5 Terrible Refereeing Decisions That Changed World Cup Games
VAR not included.
As Michael Jackson once famously said, I’m pleading with the man in the middle, I’m asking him to not book our full-back for that foul, he barely touched him. Such is the life of a referee.
It’s a weird existence as we usually consider a good officiating performance as being one that goes almost entirely unnoticed. We only tend to talk about them when things go wrong, ergo, the less we’re doing that, the more they’re doing right.
But, sometimes they’re all we can talk about after the final whistle and, in tournament football, if their mistakes cost you, they cost you big time.
5. Clive Thomas: Brazil v Sweden, 1978
So, we’ve all played FIFA right? We sort of know that in order for the full time whistle to blow you have to lose the ball in the middle of the pitch, or knock it backwards, or otherwise just let attacking move to break down. It’s a bit more nuanced in real football but the principle is, largely, the same.
Not so if you’re Welshman Clive Thomas who, at the 1978 World Cup, blew up for full time about 1/1,000,000th of a second before Zico buried a winning goal for Brazil. Yep.
With the seconds ticking down he allowed Brazil to press forward, then allowed them to win a corner, then allowed them to take the corner and, with the ball in mid-flight, decided there was no more time.
The whistle was still in his mouth when Zico met the cross to, he thought, make it Brazil 2-1 Sweden. The protests, which compared to today’s standards are shockingly tame, were met with complete indifference as he let the teams off.
Now, the point wasn’t any good for Sweden who still finished bottom of the group but the draw eventually cost Brazil top spot, meaning they were paired in the next round with eventual winners Argentina.
4. Graham Poll: Australia v Croatia, 2006
If you’re a UK resident and you watch BT Sport, you’ll no doubt enjoy the expert analysis they get from actual referees during complex or uncertain officiating decisions. Unless of course they’re using Graham Poll that day, because the natural reaction to anything he says is “yes mate, but you once booked the same player 3 times”.
I’ll set the scene, it’s the final game of group G and both sides can advance if the result goes their way. It’s a tight affair, a nervy affair, a spiky game of small margins that you desperately need a referee to keep control of. Enter Graham Poll…
Viduka bears down on goal and is wrestled to the ground by Simunic, but no penalty. Croatian defender Tomas deliberately handles the ball in the box, but Australia get a corner. Harry Kewell’s equaliser, which ultimately knocked Croatia out was, glaringly, offside.
And finally, the icing on the cake… Josip Simunic is booked for a foul in the 61st minute, and again in the 90th but is somehow not sent off. Then, after the final whistle, he approaches Poll to give him an earful and is given a third yellow and a red for dissent. English refs, best in the world.
3. The Hand of God
Now, full disclosure here, as a member of the Goalkeepers Union I do not attach any blame whatsoever to the referee for Maradona’s infamous Hand of God. The guy was pretty far away, it all happened in a flash, and he missed it. These things happen.
What shouldn’t ever happen though, is a 6ft 2’ goalkeeper getting out jumped to a ball by a 5ft 5’ centre forward. Shilton’s nearly got a foot on him, the ball was coming out of the sky towards him, and Maradona someone steals in for the slam-dunk.
That said though, yes I suppose that is cheating and given this game was a knockout which finished 2-1, you do have to throw some blame at the referee Ali Bin Nasser of Tunisia. I mean, Maradonna literally refers to him as “my eternal friend” so, yeah, maybe it is on him.
Argentina, of course, went on to win the World Cup itself after this match while England went home to fume on being cheated out of a semi-final spot. There is an argument - quite wild one, admittedly - that this singular sporting moment did more to damage Anglo/Argentine relations than the actual Falklands War.
Sport; it’s serious business.
2. Edgardo Codesal: Argentina v West Germany, 1990
If Argentina were the beneficiaries of a refereeing blunder in 86 then karma balances itself right out only 4 years later when, in the world cup final itself, they were the victims of some… let’s just say gamesmanship.
For our younger viewers so don’t really know anything about football before the Premier League started, Jurgen Kilinsmann’s famous Klinsmann dive celebration was a cheeky reference to the fact that he did a massive dive in the world’s biggest game.
Playing a 1-2 with Lothar Matthaus, Jurgen spied Argentina’s Pedro Monzon charging in for a tackle that he was never going to win. As the challenge came he kept into the air, triple pike, hit the deck, rolled around 3 full times, and even did that weird breakdance shoulder elevation thing for good measure.
Referee Edgardo Codesal, presumably seeing this carnage and thinking “f*** me, he’s killed him”, quickly brandished the red card. Only problem one, there was precisely zero contact.
Worse still, after the 10 men understandably tried to then pull the shutters down and play for penalties, the referee awarded Germany a penalty 5 minutes from time that was softer than your new step-dad’s telling off voice.
Just goes to show, what goes around… rolls around, 3 times, and gets one of your defenders sent off.
1. Byron Moreno, Italy vs South Korea, 2002
Pains me to write this up because, obviously, the South Korea story of the 2002 World Cup was brilliant. An unfenced host nation progressing to the very latter stages, upsetting some of the games big names along the way. Doesn’t happen often enough.
But, how they go past Italy in the round of 16 leaves something of a sour taste in the mouth. While the odds were stacked against them in a simple 11 v 11 comparison, the decision making go referee Bryon Moreno more than made up for it.
First, he awarded South Korea an incredibly generous penalty and seemed happy to let the hosts get away with a number of rough tackles, while happily carding the Italians.
Then, in extra-time, he ruled out a golden goal winner for Italy that should absolutely 100% have not only stood, but ended the game. To make matters worse, then then sent off Totti for diving despite being 40 yards behind the play. Replays showing that he simply tripped.
Giovanni Trapattoni outright accused FIFA of ordering the officials to let Korea progress. Subtle.