UFC 174, from Vancouver, Canada, has come and gone. What have we learned? The card brought us the return of former UFC heavyweight champion Andrei Arlovski, a key welterweight bout between Tyron Woodley and Rory MacDonald with title implications, the debut of a pair of woman's bantamweight fighters on the big stage, some vicious injuries, and plenty to talk about. And lets not forget the flyweight title bout that headlined the card, a five round affair between Demitrious "Mighty Mouse" Johnson and Ali "the Puncher King" Bagautinov. Could Bagautinov upset the only flywight champion the UFC has ever known, or would it be a case of too much, too soon from the Dagestani fighter? Was it worth the money? Can the smaller weight classes hold their own when headlining a PPV card? Would Rory Macdonald mail in a lacklustre performance similar to his Ellenberger bout, or go back to his effective killer ways? Could Ryan Bader build from his dominant performance against Anthony Perosh while going up against stiffer competition in former Strikeforce Champion Rafael "Feijao" Cavalcante? Lets take a look at 10 things we learned from UFC 174: Johnson vs. Bagautinov
10. MMA Is A Dangerous, Dangerous Sport With Seriously Tough Athletes
UFC 174 saw no less than three vicious injuries take place in the ring. Not as vicious as Anderson Silva's leg break, or Cung Le breaking Frank Shamrock's arm, perhaps, but still vicious. On the undercard, Valerie Letourneau appeared to suffer a broken orbital bone early on in her fight against Elizabeth Phillips, but carried on through the fight to claim a split decision win in what was essentially a three-round war. By the end, her eye had nearly swollen shut. In the main card opener, Ryan Jimmo called out that his arm was broken as Ovince St. Preux worked on a Kimura in the second round, ending their fight. And in the very next match, Brendan Schaub may have suffered a break as well, in this case to his jaw. Three possible breaks in a single card. And two of those three saw the injured fighter keep fighting to the end of the match. MMA is not for the weak of heart, that's for sure. Plenty of safeguards are in place, of course, with doctors cageside, and refs who are trained to stop the fight whenever necessary, but it was still a rough night for injures. Full credit to Jimmo, Letourneau, and Schaub for enduring it all.
9. Flyweights Can Headline
It wasn't Demetrious "Mighty Mouse" Johnson's best fight as champ, but it was a solid effort against a game opponent. The action was there, the speed was there, they put on a show. Does the buying public agree? We'll find out when the eventual PPV numbers come out (the UFC never releases them, but various insider experts including Wrestling Observer's Dave Meltzer tend to have a finger on these things), but the action in the cage was solid. If the PPV numbers are low - and there's a good chance they might be - it's not due to the product. These guys can headline, it might just take a little longer to get the general public to realize it.
8. Talk Of Weak Chins Is Just That - Talk
Remember Glass-jaw Schaub? Remember how Andrei Arlovski's career was over due to his glass chin and 4-fight losing streak? Forget it. The talk is just that - talk. Look, these guys hit hard. They're 225lbs and up. Any single heavyweight fighter can knock his opponent out on any given night under the right circumstances. Some of it comes down to chance; the wrong move by an opponent, at the right time. Schaub and Arlovski both took some shots. Were they Big County right hands or JDS style boxing combos? No. However, Schaub finished the night with what was likely a broken jaw. He fought right through that. That tells you something - all this talk of glass chins is generally overrated. Forget it.
7. Ryan Bader Is An Excellent Gatekeeper... And He Might Get A Shot Yet
Remember when Ryan "Darth" Bader was expected to get a title shot? He was a rising prospect with tons of potential upside. Then he met fellow prospect Jon Jones, and it all went downhill. Jones beat Bader, got the title shot that was to have been Rashad Evans', and went on the be the most dominant champion of all time. Bader sunk into the background. He lost to Tito Ortiz. He beat a disinterested Rampage Jackson. He lost to Lyoto Machida, beat the Janitor, lost to Glover Teixeira. In essence, Bader wins over all but the very best, the absolute definition of gatekeeper. However, his last two wins have also been dominant. Anthony Perosh recieved the beating of a lifetime in their contest, in a fight that easily could have been a stoppage TKO. Last night, Rafael Cavalcante, a former Strikeforce champ, was decimated as well - not quite as badly, but worse than one would expect, given he's an ex-champ. Maybe Bader still has title shot potential. There's a story there, with him having lost to Jones in a key matchup in their past. If he can continue developing, well... Jones needs bodies, after all, and he's really only got three potentials at the moment: Alexander Gustafsson, Daniel Cormier, and possibly Anthony Johnson. After that, it's anyone's guess. Should Bader get another solid win or two, we might just be seeing him in a different light.
6. Flyweight Needs More Challengers
Ali Bagautinov probably would have benefited from another fight or two in the UFC before facing Mighty Mouse Johnson. He was game, but it was too much, too soon. The problem is, flyweight is shallow. Over a year since the division came in, and we've really only got to know Johnson, John Dodson, and Joseph Benavidez as serious challengers. There's also the popular Uncle Creepy, Ian McCall, but he has lost to Johnson already, in the flyweight division's inaugural tournament. Benavidez has lost title fights twice to Mighty Mouse, and Dodson will probably get his second shot soon. See a problem? Flyweight has been all about recycling challengers. There's a serious need for fresh faces. Hopefully the likes of Scott Jorgensen and Brad Pickett, who have dropped down to the weight class recently, can provide fresh options. They're both names, and both come to fight. Otherwise, the UFC really needs to look at recruiting, possibly from South East Asia, a market they want to expand into anyway, and one where smaller fighters are more common, and more respected.
5. Ovince St. Preux Is A Name To Watch
Ovince St. Preux has jumped up to twelfth in the light heavyweight rankings on UFC.com, and while you might not recognize all the names he has defeated, you have to recognize the skill he's been displaying of late with his submission game. Earlier in his career, the Haitain-American fighter unleashed a calf slicer in a submission victory. In his last fight prior to UFC 174, he pulled off a rarely seen Von Flue choke. Last night, he broke Ryan Jimmo's arm while working on a Kimura. St. Preux is starting to look like a serious threat, dangerous on the mat, and with a solid stand up game as well. Which is important - he's not as one-dimensional as someone like Rousimar Palhares, who you know will go straight for your leg, but he's still going to try to get you to tap. St. Preux needs to face someone in the Top 10 next,
4. Decisions Can Be As Exciting As Finishes
The Bader match was fantastic. The MacDonald match was a clinic. Letourneau vs. Phillips was outstanding. Mighty Mouse vs. Ali Bagautinov entertained for five solid rounds. All four went to decision. Yes, there were some slow spots, notably Mike Easton vs. Yves Jabouin on the preliminary card. However on a night that had just a handful of finishes, we were treated to some spectacular fights that went the distance. You don't always need someone going to sleep.
3. MMA Judging Is Still An Issue
We saw it come to a head with last week's UFC Fight Night 42, where Rob Pearson was practically robbed at gunpoint over a victory he should have had over Diego Sanchez. It was bad enough that the UFC opted to pay Pearson his win money. UFC 174's Arlovski vs. Schaub decision wasn't quite as bad, and you could argue that Arlovski took the first two rounds, despite how close they were. If you give Arlovski the first two rounds, well, Schaub didn't do enough in the third to be scored a 10-8 round, so Arlovski essentially took the fight on points, even though he didn't do all that much in the first two frames, and was solidly outworked in the third despite an active guard. The flip side of that is, Schaub could easily have been scored one of those two rounds, and combined with his third round domination, it would seem that overall, he was the stronger fighter in the bout. It wound up a split decision that just as easily could have gone Schaub's way, and as great as it was seeing "The Pitbull" back in the octagon, there's a case to be made for Schaub having won it. It was a bit of a steal. It also brings up the entire problem with the 10 point must system. With MMA using a boxing system, that strong third round by Schaub really doesn't get the credit it's due. Scoring in fights like this is simply a mess.
2. Women's MMA Is Here To Stay
What do you usually expect out of two no-name fighters showing up on a UFC preliminary card? Two fighters stepping into the cage for the first time, who haven't even fought in a major organization before? You generally expect to be able to take a bathroom break. Unless the fighters in question are female. Whether they feel they have to work harder to prove themselves, or there's just more untapped talent out there than on the much more exposed men's side of the fight game, female MMA bouts continue to steal the show. Valerie Letourneau and Elizabeth Phillips elevated the preliminary card of UFC 174 last night from "just sort of okay" to "solidly entertaining" all by themselves. Doing it in what was the first bout in the UFC for both of them is nothing short of outstanding. With the strawweight division coming in, Women's MMA is here to stay, and fights like this are why. The girls always steal the show!
1. Rory MacDonald Is Still Heir Apparent To GSP
My apologies to Big Rigg, but I'm just not sold on Johnny Hendricks as champ. Yes, the GSP fight was close - but he did lose. It's the point system more than anything that cost him the fight, but that's the sport as it stands. On top of that, he didn't look great versus Carlos Condit prior to being champ. Robbie Lawler really pushed him. He's been gifted a few decisions of his own. He's got crazy knockout power, but I just don't see him being the long-running Champion that GSP was. I don't think Rory MacDonald will be either, not in terms of winning streak, but I think he's got a great shot at holding the belt, if he continues to show up the way he did last night against Tyron Woodley. A week ago, everyone was talking about Woodley, as MacDonald had lost to Robbie Lawler, and had some dull outings against Jake Ellenberger and Damian Maia, before and after the Lawler fight, respectively. Then the old Rory Mac showed up. Ares dominated Woodley, who was looking primed for a title shot of his own. He put on a total clinic. If that MacDonald continues to be the one that turns up in the cage, he can and should hold a belt some day. He's got the creepy, disaffected sociopath look and talk down outside of the ring. Now he just needs to consistently be a killer within it.