Man Utd: 10 Stats That Prove Moyes Is Getting It All Wrong

By Joshua Jones /

Its quite clear for all to see that United are definitely not the same team under David Moyes as they were under Sir Alex Ferguson, despite having incredibly similar personnel on the pitch. Manchester United have racked up a disappointing 34 points from their first 20 Premier League games (1.7 points per game) and subsequently languish in 7th place, a massive 11 points behind leaders Arsenal and a win behind 6th placed Spurs. Not only are they all but out of the title race before the end of the January transfer window, they also suffered a 2-1 home defeat at the hands of misfiring Swansea City to knock them out of the FA Cup 3rd round for the first time since a single Jermain Beckford goal knocked the Reds out in 2010. On top being out of the FA Cup, they face a fight to stay in the Capital One Cup too, as they must now overhaul a 2-1 deficit against bottom-of-the-league Sunderland to get to the final of the cup they last won in the same year they were last knocked out of FA Cup at the 3rd round stage (Could it be an omen?). If it is to be an omen, they will face a massive challenge in the final from fierce rivals Manchester City, who's 5-0 first leg victory over West Ham seems to have them all but through. But what is it that Moyes is getting so horribly wrong? Here is a look into some of the stats that he needs to change soon.

5 Incredible Facts

Swansea's FA Cup 3rd Round victory was their first win at Old Trafford in their 102 year history. Newcastle's 1-0 win was their first at Old Trafford since 1972 (41 years) West Brom's 2-1 win was their first at Old Trafford since 1978 (35 years) Everton's 1-0 win was their first at Old Trafford since 1992 (21 years) This has been Manchester United's worst start since it cost Ron Atkinson his job in 1986.

10. Why Does Ferdinand Play?

A damning stat for the ageing defender if ever there was one, but United have won just two of the seven games in which Rio Ferdinand has featured, compared to eight of the thirteen he hasn't played in. That is even more stark a revelation when you consider the win percentages involved: 29% with and 62% without. In fact, the evidence is damning from all angles regarding Ferdinand, regardless of how important he has been in the past for United. The Red Devils have so far managed to score 1.4 goals a game with Ferdinand in the side, compared to 1.8 without him, and have conceded an average of 1.4 goals per game with him in the squad, and 1.1 without him. So the question remains, besides experience, which of course has a less tangible impact on a team's fortunes than say goals or interceptions, what exactly does Ferdinand actually bring to the United team anymore? He seems detrimental in both starting attacks and halting them and the 29% win rate surely must condemn the 35-year old to the bench for the rest of the season.

9. Why Was Fellaini Signed?

In his last 18 Premier League appearances (10 for old club Everton and 8 for United) big money signing Marouane Fellaini has not been involved in a single goal. That means he hasn't scored OR provided an assist in his last 18 league games, which is remarkably poor for a player supposedly famed for his value from midfield. So far this season for United, Patrice Evra has scored and provided an assist, Chris Smalling and Tom Cleverley have both scored and Wayne Rooney (who cost just £3 million more than Fellaini in 2006) has 9 goals and 9 assists in his last 17 league games. A more damning statistic for Moyes however, is that the two Everton players he probably should have signed - Seamus Coleman and Leighton Baines - have 8 goals between them already for Moyes' former club already this season. If it wasn't for players like Andy Carroll and Fernando Torres, Fellaini might just be the biggest waste of money in recent Premier League history, but there's time yet.

8. United Just Don't Create Chances

This season, United are creating a grand total of 5 shots on target per game on average, and with a conversion rate of just 16%, it's no surprise United haven't been scoring too many goals. Which is not what you want when you're trying to win the league. Though it is possibly unfair to directly compare, given the horde of strikers they have, neighbours Man City have a staggering 14 more goals already, and worse, United currently have the scorers of 16 of their goals on the sidelines nursing injuries. This leaves Danny Welbeck (8) as the club's highest scoring starter with 18-year old Adnan Januzaj second on just 3. With a distinct lack of chances being created, and even less being scored, it's no surprise that United have fallen to defeat numerous times this season, having been outscored by teams with notoriously misfiring strikers - including goal-shy Newcastle United, and more recently Tottenham Hotspur and Swansea City. Moyes must get his players creating (and converting) more chances if his team are to climb into Champions League contention.

7. What Does Young Do?

Granted, Ashley Young may come up with some brilliant moments of skill - most notably his goal against Stoke in the League Cup - but the main purpose of his position in the side is to create goals, which he simply hasn't done this season. In his 10 league games so far this season, the former Watford and Aston Villa winger is yet to register an assist for United - having created just 8 chances in those games. There's no avoiding that that is a terrible return for a player who sits in the top six assist givers since the beginning of the 2007/08 season (alongside fellow United players Nani, Robin van Persie and Wayne Rooney; Barcelona's Cesc Fabregas and the only opposition Premier League player on the list, Steven Gerrard). It seems all Young has been useful for this season is diving about and passing on his techniques to young Adnan Januzaj, who is currently making as much a name for himself through simulation as he is for making and scoring great goals.

6. Old Trafford Is A Fortress No More!

Under Sir Alex Ferguson in 2012-13, Manchester United's home win percentage was a staggering 84%, the best in the Premier League, which is precisely why they won the league back from Man City. In the three seasons prior to that it was 79%, 95% and 84%, all of which are the form of contenders. But this season, under David Moyes, United have an abysmal home win percentage of just 45% (and a loss percentage of an incredible 36% - higher than any season in Fergie's 27 season tenure,) which is just not good enough. Losses against Newcastle, Everton, Tottenham and West Brom, as well as draws against Chelsea and Southampton have meant United have won just 5 of their 11 home games and only 1 against a team in the top 10 (Arsenal). Under Fergie, Old Trafford was a fortress, but under David Moyes, teams are no longer fearful of their visit to The Theatre of Dreams and are taking away points, including 3 for a Newcastle side who had never won at Old Trafford in more than 40 years.

5. Are United Predictable?

It may seem daft, but could Manchester United be too predictable? A staggering 43% of the side's attacks have come down the right wing - primarily from Valencia and Rafael - and teams will be well aware of this fact, no doubt factoring it into pre-match preparation. An over-reliance on the pace and power of Valencia and under-performing counterparts in Nani and Young could cause United to be incredibly easy to predict - especially with Cleverley providing next to nothing through the centre. With knowledge that United are reliant on the right, teams will naturally play their better players on the left in hope of combating this, or at least doubling up when defending against the right-hand sided players. Unless Moyes can get his wingers performing on both sides of the pitch, he's going to pull some sort of metaphorical rabbit from a hat (or an expensive one from the transfer window.)

4. Smalling Needs To Stop

So far this season, in 14 appearances, Chris Smalling has given the ball away an average of 7 times per game. This is simply not acceptable for a defender at any level, never mind one at a club like Manchester United. This shocking stat isn't his only transgression this season, however, and by all accounts the England stopper has had a poor term. His pass completion rate of just 80% is the second lowest of any Manchester United player to take part in a game this season, and that cannot be allowed to carry on at the top level of domestic football, especially in a team that plays progressive football from the back and doesn't look to smash it forward to a big striker. By consistently playing Smalling, Moyes is allowing his opponents to win the ball back easily from a weak link in a key position and if he carries on giving the ball away, United just won't improve.

3. Inferiority To City In Every Way

Cross over to the other side of Manchester, and Manuel Pellegrini has finally achieved the perfect balance of brilliant attacking talents and solid defensive tactics. Free scoring Manchester City 'out-stat' their rivals in almost every way: the Citizens have had 278 shots on goal this season, resulting in 59 goals for their impressive crop of strikers (who are enough to keep Stevan Jovetic out of the team entirely.) At the other end of the pitch, City have conceded 23 goals - thus outscoring their cumulative opponents by 36 goals - and spectacularly so in some individual games - even if they made hard work of their last game at Newcastle. United on the other hand have had just 218 shots on goal this season, resulting in only 35 goals - having conceded 24. United are even eclipsed by their former selves, having had over 40 more shots and scoring 15 more goals last season. If United are to stand any chance of getting anywhere near the rivals, they'll need to stop getting out done by them against their opposition.

2. Mr.Reliable Hasn't Been Reliable

During the 2012-13 season, it seemed that United could rely on Javier Hernandez to come on and score if they were ever in a rut - he was quickly becoming the new Solksjaer, even if he possibly wasn't happy with his lack of starts himself. This season, however, that hasn't been the case: the Mexican striker has scored just 1 goal in 13 games so far, and hasn't scored at all in his last 8 league games, which is a remarkably poor return for Mr.Reliable. With United struggling to score goals and Robin van Persie and Wayne Rooney sidelined with long-term injuries, Moyes is therefore relying on Welbeck and Hernandez to deliver the goods for Manchester United. With Welbeck keeping up his side of the bargain, Hernandez has struggled to reclaim the form he found under Ferguson and United are suffering as a result.

1. The Death Of Fergie Time

Possibly one of the most damning stats of Moyes' reign is the death of Fergie Time. In the first 20 games of this season, Manchester United have claimed 0 points in the last 10 minutes of games, in stark contrast to last season, when under Sir Alex, United claimed 11 points with goals in the last 10 minutes of games. The idea of Fergie Time might be something of a joke now, but those stats are a testament to Ferguson's ability to motivate his team into putting their all in during the last 10 minutes. Even more disappointing for David Moyes is the fact that United are now more likely to lose points in Fergie Time than they are to gain them. The Red Devils have lost 5 points (the same as Fulham) from goals in the last 10 minutes - a 16 point turnaround from the same time last season. This stat, along with the previous 9, goes some way to exposing the errors of David Moyes in his first 6 months at the helm of Manchester United Football Club. Do you think David Moyes can turn around Manchester United's fortunes this season? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.