4 Common Misconceptions About Modern Football

By Liam Gilchrist /

4. Formations Depend On The Players Available

This is something that has cropped up in many a misguided tactical discussion since Guardiola's now-legendary Barcelona side beat Manchester United 2-0 in the Champions League 2009, and intensified in some quarters since Manchester City appointed Txiki Begiristain as director of football. The basic idea is that if a team plays 4-3-3 'like Barcelona' (they only kind of do themselves) then the quality of attacking football would improve. Of course, these tacticians would also posit the limitations of a 4-4-2, the overly-defensive 4-2-3-1 and such, maybe even throwing around words like 'catenaccio' to sound more credible but without actually understanding what it means. In reality, the formation depends entirely on the players that the manager has at his disposal. For instance, a midfield trio of Busquets, Xavi and Iniesta is perfectly balanced and more capable of out-passing opposition teams than, say, Carrick (as seriously good as he is), Cleverley and Anderson of my beloved Manchester United. Former Real boss Jose Mourinho is often criticised for being anti-football because of the ostensibly defensive 4-2-3-1 he likes to employ. In fairness to those detractors, their claims are occasionally vindicated, as in some of the Clásicos of recent seasons. However, such criticism also fails to take into account that in most games, Real had their two centre-halves sitting on the half-way line, while everyone else bar the 'keeper would be in and around the opposition box, with Xabi Alonso and Sami Khedira on hand to mop up blocked shots and clearances and send them back into the fray. So, before you suggest a formation change to your mates, or post that comment on your favourite football forum or site, remember: are these players really capable of adapting to a new system, or would the team need a new player (or players) to accommodate this formation?

3. Transfers Don't Just Happen By Magic

On the subject of new players, countless football fans around Europe are in varying states of despair, anxiety, or, if you're from Monaco, elation. Yes, it's that time of year: the summer transfer window is open and everyone is ready to spend, spend, spend! Of course, it's not that simple - not that you'd think it, based on what people say. If a team wants to buy a player, there are certain procedures to follow and protocols to adhere to, lest they want to be reported for misconduct to UEFA. A large number of people seem to forget that in every transfer (bar those with free agents) there are two teams involved (or more if the player is sought-after by multiple clubs). It is not just a case of Team A offering Team B some money and taking one of their players, nor can Team A talk to any of Team B's players without their permission. Take the Gareth Bale transfer saga, for example. Real Madrid want him, and have made no secret of this. We'll leave 'tapping-up' for another day, though that is something else which needs to be addressed by the powers that be. Now, many a football fan have suggested ways for Real to sweeten the deal, or for Spurs to get as much as they can for their prized asset (because £85 million isn't extortionate enough). These range from Di Maria plus cash, to Di Maria and Modric plus cash, to even any two players plus £85m cash. Player(s)-plus-cash deals aren't all that uncommon, but let's consider some of the facts: i) Real signed Luka Modric a year ago after a painful, drawn-out saga which saw the player refuse to play as part of his own personal campaign to escape White Hart Lane Prison. ii) Spurs are in a much better financial position than most clubs in Europe and do not need the money. iii) Bale is under contract at Spurs until 2016. If Spurs wanted to sell, they would be getting a pretty good deal. However, if they decide to hold onto Bale for a season or two (though his value would drop dramatically if he entered the final year of his contract), they would have the advantage of owning one of the world's best footballers. They are under no obligation to sell. So, please keep this in mind when you're stressed out that your team hasn't signed anyone this transfer window - not every player is available for purchase! And even if they were, what if they're already settled and happy where they are?

2. Assist Stats Aren't That Big a Deal

There really isn't a great deal to explain here; the heading is quite self-explanatory, but that doesn't mean it's any less important when talking about football. In fact, assist stats are so often hawked about that the football-following public at large are led to believe that assists are as good as goals. Indeed, I would agree that if the player in question was, say, Antonia Valencia, his assist record is substantially indicative of his form. After all, he is a good old-fashioned winger, and as such, he does a lot of crossing. The same might be said for Angel 'Makeweight' Di Maria, Jesus Navas and other more traditional wingers and crossers of the ball. However, there are times - I dare say many, many times - throughout a season where the recorded assist is not, in fact, the conception of the goal. If you don't believe me, fine - let Xavi show you: search Google for 'Xavi pass Malaga'. Now consider this: who got the assist for that goal? And who actually created it? Let that be the end of over-glorifying the assist stat. Of course, it won't be, but we can dream, eh?

1. Football Before 1992 Wasn't Rubbish

Having been born in 1988, there isn't a great deal that I remember about anything before 1992 myself, so I too am of the generation of televised football; in order to learn more about great players of the past, I have had to make do with TV shows, internet videos and stories of their skills and achievements. However, there is a worrying assumption that an alarming number of people seem to make regarding 'modern' football when compared with the game of the 1980's, '70's and so on: that players back then weren't as good as they are now, or even that they were generally rubbish. The counter-argument often given by the same people is that nostalgia is clouding the judgement of, say, Preston fans waxing lyrical over the great Tom Finney, Stoke supporters reminiscing about Stanley Matthews, and even football followers who salivate over the Brazil side that trounced Italy 4-1 in the 1970 World Cup Final in Mexico. Tell that to Sir Bobby Charlton, who is widely considered England's greatest-ever player, and one of Manchester United's. Throughout his long and distinguished career, he played against some of the greatest that the game had to offer, but there was only one man who, in Sir Bobby's own words, made him feel inferior: Duncan Edwards. Unfortunately, like many players of yore, there is precious little footage of him in action, so my knowledge of him was gleaned primarily from anecdotes. Therefore, I can't really vouch for how good he was (even though all of the anecdotes suggest that he was up there with the best players of all time). Fortunately, there is at least a decent amount of footage of many of history's greatest players, such as Best, Cruyff, Pele and Maradona. Many hours have I spent gazing wide-eyed and open-mouthed at YouTube clips of these luminaries of the beautiful game as they dazzled and delighted with their sublime skills. I suppose what I am trying to get at is that I am amazed whenever someone tells me that players back then were not as good as they are now - that Messi is definitely the greatest ever because the game is harder nowadays. It has to be said that the conditioning of players, and the rigour with which they are trained and honed into top-class athletes is getting better by the day, with developments in sports science coming on leaps and bounds over the past sixty years or so. But I wonder: will they be saying fifty years from now, when my generation is old and tired, that Messi, Ronaldo and co are nothing compared to the superstars of that age, because the game is easier now?