6 Best & 6 Worst Newcastle Managers Since 1975

One list is easy, the other pretty hard. No prizes for guessing which is which.

By Simon Gallagher /

Unless Newcastle manage to pull something spectacular out of the bag this year, the 45 years of hurt that have stretched out since Joe Harvey lead the Magpies to Fairs Cup glory in 1969 and tied his name into Tyneside history forever will continue towards the dreaded 50 mark. Since that momentous occasion, the Magpies have made 30 managerial appointments, including caretakers and interim bosses and the results have been very much a mixed bag. Sadly, not even those good enough to be classed as heroes, or even to be knighted by the Queen have managed to return the days of silverware to Tyneside, with only a few near misses. But which manager deserves to be crowned the very best since Joe Harvey hung his managerial suit up for the last time in 1975, and who deserves to be ridiculed as the very worst? Let's start by looking at the managers who almost destroyed our great club...

6 Worst

6. Ruud Gullit

You might not remember it, but when Ruud Gullit came in to Newcastle, he was classed as an exciting managerial prospect, who would return Sexy Football to the club. Unfortunately, few could ever have realised that when he said sexy, he meant a disappointing, sloppy mess of a thing with dour, disinterested participants, rather than a thing of beauty. The fan-orgasms were few and far between, and there was very little to remember in the end apart from his spectacularly misjudged attempt to take on Alan Shearer. Unsurprisingly, he lost, Shearer won and Sir Bobby Robson arrived to fix everything the Dutchman had broken - but most of all the club's spirt. Incredibly, he'd actually started pretty well, but everything after that was just a mess, and the manager seemed to enjoy provocatively p*ssing off the fans.

5. Ossie Ardiles

In another life, Ossie Ardiles could well have been a great manager for Newcastle United: he reinvented the playing style after Jim Smith's dour, reductive approach, signed a hugely useful striker in Gavin Peacock and brought through some talented youth players who Kevin Keegan would later use as key members of his team. Sadly, Ossie was absolutely hampered by a lack of funds, and by Sir John Hall's belligerent refusal to do any business until he owned the club outright, and his investment in the talented crop of youngsters was more of out necessity than choice. Without investment, and with Ardiles' hands tied at a board level, the club looked lost and spiralled towards disaster before he was sacked and replaced with the Messiah.

4. Kenny Dalglish

To go from the expansive brilliance of Kevin Keegan's football, and the near-miss of almost winning the Premier League to the dour, boring football of Kenny Dalglish was a shock to the system. Dalglish may claim that getting to the FA Cup final and coming second were big deals for Newcastle, but he made some stunningly poor decisions, both on the pitch and away from it. And while his time as boss was hampered by some key injuries - to Alan Shearer more than anyone else - his style of play was mostly horrible to watch, and better transfer dealings might have protected the club a bit more. He is after all the man responsible for the signings of Des Hamilton, Alessandro Pistone, Ian Rush, George Georgiadis, Stephane Guivarc'h and his own son. And that's just a few of them. He was never going to compare to the man he replaced, but Kenny wasn't the King he was apparently destined to be, and when he left it was something of a relief, even if it merely opened the door for Ruud Gullit's deeply unsexy football.

3. Sam Allardyce

If the current West Ham boss had written this list, he'd be somewhere near the top of the other side of his list. The shameless self-promotionalist with an ego as big as his head was always his own biggest fan, and recently claimed he would now be at a big club if he hadn't seen his chances ruined by circumstances at Newcastle. In reality, the circumstances that got in the way of his progression to being the greatest living English manager, and taking Real Madrid to Champions Leagues at a canter is that he's just not a very good manager. Or at least he wasn't at Newcastle. He played reductive, boring football, signed cloggers on massive wages and generally sulked around acting like he had been fired well before the axe ever swung because of Mike Ashley's take-over. Under Freddie Shepherd, he'd been told he was the man to make Newcastle a top four team again, but he tried his level best to make sure the team was camped at the other end of the table entirely. Still, at least he took his dismissal with good grace...

2. Graeme Souness

Graeme Souness was the man Newcastle United identified as the key to re-establishing order in the dressing room after player power had ruled for the final months of Sir Bobby Robson's time as manager. Just months later, he was sitting side by side with two of his players who had come to actual blows on the pitch in front of millions of watching fans. So that was one objective missed spectacularly. His second agenda was to return Newcastle to the top four after Sir Bobby's fifth place finish was deemed poor enough to warrant the sack. In his first season, Newcastle finished 14th and they were 15th when he was finally sacked in February 2006, so that was two major objectives missed with aplomb. But at least he signed some good players eh? He built on Sir Bobby's most shrewd transfer policy by spending £10m on Albert Luque, £8.5m on Jean-Alain Boumsong and probably £10m too much on Michael Owen. All were abject failures. A third strike. Such was his poor managerial ability that rumours of dressing room unrest and favouritism were rife, with Olivier Bernard, Craig Bellamy and Jermain Jenas all leaving on bad terms with him.

1. Gordon Lee

Much like Alan Pardew's apparent agenda to strip away any players with power in the dressing room - Nolan, Barton, Harper - or who question his authority - Enrique, Be Arfa, Marveaux - Gordon Lee's agenda as Newcastle boss was to rip out the heart, and indeed much of the talent, of the club. He might have been a big part of the club getting to the League Cup final, and ultimately getting into the top six in Division One, but Lee ripped the best parts of the team out, selling Hibbit, MacDonald and Howard, and bringing in replacements who weren't as technically gifted, but who would be better cogs in an efficient, uninspiring machine. To add insult to injury, Lee jumped ship when Everton offered him a bigger salary, and unfortunately, Newcastle replaced him with Richard Dinnis, as a direct result of his interference with player power. So what about the best managers? A harder prospect than you might actually imagine...

6 Best

6. Glenn Roeder

When former captain Roeder was promoted to replace Graeme Souness, with the club sliding steadily towards relegation, the appointment was far from an inspiring one. He was initially deemed no more than a place holder, who would guide the club through a turbulent time before handing off to a better, bigger manager. Except, that's not how the script went, and though the end of his Newcastle career was somewhat uninspiring, Roeder instilled belief, confidence and discipline in a side that was warring with itself. He turned a team seemingly destined for relegation into one that qualified for European competition (albeit through a back door), and he helped wash away the bad atmosphere left by Graeme Souness. He might not have won anything, but so tight is this list that that achievement alone deserves applause.

5. Chris Hughton

He's not quite the ceremonial lamb to the slaughter that some Newcastle fans still paint him as (that final run of results before he was sacked was abject), but through the sheer lack of available great managers, Chris Hughton definitely deserves to make this list. By all assessments, Hughton was a terrible caretaker manager, and Newcastle suffered a lot of the most catastrophic defeats in the relegation season under his care, but when he was finally given the job full-time after Alan Shearer's brief flirtation with failure, he soared. He steadied the ship when far more choppy waters were expected, cleared up the squad by getting rid of expensive flops (not so much him as the club's control), and helped instil the confidence that allowed the team to sweep through the Championship with ease. When he returned to the Premier League, he oversaw incredible wins against Villa and Sunderland, but the wins dried up somewhat, and Newcastle's board decided more experience was necessary.

4. Arthur Cox

Despite managing Chesterfield for four years, former Sunderland coach Arthur Cox was a relative newcomer to management when he took over at Newcastle, and it took some time for his talents to show. In the early '80s football wasn't really top of the agenda for most people, and crowds dipped badly, with Newcastle pulling in only 18,000 on average thanks to some uninspiring, insipid football. But then Cox pulled off an absolute master-stroke, convincing Kevin Keegan to sign for Newcastle in the Second Division, despite interest from Manchester United. Under Cox, Newcastle started to play the brilliant attacking football that would later underpin the philosophies of Keegan's Entertainers side, hiding defensive frailty with their ability to pour forward with Keegan, Beardsley and Waddle. Cox signed some incredibly gifted players, from Waddle and Beardsley to Terry McDermott, David McCreery and while he left after promotion to Division One after he wasn't promised enough funds, he was a key under-rated part of changing the philosophy at Newcastle.

3. Alan Pardew

Depressing isn't it? Though he's also responsible for some eye-gougingly poor football, some terrible decisions and a run of defeats and minimal points won, there's no doubt that in the wider context of Newcastle's modern history of managers, Alan Pardew is the third best. He has overseen a fifth place finish in the league, has taken some serious scalps of supposedly bigger teams, and has led his team to within a few matches of a European final. And he's a very rare creature in that he won the Manager Of The Year Award outside the top four, as he will no doubt keep telling everyone. Pardew has his faults - too many to note right now - but thanks to the length of his contract and some board-level commitment that would be classed as mental illness at other clubs, he has put together a comparatively impressive win rate (it's a sorry fact that anything below 50% would be classed as such) and is the first manager since Sir Bobby Robson to qualify for Europe in the front door.

2. Sir Bobby Robson

If there's one thing that Freddie Shepherd should be held accountable for more than anything else from his time as Newcastle's chairman, it's the dismissal of Sir Bobby Robson, whose "failure" was nothing less than coming fifth in the league. Robson had saved Newcastle from near certain relegation, picking up a club left in a heap at the bottom of the table by Ruud Gullit's classless "sexy" football, and announced the return of the Entertainers with an 8-0 thumping of Sheffield Wednesday. He never over-spent, even if some of his transfer dealings were better than others, he qualified for the Champions League within two years of the club facing relegation and he got the side playing the kind of football Newcastle fans love the most. It's one of the great shames of football that Sir Bobby wasn't able to win anything for his boyhood side, but there was nothing light in the decision to put his statue outside the stadium.

1. Kevin Keegan

Kevin Keegan was the walking personification of Newcastle United for a long time - even after he'd walked away from the club - and his spectre, and specifically the spectre of his football, has haunted the club in the barren years since he left the first time. When he came to the club, the Magpies were staring over the precipice into the old third division, after years of under-achievement, and with just a few key signings - in particular Brian Kilcline - he saved the club and went about rebuilding. The fact that he achieved promotion just a year later was astonishing, and that he immediately went from the First Division to the top of The Premier League is nothing short of amazing. Keegan brought a philosophy of sublime attacking football, entertaining fans around the country, and genuinely making the Magpies title contenders. Optimism poured out of St. James' Park, and though he was notoriously difficult to work above (thanks to his fancy for walking out in a huff), what he did for the club on the pitch cannot ever be over-stated. Even though his second spell at the club is best left ignored, thanks to the ridiculous interference at board-level that saw him leave, Keegan will likely be classed the greatest Newcastle manager of the Premier League era, and indeed well beyond that, until someone wins something. Who do you think deserves to be counted as the best Newcastle manager ever?And who is your choice for the worst ever?