12 Newcastle Players Who Returned For A Second Spell On Tyneside

Whose second coming was inspired? And whose went down like a lead balloon?

By Chris Waugh /

Newcastle United is a club that not only manages to find a place in the heart of Magpies supporters, but also in those of the players who pull on the black-and-white-striped jersey. Footballers tend to build a largely-unbreakable connection with a club whose supporters live and breathe the beautiful game. Toon fans adore their beloved football club - and, as a result, they tend to adore a fair proportion of the players who represent it as well. Despite this, there are surprisingly few players who, in recent years - particularly since the formation of the Premier League in 1992 - have returned to play for, or even manage, the Magpies again having originally left the club. Players have returned looking to match the past glories of their original stint at the club - but, unfortunately, that has not always been the case. Some have cemented even more strongly their place in Newcastle United folklore as a result of returning, while others have (at least partially) damaged their reputation. With the likes of Andy Carroll, Demba Ba and Yohan Cabaye linked with potential moves back to St James' Park this summer, whatculture.com/nufc has looked into previous occasions when players have made the decision to return to Tyneside. So here are 12 Newcastle United players who returned to either represent Newcastle United on the pitch once again, or even manage the Magpies - with mixed results...

12. Peter Beardsley

First Spell (1983-87): League Appearances: 147 League Goals: 61 Second Spell (1993-97): League Appearances: 129 League Goals: 47 Capped 59 times by England, Hexham-born Beardsley is one of the finest players ever to come from the North East. The incredibly-talented forward scored 47 goals in 129 Premier League appearances for Newcastle and he was one of the stars of Kevin Keegan's Entertainers side - and that was only just during his second spell. Having started his career at Carlisle United, Beardsley twice moved to Vancouver Whitecaps, as well as Manchester United, before he signed for his boyhood club in 1983. A return of 61 goals from 147 league appearances between 1983 and 1987 was impressive enough, but the fact he added another 47 later in his career shows he was right to return in 1993 after spells at Liverpool and Everton. Only 5ft 8in tall, Beardsley was a supremely-talented footballer who wowed Toon supporters - as well as the fans of every single other club he played for. Since 2001, Beardsley has operated as Newcastle's reserve-team coach, as well as John Carver's assistant.

11. Kevin Keegan - "The Second Coming"

First Spell (As A Player, 1982-84): League Appearances: 78 League Goals: 48 Second Spell (As Manager, 1992-97): Games Managed: 251 Wins: 138 Raised as a Newcastle fan due to his father's allegiance to the Magpies, Doncaster-born Keegan played for Scunthorpe United, Liverpool, Hamburger SV and Southampton before he finally became a Magpie in 1982. After netting an impressive 48 goals in 78 league games, Keegan then moved to Blacktown City before retiring in 1985 - but just seven years later the 63-cap England international was back on Tyneside, this time as manager. With the Magpies struggling at the bottom of the old Second Division, John Hall orchestrated "the Second Coming" of "King Kev" - and what a brilliant decision that proved to be. As well as avoiding relegation in his first season, Keegan then led Newcastle to promotion the year after, before his "Entertainers" side narrowly missed out on the Premier League title during the 1995-96 season. During 251 matches in charge, Keegan claimed 138 victories as Toon boss - and became one of the best-loved managers in the club's history.

10. Olivier Bernard

First Spell (2000-05): League Appearances: 102 League Goals: 6 Second Spell (2006-07): League Appearances: 0 League Goals: 0 French defender Olivier Bernard arrived on Tyneside from Lyon in 2000 as a complete unknown - yet he managed to establish himself as first-choice left-back in Sir Bobby Robson's Champions League side over the course of the next five seasons. Reasonable in defence, but someone who loved to link up with fellow Frenchman Laurent Robert in attack, Bernard bombed forward from left-back on every possible occasion during his 102 Premier League appearances for Newcastle. After failing to agree a new deal with Newcastle in January 2005, Bernard signed for Southampton before moving to Rangers. Yet by 2006 he was back in the North East - although he failed to make another Premier League appearance for Newcastle due to the fact he suffered from a series of niggling injuries and then a hip problem. His first spell was extremely successful, but unfortunately Bernard's second stint at St James' Park was anything but.

9. Pavel Srnicek

First Spell (1991-98): League Appearances: 150 Second Spell (2006-07): League Appearances: 2 He may not be a Geordie by birth, but Pavel Srnicek is so loved by Newcastle fans that he even has his own chant: "Pavel is a Geordie". The Czech goalkeeper played for the Magpies between 1991 and 1998, and then again briefly in in 2006, and he became adored by the Toon faithful. A total of 113 Premier League appearances arrived for another one of Kevin Keegan's Entertainers - and that is one of the many reasons why "Pavel is a Geordie". However, when he returned during the 2006-07 season Srnicek was merely third choice behind both Shay Given and Steve Harper - despite having enjoyed a thrilling battle with Shaka Hislop for the No 1 jersey during the 1990s. A wonderful character, and also a very good goalkeeper. He may not have played much during his second stint on Tyneside, but Srnicek's infectious personality certainly had a positive impact on the Magpies squad.

8. Nolberto Solano

First Spell (1998-2004): League Appearances: 182 League Goals: 37 Second Spell (2005-07): League Appearances: 58 League Goals: 8 One of the most-successful second stints as a player at Newcastle United, that's for sure. Whenever Nolberto Solano is mentioned by a Newcastle fan, they do so with a smile - because the little Peruvian was simply majestic at times. A member of Sir Bobby Robson's thrilling Champions League side, Nobby Solano and Laurent Robert would occupy either wing and deliver pinpoint crosses and set-pieces to the likes of Alan Shearer and Craig Bellamy. Having signed for Newcastle for just shy of £2.5 million in 1998, Solano made 182 Premier League appearances and scored 37 goals - many of them memorable - before he left for Aston Villa for £1.5 million in 2004. However, just 18 months later Solano was back on Tyneside for the same price for which he was sold - and he once again proved to be a hit, scoring eight goals in a further 58 league appearances. Since retiring Solano has moved into coaching - and he continues to play the trumpet for his own Salsa band, "The Geordie Latinos".

7. Lee Clark

First Spell (1990-97): League Appearances: 195 League Goals: 23 Second Spell (2005-06): League Appearances: 22 League Goals: 1 Never has a person sounded so Geordie in TV interviews - and Lee Clark remains as broad now as he was when he was playing for Kevin Keegan's "Entertainers" during the 1990s. The Wallsend-born midfielder made 195 league appearances, scoring 23 goals, for his hometown club between 1990 and 1997 before moving to their bitter rivals Sunderland after falling out of favour under Kenny Dalglish. A battling midfielder, he was already adored by the Toon faithful but the photograph of Clark in a "Sad Mackem B*st*rds" top really endeared him to Magpies supporters - and that facilitated a move to Fulham in 1999. After captaining the Cottagers back into the top flight, Clark then returned to Newcastle on a free transfer in 2005 - where he made a further 22 league appearances and scored one more goal for the club. His second spell was certainly not as glorious or fun as his first with the Entertainers, but Clark still made a reasonable contribution to the Magpies during the 2005-06 season.

6. Glenn Roeder

First Spell (As A Player, 1983-89): League Appearances: 193 League Goals: 8 Second Spell (As Manager, 2006-07): Games Managed: 72 Wins: 33 What a centre-back - and a captain - London-born Glenn Roeder was for Newcastle United. Signed from Queens Park Rangers in 1983, the former England B international made 193 league appearances for the Magpies over seven seasons, netting eight times. Unfortunately for Roeder he fell victim to the curse of the caretaker boss when he returned to the club, having been elevated from his position of youth-development manager once Graeme Souness was sacked in February 2006. Extremely successful during his time in temporary charge of the Magpies, but once his appointment became permanent then life became a lot more difficult for the former Newcastle skipper. Loved already on Tyneside for his battling traits as a centre-back, Newcastle fans really wanted Roeder to succeed as a manager when he took charge - and he did, for a period. Of his 72 matches in charge, Roeder claimed victory in 33 of them and lost just 24, giving him a win ratio of 45.83%. This was bolstered by European successes, however, and, although Roeder's tenure overall was a successful one, it ended in disappointment and his resignation in May 2007.

5. Alan Shearer

First Spell (As A Player, 1996-2006): League Appearances: 303 League Goals: 148 Second Spell (As Manager, 2009): Games Managed: 8 Wins: 1 Born and raised in Gosforth, Newcastle's greatest son played for Wallsend Boys Club but he was forced to move down to Southampton in order to make his breakthrough. After winning the Premier League with Blackburn Rovers, his boyhood club came calling, as did Manchester United, but Newcastle paid a then-world-record fee of £15 million in order to bring Shearer back home. Capped 63 times by England, Shearer netted a Newcastle-record 206 goals during 405 appearances for the club - including 148 in 303 Premier League games. "Wor Al" captained Newcastle during Sir Bobby Robson's tenure and also played for Kevin Keegan. A uniquely-talented finisher, Shearer is arguably the greatest player ever to represent Newcastle United Football Club - and, to make things even better, he's a Geordie. Unfortunately for Big Al, he could not turn down Mike Ashley when the Sports Direct magnate called for a saviour to try and resurrect Newcastle's doomed 2008-09 season - but, with just eight games remaining, Shearer couldn't turn around the horrendous slide. Kevin Keegan had resigned just days into the season and then Joe Kinnear's terrible tenure ended when he became ill, and the job of saving the Magpies proved too much for their greatest-ever goalscorer. From eight games in charge, Shearer won just once as Newcastle were relegated to the Championship - giving him a win ratio of just 12.50%. Far from tarnishing Shearer's reputation on Tyneside, however, this merely blotted his copybook slightly.

4. Robbie Elliott

First Spell (1991-97): League Appearances: 79 League Goals: 9 Second Spell (2001-06): League Appearances: 63 League Goals: 2 Two spells at Newcastle United for Gosforth-born Elliott brought 133 Premier League appearances and nine goals - as well as Champions League football on both occasions. The dependable left-back played under Kevin Keegan, Kenny Dalglish, Sir Bobby Robson and Graeme Souness - and never let his boyhood club down. Hardly the most gifted of footballers, Elliott gave his all for the cause and always performed admirably in defence - even providing important cover to the Magpies' first teamers towards the end of his career.

3. Kevin Keegan - "The Third Coming"

First Spell (As A Player, 1982-84): League Appearances: 78 League Goals: 48 Second Spell (As Manager, 1992-97): Games Managed: 251 Wins: 138 Third Spell (As Manager, 2008): Games Managed: 22 Wins: 7 When Kevin Keegan returned for his "Second Coming" (or "Third Coming" for the purposes of this article) as manager following Sam Allardyce's dismissal in January 2008, Newcastle fans were positive about the future - but, unfortunately, within eight months everything had turned sour. Keegan won just six matches in 21 games in charge during his second spell as manager - but that was the least of his problems. Mike Ashley's decision to employ Dennis Wise as director of football saw King Kev fall out with the board over incoming and outgoing transfers, forcing him into a position where he felt compelled to resign (for a second time). Eventually suing for "constructive dismissal", Keegan's second spell ended acrimoniously - and with a win ratio of just 28.57%. A deeply depressing way for one of Newcastle's finest-ever players and managers to end his association with the club.

2. Joe Harvey

First Spell (As A Player, 1945-53): League Appearances: 224 League Goals: 12 Trophies Won: 1951 and 1952 FA Cup Second Spell (As Manager, 1962-75): Games Managed: 591 Wins: 224 Trophies Won: 1969 Inter-Cities Fairs Cup What a legend Joe Harvey is at Newcastle United Football Club - and that's the reason he is the only entry on this list from outside of the Premier League era. The Doncaster-born half-back started his playing career at Wolverhampton Wanderers before moving to Bournemouth and Bradford City. He eventually arrived at St James' Park in the immediate aftermath of World War II in 1945, and made 224 league appearances for the Magpies, scoring 12 times. During one of the most-successful periods in Newcastle's history, Harvey helped the club to back-to-back FA Cup wins in 1951 and 1952 as a player. Then, having retired in 1953, Harvey returned to Newcastle nine years later as manager - and won 224 of 591 matches in charge between 1962 and 1975. As well as leading the club to promotion as Second Division winners in 1965, Harvey achieved what no Newcastle manager has done since - lifted a trophy. With the 1969 Inter-Cities Fairs Cup as manager to add to his FA Cup double as a player, Harvey's two spells at Newcastle were certainly extremely successful.

1. John Carver

First Spell (As A Youth Player, 1983-85): League Appearances: 0 League Goals: 0 Second Spell (As Caretaker Manager, 2004): Games Managed: 1 Wins: 1 Third Spell (As Caretaker And Then Interim Head Coach, 2004): Games Managed: 20 Wins: 3 Technically he never made a first-team appearance for Newcastle while in their academy set-up between 1983 and 1985, but John Carver did still return to the club first as an assistant manager, and then eventually as interim head coach. Well he is - sorry, was - the best coach in the Premier League after all... When Alan Pardew left the Magpies for Crystal Palace in January 2015, Carver was originally placed in "caretaker" charge of the club - and, despite losing all four matches he was given control of, Sir Bobby Robson's former assistant was then named as "interim" head coach for the remainder of the season. Carver's spell in charge of the Magpies was absolutely horrendous - with a side who sat in mid-table at the turn of the year dropping like stones down the Premier League table thanks to just two victories from his first 18 Premier League matches in charge. A victory on the final day of the season against West Ham United at St James' Park kept Newcastle in the Premier League, but Carver returned a win ratio of just 15% from 20 matches. Arguably Newcastle's worst-ever manager. For all the latest NUFC News, Views and Transfers make sure to follow whatculture.com/NUFC on Twitter and Facebook.