Newcastle: 10 Major Mistakes Pardew Has Made In 2014

Looking back at the worst year in modern NUFC history.

By Simon Gallagher /

On the back of two Premier League victories, things are finally looking up a bit for Newcastle, and the more optimistic of Toon fans will no doubt be hoping that this can be the start of the kind of run that turned the side into top 7 contenders for a brief period last season. Unfortunately for those fans, a lot has happened since that 7 win in 10 run at the end of 2013, and while many will continue to suggest that Newcastle's spectacular implosion in 2014 was all because of the sale of Yohan Cabaye, the manager has made far more individual errors that have contributed just as much. Newcastle have been a broken club in the past year, rudderless at times, playing entirely the wrong system and adopting a small club mentality that has bled into every performance at the most fundamental level. Most of those issues can be pinned on the manager, and while every Newcastle fan will hope that he can learn from the bleakest year in recent Newcastle history, it remains to be seen whether Pardew is the right man to identify and address everything that is wrong with his team. Here's hoping that the first two wins of this season will kick-start a change in the culture of the club, but for that to happen, Pardew cannot repeat any of these major mistakes.

10. That Bloody Set-Piece Model

The biggest benefit of Mike Williamson being injured is that it stops the team from setting up every single set-piece that isn't deemed direct (i.e. most of them) as a knock to the back post for the centre-half to head across the goal or into the back of the net. It might be a nice idea on paper, and Williamson's height can surely be seen as an advantage, but it fundamentally ignores three key points: 1. Mike Williamson cannot head balls where he wants to, or with enough power to trouble anyone. 2. Our set-piece takers usually cannot get it onto his head molested anyway. 3. We have literally six players on the pitch who would be more of a threat as the target for a crossed ball. Quite why the coaches have not realised that the current set-up has provided a worryingly low number of goals and is probably not the best way to go is baffling. Surely Pardew must have at least once scribbled something about it on his note-pad during a game?!

9. Playing Vurnon Anita In The Wrong Role Entirely

A lot has been said of Pardew's tendency to play square pegs in round holes, or just forcing the pegs where there's no hole in the first place, but it is an accusation that absolutely rings true in his use of a couple of Newcastle players. Persisting with Yoan Gouffran out wide gives Newcastle hard-work, but robs the Frenchman of his goal threat; playing Moussa Sissoko out on the right stops him putting in the kind of performance he did against Spurs, and most importantly, relying on Vurnon Anita as a defensive midfield enforcer fundamentally misunderstands what type of player he actually is. Unfortunately for Pardew, Anita is not Cheick Tiote: he will not bleed and make others bleed to stop the other team play, he is far more technical, far more creative, and completely unsuited to being a breaker in front of the defence. That is why he looks like he hasn't settled, as the manager so elegantly, and unnecessarily said before the Spurs game, and why fans insist on complaining about his height and weight.

8. Persisting With Paul Dummett

He might be a Geordie, and thus for some reason more worthy of praise than any other nationality of player in Newcastle's line-up apparently, but Paul Dummett is the third best left-back at the club at the minute. Even ignoring the claims of Davide Santon - who seems to have suffered the kind of mysterious injury that only afflicts players on the verge of being sold quietly - both Massadio Haidara and Vurnon Anita are better left-backs than the North Eastern Welsh international. His decision making is probably worse than Steven Talyor's, his attacking threat is precisely zero for 90% of the time, and his positional sense is catastrophic at times. He might be passionate, which goes along way with managers like Pardew, but he also invites way too much pressure down the left, and makes whoever plays in front of him look bad, unless they're willing to do as much running as Yoan Gouffran is. Simply put, he should not be in the first team as anything other than a back-up to the back-ups.

7. Not Working Harder To Get A Centre-Half In

There are inevitably suggestions every time the transfer window opens that Alan Pardew has absolutely no control over who is bought and who is sold for Newcastle, but the official club line reads that Pardew works with Graham Carr and Lee Charnley to identify targets, and run the rule over those that are presented by the scouting team. If that is indeed the case (and who knows if it is, really) then you have to question why Pardew didn't have a centre-half at the top of his agenda: he should have stated in no uncertain terms that he wanted additions to the back-line. Yes, Jamaal Lascelles was signed, and he is a major prospect, but sending him out on loan for another season, and generally relying on a Championship player to make an imemdiate impact in the Premier League was not the only answer Newcastle needed. Apparently, Newcastle did try to get another centre-back in, but were too late, which is frustrating consider there were suggestions that both Yanga-Mbiwa and Steven Taylor were available for transfers at one point this summer. If that really was the case, then more should have been done to bring in more cover, or even a first-teamer, considering Newcastle currently have only two fit.

6. Openly Criticising Young Players

As much as Paul Dummett is not good enough to play every game for Newcastle - particularly in the Premier League - there is no excuse for the manager singling him out for criticism, along with the likes of Sammy Ameobi, when he is so keen to protect his foreign players, as if they are somehow more fragile. At the minute, Newcastle's whole philosophy when it comes to youth is broken: players are signed, forgotten about, farmed out on loan and then castigated for not working hard enough in the rare cup games they are given an opportunity to shine in. They should obviously not be given hearty slaps on the back if they are not doing well, but there is something horribly disjointed in the way Pardew treats youngsters (and particularly British ones) compared to his protection of more experienced players who could probably cope with more criticism. Frankly, for a manager who prides himself on protecting players (his excuse for making excuses), the idea of public performance shaming is not really on, and you have to question how it will affect those players' confidence in the long term. In one breath he's saying Sammy Ameobi is brilliant, but then he questions why he hasn't made it in the Premier League yet (probably because he is dropped after every impressive cameo), and then calls him brilliant again. It's jarring even from the outside.

5. Not Playing Our Own Football

For most of the last year, because of the sale of Yohan Cabaye, Alan Pardew has adopted a small club mentality that has been roundly and fairly criticised by the fans. He has set up his teams, even at St. James' Park to play reductive football designed only to contain the opposition, rather than playing to the strengths of his own players. Too often, Newcastle have played on the back foot, allowing teams to play their own way, which inevitably gives even the less able teams confidence to play like the home side, knowing that Newcastle will only attack once their threat has been dealt with (if at all). There has been too little confidence in the past 12 months of football, and too much heavy reliance on deep lying defensive midfielders, when taking the game to the opposition would have been far more effective. And frankly, trying to play containment football against teams like Swansea is no more than an open statement that they're the superior team from the outset.

4. Blaming It On Ben Arfa

Don't blame it on the system, don't blame it on the lack of a plan B, don't lack it on the transfer policy. Blame it on Ben Arfa. Back in 2011/12, when Newcastle played as part of the attacking 4-3-3, Newcastle soared to fifth in the league on the back of a run of form that was as much down to Ben Arfa's enterprising approach play as it was down to Papiss Cisse's explosive striking form. The cogs worked together perfectly, but Demba Ba wasn't happy and Alan Pardew was forced to change his system to return the Senegalese striker to his preferred central position (ironically so he wouldn't lose him, which he ended up doing anyway). And then when Ben Arfa was given a different role entirely, and was expected to track back and contain the opposition, rather than simply looking to unlock attacking opportunities, he inevitably didn't work. He was a gold-plated, diamond, encrusted square peg thrust into a bland round hole, and of course he wasn't going to work: but Pardew took that ineffectiveness as some sort of personal slight, and basically accused Ben Arfa of being wilfully defiant, pinning the problems of his broken system onto the Frenchman's shoulders, hen he should have been working harder to accommodate his talents. Whether the criticism was fair is not the key thing here, because all Pardew did was make a martyr out of the player and force a wedge between himself and the fanbase.

3. Letting Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa Leave

The decision not to sign a centre-half this summer was already a bad decision with four centre-halves at the club, because two of them could and should have been improved upon. Mike Williamson is a solid enough option for the squad, and Steven Taylor seemed to have been written off entirely - not to mention the club's infuriating treatment of Yanga-Mbiwa - and reinforcements should have come in. But then, that lack of movement was proved even more ridiculous when Newcastle decided to go ahead with Yanga-Mbiwa's move to Roma on loan in the very last hours of the transfer window despite their apparent replacement falling through (and signing for Southampton, depending on who you believe it actually was). Pardew should have strongly protested the fact that he would be left with only three centre-halves - and pointed to the injury records of both Coloccini and Taylor - and told the club to hang their desire to reclaim the money they'd paid for Yanga. Instead, we now have two fit centre-halves and no opportunity to sign anyone until January, at which point prices will go up as selling clubs know full well how desperate Newcastle are for reinforcements.

2. Ignoring The Ineffectiveness Of His System

The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results, but nobody seems to have told Alan Pardew as much, as he has persisted with a reductive 4-2-3-1 system that was designed to take advantage of a number 10 that he didn't have at the end of last season thanks to the loss of Cabaye, and he hasn't got now thanks to the injury to Siem De Jong. Pardew needed to redevelop his tactical approach to use the players he actually had available, rather than wrongly assuming - as Louis Van Gaal was accused of at the start of the season - that the system would overcome issues with personnel. It would have been more sensible for most of this year either to play 4-3-3 (as Newcastle are now pretending to do, despite lining up in the same 4-2-3-1 formation when on the pitch), or reverting to 4-4-2, rather than isolating the lone striker, and asking the wide men to cover the full-backs. It just made Newcastle look toothless, and is the over-riding reason why the Goal Difference column has looked so unhealthy.

1. Not Keeping A Tight Hold On His Temper

As Pardew is probably now being briefed on a weekly basis by the "crisis management" team provided by Keith Bishop, the public image of a manager can go some way to appeasing the fan-base. Far worse managers than he have been enduringly popular with fans at other clubs because of the way they have carried themselves publicly, and even the most arrogant of managers have gained respect because they remain professional. Unfortunately for Pardew, he comes with something of a track record of touchline controversies and wayward behaviour, and the reckless decision to "push David Meyler away with his head" - as he maintained was his intention - against Hull last year was the final straw for fans who were already unhappy with the performances of the team. Despite the grumblings that greet every accusation, fans - even at Newcastle - are a fickle lot - and victories can change perceptions of managers very quickly (as they will if Pardew wins ten in a row), but it's far harder to forget a manager headbutting a player, or pushing a linesman, or calling a respected fellow manager a "c*nt" live on TV, especially when the team werent't winning. Jose Mourinho and Arsene Wenger get away with it because they're top four managers, and Louis Van Gaal's bullishness is applauded because he is turning Man utd around, but it's impossible to endure a manager making such primally poor decisions when the team are slumping to defeat after defeat. Which do you think has been Pardew's biggest mistakes this year? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.