In recent years, Tottenham Hotspur have become one of the Premier League's big spenders. That's not to say they're as wild with their money as the Chelseas, Manchester Citys or Liverpools of this world - Spurs net spend in recent years is actually quite modest when you take in to account the money they've brought in from player sales - but they have certainly splashed out big money on a number of players over the past few seasons. However, spending doesn't guarantee success - as Spurs have found out to their peril with just one trophy since the turn of the millennium (the 2008 League Cup) and a single Champions League run in 2010-11. Last summer, the White Hart Lane club broke their transfer record no less than three times - bringing it up to £30 million - following the world record sale of Gareth Bale to Real Madrid and they now regularly spend tens of millions on players every season. In this article, we're going to take a look at some of the most expensive signings Spurs have ever made who simply didn't repay their cost on the pitch. Here is the most expensive Spurs eleven that simply failed to deliver...
11. Heurelho Gomes (£7.8 Million)
You should always be wary of Brazilian goalkeepers - even when they've played at international level - because it's not a country renowned for producing good ones. Heurelho Gomes wasn't really an exception to that rule, despite his cost. Gomes signed from PSV Eindhoven and, having conceded just 24 goals in his final campaign in the Netherlands, he also impressed against Spurs in the old UEFA Cup in fact, it was his performances against them that brought him to their attention. Gomes performances for Spurs were erratic to say the least. He showed some signs of a brilliant ability to shot-stop, but his handling and willingness to commit himself was poor and he cost Spurs several points in his time at the club. His main problem was that he was severely lacking in self-confidence. This was epitomised when Brad Friedel who was 40 years old at the time arrived as Gomes' competition in 2011. The Brazilian lost his place, seemed content to be a squad player and spent a couple of years out in the cold before startinh to express discontent at his treatment and was loaned out to 1899 Hoffenheim in 2013. He didnt impress in Germany and he has recently moved to Championship side Watford on a free transfer.
10. Ben Thatcher (£5 Million)
Prior to landing new signing Ben Davies for £10 million, Spurs hadn't really spent an awful lot on left backs, but Ben Thatcher was relatively costly and didn't perform well at all. He was brought in by George Graham despite the fact that he was never really good enough to be playing for a club at the top end of the Premier League table a point epitomised by the fact that, once Graham had left the club just a few months after the defender arrived and been replaced by Glenn Hoddle, Thatcher barely featured for the club again. In a nutshell, he lacked talent. He was a rash, overly aggressive player with a tendency to lash out needlessly. When he joined Spurs, Thatcher indicated that he hoped it would help him achieve his ambitions of playing for England a mere two years later he had given up on the idea and opted to play for Wales (for whom he only played for seven times). By that time, hed already joined Leicester City for just £300,000 a £4.7 million loss on a 27 year old player signed just two years earlier.
9. Sebastian Bassong (£8 Million)
Spurs signed Sebastien Bassong from Newcastle United just one season after the Magpies had signed him from French club Metz. The £8 million fee represented a sixteen-fold profit for Newcastle, who had paid just half a million pounds for the Cameroon international, despite the fact he had only made 26 league starts for the North East club. Unfortunately, in a spell at Spurs that would be three times the size of his spell in Newcastle, Bassong only managed seven more league starts than he did for the Magpies. He failed to stamp his authority on the first team, couldn't hold down a place and was soon surplus to requirements. A loan spell at Wolves when they were in the Premier League was followed by a permanent move to Norwich City, who were also in the Premier League at the time. The fee was undisclosed but it almost certainly represented a loss for Spurs. Bassong now still plays with the Canaries in the Championship, following their relegation last year.
8. Jonathan Woodgate (£8 Million)
Jonathan Woodgate was a top player in his time, but his huge injury proneness meant that he very rarely contributed close to enough to the clubs he played for (he's at Middlesbrough now and barely plays). He spends most of his time in the treatment room and unable to play. When he joined Spurs, he cost the club £8 million (from Middlesbrough, incidentally) and he lasted three and a half years at White Hart Lane. However, during that spell, he only managed 49 Premier League appearances and just 65 in total (and, when he did play, he left the field more times than anyone would care to count). Woodgate and Ledley King could have been a world class central defensive partnership for Spurs, had they both been fully fit, but they simply never were. Still, at least Ledley King didn't cost the club £8 million, only stay for three years and barely play at all.
7. Alan Hutton (£9 Million)
Alan Hutton cost Spurs £9 million - a risky deal for a player who had only ever played in Scottish football, even if it was the then very dominant Glasgow Rangers. Scottish football is (quite literally) in a different league to the Premier League in England and paying that much for someone was always likely to end badly. The Scotland international right back proved himself to be a hugely overpriced player who simply wasn't cut out for life at the top end of the Premier League. He made 39 league starts in three and a half seasons at the club a spell that included a loan stint at Sunderland. He now plays for Aston Villa, having moved there permanently. He has spent loan spells away from Villa Park at Nottingham Forest, Real Mallorca and Bolton Wanderers, but appears to have finally broken in to the Villains' first team.
6. Erik Lamela (£30 Million)
First of all, it's only fair to say that Erik Lamela hasn't delivered YET. Of the players on this list who are still at Spurs, he seems the one most likely to deliver eventually, but it is definitely fair to say that he hasn't so far. Lamela cost a club record fee of £30 million when he joined Spurs from Roma last summer and a lot was expected of him very quickly - perhaps a little unfairly, given his age, the change in style of play and culture and the pressure he will have been carrying on his shoulders. He had a torrid first season, performing poorly when he did play and spending much of it out injured with a bad back, leading some critics to say he was a waste of money. That said, Lamela's attitude this season has been great. He appeared happier, more a part of the group and positive and excited about the season during the club's pre-season and his performances so far have been much more encouraging than last year. Still, he has a long way to go before he pays of his hefty fee.
5. Paulinho (£17 Million)
Like Erik Lamela, Paulinho was Spurs' record signing last summer - albeit only for a brief amount of time - when he joined from Corinthians in his homeland of Brazil for £17 million. While showing some encouraging signs - contributing a couple of goals and performing particularly well in the odd games, such as the one at Stoke City - that fee seems to be far too much. More often than not, Paulinho was very underwhelming and massively failing to live up to his billing of "Tottenham's Frank Lampard". He had a terrible World Cup with Brazil and was singled out for criticism by his own fans and, in contrast to Lamela, he doesn't seem to be showing any signs of improvement this season and isn't in Mauricio Pochettino's first choice eleven.
4. Wilson Palacios (£12 Million)
Having previously played for Olimpia in his homeland of Honduras, Wilson Palacios impressed enough in one season with Wigan Athletic in the Premier League for Spurs to splash out £12 million on the midfielder. The battling enforcer's time at White Hart Lane wielded mixed levels of success. He started his Spurs career very well notching an assist in his first match against Bolton Wanderers and earning the Man of the Match award in his second match in the North London derby against Arsenal - but he struggled to hold down his place in the team after that and he was limited to 21 appearances in his second and final season at the club. Palacios would be shipped out to Premier League rivals Stoke City for a fee of around £6 million in 2011, giving Spurs a 50% loss on a player they had bought just two years earlier and, at 27, a player who should really have been in his physical prime. He wasn't a bad player for Spurs, but a £12 million player he certainly was not.
3. David Bentley (£15 Million)
Poor David Bentley finds himself in an awfully large number of negative articles here at WhatCulture.com, but nobody should really be surprised by that. The former England man cost Spurs £15 million - which was one of the largest fees they'd paid for a player at that point (2008) - and he failed to deliver quite spectacularly. Touted as the next David Beckham, Bentley had impressed in his time at Blackburn Rovers, earning himself a reputation as a set-piece specialist and scoring a decent number of goals for a right winger - but it just didn't work out at White Hart Lane. Aside from a great goals against rivals (and one of his former clubs) Arsenal, he did very little and was loaned out no less than four times (to Birmingham, West Ham, FC Rostov and previous club Blackburn, respectively) and couldn't get in the first team - largely due to what some people say was a bad attitude. He has now retired from football, even though he has only just turned 30 years of age.
2. Roberto Soldado (£26 Million)
Like both Erik Lamela and Paulinho before him on this list, Roberto Soldado was Spurs' record signing for a period last summer, as he arrived from Valencia for £26 million. Like both Erik Lamela and Pauilinho, he had a very disappointing first season. He scored just six Premier League goals - only two of which came from open play, as he scored four penalties - and really struggled to adapt to English football (perhaps thanks to being played as a lone frontman, which doesn't suit his style of play). In terms of the future, he kind of falls between Lamela and Paulinho. While Lamela is expected to go on to shine and Paulinho's days at the club seem somewhat numbered, the jury is still out with Soldado. He appears to be in the manager's plans for the time being, but isn't starting and needs to come good quick if he is to make it at Spurs or be truly branded a flop.
1. Sergei Rebrov (£11 Million)
In the year 2000, Spurs smashed their then transfer record by signing Ukrainian international striker Sergei Rebrov for £11 million from Dynamo Kiev. He arrived with a big reputation, having formed a famous and formidable strike partnership with the legendary Andrei Shevchenko at both club and international level. However, in 59 Premier League games for Spurs, 37 of which were starts, Rebrov only managed ten league goals. His time at White Hart Lane saw him twice shipped out on loan to Turkish side Fenerbahce and he would eventually sign for Spurs Premier League rivals West Ham United, for free, in 2004. £11 million well spent he was not and he certainly didn't deliver the goods expected of him. So there you have it - the most expensive Spurs eleven that simply failed to deliver (that team came to £148.8 million, for the record). Did you enjoy this article? Do you agree with the entries on this list? Which other expensive Spurs signings failed to deliver? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below. And please feel free to follow me on Twitter!