa League campaign that brought the must shame on Mowbray's Celtic before Christmas. Things had been running reasonably smoothly in the league until they first faced Rangers at Ibrox. A 2-1 defeat started a chain reaction of losses for Tony's Celts. They became far adrift of their Glasgow rivals. Things got desperate for Mowbray in January. Rangers were 10 points clear at the top of the table, and Mowbray told his team in the dressing room that they weren't good enough to where the green and white hoops, and decided to shake up the team. As told near the beginning of the article, Scott Macdonald, our leading scorer - a proven striker - was sold to make way for Robbie Keane who came in on loan. More loan signings were made, one of them being Diomansy Kamara, who turned out to be a waste. He scored a couple of goals, but to let Scott Macdonald go and get Kamara in for a loan was disappointing. Keane and Macdonald would have worked great together. Two main midfielders were also sold, Barry Robson and Willo Flood. It was clear Mowbray was going for broke. Celtic had to attack, attack, attack. He just forgot to tell his team how to defend. The shake-up didn't work, and Mowbray's stint ended horrifically with an embarrassing 4-0 defeat away at St Mirren. Neil Lennon took over and showed him how its done, as he won the last remaining 8 games in the league, including a 2-1 win at home against Rangers. Looking back, it was a painfully bad decision to appoint Mowbray. He was a proven yo-yo manager, nothing better. He could perform in the lower leagues with the Midlands team, but when it came to the big games he didn't have a clue, and thats exactly what happened with him at Celtic. He couldn't beat Rangers, and he ruined Celtic's astonishing home record in Europe, managing to be beaten and draw to teams which were deemed inferior to Celtic at the time (Hamburg and Rapid Vienna). When he realised how difficult the season was going he threw his composure away, and it ended up being one of the most miserable seasons for Celtic fans since the dark 90s era.

1. The Jimmy McGrory Managerial Era

Jimmy McGrory is one of the most fondly remembered Celts of all time. The legendary striker achieved one of the most astonishing goal/appearance ratios in history: 468 goals in 445 appearances (Gordon 2013). As a manager between 1945 and 1964 though, Jimmy McGrory endured a more difficult spell, but it wasn't all his own doing. Sir Bob Kelly was Celtic's chairman at the time, and his name instantly splits opinions of the older Celtic generation who were alive during this period. Kelly was a true Celtic man who always had the interests of the club close to his chest, famous for successfully defending Celtic's right to bare the Irish tricolour at Parkhead. Alex Gordon's book, "Celtic: The Awakening" (2013) goes into great detail with the aid of Lisbon Lions Bertie Auld, Billy McNeill and many others about Kelly's meddling conduct, and how it affected McGrory's day-to-day involvement: "It was obvious to all that Jimmy McGrory was not being allowed to manage. Chairman Robert Kelly would ask McGrory to submit his team sheet at the Thursday night board meeting and then make what he believed to be 'appropriate' adjustments" Berite Auld also recalls an incident which showed an example of Kelly's ways, when the third team goalkeeper, Willie Goldie was seen waiting for a bus to Celtic v Airdrie in 1960. The Celtic coach pulled up and invited him on, and Kelly, the chairman, told him he was playing as he was so impressed with the fact he was making his own way to the game. They got beat 2-0 by lowly Airdrie, and Goldie never played again... It then becomes very apparent that McGrory is totally out of his depth, and in many areas of the book, players are quoted describing McGrory as "too nice to be a manager". His management style was dated, and in all honesty, he was not the coach. So why did this era last so long? Well one can only imagine it's because it suited Kelly down to a tee. The only reason he kept his job was because Kelly could have more say in terms of team selection. McGrory offered no resistance to Kelly's meddling, so even though the team was enduring a long period of no success, Kelly was mostly free of criticism. McGrory was free of criticism too as he was so well regarded at the club. No Celtic fans would try to shoot down such a legend, so Kelly was allowed to keep things the way they were. What he didn't take into account was that he was killing the club. While he believed that he had the club's interest at heart, it was really only his interests. Gordon believed that Kelly "thought he was Celtic" This was an era filled with so many huge errors that culminated in such a terribly unsuccessful period for Celtic, with the Hoops winning 2 out of 20 games against Rangers, and winning no trophies at all for 8 years between 1957 and 1965. Unheard of nowadays for Celtic. Can you think of a time when decision making was particularly poor which resulted in poor seasons for the Celtic or the club you support? Please detail these in the comments section below, lets have a debate!