Newcastle: 10 Things Pardew Should Be Applauded For

He wasn't the messiah, but the former Toon boss does deserve at least SOME credit. Doesn't he?

By Tom Astley /

So this is a tough one for even the biggest Pardew apologist to handle: what did Pardew ever do for the Toon? The suave, silver-tongued Cockney didn€™t exactly endear himself to the Geordie faithful over his atypically long tenure in charge at St. James' Park. He wasn€™t particularly wanted when he came, he wasn€™t particularly welcome when he was there, and he won€™t be particularly missed now he€™s jumped ship to Palace. Pardew took more flak that any manager in recent memory (apart from Joe Kinnear maybe, but it's questionable whether he even counts as a proper manger: most Toon fans try to think of Kinnear€™s time in charge as a particularly weird and unpleasant dream), and not all of it was down to the €œunrealistic expectations€ of the €œfickle fans€. From excuses upon excuses; signalling his discontent with Hull City€™s David Meyler by €œpushing him away with his head€; his self-admitted €œridiculous behaviour€, and, to put it modestly, questioning the age and anatomy of Man City manager Manuel Pellegrini; he spent a lot of time attempting to sabotage any glory he could have been due. But now that the dust is beginning to settle on Pardew€™s somewhat unexpected move to Crystal Palace (with three entirely unexpected wins on the bounce), it might be worth re-evaluating his tenure at the Toon. And in the harsh light of day, there€™s more than a few things that Pardew did in his time on Tyneside that might just warrant a begrudging round of applause from the Toon Army. Let the revisionist history begin.

10. He Won The Manager Of The Year Award

In the 2011-12 season, everything went right for Pardew. OK, not everything, but he won an award: manager of the year. A fifth place finish (more of which later, because the two deserve separate mention) represented a significant achievement for the club, and that was at least partially down to Pardew€™s policies and purchases. Although there's a lot to be said for Roberto Martinez€™s recent questioning of the game's obsession with dishing out individual awards in a team game, credit where credit€™s due: Pardew got a Newcastle team to punch well above its weight that season, and fully deserved the accolade. No other Newcastle manager has ever won the award, and Harry Redknapp is the only other English manager to win it, so that€™s one in the tick column.

9. He Stuck At His Playing Career

With the best will in the world, and that header for Palace in the Semi-final against Liverpool that every media outlet has been playing on repeat since he moved back there aside, Alan was never a world beater as a player. In fact, he was very nearly never a professional player at all. He stuck it out as a part-time, non-league player until he was in his late 20s, working as a glazier whilst playing for the likes of Whyteleafe and Epsom & Ewell ('who?' 'exactly'). In the mid-80s he even gave up football for a spell. But he stuck at it, kept going, and eventually got his move to the professional game. And in a modern football world, where nine year olds are bought and sold, where someone can be legitimately, and regularly, described as the €˜new Messi€™, despite the fact that the original (or €˜old€™) Messi is only 27, that is something of an achievement.

8. He Endured, Despite The Criticism

Pardew took that sticking power into his managerial career, particularly at the Toon. As every commentator was always keen on pointing out, 'Pards' was the 2nd longest serving manager in the Premier League when he left, and in the cut-throat world of managerial merry-go-rounds that€™s got to be worth something. During the most recent 'Sack Pardew' campaign, it became almost impressive to see how defiant Pardew could be. He turned oblivious struggle into an art form. He made deflection and excuse-making and €˜we€™ll take the lessons we€™ve learned today (in another drab defeat) into the next game€™ look less like defeatist apologies and more like some sort of stoic philosophical stance. And that personal defiance rubbed off, occasionally, on the team. Who could forget the fight back against Arsenal in the 4-4 game? The club has literally never witnessed anything as insane as that. Plunging from the depths of despair at half-time to a euphoria that was actually more frightening that pleasurable when Tiote€™s pile driver went in was one of the most amazing spectacles the Premier League has ever produced, whether you're a Newcastle fan or not. And Pardew was at the helm. If it was his fault the team had totally capitulated by half time, then it has got to be to his credit that they fought back. That game alone is worth applauding Pardew for. He gave the club that memory at least.

7. His Excuses Deflected Blame From Players

Perhaps the funniest, and most critical (certainly the most truthful) song about Pardew that rained down from the terraces was €œit€™s never your fault, it€™s never your fault, Alan Pardew, it€™s never your fault€. Pardew became famous for blaming anything and everything else for harrowing defeats... apart from himself: The Olympics, the wealth of other teams, the Notting Hill Carnival, not to mention underhanded jabs at the fans for not supporting the team. In fact, so famous and absurd did his list of excuses become, that the €˜sack Pardew€™ website included a random excuse generator on their home page. But, excuses aside, for the most part, Pardew had a skill for managing to deflect criticism and negativity from the terraces away from the players €“ and honestly, more than a few of them have deserves their fair share of blame for some of the terrible runs the Toon have put together of late. It could be argued that putting the blame on a wide variety of sources kept dressing room morale up at a time when it really should have been on the floor, and he deserves a little bit of credit, however inadvertent, for that.

6. He Looked Pretty Sharp

Alright, it might be scraping the barrel already, and this is only number six on the list... But come on, those thick rimmed, hipster glasses, those crisp suits, those pencil ties, the suave, silver fox side-parting. And that time he tried growing designer stubble. Alright, all of these things mean absolutely nothing in footballing terms (or they certainly shouldn€™t) but at least he cut a respectable figure on the touchline (at least visually, when he wasn€™t swearing at other managers, pushing over linesmen or nutting opposition players). He looked a lot better than a dishevelled and confused Joe Kinnear in his horrible machine-wash polyester suits that looked like they€™d been in mothballs since his €˜heyday€™ in the 80s when he €˜won every trophy going€™. €˜At least Alan Pardew wasn€™t Joe Kinnear.€™ Is that all we€™ve got in terms of compliments? Oh dear.

5. His Record Against Chelsea

This season€™s victory at home to Chelsea was particularly sweet €“ and if there's one thing worth applauding Alan Pardew for, then it should be that he managed to wipe the smug grin off of Jose Mourinho€™s face (at least for this season), and pop the increasingly obnoxious bubble of the €˜new invincibles€™ that was being blown around Stamford Bridge. In fact, that game summed up most of Pardew€™s reign (most of NUFC€™s history, when it comes to it): moments of brilliance, moments of defiance, catastrophe (having to sub on a rookie goalie, who has since proved that he is far from able to do the job that was asked of him, Steven Taylor€™s needless red card), and then anxious holding on that isn€™t even really fun to endure, followed by a reaffirmation of the reason the Toon Army can€™t help but love the club in the end. Then there was Cisse€™s double at the Bridge. Beautiful. Applause due.

4. He Put Up With Mike Ashley€™s Restrictions

Most of the blame for Newcastle€™s recent failings shouldn€™t be exclusively laid at Pardew€™s door. The big man upstairs (emphasis on the €˜big€™) has to shoulder a lot of the blame for the restrictive conditions under which Pardew was working, and under which the fans continue to suffer. It€™s pretty clear that transfers, at least those leaving the club, weren€™t decided by Pardew at all, and he was made to look a fool by the way the Andy Carroll sale was handled. A less determined man might have spat his dummy and walked, but Pardew stuck at it, and made the best of what was often a pretty bad job (old clichés about the job being a poisoned chalice have at least a grain of truth in them).

3. He Finished 5th

Back to that season again. But it is easy to forget how unexpected that was, and what an achievement it represents for a side who had been hemorrhaging their best players to the €œso-called top four€ and elsewhere. There were moments in that season where the football was fluent and the side played with a swagger reminiscent of Keegan€™s side (the first time around). Or at least it was as close as we€™ve got to those dizzy heights since Bobby Robson was shown the door. That the club didn€™t build on that success, that they let the €˜prize€™ of Europa League action turn into a curse rather than a blessing, that they€™re now back to being as likely to struggle to stay up as they are to push for Europe shouldn€™t take away from the success of that season. Demba Ba€™s hat trick at Stoke, beating Man. United (always an unexpected, but delicious, treat in a season), beating Liverpool at home. Alright, the lads got a howking off Fulham and Spurs, but they finished above Chelsea, and that€™s got to be worth a round of applause in anyone€™s book. In fact, Cisse€™s brace at Stamford Bridge was worth the price of admission on its own for that season. The glory is shifting away from Pards a little bit here... but they were both fantastic goals, weren€™t they? And they happened whilst Pardew was manager, lest you forget.

2. He Listened To Graham Carr

When it turned out that Pardew was stalling on moving to Palace because he wanted to bring some backroom staff from NUFC, Toon fans worried that it must be head scout Graham Carr that was going to be travelling down the A1 (it turned out to be barrel-chested, crowd-baiting goalkeeper coach Andy Woodman, which was less of a concern, and even he hasn't upped sticks). Carr is widely praised for the astute singings that Newcastle have made, in particular the €˜French revolution€™ of players (emphasis on the €˜revolve€™, given how many of those players seem to be moving on to elsewhere), and Pardew should be applauded for listening to his advice. It€™s not just on bringing great, underrated players into the club €“ Ba, Cisse, Cabaye, Debuchy, Santon, Ayoze Perez, etc €“ that Pardew deserves some plaudits, but also on shipping out players who had outstayed their welcome as well. Alright, leaving out the "he's definitely staying - I guarantee he's staying - oh he's gone" debacle that surrounded the sale of Carroll (and Cabaye, to a lesser extent), the fact that some Toon fans would have Joey Barton back in a New York minute, and that Kevin Nolan clearly proved he had another season or two left in him after NUFC unceremoniously dumped him?... And did they really need to sell Demba Ba? Did they honestly put up as much of a fight as they could? And Debuchy... Ok, so maybe not all great.

1. He Finally Left, And For Actual Money!

So, a bit of a back-handed compliment to finish with, but think about it: after the second 0-3 against the mackems, most Toon fans would have carried him down to London personally. As recently as November, most Toon fans would have had a whip round to pay Pardew off, and it would have being a hefty pay off, mind you, given the length of Pardew€™s contract. But not only did he save the club a few quid (or, more precisely, save Ashley a few quid, which more than likely won€™t be seen in players on the pitch), he actually managed to make some dosh as well. It was reported that Palace forked out as much as £3.5 million to witness the €˜Pardew punch€™ (the celebration, not his tactic for discussing controversial decisions with the fourth official) for themselves. More importantly, by waiting until he was wanted elsewhere €“ by jumping before he was pushed €“ he has made the club look like a more welcoming place for the next incumbent (particularly, as seems likely, if they€™re coming in from abroad, and haven€™t paid close attention to the continual circus that is NUFC). If the media had been able to run with €˜fans push out Pardew€™, it might have made the next lunatic who sips from this particular poisoned chalice think twice before stepping in. Do you think Alan Pardew actually deserves praise for what he did at Newcastle? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.