Man Utd: 8 People Who Openly Criticised Van Gaal

The Dutchman has a habit of not exactly making friends.

By Simon Harrison /

Louis van Gaal's Premier League debut wasn't exactly the stuff dreams are made of, as the new Dutch coach played out a 2-1 defeat in his inaugural match at Old Trafford. As is the customary nature of the English top flight and all of the expectation that goes along with it, the more sensationalist of supporters may already consider the former Netherlands manager as under heavy pressure. The Red Devils' new coach, however, is no stranger to criticism, having plied his trade for both his country and top European clubs, with no external pressure as great as the objectives and aims he places on himself. Due to his unique methodology of coaching and also meshing together a cohesive squad, Van Gaal has had plenty of critics over his long career, with both fellow coaches, former players and journalists having unsavoury words to say about the Dutchman's practice. When departing from Barcelona, he mustered up the famous line: "Friends of the press. I am leaving. Congratulations." What can be certain, is that Van Gaal isn't in last chance saloon, but merely months into his Man United tenure, he has already been subject to differing criticism - something the former Ajax coach will definitely have prepared himself for - after all, you have to have thick skin in order to be a football manager at the pinnacle of the sport.

8. Alexander Buttner

One of the more low-key departures from Old Trafford this summer was that of Dutch left-back Alexander Buttner, who had previously shown flexibility as a converted winger at his former club Vitesse. Though he wasn't given an abundance of minutes during his two years at Man United, there were certainly sour grapes with regard to the manner in which he completed his permanent transfer to Dynamo Moscow. Given the utilisation of Dirk Kuyt as a wing-back during the World Cup in Brazil, the Dutchman left as though he was "unfairly ignored" before his time at the Red Devils came to a close. Using a rather small sample size to argue his corner, Buttner drew upon his Man of the Match winning performance against Bayern Munich in the Champions League, where the 25-year-old came out victorious in his duel against Netherlands international Arjen Robben. Due to the limited nature of Kuyt's delegated job during the World Cup, Buttner remains of the belief that he could have donned the shirt of Man United for at least another season, as he told the Sun: "When I see how the left-back position was filled against Argentina, I know I could have played there." "I'm disappointed in Van Gaal for not giving me a chance."

7. Dennis Bergkamp

While not a direct criticism of Van Gaal, during Bergkamp's biography 'Stillness And Speed,' the former Ajax forward has a few choice words to say about the Man United coach's philosophy and how he constructs his sides. While the likes of Johann Cruyff relied upon individual brilliance to inspire his playing side, Van Gaal asks from his players the exact opposite, with the team coming before any particular talent. While the selection of a captain is a mantle the Red Devils' boss has been proven to take seriously, above all, the system and the collective come before any star player. "But what if you have ten mediocre painters and Rembrandt?" Bergkamp questions. "Do you tell Rembrandt he does not have to imagine and that he doesn't represent more than the others? Or are you going to give him the feeling that he is special and let him display it, so he can produce his finest work." The autocratic managerial style of Van Gaal may kick-start a stagnant Man United, with all players pulling for the same common cause of sheer improvement, but there is a risk that the lack of liberty within the coach's training methods could leave the more ego-driven players to question their worth and feel they are appreciated within such an egalitarian dressing room.

6. Zlatan Ibrahimovic

The following example certainly illustrates how a world-class player can become frustrated and alienated in the conditions which Van Gaal imposes upon his personnel. Known for his outlandish comments and perceived arrogance, Zlatan Ibrahimovic is man a who became disillusioned with life under the current Man United boss and shows no signs of forgiving his former superior. In a revealing interview with Sports Illustrated, the Swedish international was highly critical of the Dutchman's treatment of his players, which perhaps could be seen to link back to Van Gaal's days as a P.E teacher. "He's the boss and everybody else can, how do you say - they're soldiers. I mean, you have to have a little bit of feeling in the whole thing. Many big stars have problems with him because of the way he is. "And I understand it, but when you come to a team with 22 big stars, that's what you treat them like? Like small boys?" Zlatan arguably isn't the best barometer of criticism, or indeed of reality at the best of times, but his criticism does at least offer an insight into how a superstar, self-anointed galactico would view Van Gaal's methods.

5. Paul Scholes

In his newly adopted pundit role, Paul Scholes has gone from press recluse to enjoying himself in front of the camera, with plenty of opinions to go along with his presence on BT Sport on the opening day of the season. Criticising the manner in which Van Gaal's 3-5-2 system applied itself at Old Trafford, Scholes harked back to his former club's success of old, with entertainment appearing to be high on the ex-midfielder's agenda. "When you look at United the last 20 years, it's been 4-4-2 or 4-4-1-1 and that was where we had all our success. 3-5-2 may be something Van Gaal is a little obsessed with because it worked in the World Cup for him - there's no doubt about that. "But this crowd need a little bit of excitement and for me 3-5-2 is not a boring way of playing but it is a very slow way of playing, all about possession rather than having that thrust and ability to score goals," he reasoned. While Van Gaal adopting a rather negative 3-5-2, as opposed to his regular 4-3-3 variants, suggests that the Dutchman doesn't have the players at his disposal to stick strictly to his own philosophy, first-day criticisms were always likely.

4. Sam Allardyce

Adopting the same line of critique as Scholes, West Ham boss Sam Allardyce also shared his penny's worth about one of the newer tactical introductions to the Premier League over the past year. Last season, Hull tinkered with the 3-5-2 formation, allowing for a fairly comfortable consolidation campaign for Steve Bruce, but this year sees Queens Park Rangers and Man United lining up with three men at the back on the opening day. "'Cause it's the old World Cup fad they think, look, it's happening at the World Cup let us have a try at it," the Hammers' boss told Sky Sports. "Systems are needed to be associated to the players you have available at your club. I think for me, personally, and this is only a personal opinion and not every manager's opinion of course, and certainly by the looks of it not Louis van Gaal's opinion, that he's more into the system that he wants rather than the players he has playing to the system that maybe suit them. "But I think systems are about suiting the players that you have available to you and that gets the best out of them in the end. In the end they're not the all-important thing, the most important thing is understanding each other as individuals, understanding our strengths and weaknesses and working within the system that we play to our best ability. "If you get that, then you get results and if you don't get that then systems don't mean that much, 'cause it still breaks down whatever system you play and then you lose football matches." Self-awareness hasn't always been Big Sam's strongest point - considering he identified himself as a prime candidate to manage Real Madrid, despite the obvious issues with that assessment, but it's hard to actually disagree in this respect. There have been other accusations that Van Gaal is merely using the system without considering the players he has available, which is why he was forced to start with Tyler Blackett on Saturday, and also why he was forced to change the system at half-time.

3. Raymond Verheijen

No stranger to criticising Man United's training methods, former Wales fitness coach Raymond Verheijen saw fit to lay the blame for Luke Shaw's hamstring injury at Van Gaal's door. Naming double sessions and trying to get the former Southampton star up to match condition too quickly as the factors behind the Englishman's injury woe, Verheijen took to his favourite medium of Twitter to air his grievances against the Dutchman's regime at Old Trafford. Finding a correlation between the Netherlands' niggling injuries during the World Cup, Verheijen labelled Van Gaal's methods as culpable: "At Man United, in the first few weeks, LVG has applied the same approach and, as expected, with the same result: accumulation of injuries. "The Luke Shaw case is the climax of Manchester United's predictable pre-season injury crises due to 'too much training too soon.'" "LVG is tactically superior to most other coaches, but planning and periodisation is not his strongest point: double sessions and muscle injuries." Having been a stern critic of former United boss David Moyes, Verheijen doesn't appear to be taking his gaze from Old Trafford, with Van Gaal his new target.

2. Rivaldo

Another example of possible mismanagement from Van Gaal, is that of the saga involving Rivaldo during the Dutchman's tenure at Barcelona. Despite enjoying success with Brazil at the 2002 World Cup, Rivaldo was to come back down to Earth with a bump, upon hearing the news of ex-coach Van Gaal returning to Camp Nou for his second stint in charge - a superior which the Brazilian didn't quite see eye-to-eye with. At first, Rivaldo appeared to be able to put his differences aside, announcing that he would be prepared to play wherever Van Gaal asked him to, even in goal. A strange and possibly facetious comment, given how the Brazilian had previously made his disdain public when the Dutchman fielded him on the left-hand side rather than centrally. When making his way from Camp Nou due to what the club director labelled a 'technical decision', Rivaldo had something rather profound to say on television in his native country. "Van Gaal is the main cause of my departure. I don't like Van Gaal and I am sure that he doesn't like me, either."

1. Johan Cruyff

The clash of ideas and philosophies between Johan Cruyff and Van Gaal was always going to end in disagreement. While Cruyff felt his way through matches, playing through intuition and organically, Man United's coach prefers a stricter and more meticulous approach, one which would strangle the liberal nature of Cruyff's ideals, despite Van Gaal taking plenty of inspiration from 'Total Voetbal'. "Van Gaal has a good vision of football, but it is not mine. He wants to gel winning teams and has a militaristic way of working with his tactics. I don't. I want individuals to think for themselves. "You judge players intuitively and with your heart. On the basis of the criteria which are now in use at Ajax I would have failed the test. My two qualities were great technique and insight, which happen to be two things you can't measure with a computer." Much of the criticism levelled at Van Gaal boils down to his militaristic and autocratic approach, with certain star players feeling under-appreciated, but following the lack of strict ideas and direction at Old Trafford under David Moyes, the Dutchman is definitely an astronomical improvement - with the track record of making big decisions regardless of player or press backlash. Which other criticisms of Van Gaal deserve to be on this list? Share your thoughts below.