Transfer window deadline day. For Manchester United fans, it promised so much and delivered so little. "Silly season" is over again for another four months and the dust has settled following a crazy 24 hours that saw Premier League clubs set new spending records. In total, £140 million was spent on deadline day in England, and United's outlay on players accounted for only £27.5 million of that. By contrast, Arsenal spent £42.4 million on Mesut Ozil, while the Red Devils were completely blown out of the water in fiscal terms earlier in the window as Tottenham spent over £100 million Manchester City £90 million and Chelsea £66 million. That really puts into perspective just how disappointing United's summer has been as the champions were left behind by their main title competitors. While City have signed Alvaro Negredo, Stevan Jovetic, Fernandinho, Jesus Navas and Martin Demichelis, the Red Devils signed Guillermo Varela and Marouane Fellaini. Where did it all go wrong? The finger of blame must be pointed at United's new Executive vice-chairman, Ed Woodward - a David Gill he ain't - but mostly at new manager David Moyes. The Scotsman failed spectacularly in this summer's window, and here, we perform the autopsy on his dismal transfer dealings at Old Trafford.
5. Wasting Too Much Time On Cesc Fabregas
Far, far too much time was wasted in the pursuit of Barcelona's Cesc Fabregas this summer. United's interest in the midfielder started on July 15 with a £25 million bid, which was considered but ultimately determined to have fallen below Barca's valuations. Then, on July 22nd, a second bid of £30 million was made, which prompted the Spanish giants to come out and declare the player was not for sale. Yet until as recently at August 24, one month later, Moyes was still chasing the ex-Arsenal captain and was considering a £40 million offer. Meanwhile, while all this was happening, more affordable and realistically available players such as Luka Modric, Ander Herrera and Daniele De Rossi were being overlooked. United came in with a bid for De Rossi last Friday, three days before the closure of the transfer window, and it was already too late. Instead of persuing alternative targets sooner, Moyes was too hung up on capturing Fabregas.
4. Not Bidding For Thiago Alcantara
United were strongly linked with Barcelona's Thiago Alcantara earlier this summer and were even though to have agreed a £17 million deal with his club for the midfielder to join on a five-year contract. His move to Old Trafford was considered imminent - that was until he signed for Bayern Munich instead. And it has since transpired United didn't even put a bid in. The youngster joined the German giants for £21.6 million and it is astonishing that Moyes didn't try to land him for that amount. Considered one of the finest young talents in the game, Alcantara's original release clause was £77 million, but because he didn't play a set amount of games for Barcelona the season prior, he was allowed to leave for a fraction of that amount. Which makes it all the more unforgivable that Moyes didn't enter the race at all. United have been crying out for a new midfielder all summer, following the retirement of Paul Scholes, and Thiago would have been the ideal solution to their problems in those regards.
3. Undervaluing Key Players
As well as a new midfielder, United also needed a new left-back this summer and were as such linked with Everton's Leighton Baines. With Patrice Evra now 32 and entering the winter of his career, bringing in a future, long-term replacement this summer was considered important. The Frenchman was at times a liability last season as United endured their worst defensive record in 11 years and though he has started this season promisingly, having a world-class left-back in the squad to provide him with competition would have only been a good thing. Evra's understudies, Fabio and Alexander Buttner, are nowhere near ready for first team football and if the former Monaco man gets injured later in the campaign, the Red Devils are going to be stretched. Baines is considered one of the best left-backs in England and might have joined United had he not been horrifically undervalued by Moyes. The Scotsman made two bids in the end for the defender, the first of £12 million on June 27 and another of the same amount on August 19. That second bid was of £28 million and also to include Marouane Fellaini but by valuing Baines at the same amount as an originally failed offer shows extreme naivity on Moyes's behalf. The United boss should have pushed the boat out for Baines and paid what it would have taken to land his services, but in the end he showed disrespect to Everton who correctly blasted his offer as "derisory and insulting".
2. Not Getting The Paperwork For Fabio Coentrao In On Time
On transfer deadline day, it emerged that United had made a shock loan bid for Real Madrid's Fabio Coentrao after giving up on Leighton Baines. By the time the 23:00 BST cut-off point had been and gone, confusion reigned as to whether or not United had actually been successful in signing the player. And the reports early this morning suggest they have failed due to the necessary paperwork not being filed in time, which again demonstrates staggering incompetence on Moyes's behalf. And it again proves that he simply left it far too late to complete deals. The bid for Coentrao came with just hours of the window remaining and was the very definition of "last ditch". United should have gone in for the Portugal international far sooner, and if they had, they might have landed their man.
1. Paying Over The Odds For Fellaini
The only thing David Moyes did right this summer was signing Marouane Fellaini but in the end he still managed to make a botched job of things by paying way over the odds for the midfielder. On August 19, Moyes made a £28 million bid for Leighton Baines AND Marouane Fellaini and yesterday paid £27.5 million for just Fellaini. You don't have to be a maths expert to work out that one simply does not add up. Talk about panic buying. There's no questioning Fellaini's ability, and he will doubtlessly improve United by lending them an imposing physical presence in the middle of the park and a persistent danger from set-pieces. But Moyes could have signed him for a LOT less. Why, for example, did United not activate the Belgian's £23.5 million release clause in July when they had the chance? If they were seriously interested in the player, surely that would have made better business sense. But, of course, they were holding out for better options at the time, like Fabregas, or De Rossi, or Ander Herrera, and in the end pressed the big red button on Fellaini. Did David Moyes fail in the transfer window this summer? Who should he have signed? Let us know in the comment section, below.